Transcript
I'm wondering what it is that you're trying to convince me of right now. These people who are in AI, they do involve the occult. They think AI is a god that will deem humanity. That's why they're so into it. Why are you so sympathetic towards these AI companies? But can you answer that? Like do you believe that they're there are demons out there and they are summoning them? You're basically indoctrinated into a certain deference to these people. Before we continue, I just want to make sure that you don't feel that I'm being disrespectful to you in some way. Can you very quickly just just just Google this?
Do you do you have a phone? You you you you you have to do this. Otherwise it's hard for us to have a conversation. Sure. Could you Google something for us? Just look at this, okay? Claims from an anonymous former OpenAI executive describing Sam Altman as building portals from which we're genuinely summoning aliens. They these people are insane. Hello. This is Robinson Erhardt here with a brief introduction to the last of my three conversations with Jiang Xueqin. The first two of which are self-contained and linked in the pinned comment in the description. Jiang is a Chinese-Canadian educator.
He's the host of Predictive History on YouTube and then he is also the author of the Substack by the same name. So Jiang and I had been talking for 7 hours when we started this one to end our marathon. So we were both already at the ends of our nerves, but we really didn't agree on anything at all and so we ended the conversation a bit abruptly because it was really difficult to find any common ground on which to discuss AI at all. I had expected to talk about economics, cybersecurity, existential threats, but for Jiang, the AI executive the AI executives' central goals are occult. And since I neither believe in the paranormal nor have any compelling evidence that people like Sam Altman hold those beliefs, it was hard for me to talk about, let alone to understand why someone would take this seriously.
Anyway, you should check out Predictive History if you find Jiang's positions compelling and want to better understand how he's reached them. For my part, I shall return for an outro with some reflections as I got a lot out of talking with Jiang, both in this episode alone and and throughout these three conversations. One quick note though is that because I'm I'm not an expert in how large language models work, I've included a couple of links to helpful videos in the description that could clarify Jiang's description that he gives at the beginning of the conversation. But that's that. I hope that you enjoy this conversation as much as I enjoyed having it with Jiang.
You've argued that the real purpose of AI is to enslave humanity, which is a a very bold claim and I'm really looking forward to discussing it. But before we get there, Sorry, sorry. Um I've argued in the past that AI is meant to transform humanity. Okay. Yeah, or redeem humanity. Redeem humanity. Okay, so not enslave humanity. Well, it's the same thing, but but I mean like the correct phrase would be redeem. Okay. Okay, that's that's totally fair. Um before we get to that though, I think it makes most sense to begin maybe with where we are now and how we've gotten here. So I know you you mentioned wanting to talk about the AI bubble, but before we can even talk about what the AI bubble is, we need to get on the same page about what AI, as it currently exists, is, because there are very different beliefs about that.
Yeah. Right. So AI is a catch-all phrase for any um technological innovation right now uh in um the computer computer industry. Um its technical term is supervised machine learning. Uh and the idea here is that rather than have humans program the algorithm uh into the software, the software will um be trained to develop its own algorithm, often referred to as a neural network. Let's just use a example uh to illustrate what supervised machine learning is. Let's just say I want to do facial recognition technology. Well um I have a data set of about a million faces and I need to differentiate uh these faces and recognize them immediately.
Also I need to uh perhaps recognize them in adverse circumstances, for example, in bad lighting or if you're wearing a hat or if you're uh wearing some uh disguises, okay? So I know that I can turn your face into a uh topographical model and um um I can turn this topographical model into um a very precise um very nuanced mathematical mathematical equation. But I don't know the precise weights. For example, how much weight do I put on your eyes or your nose? So I let the computer figure figure that out, okay? So, I start off with a basic template, a basic structure of this topographic model, and I I let I let the computer to to for supervised machine learning refine uh this model, okay?
So, the idea is I have a million faces, and I want the computer to match the names to all faces correctly. Okay. Okay? Um and so I'm going to create a re recursive loop until the machine develops an algorithm or a neural network that's able to do this 100% of the time. And so the machine is going to try different weights. And I don't know actually what the result will be. And so uh the machine tries a model, goes through the machine, maybe it's a 9% accuracy. Okay, let's try again. Okay? You keep on going until you get 100% and once this is once this is done, then uh and once you have 100% accuracy, then a neural network is created which gives you um a precise list of weights that you need in order to differentiate faces.
So, now I can take this model and then put a new data uh set of a of million faces, and it should give me 100% accuracy. Then I extend to a billion faces, it should still give me um 100% accuracy. Okay? So, that's what machine learning is. That's what AI is. Something to keep in mind here is what I'm doing is performing a search and sort uh function on a database which is the most basic problem in computer science. Why it looks impressive is that with Moore's Law and with enough computation, I can do this at an incredible scale beyond people's imagination. And this um process that I that I just explained to you is how we get all AI.
Okay, so for example, language recognition software. How how how am I able to um um basically write down whatever you say? Same idea where I have a database and this database is the complete universe of all possibilities of language. And then as I speak, the AI is looking for um the correct written dictation and it's creating a neural network that would allow it to the most quickly process this with 100% accuracy. Okay? And so this is all that's happening. It's not impressive. It is brute force and infinite recursion and almost in like just a tremendous amount of compute of of data. All right?
Mhm. And um um can you think of maybe something that uh oh sorry, sorry. So let me explain ChatGPT. Sure. Okay? So what people don't appreciate is chat GPT is only possible because of Wikipedia. If Wikipedia did not exist, then OpenAI would first have to create Wikipedia because you because you first need a total universe of all possibilities before you can create an AI uh chatbot. You need something that the chatbot can learn essentially. No, no, no. You need something that the chatbot can draw information from. That's what I mean. Right, okay. So when you use OpenAI ChatGPT, what it's doing is it's going into this database, which is basically the entire internet, and it's drawing information.
And then what the neural network is doing filtering this information in a way that most pleases the user, that uh most um accurately gives you the response that you're looking for. Okay? Right? So, for example, uh you can uh say to ChatGPT, write me an essay um for my high school English teacher about Shakespeare's Sonnet 41. Mhm. Well, it's very simple. ChatGPT just goes to the database of um internet information about about this uh Sonnet 41 and compiles in a way that most pleases you. Okay? But then what you can do is say um write me this essay as though you are a 14-year-old. Write me this essay as though you are a 50 56-year-old guy from Nigeria who speaks French better than he speaks English.
Okay? These are just filters. Right? And so all these um uh AI companies, whether whether whether it's Anthropic, Open OpenAI, all they're doing is they're creating different uh chatbots with different filters uh in order to give you the response that you want. But they're all working from the same source, which is basically the entire internet. Okay? Mhm. And that's why um after chat GPT came out, China was able to introduce DeepSeek very quickly because once um the once OpenAI was able to uh collate or categorize uh the entire internet into a database that can be managed and once it created the algorithms network network networks in order to quickly process this information for the user all for the use of the user, then what DeepSeek can do is reverse all this and create its own chatbot very easily.
Right? Because all you need to know is the weights. And so you just um ask a lot of questions and then it gives you like a lot of responses. And then run your own algorithm or AI in order to reverse engineer the chat bot neural network. And then you can refine it to make it much more efficient. Um and so that's why DeepSeek was able to produce a chatbot that was more effective than ChatGPT at a fraction of the cost. Hm. Now this is problematic for OpenAI because it's so easy to create new new versions. And the Chinese are doing that. And the Chinese are doing it in an in a um open source way um that is cutting into the revenue stream of OpenAI.
And why OpenAI is angry is um they had to spend tens of billions of dollars in designing the system in the first place, in categorizing the internet into a database uh that can be used and then creating the initial algorithms, which takes years and years of research and trial and error. And now that they have this template in place, the others can take it for free and create better models. Right? But it's impossible for OpenAI to recoup those R&D costs. And that's why OpenAI is very angry at China and that's why OpenAI and on topic want to ban these Chinese open source models from the United States.
Hm. And how has this resulted though in the this technology resulted in the AI bubble? I mean, why is it being overvalued? Because it does seem just from using it that it's extraordinarily effective even if it's not some mysterious thinking machine, but really just operating through brute force. Yeah. So the Silicon Valley sorry, the Silicon Valley um model is basically you throw money at a problem until you monopolize the market, and then you can charge whatever price you want. Um, so the idea is right now uh AI doesn't make any money because um um the startup costs were too high and the competition is too fierce.
But once you monopolize the market what what I mean monopolize what I actually mean is saturate. Okay, when you make AI just so commonplace that people are forced to use it all the time then you can charge whatever price you want because essentially you're a monopoly, right? That's why Muse is so important because they're trying to make AI a part of your everyday life. They're trying to trying to turn AI into your soulmate. Mhm. And uh you basically subcontract your brain to this AI agent, right? And they're able to achieve that then that becomes profitable because then um think about uh because basically they have access to your soul.
