Transcript
Today we're going to finish our discussion of savings, continue my nagging on you guys about how you should be saving money, and then we're going to move on and talk about international trade. So let's finish our discussion of savings. Now savings turns out to be a critically important element of growth in the economy, and we've now traced through why that happens. Okay? Our basic story is as savings goes up, as savings goes up, that means that the capital supply shifts out. So as capital supply curve shifts outward as people save more, that's an increase in the capital supply curve in the capital market.
That means that interest rates fall. Okay? Because there's more supply for given demand, the price is going to fall. The price of capital is the interest rate. So as people save more, that's more supply to capital markets, it's increasing the pool from which firms have to borrow. For a given pool, firms have to pay less money to borrow from that. If the interest rate goes down, that means the NPV of investment goes up. Because remember, the net present value of investments is a negative function of the interest rate. The lower the interest rate, the more firms will say, "I might as well buy a new machine cuz the bank's not paying me anything." Okay?
That means that NPV investment goes up, which means investment goes up. So the bottom line is the way we get firms to invest more and grow the economy is by saving more. When we save more, we increase capital supply, that lowers the interest rate, that raises the NPV of investment, which leads to more investment. So, that's the link by which savings leads to economic growth. Is it savings leads firm to invest more. Okay? Is that clear from the sort of the the structure we built in the last couple lectures? Okay, if it's not, just go back through and work through the math, but you'll see we talked about the capital market.
The interest rate's the price in the capital market. Last time we talked about the interest rate, the the lower the interest rate, the higher the net present value of any given investment. That means firms will invest more. So, that means a critical public policy concern is getting people to save enough. Now, the obviously that varies with economic conditions. In a deep recession, we don't necessarily want as much savings as we're not in recession. But, in general, in the long run, we will grow more as an economy if we save more as a society. And the US has an incredibly low savings rate. Our savings rate in the US, depending how you define it, is maybe 3 to 5%.
In Europe, in Japan, it's like 15 plus percent. Okay? So, we have a very low savings rate. And as a result, that has led public policy makers to try to think about tools they can use to encourage savings. And the major tool we use in public policy to encourage savings is the tax subsidy to retirement savings. The tax subsidy to retirement savings is the major tool that we use to increase savings in the US. Okay? Now, how does this work? Okay. The basic logic is the following. When I put my money in the bank, and I earn interest, that interest gets taxed. Just like my labor supply gets taxed, my capital income gets taxed.
Okay? So, when I put money in the bank, I don't just earn the interest rate. Well, make use our where we care about real interest rate. I don't use the real earn interest rate. I earn R * 1 - tau, where tau is the tax rate. That's all I take home. So, the bank pays me 10%. Say inflation is zero, so nominal interest rate is the same. The bank pays me 10%, and my tax rate is 50%. I only take home 5% on net. Okay? If we assume substitution effects dominate, which is the big assumption, but it typically one we make, this will lead This means the taxation by lowering the return to savings will lead to less savings.
So, by taxing people's savings, we lead to less of it. Because we sort of assume substitution effects dominate. Okay? To offset this, we say, "Well, I'll tell you what. If you save for retirement, we won't tax it." So, if you save it and you pull it out next year, we're going to tax it. But, if you put it in special accounts, which we've labeled as retirement savings, we won't tax it. Okay? So, these have a number of forms. One form is employer-sponsored pensions. These are things where your employer takes some of your pay, puts it aside in an account, and when he does that, you're not taxed on that pay.
So, if MIT If MIT is going to pay me $100,000 and they pull $10,000 aside and put it in a pension, I'm only taxed on 90,000. That 10,000 isn't taxed. And likewise, the interest that's earned on that isn't taxed. Okay? There's also 401(k)s. A 401(k) is like a pension, but where you control the money. So, when you get a job, you might get offered a 401(k). That's something where some of your money gets pulled out of your salary, it doesn't get taxed, and it gets saved instead, and you control where it goes. Okay? And then, we also have individual retirement accounts, um the unfortunate name IRA.
It's not the Irish Republican Army, but individual retirement accounts, which are similar features where you can take your money and save it on a tax-free basis. Okay? Now, here's the trick about how all these things work. Is they're not actually tax-free. They are tax-deferred. And what do I mean by that? What I mean by that is that when you take the money out, eventually does get taxed. So, the way say your 401k would work, you get a job at, you know, whatever, some you know, at Google. Google offers you a 401k. You put money in it. That money then accumulates. And when you take it out, you put money in that money's not taxed when you put it in.
