Transcript
good morning good morning yes so I want to pick up where we were last time we talked last time about mle's elegant experimental design and not just elegant but very careful too and having uh organisms that bred true and a lot of work went into that um we talked about his observations and his uh really great choice to count we talked about his ability to look at numbers that were approximate and somehow Inuit it what was interesting about them namely how to take rough numbers and say hm I think this is a 3:1 ratio although that was an abstraction and but but a very good one on his part and it and it's hard to know when to make those leaps and when you you're kidding yourself but mendle got a lot of data I didn't mention that he'd worked on not just round and wrinkled but he worked on seven different traits across P plants all seven showed these very consistent properties of going uh there was a recessive and a dominant phenotype and in the first generation the dominant phenotype by definition was evident in full force and in the second generation we saw 3:1 segregation he felt pretty good about that he made other predictions based on this and he was able to put together a very coherent story and as I also explained last time it sunk like a stone because it was an utterly abstract Story the idea that there were these particles of inheritance factors of inheritance you couldn't put your finger on them and people hate stuff you can't put your finger on they say it's just a model well as I mentioned last time the disc discovery of chromosomes in cells was really laid the foundation for the beginning of uh a rebirth of interest in mendelism in in mle's ideas uh and the interesting part of that characterization of chromosomes was the choreography that we talked about last time that normally in cells going undergoing mitosis normal mtic division to make more and more cells when you stained the cells and looked at them before they went into meiosis you saw these x-like structures however many there were they lined up along the midline of the cell they appeared then to sometimes you could even see them kind of attached to something pulling them back and they would pull back to make two cells Each of which had half of the X somebody asked last time I drew I drew four chromosomes was that because cells have four chromosomes the answer is no it's because I had room to draw four chromosomes in that cell and so this time I drew six chromosomes to indicate that you can have different numbers of chromosomes they are usually but I should note not always an even number of chromosomes in uh higher organisms but anyway uh so I drew six this time and what's interesting was this meiosis the generation of sperm and eggs for example and animals there the chromosomes lined up with a different choreography they lined up in pairs and where you could see differences in the shapes of chromosomes like maybe the the little crossing point was lower down they would appear or the chromosomes were shorter in length they would appear to find their own partner the one that had the same basic shape and they would line up in pairs then they would undergo a series of two divisions a myotic one division meiosis one and a second division meiosis 2 and in meiosis one you would get one copy of each pair then it would undergo a second round of division that looked very much like mitosis where these X structures would be split into two pieces the notion then that pairs would go go to Singletons and then upon fertilization Singletons would come together to reconstitute a pair really did fit mendal and thus was born the chromosomal theory of inheritance so whoops the chromosomal theory of inheritance are you overwhelmed by the chromosomal theory of inheritance have I given you overwhelming evidence to believe it no how come oh we've heard it so often before and it's it seems natural to us now seems natural to you now but I mean you know the only evidence is that there's something else that's got pairs in cells right what's what's to say that that some other thing that pairs up in cells actually is the carrier of genes the chromosomal theory of inheritance is that mle's abstract factors genes live on these chromosomes are these chromosomes or something like that they're carried by these chromosomes and simply the fact that the choreography of the chromosomes is not the same sorry is the same as the choreography of mle's genes that's correlation in fact it's expose facto correlation I didn't have any prediction that these chromosomes would do it I just saw that the chromosomes did it and I said okay you know that that could explain mle's uh observations about genes and there's a world of difference between that could explain that is consistent with the data and that presents a compelling case that this is true so there were some people who immediately bought into the idea of the chromosomal theory of inheritance and there were other people who remain great Skeptics about this that these chromosomes were themselves quite irrelevant to inheritance and indeed many people who at this point the early 20th century felt that the whole business of genes was still not such an overwhelming uh idea anyway and trying to unite these two was going a bit far out so uh now I have to bring you back to something of the things that that uh we left unresolved last time which is mle's second law of inheritance because if we're really going to start building a case that chromosomes really do carry genes then we better get some serious consistency with much more complex aspects of the theory or we better look for some contradictions so you recall and I mentioned that mendal studied seven different traits two of them roundness and greenness both dominant phenotypes underlain by these hypothetical genes Big R Big R Big G Big G and the recessive traits associated with these same genes wrinkled in yellow little r little r little G little G