Transcript

The production of this program is made possible thanks to the support of the following and viewers like you. The news in British Columbia is all about Drippa, the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. The premier of the province, David Eby, in response to the December 2025 BC Supreme Court ruling of a case known as Gitga'atla, raced to amend the act. His attempts to do so have become a head-spinning spectacle. The original case began in 2023 with a challenge to the Mineral Tenure Act, which allowed mineral explorers to strike a mineral claim without acquiring agreement and consent by the historical First Nation to the area.

The case upheld the miners' position that consent was not required during exploration. It was the first challenge to Drippa. It was immediately appealed and in December of 2025, the Supreme Court of BC overturned the lower court ruling stating the Declaration Act gives a statutory mandate and duty to take all measures necessary to bring British Columbia's laws into alignment with UNDRIP. In other words, says Indigenous legal authority Robin Younger, the BC government must, as stated in its own words, follow the law it wrote and the court has no option. I invited Robin Younger of Miller Titerle LLP to join me for a conversation that matters to outline exactly what Drippa is and the legal ramifications of amending this legislation.

Robin, welcome. Thank you for having me. So, let's go back to the origins of Drippa. I mean, this was at a time when we would say that efforts to find a path towards reconciliation that was working for all were really well-intentioned and moving, I would say, in the right direction. Uh and there was the move federally and also a push that was coming to us from internally to adopt the principles of UNDRIP. British Columbia then drafted and instituted Drippa or the Declaration on Independent Indigenous Persons' Rights. Was the original act, uh you know, from your perspective legally sound? Uh no, I don't believe it was legally sound.

In November 2019, I I put an article in the Vancouver Sun talking about the significant questions and concerns that may arise from the Drippa. And one of my statements was that it will now be impossible uh for government to live up to the expectations that Indigenous groups will now quite reasonably hold without fundamentally affecting the rights of third parties. And I believe that's exactly where we find ourselves today. Whether a statute is well-intentioned or not is a is never the issue. The issue is what does it say, how will it play out in court, and how will that affect the relations between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples in British Columbia?

And you know, I sit here with with great great concern um you know, noting that there's appears to be even greater discord now than there was, you know, in 2019. So, I I don't think it's been very constructive and I do think there were legal problems with it right from the beginning. And um you know, it's fair to say that there are significant and we're acting for a client right now that's bringing a constitutional challenge to the Drippa seeking to have it declared invalid uh for reasons very similar to those I noted in 2019. So, what were those reasons back in 2019 that you maintain today that you say this does not work?

Well, there's a number of them. Um and they're all set out in the claim that's available on the internet if anybody wants to read it at the Fera p h a r a website. But, you know, point one is that under our constitution, it is the federal government, not the provinces, that have responsibility for legislating in relation to First Nation matters. The terms used in our uh Constitution Act 1867 are Indians and lands reserved the Indians antiquated terms, but it's it's First Nation issues. And you know, I believe that the statute is primarily in pith and substance a law related to Indigenous matters, Indigenous rights, and for a whole host of reasons, we just don't think it's appropriate for uh Indigenous rights to differ among provinces and based on, you know, what provinces decide to do or not do, confer, claw back, we just don't think that's a problem.

An- another problem is that we have a constitutional framework in Canada that already protects Indigenous rights. And it's called Section 35 of the Constitution Act 1982. It's one of the we're one of the few countries in the world that have constitutionally protected Aboriginal rights. And since 1982 and through a series of cases, the Supreme Court of Canada has consistently been developing the law in, you know, I think a reasonably well-structured way to deal with both asserted but unproven rights and ultimately proven rights. And you you know, you'll know of these cases like the Haida case that gives rise to the duty to consult.

Um the Tsilhqot'in case in 2014, you know, historic case, first time Aboriginal title was found anywhere in Canada. So, that's, you know, that's one of the reasons. An- another reason is this Section 3 of the Drippa that requires the government to take all measures necessary to ensure our laws match up with this UN document, the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Uh the UNDRIP is is not a legally binding document. It's it's a resolution of the General Assembly. It's not a convention. It's not a treaty. No country signs it. No country ratifies it like they would you know, a a typical human rights instrument.