But, when you take it out, it is taxed. Okay? So, it is eventually taxed. So, why would that What good does that do you? What good does that do you if it's going to get taxed eventually anyway? Yeah. Well, you don't get taxed right now, you get more money now, which will then accumulate more money cuz it's compounding interest. Right. It takes advantage of present value. Remember we talked about this last time. With present value, money in the future is worth less than money today. By the same logic, paying taxes in the future costs you less than paying taxes today. Because if you have the money today, you can earn all this interest on it, and you have to pay taxes on it off in the future.
So, let's see an example of that. Let's look at figure 18-1. Okay? Let's say you have two types of accounts, a regular account or an IRA account, which is a tax-deferred account. And let's say the tax rate is 25% and the interest rate is 10%. And let's say you're just going to put the money in. To make life easy, imagine you put the money in for a year. Imagine you're retiring next year. This is a super easy example. You're retiring next year. The question is for this last year of work, should you put your money in a tax-deferred account or in a regular account? Okay? Well, if you put it in the regular account, you will take your $100 in earnings and pay $25 of taxes right away.
So, you only get to put $75 in. On that $75, you'll earn 750. And when you take the 750 out, you'll pay $1.88 in taxes. Okay, so you paid $25 on your earnings, you paid another $1.88 on the interest you earned. And you end up with $80.62. Now, let's say instead you set up an IRA. Well, there you get to put the whole hundred in. That $100 earns $10. And when you take out the $110, then you pay tax on it. So, you pay 27.50 then in the end. But if you put it all together, you end up with more money. 82.50 rather than 80.62. Why is that? It's because you delayed paying taxes by a year. By paying taxes 1 year later, you got to earn the interest on that money during the year.
Think of it this way, if you pay taxes now, the government gets the money and they get to earn interest on it. If you pay taxes next year, you keep the money and you earn interest on it. So, it's much better to pay taxes later. And that's why these accounts matter. It's a simple example. Okay? It's a simple example. If you have a 30-year account, if if we kept the interest rate at 10% and the tax rate at 25% and did a 30-year calculation, you would have twice as much money after 30 years if you put it in an IRA rather than putting it in a regular bank account. So, even though it eventually gets taxed, it's a big advantage.
It's a big advantage. And that's why we think that's why public policy introduced these tools, 401Ks, pensions, IRAs, because they're trying to encourage saving by raising the return to saving. Okay? And they hope that by encouraging saving, they'll get all this good stuff coming out of it. So, that's why these things um uh come up. So, the first lesson is 401 just like my continued nag on you is save early and save often. Things like 401Ks, by putting your money away, not only do you get the compounding I talked about before, but you also get the tax benefit of paying taxes later rather than sooner.
You get the compounding on the money and the compounding on the taxes. Okay? So, these kinds of retirement accounts, when you get your job and you're thinking about why would I worry about retirement, worry about retirement. There's a big uh there's a big advantage. Now, then you ask me, "Okay, that's fine, John, but when I get my 401K paperwork, I've got like a million things I can invest in. What do I do with the money?" So, let's talk for a couple minutes about investment strategy. About what you do with the money. Okay? So, let's think about three different ways you can invest your retirement money.
Three class of options a 401K will typically have. They'll typically be a money market fund, market fund, a bond fund, and a stock fund. And there will be various combinations of these, but these are the categories. What do these mean? Money market means the money's invested in government bonds. Okay? The money's invested in what are called treasury securities. Government bonds. These are things which are ultra safe, as long as the US doesn't default on its debt, which you've never done in our history, and the good Lord willing we do in the near term. As long as the US doesn't default on its debt, you get paid back.
These are super safe. It's the safest place you can put your money. But they pay a very low interest rate. Right now, they're paying interest rates a typical government bond fund right now would be paying interest rate of around sort of maybe 2%. 2 to 3 maybe 1 to 2%. Very low interest rate. Maybe up to 3 now, but very very low single digits, but totally safe. A bond fund invests your money in corporate bonds. These are Basically, this is making loans to corporations. Instead of loaning the money to the government, you loan the money to a corporation. You're not actually buying a bond in GM, that's too hard.