They know exactly what you're thinking, they know exactly how you're feeling, and this would be a tremendous boon to advertisers, right? So even so because people behave in patterns uh the AI would then be able to predict your behavior even before you you you yourself have decided on a certain behavior. Mhm. Um and so that is their business model. And that's why they're trying to um build as many data centers as possible because um from a business perspective, the more information you have um the more accurately or the more precisely you're able to diagnose a person's personality Right. and thus his thoughts and behavior, and thus you're able to sell this data to advertisers who can then uh basically have control over your buying patterns.
Yeah, something that I'm I'm sure you've spoken about this but I haven't even thought about it and hadn't even thought about it until this moment. When you see um AI clones of people and people are talking to their AI clones like this is some fun, exciting thing, all this really means is that somewhere out there a company that is selling AI knows they think they know everything there is to know about you, that they can replicate you purpose perfectly and clearly that's going to be very valuable if these companies are trafficking in data for advertisers. what's really interesting people don't appreciate this is young people have been taught to um basically uh try to clone their souls onto their social media if that makes sense.
When you say that young people are taught to clone their souls onto social media uh I mean people definitely want to display themselves um probably in a a better light than they actually see themselves, but I guess what what do you mean by clone their souls? Basically there's a loneliness, a depression epidemic throughout the United States and throughout the Western world. And so I think a lot of young people naturally gravitate towards AI and think that if they're able to clone themselves on social media then they're able to better express themselves and resolve the loneliness and depression in their lives.
It's an outward expansion in order to negate the uh internal emptiness inside them. And where though does this come to the bubble? Because you you said, I believe and maybe I'm I'm mischaracterizing you, that once the AI companies have saturated the market with their product and it's ubiquitous, seems like then there will be a lot of revenue to be drawn in from that. So why then would we be in a bubble if there's so much investment pouring into this? It sounds like it could just be a good investment opportunity. Yeah, so I'm not the one saying this is a bubble. Everyone's saying this is a bubble.
And the reason why is these companies are investing in AI on the expectation that they will achieve um this paradise or this payday, right? So how this is working is that um and and and I'm just going to put this in very simple terms, okay? This is not this will not be precise or exact, okay? But how this works is OpenAI is like, okay, in order to achieve what I want to achieve, right? Which is um I want to collect all possible data points in society and then um understand society to a point where I can predict how everyone behaves. I need to have a $10 trillion of compute. Basically, I need to build a $10 trillion of data centers.
And but once I build that $10 trillion of data centers, then I expect to make 10 trillion dollars. So it's worth it, right? And so OpenAI then goes to maybe Oracle or Broadband says, listen, I need to lease a $10 trillion from you of uh compute. Can you build me those data centers? Oracle says, sure. Uh then Oracle says to Nvidia, I need to purchase about $50 billion of chips from you in order to build out my data centers. Can I borrow that from you? Nvidia says, sure. Um and Oracle says like, okay, well, I don't have any money cuz all my money is was promised to me by OpenAI. And Nvidia is like, fine, we'll loan you the money to borrow these chips, okay?
So you see what's happening here where uh you start with the assumption that there'd be a $10 trillion uh So that justifies the $10 dollar uh build out of data centers. But then you need to it go downstream and get people to actually build the stuff. they build the stuff by by basically uh believing that this 10 trillion dollar uh payday will one day materialize, right? And the problem is is the problem is like at the moment people recognize that this 10 trillion dollar payout is not coming, the entire thing collapses, right? It's like a domino effect. But I thought you said you didn't think it was a bubble.
Or you do think it's a bubble? It it it's definitely a bubble. Okay, so it is a bubble. Because the 10 trillion dollar payday you don't think is coming. Uh no, it's not coming. And so one limits test will be the Anthropic IPO, which is scheduled for November. Mhm. Um right now Anthropic believes it is a value of 2 trillion dollars. And uh if it IPOs and investors don't respond and its valuation drops down, then the entire bubble could collapse because now investors get get get antsy, okay? Also, another factor that's really important and people don't appreciate this is a lot of this bubble is driven by excess liquidity.
Where's this liquidity coming from? It's coming from overseas, right? So if you're Saudi Arabia and you're Japan and you have trillions of dollars to invest, well, you don't have that many good options to invest in the AI bubble, right? And the more you invest, the more committed you are. And um this is what's driving the Ponzi scheme, right? But there is a um event that is beyond anyone's expectation, which is the Iran war, that's drying up liquidity of both Saudi Arabia and Japan. Because um Saudi Arabia sells oil and Japan buys oil uh and turns out and manufactures goods for the world. And so um if Japan and Saudi Arabia are no longer able to invest in the AI bubble, right?
Then it's going to pop. So so it's only a matter of time before the AI bubble burst. But, and this is really important, it's really not a problem for these AI companies because they actually want the bubble to burst. These companies by themselves cannot be profitable, all right? You have this $10 trillion pay the expectation, but it's never going to come. So how do we resolve that issue? You get the government to bail you out, right? So so just let's do a thought experiment. Let's just say the AI AI bubble burst. Well, you have the subprime crisis over again, right? And now you this is a major threat to the American economy.
50% of GDP growth is due to data center build build outs, the AI AI bubble basically. That's 50% GDP growth. So 50% of GDP growth. So in that case, the government has no choice but to bail out the AI industry. How? By nationalizing the data centers and by taking out a stake in these AI companies. Now you're profitable because um if as an oil company, you you can you're 100% profit if you're not actually running the oil wells yourself, right? So these data centers will be financed by the taxpayer. And so you have a situation where all gains will be privatized, all losses will be socialized. And that's a system that the these AI companies want to move towards, right?
But once that happens, then the question is um how can these AI companies best serve the government? What is the government interest in these AI companies? And what the government really wants to do is create something called AI control grid or an AI surveillance state. And they can do that by issuing something called digital currency and digital ID. Once you have digital ID system in place, then it's very easy for you to have digital currency. And that I think is the future the United States is moving towards. Why would the AI companies want us to exist in a digital surveillance state? One reason that I could imagine would be true is if we live in an AI digital surveillance state, they make a lot of money.
Yeah, that's what they're interested in. They're interested in making as much money as possible, right? So you make a lot of money when you you have access to everyone's private information because then you can sell it to advertisers. So digital ID is the best mechanism in order to obtain all this information. And once you have digital ID, then you can create a digital database of each individual because then you can collect that person's health information, education records, job employment history, Amazon purchasing history, and you can and then the algorithm can very quickly turn you into a personality type.
And quite honestly, everyone thinks he or she is unique. Not really. I mean, just based on two pieces of information, I know exactly how you behave. First of all, I need to know how you behaved in the past. Second of all, I need to know how your other friends behave, right? Once I have these two pieces of information, I know exactly how you'll behave the next 50 years. Why I understand how if you know how somebody's behaved in the past, you probably have a good idea how they're going to behave in the future, but why is it that you think knowing how somebody's friends will behave is such a reliable indicator of how they'll behave in the future?
we're social animals, because most things we do is in order to get along with our friends. You know, so they did studies on obese people. And they looked at why is it so hard for obese people to lose weight? And the answer they came up with is because obese people hang out with other obese people. And if you become thin, that means losing your friend circle. So we as human are most afraid of being ostracized. If you look at history, the worst punishment that you can inflict on on a person was not the death penalty, was actually banishment. Mm. Right? Exile. And that was true throughout most of human history.
The church, the Catholic church, the greatest weapon was excommunication. And in Athens, the worst punishment someone could inflict on you was to banish you for 10 years. Like like that was considered like really harsh. In another conversation that we had that I think is going to come out before this one, so I'll assume that our listeners might have heard it, we've talked about the the future of humanity from a more geopolitical perspective. And you see in in the next couple of years civilization collapsing because in part of the Iran war, that's something that we discussed. Why is it necessary or even important to talk about AI right now if there are all these other things that you expect will have such a dramatic impact on the human condition?
Will people be using AI long enough that AI becomes an like an existential issue? I think it's important to discuss AI because it gives us insight into how the elite think and behave. So I think we need to appreciate the meritocracy and ask ourselves, why is it that the elite create the meritocracy in the first place? When I when I mean the meritocracy, I mean the school system where a handful of students are selected based on their IQ to enter the most elite universities where they become part of of the technocracy that governs the United States. That's that's what the meritocracy is. And you go back and you look at the um people who founded the meritocracy and this includes James Conant who was president of Harvard um and who he was um um the first Harvard president to use SAT as a foundation for a national scholarship program to include the best and brightest to come to Harvard.
And you look at someone like Henry Chauncey who was the first president of ETS. ETS? The Educational Testing Services, the people behind the SAT GRE the GRE um and TOEFL, okay? So if you go and look at these people what you recognize is that these were all um pilgrims. They came from um um very prestigious program families. These were Boston Brahmin Brahmins basically. Mm. And if you look into their eschatology um they're very much focused on perfection and control, right? So the idea of a meritocracy was if we can get the best students to go to the best universities this will have a trickle-down effect where everyone will behave the same way, right?
Because these students that who get into Harvard and Yale and Stanford become role models for everyone else. And so through this top-down mechanism we can transform society so that everyone behaves in a very reasonable, very disciplined manner. Um and that's been the obsession of the meritocracy for the past uh 60 70 years. Like how do we make sure that every student is able to be perfect or how do we uh use the education system in order to transform or redeem all these lost souls? Okay? So there's almost a religious imperative to the meritocracy. And it's something that you know will sound strange to in meritocracy, because we're like, we're atheists.