when you make a first generation cross what do you get sorry you get r BR and green phenotypically and genotypically what are they big r little r Big G little G right that would be the genotype these organisms would be heterozygotes in fact they'd be double heterozygotes there'd be a heterozygote for the gene that controls shape and a heterozygote for the there'd be heterozygous for the gene that controls seed color okay now suppose we do a cross back to our r g g the parent that is that has the recessive phenotype for both of these traits we're practicing our words here right what will this parent the second parent contribute in its gametes what will the gametes from that parent be little r little G they have to be little r little G because that's all it's got to offer so little r little G okay what will this parent contribute could give a Big R Big G could give a little r little G could give in principle a little r Big G or a Big R little G in theory any of those are possible and uh what's the uh ratio that mendal reports one: one to one to one so equal that's right one to one to one: one that's the independent assortment of traits that's what he calls this independent assortment of traits that is to say the inheritance of round and the inheritance of uh green are uncorrelated to each other right knowing which one you got for roundness which one you got for greenness they don't convey any information about each other so how could we explain this in terms of chromosomal theory of inheritance well we could explain this in terms of the chromosomal theory of inheritance by saying for example that uh in this heterozygous parents here big r and little r were carried on chromosomes that paired up with each other homologous chromosomes and Big G little G were carried on a different pair of homologous chromosomes in my meiosis picture there okay so if that was the case then when these chromosomes segregated to in the first meiosis step meiosis one it might be that Big R and Big G were on the left side it might be Big R and little G were on the left side it might be that that little r and Big G were on one side Etc because these are different chromosomes they could have chosen to line up in in different ways that's all cool so mle's Law of Independent Assortment is consistent with the chromosomal Theory except we pointed out last time except if Big R and Big G were on the same chromosome then we'd have some explaining to do so maybe mendal was just lucky and Big R and Big G happen to be on different chromosomes but what if he takes a third trait well maybe the reason he got one one one for those traits was it was also on a different chromosome and a fourth trait and I said he studied how many traits seven seven traits if they all gave one to one to one to one assortment they'd all have to be on different chromosomes how many chromosomes do peas have How many pairs of chromosomes the pe's have seven seven very interesting he might have just gotten lucky in fact he did we know that they are on different chromosomes though it makes you wonder whether maybe he had an eighth trait that did something funny and decided not to put it in this paper I don't know it's interesting um like I said there's Choice involved in what what you want to report at at what point here so suppose we instead had Big R and Big G little r little G happen to have been on the same chromosome then they would have been inherited from a common from the common parents here say from here into the F1 the F1 would look like this they're different chromosomes it would look like this if from the same prosome would look like this and now let's make a little scorecard of what's going to get passed on to the next Generation we've got the possibility that it will pass on this one could pass on oh let's let's keep score Big R Big G could get passed on little r little G could be passed on Big R little G could be passed on and little r Big G could be passed on and if they are on different chromosomes we expect a quarter a quarter a quarter and a quarter but if they're on the same chromosome what do we expect what will come out of this either you're going to get this one in which case you get both Big R and Big G or you're going to get this one in which case you get little r little g a half a half Z 0 oo that's very different what does mle's Law of Independent Assortment say it favors this but mle's Law of Independent Assortment can't possibly be right if we see this so mendal didn't observe this but if we really believe this chromosomal Theory we'd expect to see it eventually so who's going to be right mendal or chromosomal Theory you vote for both how many vote for mendal how many vote for chromosomal Theory how many vote for both how can you have both that they be contradictory how how many vote for neither okay fine um so uh we have a very different prediction notice that these are the parental types of chromosomes they're the ones that went into the cross in the first place Big R and Big G these are the non-parental types of chromosomes they're the ones they're the combinations a Big R and a big G that didn't match either of the two parents they would have that that's a new combination there well it took a while before folks sorted this out and it was eventually sorted out in fruit flies and it is of course the case that neither mendle nor this strict prediction from the chromosomal Theory turns out to be correct mle's Law of Independent Assortment does not hold for all traits but this very rigid model of two Alternatives does not hold either so let's take a look at some real data the data comes from Thomas Hunt Morgan a developmental biologist who eventually became one of the great geneticists of the uh Century at Colombia was Columbia University studying fruit flies and he studied fruit flies rather than peas you think of any good reasons why it would make sense to study fruit flies rather than Peas sorry has four chromosomes