So, what these 401K accounts do is they say, "We're going to buy a bunch of bonds. We're going to put them together and let you own a small piece of that entire set of bonds." That's what a bond fund is. Okay. So, you're going to own a small piece of a bunch of corporate bonds. The difference is, unlike the government, corporations do go out of business all the time. So, these are riskier. Okay, these are riskier. But they pay a higher interest rate. Bond funds typically are paying 4 to 5% right now. Okay? Then finally, the last thing you do with your money is you can put it in stocks. You can literally own corporate equity.
You can own a piece of companies. Okay, you can own a piece of the companies. And then, what you get is you get something It doesn't really matter. With these two, it only matters you get paid as long as the company doesn't or the government or the company doesn't go out of business. Here, you get paid in proportion to how well the company does. If it does really well, you make a lot of money. Stock prices go up. It does badly, you lose money. If it goes bankrupt, you lose everything. Okay? So, it's similar to these in that bankruptcy costs you everything. The difference is, these are either you get paid or you you bankrupt.
Here, you get It's much more variable. Things do well, you get more. Things go badly, you get less. So, this is the riskiest option of all, but it also pays the highest rate of return. Traditionally, stock investments pay a long run of return of about 7% a year. So, what we see here, we compare these as what economists call the risk return trade-off. The risk return trade-off. The riskier things are, the higher you earn by investing in them. But, the riskier that earning exists. The more you earn by investing them, but the riskier that earning exists. Okay? That in other words, people are willing to accept a lower interest rate for a safe investment than they want for a risky investment.
And we'll talk about in the next lecture in two lectures from now why that is. Why people's preferences are that way. It's cuz people are what we call risk averse. People don't like risk, and we'll talk about why. That's a natural way to be. Okay? So, basically, that is your set of choices. And what economists recommend is that the key in all these investments is to diversify. The key recommendation of economists is diversification. That you put your money, you spread your money across these options to get the right balance of risk and return. Okay? So, that basically, if you're someone if if you're someone who uh Now, how you balance depends on your taste for risk.
If you're someone who really hates risk, you can put most of your money here. But, it's silly to put all your money in money markets because you're losing out on a lot of return. If you're someone who's risk loving, you might want to put most of your money in stocks, but still to put all your money in stocks because you're you have you you hot much higher risk. You want some safety behind you as well. So, economists would say you should diversify. Now, that's a general I can't tell you what percentage is the right percentages. I tell you diversify, but I can give you one specific piece of advice.
That when you go work for company X, the one thing you do not want to do is put your money in the stock of company X. Why is that? Why is the last thing you want to do when you go to work for company X to put a bunch of your money in the stock of company X? Yeah. No, I No, this would be through a 401 401K account. It wouldn't be like that. Yeah. If you lose your job or if the company shuts down you lose both your job and your That is the maximally risky strategy. Because you are tying your risk of your investments to your risk of your salary. Okay? That's the most risky thing you can do. Okay?
So, absolutely. What you would not want to do is go work for Google and say, "I'm going to put all my retirement in Google stock." You might think Google's safe, but safer companies than Google at companies thought to be safer than Google at some point have gone bankrupt. If Google's bankrupt, you're totally screwed. You've lost all your savings and your job. So, the last thing you want to do is that. Yeah. Like if you really want to work for a good position, they they give you bonds as like bonuses. Well, I mean, certainly a lot of companies give you stock options where you're sort of stuck in the stock of that company.
And my little lesson there would be, "Well, that's part of compensation, but as soon as it vests, sell it and get out." Okay? That doesn't mean you shouldn't You should You should value It's not saying stock options in a company are worthless. They're worth something. It's just they're worth less than if they just gave you the cash. Because if you got the cash, you could invest it in somewhere that wouldn't be tied to your job. Okay? And this came to a head with the example of Enron, which is sort of before your time. Okay? That's sort of when you were young. But, basically Enron was an energy company that got into some really shady dealings to try to essentially prop up its stock price.
To make itself look valuable, it essentially created shell companies that were the same company and sold to them. So, it looked like it was generating a lot of sales, but it was just selling to itself. Okay, illegal it was illegal activity. But, it caused their stock price to go through the roof. And Enron, in order to have enough money in in the company, encouraged their employees to invest all their retirement savings in Enron. Indeed, the Enron 401k said, "We'll give you extra money in your account if you invest your money in Enron." So, most people in Enron had their retirement savings invested in Enron.
When the whole thing And Enron was a very successful company, very in the Fortune 500, doing quite well. When the whole thing collapsed, these people not only lost their jobs, they lost their entire savings. Okay? That's the problem non-diversification. And the ultimate form of non-diversification is to invest in the company you're working for. Okay? Have I scared you enough? Any questions about that? Okay. Now, let's move on. That finishes our discussion of savings. Let's move on to a totally new topic, which we'll talk about this lecture and the rest of next lecture, which is international trade.