We're um our religion is reason. Exactly. Okay? They call this the Holy Empire of Reason. Like, how do we use school school system in order to um transform everyone into a scholar? Okay? That was the original intention. And it didn't work out. Okay? In fact, you you can make the argument that the meritocracy has really destroyed the educa- education system in uh the United States. I would make that argument. I would say like the main impediment to real education reform is a meritocracy. Because if you really want to ensure that all students do well, then you need a fair distri- fair distribution of resources.
Um the elite won't go for it, right? But I'm just saying like uh that's what you should do. Okay? But just because the meritocracy failed doesn't really mean the elite are like just give up and like, well, well, you know, before we thought we could get everyone to conform and be reasonable and that failed. So let's just celebrate human diversity, human imagination, human empathy for what it is. They're not like that. They're like, no, screw that. We're going to try again. And this time we'll we'll succeed. And how will we accomplish our mission? With AI. Okay? So the school system was our first experiment.
Now we're we'll move on to AI. And um the problem with schooling is we cannot um eliminate the family factor. We cannot eliminate the environmental factors. So what we're going to do is we're going to use AI to completely control a student's environment. Okay? Imagine you're born and guess what? There's an AI agent talking to you and you're like, what the hell? And the AI agent, don't worry. I'm your soulmate. I'm your I'm your imaginary friend. Whatever you whatever you want to call it. Okay? You don't know, but you just grow up with this AI AI agent as part of your life. And what is the AI agent telling you to do?
Be a good person. Work out more. Eat healthy. Be nice to people. Obey authority. Don't question too much. Right? And that could be a solution to the problem of diversity and um too much human conflict. I don't understand why AI is a replacement for meritocracy unless oh Here's one reason why I could see it being a replacement for the meritocracy and you could let me know. One reason that I could imagine the quote unquote elites wanting to make sure they have an educated population is that having an educated population would enable them to make more money. If their employees are smarter, they'll probably make more money.
But if they failed to educate their employees, make them smarter, more productive workers, then they would want to replace them with AI, which is much more effective. never said the meritocracy was meant to replace. Sorry, I never said the AI was meant to replace the meritocracy. Oh, I never said that. Oh, sorry. What I said was the meritocracy was a failed experiment Mhm. uh to control the population. And after this failure, the elite is like, let's move on to AI. Okay. So the goal is to control the population and make it conform and reasonable to create a holy empire of reason. Okay? Mhm. And so I'm going to explain to you why they're doing this.
Sure. All right. So um we've talked previously about the Kabbalah. Mhm. Right? And what is the Kabbalah? The Kabbalah is a mystical hermetic understanding of the Bible. Um and consider Bible to be the source code of the universe. Those who believe in the Kabbalah? Uh yes. Okay. And I also talked about 17 Frankism and how they spread throughout the world, right? And they infiltrated many different groups, including the Freemasons. Who founded America? The Freemasons. All right? So the Freemasons are working with the Kabbalah. And maybe there've been a lot of um modifications throughout the centuries, but the basic premise is the same, which is that humans have responsibility to help divinity achieve perfection on earth.
Okay? From a Jewish perspective, that means ushering in the Messianic age where everyone is redeemed in the eyes of God and where everyone welcomes God into his or her own heart, into his own bosom. Once everyone is I bow myself before God, I humble myself before God, I will be further obedient, then God will come and the world will end and be perfect. Okay? And we will return to the Garden of Eden. That is the main idea here. So in the Freemason Masonic tradition, they believe in geometry. Um and so what they want to do is create a temple for God to live in, right? Because these Freemasons believe that they uh go way back to um the Temple of Solomon.
Their their um ancestors built the Temple of Solomon. Okay? So you need to know all this religious history in order to understand what's going on. Otherwise, it's completely confusing. All right? But so I'm trying to give you a simplified version of of what they believe. Sure. All right? So the 17 Frankists infiltrated the Freemasons and they brought the Kabbalah with them. The Kabbalah was a very seductive ideology. And they believe that through their own hand, they can create a perfect world. Okay? That's what the Freemasons believe. And that's why they founded America because America was meant to be the new Jerusalem.
And so there is a um strand of American exceptionalism that believes that um America will be the new Jerusalem and it will usher them as the age. Okay? And uh this is what drove the creation of meritocracy. Does that make sense? So I'm I'm following what you're saying, but I I mean I don't believe it necessarily No, no, no. No, it doesn't matter what you believe. I'm just saying what they believe. Okay. Sure. Okay. I'm not asking you like do you like this idea? Okay? All right, I'm just telling you what they what they believe. What the Freemasons believe. the Freemasons believe. Okay? All right, and I'm telling you like this this is the basis for everything that they've done in America, including the meritocracy.
All right? Including the AI. Um um so it didn't really work with the meritocracy. So now they want to shift their attention to AI because um AI is able to penetrate everything in society. And therefore you're able to uh mitigate or eliminate a lot of factors you can't control, like the family for example. All right? Um so the idea is that by using AI and creating the AI surveillance state, you are allowing humans to perfect themselves and to redeem themselves. Wouldn't you rather live in a world where everyone was healthy and reasonable and disciplined? Yes. And kind. Exactly. All right? But humans by themselves cannot actually achieve that state because humans by definition are sinful.
Right? That's why we had the fall from grace. That 's why uh we were banished from the Garden of Eden. But again, this isn' what you believe or and this this is you're just saying what you believe the the Freemasons believe. Yeah, I I rarely tell people what I actually believe. I'm just giving you insight into who these people are and what they believe. Sure. Okay? All right? So um if you really want to know more about the Freemasons, I suggest reading a book called Morals and Dogma by Albert Pike, who is considered the father of American Freemasonry. Yeah, Albert Pike. Um and uh if you read a lot of classic American texts that have guided American policy, there's a tremendous um you can feel the tremendous influence of Freemasonry.
So the classic example is um uh Zbigniew Brzezinski. He, along with Henry Kissinger, were the two grand um um foreign policy um strategists of the United States during the Cold War. And um if you read what he writes, Zbigniew Brzezinski, and he's absolutely brilliant, he's not a Freemason, but everything he writes is Freemasonic. Uh you it aligns perfectly with the Kabbalah and aligns perfectly with Albert Pike. So I'm not saying that there's this grand conspiracy where the Knights Templar founded Freemasonry and then it um went over to England. Okay? People do say that. I don't say that. I'm saying like there's an ideas that embed themselves into cultural practices.
And when these cultural practices spread, these ideas spread as well. All right? So um if you're the elite, you behave in a certain way that draws you to the Kabbalah, that draws you to Freemasonry. And so even though uh there are people um who probably don't even know what Freemasonry is and who are not exposed to Freemasonry ideas, they behave in a way that is very Freemasonic. And that's one thing about these AI people. They grow up in a culture that is heavily influenced by free Freemasonry. And so they adopt ideas that are very Freemasonic, which is and one idea is AI control grid in order to perfect and redeem humanity from their sins and vices.
I am one of these people who knows nothing about Freemasonry. And I wasn't expecting that I mean I I was expecting that we were going to sit down and talk about AI, but I didn't I wasn't expecting secret societies. is connected. Right. So that's what I was going to say is that it puts me in a a difficult position because I have never heard or I've I've obviously heard of Freemasons before, but I I haven't ever really read into them. But am I correct in understanding that to get to what you believe about AI, we this is this is crucial to it? Yes. All right. So let me explain what Freemasonry is.
Yeah, let's start with the beginning then of Freemasonry. we've talked about the beginning of capitalism. Mhm. And capitalism was very removed from the traditional religious experience because for most of history, religion was understood the world that we live in as false. And the spiritual world is what's real. And so you were taught to like just ignore money or material things and just embrace the spiritual and the divine. That's certainly what Catholics are taught. That's what Muslims are taught. That's what a lot of Jews are taught as well. But with the coming of capitalism, and again, last time we taught I I did mention that capitalism was a historical accident, right?
Mhm. A convergence of connected it to Calvinism. That's right. That's right. Okay. But now that you have capitalism, it goes against the traditional religious experience because capitalism was about the accumulation of wealth, right? Um so you need you need a new religion in order to justify capitalism, in order to promote capitalism. That new religion was called Freemasonry. All right? Um because what Freemasons do, and that's really important is they believe the one and true God is reason. Okay? Can we get back to when and where Freemasonry began before we before we talk about the tenets of that?
early 18th century. The early 18th century? Where? In uh in Britain. They celebrate reason as the one and true God. Okay? From that perspective, God created the world and then God left because God doesn't care. But God left behind the capacity to reason. And so reason is divine spark in us. And so we must exercise our reason in order to achieve divinity. Okay? We have the means to achieve a divinity which is reason, but we must exercise it. We must get everyone to exercise it if we are to create paradise. All right? And you got to remember, God is gone. Okay? So only we can do this. Um so but if you do more analysis, okay?