instead of seven I mean you know four or seven anybody been to Columbia University I mean it's where you going to plant peas right I mean it's it's in it's in Manhattan also what else is wrong with studying peas they take too long how many generations peas are you going to get a year in Manhattan not so many fruit flies how long do they take couple weeks you get a generation every couple weeks if if you actually want to write some papers I mean if you have a day job as a monk you can you can do these pee things that take a long time but for example if you were trying to get tenure at Columbia you might want to actually do something that you could get a couple Generations every month or something like that so the fruit fly was much better they also you know they don't take fields and things you grow them in little vials with uh with some food at the bottom some yeast U uh medium at the bottom and a little cotton stopper at the top and you know it's convenient you can grow zillions and zillions of fruit flies so that's why the fruit fly was chosen easy short generation time etc etc and there were a lot of natural variations out there geneticists love to to choose organisms that are just easy to work with so you can do a lot of work so um and fruit FES do have four chromosomes but I so n equals four that is four pairs of chromosomes uh so we set up a cross the F0 cross was between a normal fly and the way we say normal in genetics is wild type okay wild type that is the type in the wild it actually doesn't mean that it is the type in the wild it means it's whatever type the geneticist has chosen as his or her reference strain but it's called wild type and he set up across between a wild type fly by a fly that had two interesting properties its body was black and its wings were in bad shape and they were called vestigial there you know these funny little wingy things that weren't weren't uh uh that that didn't work hadn't grown out right Etc so instead of the normal fly body collar which is kind of a tan around its middle it was black all around its middle and its wings were very short um the hypothesis is that there were genes controlling and in fact by demonstrating melan inheritance black was a single melan trait which was recessive to the normal body color vestigal was a single mandilion trait which was recessive to the normal body shape and the genotype of wild type was homozygous normal which I'll write as plus over plus now geneticists actually prefer these plus terms rather than big RS and little RS plus over plus and we'll take a female and we'll cross her to a male who is homozygous for the gene that controls the body color there and this Gene that controls Wing shape and we'll look at The Offspring so makes F1 the F1 have what genotype they're plus over black plus over vestigial F1 okay so then what he does is he takes say these males and he crosses them back to these flies here that have the doubly recessive phenotype doing what we call a test cross that's now the name we're beginning to introduce more of these names a test cross when you cross back to the homozygote for the recessive phenotype and uh what he gets out same exact picture I drew before but we're just getting used to nomenclature and getting used to you know slightly different nomenclatures here he could either get uh he always got black vestigal black fesal black festial black fdil from the parent on the right and here he could get plus plus he could get black vestigial he could get uh black plus uh or he could get plus vestigal and as we said over there the predictions would be that if these were on different chromosomes he would get 25% 25% 25% 25% if they were on the same chromosome under a very simple interpretation of the chromosomal theory of inheritance he would get 5050 0 and in fact what did he get 965 944 206 and 185 what do you make of it which which theory is confirmed neither well maybe this is just the statistical fluctuation around the first line you don't think so how come way too wild way too wild but I mean these are wild type so maybe no so what do you I mean you think those numbers are too far off a quarter quarter quarter to be believable there too much relation between Plus+ and bvg oh not only are they are they way off a quarter quarter quarter quarter but something is fishy the two parental types are much higher than the two non-parental types that saying something to you oh interesting what about this other one 5050 could this be a fluctuation around zero no that's this one's really pretty easy to reject because zero this is not like close to zero this should be zero you shouldn't see any of those right because they didn't go in if they were on the same chromosome so uh what are we going to do we're acting like mendal good we're seeing something funny in the data here you even see saw something that is beyond just it's a little weird but it's actually a little weird in some interesting Direction uh let's how how many of them are of the parental type now it's 965 plus 944 how many are the non-parental type n it's 206 plus 185 so let's figure out what's the proportion the frequency of non-parental types well it's uh 206 + 185 over 206 + 185 + 965 + 944 which is 177% okay so it's 17% we now know what the answer is when you take two traits and you cross them in this fashion two recessive traits and do a test cross the ratio will neither be a quarter quarter quarter quarter or it it's not going to be one to half a half Z 0 in fact it will always be 177% why why not oh but mendle looked at his data and he said 3 to1 it's trying to say 3 to one isn't this trying to say 177% yeah well see that's the thing is is what to make of this number what does this 17% mean now of course you all know that this is genetic recombination right you know that these chromosomes are exchanging material I can't kid you about that but put yourself in the days of Thomas Hunt Morgan looking at these data and trying to figure out what is the 177% trying to tell them there were people around Colombia and elsewhere who were saying oh this 17% number says a lot about physiology it's a statement about the developmental relationship of genes and they were trying to read all sorts of things into these numbers now first thing is Let's test some more pairs of traits how about another pair you do that do you get 17% no turns out maybe you get 8% you do it with another pair maybe you get %.