And let's start with what is international trade? And why the ruckus? This is a great time to be teaching international trade, probably the best most exciting time of the of any year I've ever taught this topic. It's front and center in a way it hasn't been probably in decades. So, what's the big deal? Well, let's talk about a simple example. How many people have ever given someone roses for Valentine's Day? Raise your hands. God. MIT man. All right. Uh Okay. That's okay. When I was your age, I hadn't either. Um Now, here's an interesting problem with Valentine's Day. Valentine's Day falls in the winter.
Roses don't grow outside in the cold in the winter. So, what do you do? Well, for many years what we did was we had hot houses where we grew basically were dedicated the their reason for existing was to essentially grow Valentine's Day roses. Essentially an industry around growing these indoor roses in the winter so that you could so you could have them available. But, what happened over time is we realized it was a lot cheaper to actually buy the roses in Colombia or countries like that and fly them up than to actually have them grown here. So, what happened was we all now get all the roses we get now in the winter come from South America.
Okay? And we don't grow roses in America anymore in the winter. So, is that a good thing or a bad thing? Well, on the one hand, roses are a ton cheaper now than they were when I was a kid. Okay? So, that's a good thing for the romantics among us. You can get a dozen you can get a rose you can get a dozen roses for 25 bucks. It was like 80 bucks when I was a kid or something. It was crazy. Okay? On the other hand, a bunch of guys used to grow these roses out of jobs. There was an industry devoted to growing these roses. And these people now have no job because they're grown somewhere else. So, how do we think about this trade-off?
It's sort of a microcosm of the larger debate around international trade. The larger debate about whether trade is good or bad comes down to this roses example. It sort of summarizes that issue. So, now we think about international trade we think about three concepts. We think about exports, which are the amount of goods that we sell to other countries. Okay? And imports, which is the amount of goods that we buy from other countries. So, a country exports to other countries, it imports from other countries. Okay? Currently, the US exports about $1.6 trillion of goods a year. That's with That's trillion with a T.
And imports about $2.4 trillion of goods a year. Leaving us with an 800 billion trade deficit. You may have heard the president mention this once or twice. Okay? An $800 billion trade deficit. So, the question you want to ask is how big a problem is this? That we've a trade deficit. And the answer economists give is none problem. Okay? No No Spinal Tap fans here? Okay, whatever. Um okay. Uh so, basically, let's explain this in a simple example. Imagine that you have two Pikachus and your friend has two Jigglypuffs. Okay? And you want to have a more diverse set of Pokémon. So, you go to your friend and you say, "I will trade you one Pikachu for one Jigglypuff." So, you send your friend a Pikachu.
He sends you a Jigglypuff. You've just created a massive Pikachu deficit. Think about it. You used to have two Pikachus. You sent one away. You You You sent one away. You didn't get any Pikachus back, did you? So, you've created a huge deficit of one Pikachu. Is that bad? No. You got a Jigglypuff. You're happy. You wanted to make the trade. You made the trade. Calling the trade deficit defined trade deficit in terms of If you define trade deficit instead of terms of Jigglypuffs, you've got a huge trade surplus. Used to get no Jigglypuffs. Now, you get one. So, what Basically, a trade deficit trade surplus is all about an arbitrary definition.
The bottom line is America sends spends $800 billion more. You're you're money to other countries, but we get 800 billion dollars a year more stuff for it. There's no bad or good. It's just the way trade works. Okay? So, anytime you've had a trade in your life of anything with a friend or whatever, you've created a deficit and a surplus. But, that doesn't mean anyone was worse off or better off. Whether you're worse off or better off depends on the the the indicators of the trade. Depends on how much each party values what's going on. Okay? So, basically if I said, "Oh good lord, if I had a headline, good lord, you know, Gruber creates Pikachu deficit.
Must end trade with Jigglypuff land. Okay? And we must shut down trade cuz good lord we're we're creating this huge Pikachu deficit." That would be bad. Because I wanted to trade my Pikachu for Jigglypuff. I was happier. Okay? That would be a bad thing to shut that off. And that in this stupid example is why economists like international trade. Okay? It's the same reason we like trade in general. Think about this whole course. This whole course is about a bit about trade. It's about been trading our money for cookies and pizza. About trading a firm's money for workers and machines. Okay? About trading my time for a wage.