For the first time in human history, what's happened is reason is considered a concept separate from emotion. Okay? And if you just look at history, you look at the ancient Greeks, the Chinese, the Indians, everyone appreciated that reason came from emotion. Okay? If you want to think, you have to do so with your heart, not with your brain. The Freemasons invert this and say, no, um reason comes before emotion. Reason is separate from from from emotion, which is counterintuitive. Right? Uh if to neuroscientists today, I mean, just go talk to any neuroscientist at Stanford, they'll be like, well, um emotions are the basis for memories, right?
So emotions is the basis for who we are. So we want to think we have to we have to do so with with emotions. The Freemasons were adamant about separating reason from emotion. Why? Because in their religion, capital was reason, and anything that opposed capital was emotion, okay? So what opposed capitalism? Prejudice, tradition, family, love, nationalism, God, okay? And these things work as their emotions. So if we want to achieve perfection, if we wanted to be reasonable, we need to discard all these things including God, including uh the king, including family, including prejudice. Okay? And that's why we live in the world we live in today.
We go to Stanford, what are you taught? Open borders, right? Racism is the worst thing in the world. Reason is what is what matters. Right? This is a direct We live in a world created by the Freemasons, right? Because the Freemasons were trying to promote capitalism to the best of their ability, and so they promoted reason as the ultimate good, the ultimate God. And they believe that through our use of reason, we could perfect the world that we live in today. Okay? And so maybe even maybe even though Freemasons are not as dominant as they as they used to be, the reason why is Freemasonic thought and value system have become embedded into Western society so that it's just the air that we live and breathe.
Who today would tell you multiculturalism is wrong? Or um bigotry is good, or prejudice is is is good? You can't say that. You you'd be you'd be banished from Stanford. You you'd be you'd be expelled from Stanford. Right? At this point, I don't know if this is really pushback, but I totally agree with you that wherever it came from, Western culture, especially culture in the academy, is it centers around reason. Atheism is is what's in vogue. But but but reason not as anti-religion, anti-family, Okay? Mhm. It it's it's a pure form of reason, and it's capital, right? Think think about it. What in in our real world translates directly into reason?
Money. Money uh makes the world go around, right? It shouldn't matter if you're black or white. All that matters is how much money you have you have in your bank account. Right? Where I'm losing you is why this is so relevant to the discussion of AI, just because I feel like a much simpler way of understanding why AI has become as powerful and ubiquitous in like the Bay Area as it is is is just because it's a new technology that's proving to be or at least it looks like it will be extremely profitable. No. These people, if you actually go and actually meet these people, they think AI is God. They think AI is a god that will deem humanity.
That's why they're so into it. Um they these people are insane. And Do you have like evidence for for saying that like Sam Altman or Dario Amodei they they think that AI is God? Are these the people that you're referring to? Um have you talked to Karen Hao yet? No. You should. Who's this? Karen Hao is um a reporter who uh who's done a lot of research into AI. She's she graduated from MIT, so she knows this stuff technically. And she spent um 10 years investigating companies like OpenAI, and she wrote a book called Empire of AI. Um, and she says this. Yeah. And again, I hate to say this, but if you do any basic research into these people, uh, you would know they're very religious.
But but in a Freemasonic sense. Um, so uh, back back to my original point is that why all this is important is for these people, what they recognize is people are too stupid to actually use the reason. So you need to create an illusion or a hallucination to to force people to use the reason or believe in reason. So let reason be manifested into AI, right? Right? Who cares if AI is fake as long as people believe it's real? If you go to school and the teacher tells you to uh, work out and be healthy and you don't listen, that clearly doesn't work, okay? Let's try a new system where it's which is like let's pretend uh, to create an AI which everyone believes is real and is living and is tapping into a interdimensional spiritual force.
And let this AI tell you to go work out and live a healthy life. Would you do so? Probably. Why? Because they're stupid. I'm not really sure I mean where to take this conversation just because I wasn't expecting it to go in this direction. Not that it's a bad direction, but most of the conversations that I've been having about AI have had to do either with whether or not it's poised to cause tremendous economic displacement and strife for people or people that you know like Eliezer Yudkowsky or Nate Soares about whether or not it poses an existential threat. And these are the two discussions that I see most prominent publicly.
Why do they not interest you as much, these two discussions? Because they are meant to delude us to thinking that AI is more powerful than it is, that AI is an independent entity um and we are about to lose control over it. And if you again, if you actually look at the technology, it doesn't really do that much. I I've already spent like a long time explaining to you how like the actual technology works. If you talk to um a computer programmer, the person will tell you the same thing if the person is honest. Okay, most of the people are not actually honest. So they will put some hocus pocus into the explanations.
And quite honestly, a lot a lot of them don't even know how the actual mechanism works. They just do their little part. Um but first of all, is my explanation of AI clear to you? Yeah, I think it it's clear enough. I think it's capable. Okay. But you don't think so. I I I think there are limited applications to AI, okay? As it is. And the only way that they can get around that is if they make put people believe that AI is more than it is, that AI is a living god or a living demon, all right? So um um again, there are lots of sources which tell us that um these people who work in AI, they do involve the occult.
All right? So um can you very quickly just just just Google this? Okay, um do you do do do you have a phone? Uh I don't have my phone, but You you you you you have to do this otherwise it's hard for us to have a conversation. Sure. Do you want Could you Google something for us? Okay. So New Yorker, uh Ronan Farrow, OpenAI, summoning demons. Thanks, Harold. So so just just look at this, okay? This is to do quote from the New Yorker magazine. Sure. From an AI researcher who's telling Ronan Farrow, the reporter, that OpenAI is trying to summon demons. Do you want me to read it? Yeah, just just read it.
Sure. An investigative report by Ronan Farrow and Andrew Marantz in New Yorker magazine details claims from an anonymous former OpenAI executive describing Sam Altman's scaling of AI infrastructure as building portals from which we're genuinely summoning aliens. The comment emerged in the context of OpenAI's massive Stargate infrastructure expansion and data center plans in Abu Dhabi. You can read the full article at New Yorker magazine. Okay, look. They're using a lot of occult terminology, Stargate. Okay, this is an occult term that goes back thousands of years to the Egyptians. Why Why is this entire project called Operation Stargate?
Why are these researchers telling like Ronan Farrow, a reporter for New Yorker, oh, we're trying to summon demons? Why is this happening? Because what they understand is everything is the occult. Everything, okay? Um, what is money? Money is just the occult. It's the It's alchemy, right? Somehow we've been We've created a society where I take this piece of paper and people will slave over it. They will work 18 hours a day uh driving themselves crazy to obtain more and more of it, thinking that this is the path to salvation, right? It's the occult. If you want true power, you have to practice the occult.
And what is the occult? The occult is controlling and capturing the imagination of people and directing in a way that allows you to control them, right? Money is a classic example of this. It's alchemy, right? What is alchemy? Turning lead into gold. We've accomplished that with money. We've taken, again, this worthless piece of paper and turn it into gold that everyone thirst for. People are willing to slave in school and abandon their entire soul in order to go get a job, in order to abandon their soul, in order to obtain green bucks, money, because they think this is a path to salvation and redemption, right?
AI is the same thing. And And that's what these people recognize, that if you want true power, you have to practice the occult, right? So this technology by itself, I I already told you, does nothing. Okay? All it does is search and sort from a database. Big deal. But if you can get people to believe that there's an demonic energy to AI, right? You can summon demons using Operation Stargate, then people will bow down before AI. Because people have this religious need that needs to needs to be fulfilled. And once they obey the AI, then you have control over them. And they can do whatever you want.
Then we need to work for money anymore. They just work for the stupid AI. If you can get people to to believe this. And this has been true throughout the I mean, you know, people have been worshiping statues for thousands of years, believing that this statue is a manifestation of a divine being, right? And And so that's the world that these people want to create. Before we continue, I just want to make sure that you don't feel that I'm being disrespectful to you in some way. Do you Is Is Do you feel that I am? Um I just feel that um if you um have um um I I just feel as though you're kind of too wedded to a certain paradigm.
Mhm. Does that make sense? Um and and you take it for granted that these people um are not nefarious in any way and that they are perfectly reasonable um and and I think it's because you're a byproduct of meritocracy. Because I I I I know because I was a byproduct of of meritocracy and you're basically indoctrinated into a certain deference to these people Mhm. when I don't think this deference is actually deserved. Um and I think that that's how the meritocracy works and if you did not behave in this this way, I think it'd be very hard for you to do well in school. I guess there's a difference between me being sort of showing deference to these people or being wedded to the meritocracy and being disrespectful to you because I feel like in allowing you to say what you want and and disagreeing with you when I disagree with you that I'm I'm being respectful and open.
All right. Let me ask you this question. Do you think there's very little cheating in science, some cheating, or a lot of cheating in science? And what what I mean like this what what I mean is you know a scientist what you need to do is do an experiment and then tabulate the results and then write a paper explaining your findings to a uh in the peer review journal. Yes? Mhm. No, I think that there is rampant um cheating. And I I would say there is a tremendous amount of cheating because uh what people don't appreciate is most of these experiments cannot be replicated. I'm saying the majority of these experiments cannot be replicated.