so it's not a constant we can reject the idea that 17% is some constant like e or one over Pi or something like that um but we we we we look at these numbers and a lot of folks wanted to interpret these as physiological numbers something about the biology of these traits so uh we could we can give this thing a name the frequency of non-parental types we can call this the recombination rate because we got new combinations right this recombination rate might mean and I and you know already that you're thinking what it really means is somehow we have black black plus plus and in the F1 we have vestigal vestigal plus plus and that somehow these two chromosomes have have exchanged genetic material so that the new chromosome you get is like this and you get a recombinant type you get recombination between these chromosomes and there's a recombination rate and the recombination rate is how often this kind of an exchange occurs and what does the recombination rate depend on the distance between those two genes you know this because you've been told this since kindergarten right it's in all the high school textbooks and things like that or something or or whenever they start they they teach genetics earlier and earlier these days so in any and it's and it's on TV and stuff but that's a nice idea that the recombination rate depends on the distance and this rate which might be 17% or it might be 1% or it might be 8% or it might be who knows depends on the distance as is a reflection of the distance but golly what's the evidence for that aren't we just making up a theory to explain the data here we don't have a theory to we we're just trying to fix the chromosomal Theory the chromosomal Theory wouldn't predict these recombinant types it would have predicted we only get parental types out so because we do get par nonparental types out we say well chromosomes are promiscuous and they'll exchange Parts because we don't always get the same ratio we have to make up the fact that somehow uh the ratio is different because of something distance we can't observe distance no way that that Morgan was able to look at the chromosome and see where the genes were so basically any number you want to give them he'll just say it's the distance this is not overwhelming now what's even the evidence that chromosomes exchange material why do why do we think stuff like that even happens ah turns out you can take fruitfly gametes and other gamits and look at them in the microscope what you do is to look at them closely the chromosomes during meiosis you put a cover slip on them you squish them down add a little dye and you'll look and it turns out that really truly when you look in the microscope you can see stuff like that of chromosomes lying on top of each other like that these are called kayata crosses kayma or the plural kayata you can see in the microscope so does that convincingly demonstrate that recombination occurs are you overwhelmed why not yeah you put a bunch of chromosomes down you put a glass cover slip you squish them the fact that two things lie on top of each other I mean this is what it takes to do sciences you actually have to be pretty hard-nosed about not being willing to take evidence that supports your theory just because it supports your theory skepticism is pretty important here so you squish down the cover slip and sometimes not always sometimes some chromosome lands on top of some other chromosome big deal so how are we going to actually get any convincing predictions that's what it took with mendal what convincing predictions can we make that this recombination phenomenon has something to do with the disposition of genes along chromosomes and if so might provide some support for the chromosomal theory of inheritance well when you're in a quandry you got some new area you got messy data you need new thinking where do you get new thinking from you get new thinking from students because old folks are thinking you know in whatever way they were thinking so what you're really need are young students to come along to the field and look at the data in some fresh way so in this case the hero was a europ student at Colombia they didn't call it europ but it was the same thing it was a sophomore working in the lab of Thomas Hunt Morgan who came along and solved this problem very nicely um as you know I think in part because sophomores had not been polluted by all sorts of Prior thinking um so the idea of genetic Maps arises through the work of one Alfred Sturdivant Sturdivant was a sophomore at Columbia in 1911 and while an undergraduate working in the lab of Thomas Hunt Morgan he went home he he he he you know was working in the lab and he took home a pile of data and he said I got to make sense out of all this data doesn't I I don't understand exactly what's going on here's some of the data he took home Morgan's lab had set up crosses not just involving two traits but three traits simultaneously they actually set up crosses involving three traits black what's called cinear which is an eye color and vestigial they looked at the F1 when Crossing back to the homo the tripley homus fly here and they counted the number of re combinant types of different sorts you could look at recombinant types between black and vestigal we've already got those data you could look at recombinant types between black and cinear you could look at recombinant types between cinear and vestigal now I've drawn this as if these things live on a