Life is all about trades. International trade is just another example of that. Just cuz got this bizarre label of a trade deficit, we think about it differently. Okay? So, that's sort of basically if you think of think about Now, let's replace Pikachus and Jigglypuffs with the US and a poor country. Instead of US having two Pikachus, the US has tons of money. Instead of the poor country having two Jigglypuffs, the poor country has really underpaid workers who can make stuff really cheaply. So, I in USA wait, I have a lot of money. You got a lot of sweaters. I'm going to send you my money and get your sweaters.
I'm better off cuz I was happy to buy those sweaters cheaply. You're better off cuz you can't eat sweaters, you need money. So, you get some of my money. We're both better off, but I've created a trade deficit. Okay? That is not inherently a problem. Now, of course, the reality is more complicated. The reality is that when I send the money to those countries to buy the sweaters and I bring the sweaters in, my consumers of sweaters are much happier. And I keep focusing on sweaters because it's just amazing. Okay, this sweater I just got at Old Navy. Okay, $15. Pretty nice. It's decent, you know, it's not cotton, whatever.
$15. This would have been a fortune when I was your age. Okay, in those days dollars it would have been $30 and that would be like $70 today. Okay? Why? China. Okay? Because we used to we used to make these in North Carolina. Now, we make them in China. Okay? So, the good news is I went to Old Navy. I got two pairs of pants and like four sweaters like a hundred bucks. Okay? That's the good news. Okay, the bad news is the guys in North Carolina lost their jobs. That's the bad news. So, there's a trade-off. Now, I'm going to argue over the next lecture and a half that that trade-off is worth it in aggregate, but we can't ignore the fact there's a trade-off because that's what leads to the very intense debates around international trade.
Is the fundamental tension between the consumers of goods that are made cheaper by international trade and the producers of goods that get wiped out by international trade. Okay? So, that's our setup. That's our big picture. Now, I'm going to dive in and I'm going to teach you the nitty-gritty of how we think about this with models, but that's the big picture I want you to have in mind. So, let's dive into the models. And to do the models, I need to introduce a new a a tool to you, which is the production possibility frontier, the PPF. The production possibility frontier. What the PPF shows you is the maximum combination of outputs you can produce for any given set of inputs.
Okay? So, basically let's think about that. Let's go to figure 18.2 cuz it's easy to see this graphically. Let's go to figure 18.2. Let's think of you as a firm. And you as a firm produce two things. Problem set points and exam points. Sorry, it's all you're good for at MIT here. You produce problem set points and exam points. But you can produce either. Those are two things you produce. And to make life easy, let's say given your innate intelligence the points are produced a function of time. Clearly, the more time you put in studying for an exam, the better you do. The more time you spend on a problem set, the better you do.
And you have one scarce input, which is time. This production possibility frontier tells you if you devote your scarce input across different activities, what will the result be in terms of what's produced? So, what's this line saying on the left-hand side? It's saying, "Look, if I put all my time into studying for exams, I'll get 200 points on exams and zero on problem sets. If I spend all my time doing problem sets, I'll get 200 points on problem sets and zero on exams. And some combinations in between." That is a production possibility frontier. Okay? It shows the combination of outputs you get for any given fixed level of inputs.
Now, what is wrong with the graph on the left? And why is the graph on the right probably more realistic description of what your actual production possibility frontier looks like. Yeah. Like, you know, if you can get more points on a problem set and you know more, you're probably more well prepared for the exam. Yeah, it's wrong because in fact, what this system features is something we call economies of scope. We talked about economies of scale a number of lectures ago. The notion that when uh if you double inputs, do you double output? This economies of scope, which is that by producing more than one thing at once, you may get better at both.
But by studying for an exam, you get better at problem sets. And by doing problem sets, you do better on the exam. So, what that means is doing some of both leads to a better outcome than doing all of one or all the other. Okay? You get a concave to the origin production possibility frontier. A concave to origin production possibility frontier demonstrates economies of scope. Doing some of both is better than doing all of just one and all the other. And that makes sense for you in doing problem sets and exams. It makes sense you'd be better off doing some of both than devoting all your attention to one and just just one and just the other.
Okay? So, that is a production possibility frontier. Now, there can also be diseconomies of scope. Another great example for MIT is that when I was here as an undergrad, I came in as a tennis player and I was on the tennis team. Now, tennis was only in the fall and spring in the winter they had squash. So, I thought I'd play squash. Well, it turns out that the key with tennis is keeping your wrist firm. And the key with squash is keeping your wrist flexible. And by playing squash, I screwed up my tennis game. And by playing tennis, I screwed up my squash squash game. So, I had a diseconomy of scope.