And um and you know, the requirement to change our laws to match up with it comes from Section 3 of the act, which you noted the court relied on in Gitga'atla. And we take the view that one legislature can't pass a law telling future governments and legislatures what their laws must look like. There there's also issues about co-decision-making and consent decision-making under uh the Drippa Section 6 and 7. This is a provision that doesn't exist in the federal counterpart. It was the this part of the Drippa that was at issue with the um you know, high-profile land act amendments in 2024. And they have the ability under those sections to uh establish agreements with First Nations to give co-decision-making and consent decision-making powers.

And um we believe that there are issues about uh who is whether you lose your right or don't have a right to vote for people that are governing you because if Indigenous groups are governing non-Indigenous people in respect of these matters, but non-Indigenous people don't get to vote for them, we believe there's an issue there. So, there there's a whole series of issues and ultimately it will be up to the court to assess them, but they're not, you know, new. They've been out there and noted for quite some time. The production of this program is made possible thanks to the support of the following and viewers like you.

Well, when Drippa was first introduced, there didn't seem to be any legal challenges as I noted in the um uh in the introduction, this mineral tenure act was really the first challenge coming forward to Drippa. And initially the court said, uh nope, uh we don't believe the Drippa applies. But, the the challenge has now thrown all of this into question. What's the next step on this? I I know it's because the Supreme Court of BC has now ruled saying, yes, it does. Will there be another appeal or does it have to go back to the legislature to be changed if there's going to be any change in direction on the way in which it's applied?

So, that's a very good question. The Gitga'atla decision is very interesting in terms of how it progressed. At the Supreme Court level, the court did find that there were problems with the Mineral Tenure system, but it wasn't based on a requirement of the UNDRIP and the Drippa. And the First Nation, so the First Nation kind of won, but appealed the parts that it didn't succeed on in relation to the UNDRIP. And it was at the BC Court of Appeal that the court has issued these reasons that, you know, have I think profound implications for many other statutes and statutory decision-makers. The premier has talked about, you know, all these other cases for which pleadings have been amended since the Gitga'atla case.

Um so, it's now been to the BC Supreme Court and the BC Court of Appeal. There is no right to appeal this case any further. The government is trying to get the Supreme Court of Canada to hear an appeal of it. It's filed that appeal. And it's up to the Supreme Court of Canada to decide whether it will hear an appeal. So, that's called seeking leave. And and we just don't know whether the court will or won't. Most cases for which people ask the court to hear the appeal at the Supreme Court of Canada are not heard. But, on the other hand, you know, this is an important case and and it may get heard.

If it doesn't get heard at the Supreme Court of Canada, uh the courts won't have any further role to play. The decision is what it is. So, it can go back to the legislature and be amended as law. And then what happens? Well, you raise an interesting point because under traditional constitutional law in Canada, any legislature can change, amend, repeal legislation that has been passed previously. The legislature is supreme. There are provisions in the UNDRIP, not directly in the DRIPA, but in the UNDRIP, that require significant cooperation and and consultation with indigenous groups before passing or changing laws that may affect them.

And so one of the issues that arises in this case, it's a bit of a catch-22, is given the Court of Appeal's decision that the government has to, you know, effectively act consistent with the DRIPA here, um are they able to amend this without either the consent or close to the consent of the First Nations? And you know, would the consultation required under, I think it's Article 19 of the UNDRIP be, you know, significant I think it would probably be more significant than um you know, the limited number of meetings that apparently have happened over the last few months where the First Nations have expressed, you know, profound concern about the process, not just what the government is doing, but also the process itself.

So in other words, DRIPA it has to be followed to change DRIPA. That's the argument. That's going to I think ultimately be for a court to decide. I think there are, you know, probably better arguments on the other side that the legislature always has the right to change the law, but I don't think the question is so much whether it can just change the law, it's what standard would it have to meet in terms of the engagement with indigenous groups. And meaningful consultation is sometimes distorted or misunderstood to mean, oh, you can never do anything without consent. I don't think that's what meaningful consultation means, but as I noted, at least from what I've seen in the media, the First Nations, you know, certainly have some profound concerns about the process that's been followed today, you know, in the last number of weeks and months regarding potential amendments and suspensions and all these sorts of things.