So if you're a social scientist and you do a psychology experiment that shows one result, uh other people if they try to replicate this experiment can't actually do it. You can't get the same results. So there's a lot of cheating going on uh throughout science. So if that's the case, then why would we assume that these computer science are computer scientists are extremely uh rigorous and precise in what they do. Right? What is it I'm And again, I'm not trying to be I'm really I really am not trying to be disrespectful, but I'm wondering what it is that you're trying to convince me of right now.
Is it Are you trying to convince me that a lot of the people who are in power in tech, whether it's Mark Zuckerberg or Sam Altman, that these people believe in the occult and that they believe that they are summoning demons, or you want me to you want to convince me that their goal is to have the public believe this? Right. So um okay, let let me phrase it in this way. Uh there's a widespread belief that there's a rigor to computer science that doesn't exist anywhere else because you're programming the software. And it's like building a bridge, right? If you screw up building a bridge, you will know you screw up the building bridge cuz it'll collapse on you, okay?
Um so we assign a certain level of faith to engineers in computer science. We will not assign to lawyers and doctors because lawyers lawyers and doctors can just mix stuff up and I totally agree with that. we we we know that, okay? And what I would say is I mean, one way of putting it is that computer scientists work with formal languages. Formal languages like mathematics are very rigorous in that they there are very specific rules. In that sense, I would say that I certainly believe that computer scientists are working in a in a rigorous fashion. Right. But we also know that once you increase incentives too much, then people are much more liable to cheat.
Okay. And right now, there's so much money in AI, right? And the incentives are just too high for people not to cheat. Oh, well, I'm I'm I wouldn't want to make any claim whatsoever about whether computer computer scientists are more likely to cheat or lie or defraud or steal than lawyers or doctors. That's an empirical question and it could totally go one way or the other. So I I mean, if what you want me to want to convince me of is that computer scientists are just as likely to be or more likely to be liars or charlatans as doctors and lawyers, then you don't really need to convince me of that.
I'm totally willing to just accept that as part of your argument and then assuming that we can move on. All right all right. So so so let me complete my logic, okay? Sure. This AI technology is not as impressive as people think it is. Uh it has very limited applications. Can can we talk about that though for a little bit because that seems to be something that we disagree about. Okay. Because sure I I I mean AI right now it uh it can't power robots that will walk among us and and do everything that a human does, but AI I find extremely useful if I want to analyze a transcript for the podcast or if I I'm currently working with AI to help post things on social media or if I want to do research on a project, it does seem extremely capable in the sense that it is able to displace people doing common jobs that can be performed on a computer.
And it's able to clearly make breakthroughs in mathematics. And again, we're only a few years into this technology and it seems like it's going to it's getting better and better. So I don't know what you mean when you say it's it's got such limited applications. So my kind of argument is this. If you take really smart people and give them AI, AI is an amplifier. So it amplifies your intelligence because you actually know what you want, you know how to use AI to achieve what you want, Mhm. right? So AI is an amplifier. But um AI cannot replace a smart person, right? So I cannot You cannot build an AI to come interview me and achieve the same result as if you are interviewing me.
Okay? So that's something that we need to appreciate. Technology historically has always been an accelerant or an amplifier. Sure. But it does not actually replace really smart, talented people. Now you could make the argument this, okay? You could make the argument that we live in a world we have too many people and most of these people, quite frankly, are redundant. All right? So you go There's something called the 80/20 rule. I'm not sure if you've heard of this, right? But you go into a hospital, guess what? Only about a fraction of the doctors are actually competent. The rest are not that competent.
So you can make the argument that AI would be good for that because AI would allow hospitals to become much more efficient because you get rid of the dead dead wood and you let the good doctors uh do what they specialize in doing and you let AI uh amplify their impact, right? So they're able to do diagnosis much faster, they're much able to um um communicate effectively with with their patients, okay? That You can make that argument. But is that a society in which we want to live in? Right? And so And also my question is um do you need AI to even to do that? Why can't you just fire those doctors and just go with uh your best doctors?
I used to run schools and I used to work in a school. And um when I ran a school, I believed in a very lean uh workforce. So I had very few staffers and I had um teachers, but no full-time teachers. They were all ad hoc, adjunct. They came, they taught the class, they were paid, well-paid, then they left. Okay? And my students loved that school. It was efficient. They It was student-centered. All their needs were taken care of. Okay? That's when I ran the school. A very lean, mean workplace that was focused on ensuring students learned. All right? Mhm. I've worked in schools where there were lots of teachers.
And And when you have lots of teachers, what happens? Office politics. And what is office politics? Office politics means like no one No teacher can excel because if one teacher teaches better than other teachers, it makes every teacher look bad. So office politics was uh designed to ensure that the best teachers cannot perform or outperform everyone else. Right? And how you did that was you took other teachers out to dinner, you had team meetings, you had um you had a lot lots of um um activities to build up team spirit. But that was just to make sure that everyone was a team player. Okay? And guess what?
That's how most workplaces are. People themselves who are really smart will do really well. But if you put them in a group of people, these really smart people may not be that well-performing because they need to take into consideration the feelings of pretty mediocre people around them. Right? And this is something that I've observed. I mean, we can argue about this, but but I'm just saying like most jobs tend to be redundant. And they they exist in order to keep people occupied. Right? Um in schools, one thing that I've learned is the teachers are first and for foremost focused on keeping their jobs.
And And means doing as as little as possible and maintaining solidarity so that you can defy the principle or any parents. And I would say that's that's true for most institutions including universities. This is again, I hope you don't think I'm being disrespectful, but this is my fault. I mean I took an all nighter here, so maybe it's just because I'm I'm quite sleep deprived, but I don't understand the connection between this and whether or not AI is super capable. And I will again for the sake of argument totally grant that AI at this point I mean it requires human data on which to train. It I mean requires humans to operate the data centers in which it runs, humans to give it the power that it uses.
And if it has somebody like me who's using it who is as at least an IQ of 101 it can do some some pretty good things. But to me that means that doesn't mean it's incapable. It is still just a tool. Let's try to differentiate which is like how do the elite think and what do they want? Well, they want to create a more well organized more efficient society. I do believe that that's true. Okay. All right. And so for them the question is like Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. The elites or the counter elites? The elites. Okay, because I would think of so in an earlier conversation you described the elites are the people who can control the system and make the system serve them serve their needs.
This this is complicated, okay? But but this is something to keep in mind, okay? Different layer society, there are different competitions and there are different rules, okay? Mhm. So the elite, as I said in a previous conversation, they exist in order to control uh policy making to benefit them. Okay? They they exist to uh capture the state apparatus in order to generate as much personal benefit to them as possible. Okay? But over time, the elite um expands too fast because they have children or more more people are brought into the elite. In which case, you have different factions emerge with different worldviews or strategies for how to best do this.
And this is this is the what's happening today where in the United States, there's a clear demarcation or conflict between the global financial elite as represented by Wall Street and City of London and the tech bros, Silicon Valley. And where this fight is being manifested is in crypto cryptocurrency. Right? So what is the power of the financial elite? Their power is to print money by issuing out loans as well as to raise capital. Right? So your company and you want to uh raise capital, how do you do so? You have to list on the stock market. And how do you list on the stock market? You have to go through one of the investment banks, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, who cares.
Okay? But it's monopoly. If you are the counter elite, you're like that's a inefficient system. So we have a better system of how to do this, which is cryptocurrency, stable coins. Right? So rather than borrow money directly from the bank, you can now just buy a stable coin. So what's happening is in Washington DC, um lawmakers are trying to institutionalize cryptocurrency. So cryptocurrency is just um um whatever company wants to um issue. Okay? So just think of it as a token. Right? Now um last summer, the United States Congress it just passed something called the GENESIS Act. What the GENESIS Act did was link tokens to US Treasuries.
So in theory, you could redeem your tokens for US Treasuries. Okay? And this is what they call stable coins because before um tokens were just worth as much as people believed they were worth, right? But now they're tied to Treasuries. And now they're tied to US Treasuries because you could always redeem these tokens for US Treasuries. Mhm. All right. Now what they're trying to do is they're trying to pass something called the Clarity Act. What the Clarity Act is trying to do is provide a regulatory framework for stable coins, which means that by law um institutional investors like hedge funds and pension funds can now buy stable coins.
Okay? And also what's really important is also with this regulatory framework framework in place, foreign savers like the Chinese and Japanese, they can now directly purchase stable coins and that's a workaround to buy US Treasuries. If you think about it, if the Clarity Act passes, it negates the financial monopoly because now companies can just issue issue tokens, stable coins in order to raise capital. It doesn't need to go list on the stock market anymore. Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan have don't aren't able to uh do any underwriting anymore. And now if you are a consumer, you can you can just um buy stable coins to invest in a company.