I was worse off at both things by playing both than I'd have been at just playing one or the other. Okay? So, there can be economies of scope, which is when doing both things make you better at both, and diseconomies of scope, when doing both things make you worse at both. Okay? And that's the nature of the shape of production possibilities frontier. An economy of scope is when doing both makes you better off, a diseconomy of scope is when doing both makes you worse off. Okay? Questions about that? Now, I just introduced that tool because that tool is going to be the fundamental modeling feature that allows us to demonstrate why international trade is beneficial.
Okay? So, now we're going to take that tool and we're going to go and talk about the concept of comparative advantage. Which is the core concept in international trade economics. This is the core of of how it all works. Okay? Let's think of a particular example to understand this. Let's take the US and Colombia and the rose market. Okay? And as I said before, let's say it's expensive for the US in the Valentine's Day rose market. It's expensive for the US to grow Valentine's Day roses, it's cheap in Colombia. Okay? On the other hand, let's compare roses to computers. Roses are cheap to produce in Colombia and expensive in America.
Computers are the opposite. We have giant factories and skilled labor and giant machines that can quickly crank out computers. In Colombia, they have to like assemble the computer by hand. Okay? So, it's a lot cheaper to produce a computer in the US than it is in Colombia. It's a lot cheaper to produce a rose in Colombia than it is in the US. The way to think about this is through the lens of opportunity cost. What we're saying is the opportunity cost of making a rose in terms of computers is higher in the US. In other words, the amount of computers you have to give up to make a rose is high in US cuz computers are cheap and roses are expensive.
The amount of computers you have to the amount of roses you have to give up to make computer in Colombia is higher cuz roses are cheap and computers are expensive. So, we say that Colombia has a comparative advantage in roses. It is relatively cheap in a world of computers and roses. It is relatively cheap for them to produce roses compared to computers. The opportunity cost in terms of a gone computers is lower. Whereas the US has a comparative advantage in computers. It is comparatively cheaper for us to produce computers. So, international trade is all about what you're relatively better at.
Now, let me emphasize relative for a second. This is important concept. The reason we don't just say advantage and we say comparative advantage is it doesn't actually matter if you're better. It matters you're relatively better. Let me explain this. This is hard. This is I would say of the main economics concepts in the world that we need people to understand, this is one of the top three least understood concepts in all the world. Okay, in economics. Comparative advantage is like in our blood and we can't understand why regular people can't understand it. It's cuz it's hard. Okay? Let me give you Let me give you an example.
Take me and LeBron James. And imagine there's two activities in life, mowing a lawn and playing basketball. That's all life consists of. Okay? Now, LeBron James is better than me at both playing basketball and mowing a lawn. But, he's much, much, much, much, much better than me at basketball and only much better than me at mowing a lawn. So, LeBron James has an advantage in everything, both activities. But, he only has a comparative advantage in basketball. He only has a comparative advantage in basketball. Comparative advantage is about opportunity cost. In other words, the amount if LeBron James mows his lawn, the amount of basketball he's giving up is ungodly.
It's crazy have mow his lawn, giving up a basketball he could have played. If I mow my lawn, I'm not giving up as much basketball as I suck at basketball. So, I have a comparative advantage in lawn mowing. Might say, "How could You're not better at lawn mowing than LeBron James." I'm not. But, I have a comparative advantage in lawn mowing cuz the opportunity cost to me is much lower. The opportunity cost LeBron James of mowing his lawn is high cuz he could be playing basketball. The opportunity cost to me is low cuz I can't play basketball. Yeah. What if like you're the only one in the world that can mow lawns?
Well, that's That's That's a weird edge case. We won't get to that. Then, there'd be no no reason for That makes trade things hard. Look, we can come back to that. Now, of course, the example doesn't stop there. Should I mow my lawn? No. I should not mow my lawn. Because there is someone who's uh who has um doesn't have as much education as I, who can't earn as much money as I at work. And they have a comparative advantage in lawn mowing. I have a comparative advantage in office work. So, in fact, not only should I mow Do I have comparative advantage over LeBron in lawn mowing, but some less educated than guy has a comparative advantage over me in lawn mowing.