The production of this program is made possible thanks to the support of the following and viewers like you. Let's go back to the Tsilhqot'in case in 2014. I noted the judge in her reasoning also included a section that gave authority to the Crown. If after all efforts had been exhausted and it was deemed that the project was in the greater in the interest of the greater good of the province or the country, that the that the Crown had the authority then to move forward. And I believe that that was part of the argument that led to Site C being completed in British Columbia. Can we now should we now say, nope, that no longer applies?

So this goes to this distinction I was drawing between constitutionally protected Section 35 rights and the DRIPA. So the Tsilhqot'in decision in 2014 had nothing to do with the DRIPA. It was based solely on Section 35 rights. And and the court made a number of important findings. The the concept of title was was nothing new. The concept has existed for years, Aboriginal title. What was historic about Tsilhqot'in is the first time that the government found title in a particular place. But the court also, as you noted, talked about, well, what's going to happen now that Aboriginal title exists in this place and the First Nations have the right to use the land, possess the land, choose the use to which it's put, manage it, etc.

Because there will inevitably be some overlap with non-indigenous peoples. And the court in Tsilhqot'in made important findings based on prior case law and expanding it, confirming that governments can continue to govern in the public interest over Aboriginal title lands. They can continue to do so and infringe the Aboriginal title rights. Actually infringe them. But they must do it according to a certain standard and process. They can't do it willy-nilly. They have to be able to justify the infringement. And the types of matters for which the Supreme Court of Canada has said Aboriginal title can be justified if done properly is very broad, including mining, forestry, um you know, development generally, hydroelectric development, very very broad.

So there's been very little reliance, if if any, I'm not sure I'm aware of any reliance by the the province to use the right to justify infringement. It's almost like people just think that the Tsilhqot'in area is now not part of British Columbia and the laws don't apply and that's simply not true. But there is a I think a fairly rich balancing of interest there, even in the Aboriginal title context. It's a high threshold. I don't you know, I don't want to suggest otherwise. Infringing Aboriginal title is a pretty high threshold, but it can be done. And this is one of the differences with the DRIPA and the UNDRIP.

It does not apply the same balancing of interest tests. The language of the UNDRIP rights are, at least in my estimation, sometimes unclear, sometimes fairly extreme. There is a provision in Article 46, I believe, of UNDRIP that does say that governments can do certain things that impair the exercise of UNDRIP rights. But they're not the same as the Section 35 tests that the Supreme Court of Canada has talked about to allow governing in the public interest. Even in the case of unproven but asserted claims in title, the Supreme Court of Canada in the Haida case 2004 said, look government, you can still govern.

You got to consult, you got to consider the strength of claim, the impacts, you have to think about ways to accommodate the First Nation interest, but at the end of the day, here's what you got to do. This is the Supreme Court of Canada's words, reasonably balance Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal interests. So there's there's a disconnect there. I believe there's a disconnect there as part of that constitutional challenge that I was referring to. Was that a mistake on behalf of the legislature back in 2019 that they did not consider that? Well, you know, I I believe the act is problematic, has been problematic since 2019.

And obviously other people differ and I respect their different views out there. What I will say is very important to recognize is this. There's no other jurisdiction in the world that has done what British Columbia has done, certainly not to my knowledge. There is no province in Canada that has done what British Columbia has done. The federal government, there is a territory, Northwest Territories, has legislation similar to British Columbia's, but here here's where it differs. And the federal UNDRIP differs. BC did not just pass the DRIPA. Two years later, the government um Premier Eby was Attorney General at the time, introduced an amendment to the Interpretation Act.

This sounds technical legal stuff, it's super important, it's pretty straightforward. They added Section 8.1 that says that all BC laws, when being adjudicated by the courts, must be interpreted in a manner consistent with the declaration. The UN declaration, the DRIPA. So it mandates then. So it hardwires in a sense the DRIPA into the judicial work of the courts in ways that would not otherwise perhaps happen. And that's why BC differs from Northwest Territories and the federal UNDRIP legislation. And it's a very big deal. And when that section was going through the legislature, it was not fully debated.

Debate was cut off. Um MLA De Yong was asking questions about it and the debate was cut off through closure. So that was an amendment to the act. So the act has been amended. That was actually No, that was actually put in the Interpretation Act. It's directly related to the DRIPA, but it was housed in Section 8.1 of the Interpretation Act. And there's a bill before the house, a private member's bill to repeal Section 8.1 right now, but it's up to the government whether to advance it. The production of this program is made possible thanks to the support of the following and viewers like you. What are the legal ramifications now of going back into the legislation?