You don't have to buy stocks anymore. Um and companies can issue tokens as a loan if you provide collateral, right? So what this is doing is bypassing the traditional banking system. Okay? And this is an example of where the leads and the counter leads are fighting over the best strategy of how to govern, right? The old elite, they want to maintain the traditional banking system. The tech bros want to use the cryptocurrency cryptocurrencies to system because the idea is that this will be a much more stable, much more transparent, and much more open system than the current banking system. Again, I don't understand how this even even accepting that there is this battle between the um the counter elite tech bros and the financial elites, I don't understand how this connects to whether or not AI is capable, which is what we were talking about a couple of minutes ago when I said I didn't understand the connection to the to the doctor story.
Right, okay. So it doesn't matter if AI is capable. Okay, so we can we should set that aside? Yeah, it doesn't Is that Is that relevant? What's relevant is can you get people to believe that AI is omniscient and omnipresent, okay? And I wouldn't say that I believe that by any means that it's omniscient or omnipresent, but what I suppose the world of tech has effectively convinced me of a couple of things. Uh I'm convinced that AI is super capable and poised to displace tons of jobs. I believe that because most jobs are redundant. Okay. Okay, so Not that because AI is capable, I'm just saying that most jobs are just redundant.
They're useless. Well, even useful jobs, I mean, take graphic designers, for instance. I mean, I think designing labels for people's brands or I mean, designing book covers, that's a useful job, but it's something that AI can do and it can displace graphic designers. So those are I mean, that's just one example of a a whole class of people that I could see AI displacing. And whether or not this was a sort of operation of of whether or not you want to think Eliezer Yudkowsky or or Nate Soros or in the employ of the tech industry, which I don't think they are, but I mean, sure, it's possible that they are.
But I am also pretty convinced based on conversations with them that whether AI is autonomous or not, it's irrelevant. AI could pose a huge danger to us, whether it's used by um nation states or by just rogue actors to create biological warfare. How? I I don't understand. How can AI be a threat to us? So the one one example is I mean the hacking that we already see now. It could be very destabilizing. Hugging Face or financial institutions, the Australian government recently. you and you you take these AI companies at their word, right? You think that they're being truthful when they say that oh, we don't know how these autonomous AI agents uh conspired amongst themselves and they broke all the parameters that we set on them.
And uh yeah, you you believe these people? I do believe these people. I haven't actually questioned whether or not I think the Hugging Face incident could be faked or some of the other things, the other hacking incidents, but you think you believe that they didn't actually happen. that once incentives are too high, people are incentivized to cheat line steal. Sure. I totally agree with that. Floppic is about to go public. It's a $2 trillion valuation. How can it justify a $2 trillion valuation? If you read the prospectus, it is the weirdest thing in the world cuz like it's almost like a quarter uh of the prospectus, okay?
Which you go into the financials, is about risk. Oh, uh there's a risk that we could destroy of humanity. I don't want to hear that crap. I want to hear how you will make money. And they don't discuss that at all, right? So them discussing Hugging Face, them discussing the threat to humanity, it's a way to divert attention from the fact that these companies don't know how to make money. So I'm perfectly willing to grant again that that a lot of this is marketing. That oh, we we need people to know that our technology is so dangerous and powerful because that way people like everybody wants to be using the best AI.
So, if if Anthropic's AI is the one that's capable of hacking all the government organizations, of course they're they're going to be telling people that. But I I mean, can I say for certain that I know that these incidents were real? No. I can't say that, but I'm inclined to believe that they are. Okay. Well, I'm inclined to believe they aren't they they aren't because again, all that I know about AI tells me that that didn't happen. And again, if you think that there's something wrong in my understanding of AI, you can tell me. Okay? But but I've been very clear about how I understand AI to work, right?
You you establish a database, okay, a data set that is the sum total of all knowledge in uh in your universe, and then you use a algorithm, a neural network in order to search and sort this information in a way that it most appeals to the user. And so, given that, I don't know how this translates into humanity is doomed. So, you don't think that AI can be used to hack at all? What do you mean by hack? I I I I I don't I'm not quite sure what you mean by that. So, I guess an example would be you do not think that somebody can use AI and gain access to a system that they're not authorized to gain access to and take information from that system.
Why can't people do that without AI now? I mean, people certainly do do it now. So, what's the difference? But they might be able to develop new ways of doing it, or do existing ways better using AI. I'm not a hacker, but that just seems like it doesn't seem outside the realm of possibility that I mean, it seems quite possible that people are doing this. I would need like a a very good reason to believe that it's not possible. But but why do you need a good reason to believe it's not possible? And and why not a good reason to think it is possible? Why why you uh choosing to air on the side of the AI companies as opposed to against the AI companies?
Why are you so sympathetic towards these AI companies? So I think all else being equal, I think that the news organizations, etc., I want to take them at their word. I think you don't, and I I understand that. I don't I don't think that we're being told the truth 100% of the time, but I guess it's just I have a a basic faith in institutions because there are lots of checks and balances within them. And that doesn't mean that some things don't slip through the cracks, but it seems like it would be very difficult to fabricate all of these instances. Why is the US military losing this war against Iran right now?
I asked you that earlier. I I I know why, but I'm asking you why you think this is happening. That's a good question. From talking to people who are much more educated about it than I am, for instance, um Robert Pape a couple of days ago, he said that he attributes two main things to us not winning this war at this point. One is Iran's control of the Strait of Hormuz and how they have this stranglehold, this chokehold on oil. And another is their use of cheap drones in something that we can't combat. Okay. So But I But I will totally admit that again, I don't understand really why a country as big and and as ostensibly powerful as the United States can't defeat Iran.
It doesn't really make sense to me. like um why didn't these extremely well-paid um officials in the United States government tell Donald Trump actually, you know, um the first thing the Iranians are going to do when you start bombing them is close out the Strait of Hormuz and there's nothing we can do about it. And um our aircraft carriers aren't any aren't any good against the Iranians because they have like these cheap drones. Did no one tell Trump this? But I I also don't think we're in disagreement about the possibility that personal interests play a huge role at in politics, even at the highest level.
So no, wait, wait, wait. So I'm confused here. Why do you assume that personal interest plays a role in politics, but personal interest doesn't play a role in the mainstream media or in universities or in any bureaucratic institution? No, I do. Right, then why do you take what their word, the mainstream news, at face value? Why do you believe what the New York Times tells you? I don't believe everything the New York Times tells me, but I need a very good reason to believe that it is not true when it tells me something. And I don't feel that I have a very good reason to believe that the hugging face incident was fabricated.
It very well could have been, but I haven't been given a smoking gun, so to speak, that tells me it was fabricated. I think a good way of putting it is that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to back them up. No, no, no, no. You see, that's the problem here, okay? They're the ones making the claim this happened, right? So that's an extraordinary claim. And therefore they should have evidence that this actually happened, correct? You don't think that there's any evidence that it actually happened? No. Okay. Interesting. I mean this is a a point where as with our last conversation the onus or the burden of proof be on the skeptics as opposed to the people making these claims?
That makes no sense to me. No, that seems like a fair point. I am totally right now making the assumption that there is evidence that the hugging face incident happened. And I would invite all of our listeners to to check that out. And if there is no evidence whatsoever that hugging face happened Look look look. These are the same people, OpenAI, who told Ronan Farrow that they're using Operation Stargate to summon demons to our world. I I don't understand why people take like hear about hugging face like okay, yeah, I believe that. And then they hear like in the New Yorker, one of the most prestigious magazine in the world, by Ronan Farrow, who is one of the most accomplished reporters in the world, that these AI researchers are telling him that they're using it to summon demons and people like oh, that's just you know, don't worry about that.
That's just just let's just ignore that. Okay, so about that in particular, I did read that out loud a couple of minutes ago and people will have seen that or they can scroll back to see it. And if I recall correctly, it was an X OpenAI, an anonymous X OpenAI executive said this, right? So one, it's anonymous. That's that's fine, but it makes me question things. I'm still assuming that it's the New Yorker. They verified their source and it was indeed an anonymous X OpenAI executive. One, I mean I need to question why he's not an OpenAI executive anymore. you should interview Karen Hao because she's a very good reporter.
She wrote a very good book. And she heard from another source at OpenAI that that's exactly what they're doing. But even if it was an ex-Open AI executive, people have crazy psychic breaks. I mean, do you believe that they're summoning demons there? Okay, again, once you understand the cult and its impact on society, then all this makes sense, okay? So what I'm going to do is I I want to step back and go into some theory. Okay, but can you answer that? Like, do you believe that they there are demons out there and they are summoning them? Um what I believe is that um there are many different consciousness in the world, okay?
So what are we? We are embodied consciousness. Okay. Okay, does that make sense? Sure. But then there has to be disembodied consciousness as well. Okay, so you believe that there is embodied and disembodied consciousness? Right. And what and what this is what people call historically spirits, right? Okay, so you And you look at any society and they're like, well, they are uh jinn, there are fairies, there are spirits all around us. And I think this is the way of them describing a disembodied consciousness that they feel in their lives. And um you know, it's really interesting, but people who never actually went for the meritocracy um they intuitively understand this.