So, just as LeBron would be better off letting me mow his lawn, and I'd be better off letting him play basketball, I'd be better off letting some less educated guy mow my lawn and letting me go sit in my sit in my front of my computer all day. Okay? Comparative advantage is all about what you're relatively better at. And the key insight, okay, of international trade is that in a world of comparative advantage, people should always specialize. In a world of comparative advantage, people should always specialize. You should do what you're best at. Okay? You should do what you're best at because otherwise it's simply silly for LeBron to spend any time mowing his lawn.
As much as my wife thinks I'm just trying to get out of it, it's simply silly for me to spend any time mowing my lawn. Okay? I have a I have a comparative advantage of sitting in front of my computer and doing that stuff. So, I should hire someone else to mow my lawn. So, to actually see that, let's go to figure 18.3. This is a confusing figure, so I'm going to go through it slowly. Okay. On the top, we have the US production possibilities frontier. And to make life easy, let's assume that there's no economies of of scope between roses and computers. Make sense there wouldn't be, right? Let's assume there's no economies or diseconomies between roses and computers.
It's a linear production possibilities frontier. So, we're showing each graph is a production possibilities frontier between roses and computers, and we're assuming it's just linear, which makes sense, right? You don't You don't make better computers by making roses and vice versa. On the top, we have the US. Let's say that the US's production production possibilities frontier is the following. Given the resources we have in the US, we could produce 2,000 computers or 1,000 boxes of roses. Given our resource, our skill level, our capital intensity, etc. Now, go to Colombia. Say that Colombia, given their skill level, resources, the sunshine, the beautiful weather, any Colombians here?
Sounds perfect. It's like 75 all all time. Okay? Um you end up they can make 2,000 roses and 1,000 computers or 1,000 computers or some combination in between. So, the first thing I just want to make sure you guys guys understand why these are sensible production possibility frontiers for each country. They're sensible production possibility frontiers because they basically show the US has a comparative advantage in computers. That is the trade-off in terms of roses forgone to make a computer is lower in the US than Colombia. Okay? And Colombia has a comparative advantage in roses. Okay? The trade-off in terms of forgone computers to make a rose is much lower in Colombia than in the US.
So, comparative advantage is always about opportunity cost. Let me say it again. The US has a comparative advantage in computers cuz to make a computer we have to give up less roses than Colombia does. To make one computer we give up half a box of roses. That's the slope of this line. Colombia to make one computer has to give up two boxes of roses. So, we have a comparative advantage in computers. Yeah. So, it must be impossible to have comparative advantage in both. You cannot That's the term comparative. You can have an absolute advantage in this simple two by two model. You have comparative advantage in multiple things in life.
But, in this simple model you can have an absolute advantage in both, but you can't have a comparative advantage in both. That's absolutely right. In this model with two goods and two countries each country has a comparative advantage in one thing or the other. Okay? Or there could be weird edge cases, but generally that's right. Okay? So, so now I think of it as now let's flip and do roses. In roses, for the US to produce a box of roses they have to give up two computers. For Colombia to produce a box of roses they only give up half a computer. So, they have a comparative advantage in roses. Okay?
People understand the setup here these graphs on the left. Yeah. How does the price of what you can sell each unit for factor into what you'd actually produce? Because I can imagine that like yes, maybe you can produce more roses. But they're worth less. But they you can't sell a rose as much as you can Right. So, for right now we're ignoring prices. We'll come back to prices later. But for right now we're ignoring the prices. Right now, we're just sort of we're going to basically have prices come in in in later. But for right now we're ignoring prices. Okay? So, now let's imagine that tastes are such that consumers in the US want 1,000 computers and 500 box of roses.
That's point CUS. And consumers in Colombia want 500 computers and 1,000 box of roses. I just made this up. C CUS and CO, I just made up tastes. I just said let's just make up a case where people in Colombia like roses better, people in America like computers better. And imagine we do not allow international trade. This is the best case. Actually, international trade would be even more valuable with different assumption. I've made assumptions which make trade less valuable than it would otherwise be. I've said look, Colombia produces roses and people there like roses. America produces computers and people there like computers, but not totally.
Some US guy still wants some roses, some Colombian guy still wants some computers. Now imagine we don't allow trade. What's the outcome? Well, in the US we will produce we want like I said, we want 1,000 computers and 500 roses. So, we'll produce 1,000 computers and we'll consume 1,000 computers. So, on the chart on the right you've got production and consumption. For the US we'll produce 1,000 computers, consume 1,000 computers. We have to consume what we produce, there's no trade. And same with roses, we'll produce 500, consume 500. Colombia's the flip. So, you end up in the world with 1,500 computers being produced and consumed and 1,500 roses being produced and consumed.