I mean, First Nations have already indicated, you go ahead and do that, you change one comma, you're going to find yourself in court and you're going to have much greater uncertainty than you think that you have right now. What are the what's the process and what's the likelihood that there can be success? Well, I think legally the act can be repealed and amended. The parliament remains supreme. Um you know, a government will have to do so cognizant of any legal or other obligations to First Nations to have discussions about that. They obviously haven't gone so well, but of course, that's not the ultimate test.

That test is, have you meaningfully engaged? Um it can be done, but you know, I go back to what I said in 2019. It will likely be impossible to live up to the expectations that First Nations will now legitimately hold without fundamentally affecting third parties. This is the problem with the DRIPA. It's not that, oh, I thought it's not a good law in 2019. I thought it was going to create an intractable situation with no easy resolution or fix. And that's exactly where we are. And you know, I've I've said elsewhere, I'm not sure whether any government has the, you know, willingness and temerity to make the changes necessary uh to address the concerns arising from the DRIPA and its implementation.

And it's I I all the more important now that the case that I referred to challenging the constitutional validity of the dripa is heard in a timely way. The court may agree with us, the court may disagree with us, but if the court agrees with us and decides that the dripa itself is unconstitutional if nothing else it's a clean reset. You go back to 2019 there is no dripa and you need to focus on meaningfully implementing and respecting the section 35 rights of indigenous peoples. When you take a look at the uh the legal framework that we're in right now and its impact on investment in anything to do with crown land in British Columbia right at the moment, what's your interpretation of uh the state of affairs in British Columbia?

it's not good. I can tell you that and you know, I I work in this area. I mean it's um it is not good. And the number of people that choose not to invest in British Columbia talk to someone like me and others and they say, "Are you kidding me? That's That's how it works there? No, we're out. Thank you so much." They don't phone the government and complain. They just They just don't invest. And yes, there are some big projects that have invested and there will be some that will continue. But you know, by and large has this present situation created a net negative or a net positive on investor certainty?

I you know, I certainly come down firmly in the camp that it's it's a negative. It definitely is and already we're seeing uh other challenges rapidly uh appearing on projects that have been given uh approval. Uh now First Nations are coming along and saying, "Nope." Uh and they are uh citing dripa as the their reasons. I take a look at the mine just outside of uh Princeton in the Similkameen territory. There's now pushback on a mine that had been given an approval for an extension on its mining permit by about a decade. Yeah, and the premier has mentioned 20 different cases where the pleadings have now been amended and I I saw that um Gordon Hoekstra wrote an article in the Sun recently about some of them, but I don't think anybody really knows what all of those cases are.

The breadth of the implications of the undrip are are really important to talk about because I mean first of all, there's the Gitga'at case. Secondly, there's the 20 cases that the premier has mentioned. I'm sure there's more to come. But it's also manifesting itself in a broad range of provincial policies. It's It's affecting other court decisions. We're counsel for uh the largest private landowner in the Cowichan Tribes case and people often say, "Well, Cowichan Tribes isn't a dripa case." And and I think that's not correct. Um it's in part a dripa case. It's not primarily a dripa case. But what happened was the dripa was brought into force during the course of the Cowichan Tribes case.

And during the trial the lawyers for the Cowichan Tribes amended their pleadings to rely specifically on the dripa and section 8.1 of the interpretation act. And Justice Young in rendering her decision saying that the land title act does not provide indefeasible title to homeowners against aboriginal title. It does other things, but not aboriginal title. Uh she, you know, noted that this her reasoning, which was based in much on other things, was also consistent with the you know, dripa and section 8.1 issues. So to to say it's not a dripa case is, you know, at minimum quite an overstatement and um and I think people are starting to realize, "Wow, this is having major legal effect all over the place." And when you start talking about potential impacts on the solidity and sanctity of private property, I think you start getting people's attention, right?

Well, uh the world is paying attention. I think all of Canada is watching what's happening here. Uh thanks for giving us an insight into uh how important this this issue is and how it's unfolded. You're welcome and you're right. The world is paying attention. I mean, certainly international investors are paying attention. I international media is paying attention for sure. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you.

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Conversations That Matter: DRIPA and its legal consequences