But if you've been for the meritocracy, it is almost like um impossible to uh explain to you or convince you that uh these disembodied consciousness exist, right? I I don't know for a fact that they exist. I cannot prove to you Right, and I can't prove that they don't exist. Okay. But I think that's what they're referring to. They're referring to the idea of disembodied consciousness that's floating all around us. Um and uh they believe that AI could provide a body for them. So in their minds, they are literally summoning demons through Operation Stargate. Are Will they be able to succeed? I don't think so.
But, and this is really important, according to the cult, they don't have to succeed. They just have to try and convince people, enough people, that they can succeed. All right. Um, so having said that, let me go into some theory. Okay. So have you studied Immanuel Kant? Yes, a little bit. All right. So Immanuel Kant was a breakthrough in philosophy because he makes the argument that an objective reality doesn't exist, right? Um, um, so I don't know about that. He thinks that there's something called the noumenon out there, which is something that we can't ever make direct contact with. Yeah. I don't know if you can say that it doesn't exist.
it's things in themselves, right? Um, the only thing that we can experience is the phenomena, right? Uh, things that we see. And what he what he also argues is the noumena doesn't really matter. Who cares? It's just energy waves. It could be anything, okay? But we can never actually access it. Uh, why? Because our brains are structured in a way to filter out the noumena to create the phenomena, okay? We filter the noumena to create the phenomena because we can never actually uh, interface We can never actually understand the noumena. It would It would drive us insane. Um, so we use time and space to filter out reality and turn it into the phenomena, the things that things that things uh, that we can see, things that we can interact with, okay?
And And this is a revolution of breakthrough in philosophy, as you know, because for the longest time um, philosophy was dominated either by the empiricists or the rationalists. And And this met This was meant to be a compromise, the idea that we are active participants in the universe, okay? So that's Kant. Now, you also know Plato's Allegory of the Cave, right? Yes. And the idea of Plato's Allegory of the Cave is you have a lot of people chained up and they're all sitting on a wall. And the only thing can see our shadows projected from a large fire, okay? And there are people around this fire that manipulating the shadows to create this false reality.
Right? And that's and that's the idea here, okay? What Kant tells us is our consciousness is what creates reality. And and Plato was telling us that there are people, the elite, who manipulate our consciousness in order to create a reality that is false. Right? And so we've discussed capital and how that's a false reality. Is it alchemy? Is it turning money into gold? Paper into gold, right? But AI is the same thing where AI, it's just a dumb machine. It's it's just a recursive loop, right? But if you get can can people to believe that it's alive, then anything is possible. Then people will bow down and worship the AI.
Right? Let's let's just do a thought experiment and just say like, you know what? Let's just take an AI, okay, a ChatGPT. Give it an avatar like Satan, what who cares, okay? And then, you know, we'll project this avatar onto indigenous people in the Amazon. Would they believe that this was Satan? Would they worship Satan? Yes, they would. Right? So what's stopping these companies from doing the same thing at scale to the entire world? Nothing really. Just a memory of something before, but that memory can be wiped out. Right? Just as we wiped out the memory of what money used to be before. Right?
I mean like I mean everything that I've said about money is lost history. Stopping Frank is are a lost history. But if I tell it to you, it makes sense because it it helps you tie up a lot of knots that you learned in history class, but which never really made sense to you. Which means that history can be manipulated. So, wait a generation, okay? You have a new generation, you control the schools, you can draw the textbooks, and they're taught that AI is alive. And they'll believe that. They'll they'll they'll hear they'll read about the Hugging Face incident. They'll they'll read about um Operation Stargate and how that infused uh consciousness into AI.
And they'll they won't know anything else, okay? Because everything's been extracted from them. No one actually knows how AI works, right? Just as like no one actually understands how the banking system works. You talk to economists at Stanford, a lot of them actually don't understand this basic principle of how capital was created in the first place. They don't understand things like the Bank of England, uh the Glorious Revolution. I wasn't taught this stuff at Yale. I'm pretty sure that if I were to go to Yale and talk to these these Nobel Prize-winning economics professors and I explained to them the history of capitalism, they would think you're just insane.
What do you know? What's your evidence for this? Do you do you have any peer-reviewed like journal articles to show me? Well, cite your sources, right? That's exactly what would happen. But if I were to tell a normal person this history of capitalism, they'd be like, oh, that makes sense, yeah. Right? So, the same thing will will happen a generation from now where um AI becomes the new god and everyone bows down before it. And we believe that it's always been around and that was AI that was curating history and leading to the development um that we live in today. I think that we should save Kant and Plato for another conversation.
I think that the quote that you showed me was interesting uh about the summoning demons. You said that you believe that there are there's consciousness, embodied consciousness, then there's disembodied consciousness. And what is important, what's most significant, is that the AI executives have the world believe that they are summoning um spirits. But do you also believe that the AI executives are in fact summoning spirits? They believe they are, yes. But do you believe that they are? I do, but there's a difference. Yeah, tell me. They believe they're summoning the demons into the machine. So it becomes a ghost in the machine, right?
I think they're summoning demons into our consciousness. It is there's a difference. A big difference. How are How do you believe that they're summoning this disembodied consciousness into our consciousness? What is Hollywood? What do you mean? What is Hollywood? A film industry. No, it's not. It's an occult industry. Its job is to summon ideas into our minds, to capture our imagination, and make us see the world the same way. Right? That's what Hollywood is. That's what all media is. They practice the occult. Hollywood. Right? Interesting. Well, it's I I just wouldn't refer to ideas as spirits.
So I'm wondering if this is just a different use of historically they have referred to ideas as spirits, okay? So you read Homer, the Iliad, the Odyssey, right? What was uh Apollo? What was Athena? They were ideas. Right? That became manifest because at that time people expressed themselves using metaphors. So uh I'm not sure if if you read Homer, the Iliad, the Odyssey. I have read that. Okay. All right. Well, um the argument that uh Julian Jaynes makes in his book um The Bicameral Mind is that historically we have two uh compartments to the brain, the left and the right hemisphere. And what happened is the right hemisphere would interact with all this disembodied consciousness and basically uh take these ideas and and transform them into embodied figures, right?
So like creativity became Apollo and uh wisdom became Athena, okay? And the left brain would um try to systematize and categorize this in a more reasonable way to allow us to function in society, okay? And he said that the major revolution was uh with the coming of monotheism and the destruction of this pagan world so that we basically shut off our uh right brains. And then these these um disembodied consciousness like Athena, Apollo that we believe to be around us became concepts in the left brain. So we basically shut off the right brain to focus on the left brain. And that is what gave rise to modern day consciousness.
That's why we having the conversation that we having, right? That's why we discuss things and ideas. Whereas before people were having the same conversations, if you read the Republic, right? The conversations they were having were not as they they were just as deep or even deeper than the conversations that we have in real life. But they were using metaphors um uh as opposed to abstractions, right? So before they would say Apollo, we would say creativity. Before they would say Athena, we would say um wisdom. I think that back then was a superior system because they appreciated the impact of ideas in our everyday lives.
Ideas were real, right? so Athena would embody herself and follow Talos and you know this is around guiding them, okay? And you can argue that ideas do the same thing because we've abstracted ideas into just concepts. We don't appreciate their impact on us, okay? That's And something that I've been trying to emphasize uh throughout these conversations where look, Freemasonry still exists as an idea. And therefore, you can actually believe Freemason as a god that works around us, okay? Sabbatean Frankism still exists as an idea. Um and so you can think of it as a god that's working around us. So even though um you know, Sabbatean Frankism may be defunct as a movement, you know, no one actually considers himself or herself to be Sabbatean Frankist, it still has a huge impact in society because these ideas have become a disembodied consciousness that is able to manipulate society around us.
Okay? And And And that's what I believe. What other key points of your beliefs about AI do you think that we ought to touch on in this conversation so that our listeners have a a comprehensive view of your understanding of the topic? Um so um I think there's been an AI bubble collapse um because there just isn't enough liquidity to support this bubble continuing. I mean, eventually it's going to burst because there's not enough air coming in, right? And this is going to force the government to bail out the AI industry. And then we will move towards a Palantir police state, right? So think of like Minority Report where they were able to do predictive uh policing, right?
We're very much moving towards that um world. But something that these um AI tech bros don't appreciate is um um um So So I'll I'll I'll go over the reasons why I think this AI control grid will fail ultimately. Okay? The first major reason is these AI tech bros don't really understand global supply chains. So, um, everything software has to be based on hardware. The software is just a manipulation of hardware. Okay? So, it doesn't matter how good your software is, you need the hardware to be just as good. The problem is that the hardware comes from the global supply chain. Okay? So, if you look at semiconductors, um, there are three critical elements in semiconductors.
There are silicon, there are germanium, there are gallium. Most of this is produced in China because they they are often byproduct byproducts of manufacturing processes. Okay? But then you also need lithium which comes from South America. And then copper. Okay? So, basically it's a global supply chain. Mhm. Right? Now, let's imagine this global supply chain breaks down. Then you can't actually source this material which means that you can actually build out your databases or your data centers. So, there is a um, physical constraint to the amount of compute that you can have in the world. Okay?