Now you might say that's silly computers cost more than roses. We'll come back to prices. For now, this is just sort of we're leaving prices out of it. Okay? The point is given the taste I've suggested with CUS and CO. I just made those up. Given those tastes, we'll end up in a situation where every country just consumes what they produce cuz there's no trade, and the world as a whole will produce 1,500 ro- box of roses 1,500 computers. Okay? Now, let's say that we allow trade. What trade does is introduce economies of scope. Why? Because trade allows specialization. Flip to the next figure. The next figure is a figure for the world.
Imagine the world only wanted computers. That's the point on the Y axis. Then US would produce 2,000 and Columbia produce 1,000 would have 3,000. Imagine the world only wanted roses. The flip side we have 3,000. But if the world wants both, you get more. Why? Why is it outward bending when you allow trade? Why does trade This is not a technological change. We haven't changed it technologically. All we've done is take these two PPFs and combine them and allow trade. Why does that suddenly introduce economies of scale? Cuz what do countries get to do compared to what they were doing before when they couldn't trade?
What do they get to do now? Specialize. The US specializes in and Columbia specializes in roses. By specializing, we can make more because that's what we're good at. So, by trading, we allow specialization. Without trading, we can't specialize cuz some guys in the US want roses, we got to make some roses. But that's stupid. We shouldn't make roses. We should let Columbia make roses. Okay? If LeBron can't hire anyone to mow his lawn, he's going to mow his lawn. That's stupid. LeBron should hire someone to mow his lawn and play basketball all the time. By allowing trade, we allow people to specialize and take advantage of their comparative advantages.
Without trade, you can't take advantage of comparative advantage. Without trade, it doesn't matter if the US is better producing computers or roses. What's produced is determined by people's tastes. Okay? But with trade, you can specialize. And that yields the outcome we discussed in figure 18.5. Figure 18.5 takes the previous figure 18.3 and adds trade. So, let me go through this. The basic the blue the PPFs are the same on the left, okay? Same PPFs as before. And if you look at point CO and CUS are the same as before. Okay? We could have um 1,000 computers and 500 roses in the US or 1,000 roses and 500 computers in Columbia.
But now suppose we allow trade. What happens now? Well, what happens now is the US goes to producing only computers. And Columbia goes to producing only roses. Now let's assume, just to make life easy, let's just assume the people's tastes are proportional. So, if there's more computers and more roses, they just want proportionally more of each. So, the US, as they're more of both, wants uh you know, two two computers for every rose. And Columbia wants two roses for every computer. That's just their taste. What happens now is we shift out to these new levels, C'US and C' Columbia. Columbia. At the new levels, the US produces 2,000 computers.
All they do is computers. Columbia produces 2,000 roses. The world as a whole ends up with more. Flip back two pages and look at the table on the right. The world as a whole ended up with 1,500 rows and 1,500 computers. Now, the world as a whole ends up with 2,000 roses and 2,000 computers. What happened? Nothing changed technologically. Same PPFs here as before. All the change is by trading. We allowed people to exploit their comparative advantage through specialization. Without trading, the US was inefficiently producing roses and Colombia was inefficiently producing computers. With trading, we've now opened up the possibility that they can specialize in what they're good at and the world as a whole ends up better off.
Okay? So, and look at both countries. Both countries end up with more consumption. They They each get The US gets more computers, so flip back and forth in 18-3 and 18-5. The US goes from 500 roses and 1,000 computers to 750 roses and 1,250 computers. Colombia goes from 1,250 roses goes from I'm sorry, 1,000 roses and 500 computers to 1,250 roses and 750 computer computers. Now, the split between roses and computers here is is not determined. That's just made up. I made up what tastes look like. The The point to see The point C and C prime, that's just made up. What you care about is the bottom panel.
We care about the bottom panel. What you care about is the fact that the world as a whole now has more roses and more computers in it. And that is the mechanics of why international trade expands our production possibility frontier. We have more goods in the world once we can trade. Not because I mean, you still have the same number of Pikachu and When When I allow trade between you and your friend, that doesn't create any more goods. You each have two cards. But, in the real world, it creates trade because of production allows people to specialize. And that's the beauty of trade. All right. We'll come back next time and do a welfare analysis of why of talking about why international trade makes people better off.