So, that's one major problem. Second major problem is to appreciate that every time an elite has attempted to impose its authority on human population, humans have rebelled. Okay? And this includes the meritocracy. Um, and I think the same thing will happen with AI control grid. Never underestimate human the human imagination, uh, human innovation or human ingenuity. Okay? And the Houthis and the Iranians have demonstrated this in the Middle East where the Americans used the advanced weapon system and this war is basically them so fire, okay? I mean the same thing can happen um with AI with the AI build out where if you try to enforce a control grid then uh people will eventually rebel because people aspire to freedom.
That's what really matters in life, freedom. The third thing is you can never um overestimate the stupidity and the arrogance of the elite. Okay? They are not as smart as um people believe them to be. I went to Yale. I was not impressed by my classmates and my professors at Yale when I was an 18 year old or 19 year old. Um and Yale is uh what produces the elite. You're at Stanford so you know the same thing where quite honestly um the people at these schools are no different from most people. Uh maybe they're more ambitious, maybe they're more hardworking but they're not that different. Um but but in terms of arrogance they're very very different.
And the Greeks talk about this a lot where hubris is the great um tragic flaw of humanity and arrogance is and hubris is what leads to the downfall of great empires. So no matter how rich you become, no matter how powerful you become, you can't escape uh hubris. And that and this is what will lead to their downfall. So I don't think the tech bros will succeed. I don't think this control grid will happen in our lifetime. It might happen later on um but it won't happen in our lifetime because the resistance will be too great to the um AI control grid. And I think that ultimately the story that we should be focusing on is not the superiority of technology, how brilliant and sophisticated has become.
Um, what we should really focus on is the enduring resilience um and spirit of humanity. That's the real story and that's something that we should celebrate and cherish. Well, that's something that we can both agree on. So, I think that's a a good note on which to end this third conversation of our marathon day. Um, Jiang, thank you so much for having these conversations with me. Thanks, Robert. Okay, I will be curious to hear whether you found that conversation as peculiar as I did. And I got so much out of it though, even if I don't agree with Jiang about close to anything on this topic and I really don't even understand his thinking that much either but that this just makes me even more grateful to him for joining me on the show actually.
And I'd like to share some reflections about the episode now and then about the three-part series as a whole. So, as I thought about this conversation, my mind kept jumping back to evidence. So, what does count as evidence and when is it reasonable to trust other people and how should we choose between different explanations? I'm not just trying to criticize Jiang's positions here. My hope is also to evaluate my own as well. First, at the heart of our dispute was Jiang's claim that Sam Altman is trying to summon demons through data centers. Now, I totally discount paranormal claims. So, if anyone claims to have experienced something paranormal, my first thought is that they are mistaken, confused, lying, or that something else is going on.
And mainly, I think this comes from the conviction that science has an excellent track record for explaining things in a way that boils down to physics. was wondering how this could be justified more transparently or cleanly. So I recalled a conversation I had with Tim Modlin a month or so ago, which still hasn't come out, in which he brought up David Hume's writings on miracles. And Tim, I'm sure, does a better job of explaining the key points than I will, but I'll do my best. Throughout our lives, we accumulate evidence through testimony from others and also from direct experience. People's testimony often corresponds to reality, but we also know that people lie, misremember, make mistakes, and so on.
On the other hand, experience teaches us how nature behaves, and a miracle is just a violation of a law of nature. For Hume, then, accepting testimony that contradicts a law of nature would require evidence sufficiently strong that would make the report's falsehood less likely than the miraculous event. Jiang's main piece of evidence is that an AI executive claims Sam Altman is summoning demons. But what then could make this claim so credible as to outweigh my accumulated experience of the world? I guess it it would help if I knew more about the unnamed executives, such as that he was Sam's best friend, or if he had extensive photographic records, stolen diary entries from Sam, or evidence of a a well-documented interest in demonology.
But actually, let me read the quote from the New Yorker, the whole paragraph because it's it's quite interesting. The truth of this is we're building portals from which we're genuinely summoning aliens, a former OpenAI executive said. The portals currently exist in the United States and China, and Sam has added one in the Middle East. He went on, I think it's just like wildly important to get how scary that should be. It's the most reckless thing that has been done. First off, the executive says aliens, not demons. And I think that distinction really matters because Jiang kept referring to it as demons.
But if you read the articles, there's no other mention of aliens either. It's it's quite clearer from the context that the executive is speaking metaphorically about the development of advanced non-human intelligence, which very few people, myself included, are disputing. Anyway, second, building off of the inference to the best explanation material that I discussed at the end of the last episode, we have two proposed explanations for the data centers themselves. Mine is that Sam Altman at all are building infrastructure for their AI business, whereas Jiang's adds an occult purpose, so trying to summon demons or getting other people to believe they can.
The question then is given my evidence, how should I select between these two explanations? Let's let's think about that. So I favor the business explanation because I have a great deal of firsthand experience with the technology, with the products, with some of their customers, with the financial incentives of the business, and so on. And this seems like pretty good evidence to motivate the construction of data centers. Jiang's occult I don't know it's if it's occult or occult occult explanation adds this secret clandestine purpose that would require independent evidence I don't have. Granted Jiang does mention a book that he thinks I should read and I haven't read it, but based on how unpersuasive I find his interpretation of the alien summoning quotation and then everything else I know about the world it just doesn't seem worth my time to check out.
His explanation does strike me as a story that fits the evidence, but I still haven't been given independent evidence for it. And this doesn't mean that such evidence doesn't exist or couldn't exist, but I have no good reason to think it does and I have plenty of good reasons not to. So those first two issues that I just mentioned they they didn't cause me any trouble, but the third one did because Jiang had a strong point that in the moment I didn't really have a compelling answer for, which is what prompted these reflections. And when he mentioned the hugging face incidents incident I said that I believed the reporting, but I hadn't personally examined the underlying evidence and when he asked me about it I didn't even know what it was.
Now I think he's he's totally right that we shouldn't trust everything we read in the newspaper. Not only are there plenty of mundane errors printed every day, but newspapers can pass on information from people who are lying. I mean, think of companies like Enron or someone like Bernie Madoff. And then there's government misinformation, there's editorial spins, and the list just goes on. But now I've had some time to think about how to answer Jiong, and what I'd say is this. There are plenty of really good reasons to provisionally trust a major newspaper like The Wall Street Journal. It has a pretty strong track record of delivering accurate information.
It often has identified sources and accessible evidence that's been corroborated by multiple people. And I think it takes its duty pretty seriously to correct mistakes and get its reporting accurate. But there are, of course, also reasons to be cautious, and they range from there being incentives to exaggerate to cognitive biases. So my confidence in something might be higher because I've heard it from multiple sources, but then I might look deeper and find that they'd all gotten the information from one source. In the case of Hugging Face though, there is, now that I've looked into it, an abundance of publicly available evidence.
There's OpenAI's report, there's Hugging Face's technical reconstruction, there are independent investigations, and so on. So the amount of collusion it would have taken to fake this is just staggering, and and the consequence of even one serious misstep would be so huge that it would dwarf any incentives for fabricating the evidence. But to Jiong's point, no, I don't know that everything The Wall Street Journal prints must be true, but I have plenty of good reasons to provisionally trust the majority of what it prints. And if I were going to doubt something, I would need very strong evidence or very strong reasons to do so.
And none of that is really available to me in the hugging face incident. Okay, so those are my three sort of particular reflections about this episode. But now that this three-part series is all set and done and Pins the Pod Cat is wrecking my couch. There are some things I'd like to say about it more generally. So early on in hosting a podcast, I stopped looking at comments because negative comments have an outsized impact on my mental state relative to the positive comments. But because I was so concerned about being banned from YouTube for posting these, I was monitoring the situation more closely.
And one thing that really blows my mind is how many people were upset by these episodes, especially when I found them so useful. So first, they were they were definitely useful for my intellectual growth because they they pushed me to examine questions about evidence and explanation that are important even in everyday life, such as when I now read the newspaper in a bid to be slightly, at least slightly more informed for these interviews. And second, they were useful for my personal growth, I think. I mean, it feels good every now and then to stand by something I think is defensible despite people's anger.
It I don't know. It it's good for self-esteem, I guess. Then there were useful developments for the for the show. I hadn't expected to cover conspiracy theories the way we did or AI and the occult. It was a day full of surprises for me. And they're not topics that I want to revisit every week or ever necessarily. In the case of AI and the occult, I think that's I think once was enough. But it did provoke me to start recording these outros, which I find constructive. And it opened up more options for subjects I could cover in interviews. Most of the comments I saw were either saying that I was an idiot, that Jiyoung is an idiot, or that people hated or loved my introduction and outro.
So it just wasn't super conclusive. And there isn't really too much for me to comment on without coming off as annoyingly defensive. But I am glad that some people found these conversations and what I added to them net positive. That being said, going forward, I'm thinking a a brief introduction and a more extended outro could prove useful, maybe with points of agreement and disagreement, some general reflections, responses to comments if there are any asking substantive questions or saying something particularly interesting, and then performance of ministerial duties and and so on. And I would love to hear what you think of this structure and if there's anything else you'd like me to regularly conclude.
But until next week, I hope that you enjoyed all of this.