chromosome and I know their order you've got to remember we don't know that they live on a chromosome and and stdent certainly didn't know their order okay but I have to draw it for you so I'm drawing it for you because the notation he would have used was much too messy and there's no point in learning it um so he begins to look at the data from these different crosses what he finds is when he looks only at black and vestigial so he ignores what happened with cinear what's the rec combination rate the frequency with which he observes new types nonparental types well they'd already done the experiment in the lab and what's the answer 17% now he then looks at black to cinear so he just you know covers up the genotype at theal there are four possibilities black cinear black plus plus cinear black cinear he looks at the parental types black cinear or Plus+ he looks at the non-parental types the rec combinant types plus cabar cinar uh or black plus he counts up the number of nonparental types to the total number of flies and he gets a Rec combination rate of 9% okay so I'm just going to draw you this he he he took out a piece of paper and he drew himself black cinear vestigal he said I believe this has something to do with distance this was 177% the probability of a crossover occurring of a recombination occurring between black and vestigial 17% and the probability of a crossover occurring the frequency of a crossover occurring between black and cinear was 9% got any prediction cinear vestigal should be about 8% give or take but what if his picture is wrong what's another picture that might be where cinear is oh yeah there's an alternative picture isn't there the alternative picture is black vestigal cinear over here at 9% 177% in which case what's the prediction for cinear sigil 26% give or take right we got to be a little rough about about these things well that's not a single prediction but it's down to two Alternatives he's either expecting about 8% or he's expecting about 26% so two two alternative predictions so cinear of a Sigil combination rate 8% that's good that's very good that first time anybody's made a prediction and a quantitative prediction that's just gotten verified by data Stan also does one other interesting thing he looks at a fourth thing which is a little bit interesting when I look at the types of gametes that can come out of here right if this idea of genetic recombination is correct that sometimes in this F1 parent a crossover has occurred here sometimes a crossover has occurred here and the crossover here would give rise to black plus plus or plus cinar vestigal here it would give rise to Black cinear Plus or plus plus Vil if it went the other way is it possible that occasionally under this model you might get two crossovers might it be the case if we believe in this stuff that a crossover might occur between black and cinear and a crossover might occur between vestigal and cinar could be how often do you think that would happen sorry rarely how rarely what's the chance of a crossover here about 9% right cross over here about 8% let's say 9% 8% are about 10% just for round this so about a 10% chance of a crossover in the first interval about a 10% chance of a crossover in the second interval it's about 1% of the time much lower than the others but about 1% of the time you might see what kind of chromosomes emerging black plus festial so black Plus vestigal or plus cinear vestigal these chromosomes whoops Plus thank you these would be doubly recombinant chromosomes they would have they'd need two recombination events to explain them and you even have a prediction that you might see them at about 1% and sure enough stur devance sees them it's actually somewhat less than 1% it turns out the double is a little less likely than the independent there's a little bit of what's called interference but don't worry about it that's a second order effect at a frequency of about 1% he sees double recompence that tells him who's in the middle if cinear is the one that has this problem because if he asks how often does cabar get inherited together with plus plus that's very rare but the stigle gets inherited with plus plus 9% of the time black gets inherited with plus plus 8 uh sorry 8% and 9% of the time but cinear is pretty rare so all this together says that this model here of a linear chromosome is now making some pretty good quantitative predictions about what's going on but of course this is just three different genes black cinear and vestigal what would you like all of more of them at least all I meet person I go for the all I'm with you but but you know he's an undergraduate he's got what he can so more well it turns out that of course Morgan's lab and busily making crosses and all this kind of stuff and there was more data available so when he saw this happening he said all right let's look at some more things and he began because there's so much data from the lab going around and taking all this stuff lobe and curved wing and other kinds of funny traits and he began looking at frequencies and he found this was about 9% and this was about 8% and he found this was about 5% and he found this was about 5% and if these two were 5% his prediction was 10% and his prediction here would be 133% and Etc and etc etc etc etc etc and it all pretty closely checked out this was highly constrainted the idea that the rec combination rates would fit a simple linear model it's not perfect of course because imagine what happens suppose I have 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% I have 10 Loi in a you have 10 such intervals what will the recombination rate be 100% then if I have five more 150% how what does that mean so clearly something is wrong about just using percents you have to kind of in I mean for the efficient Autos really the percent reflects the number of crossovers uh but obviously you have to do a little bit of correction because you can have you know if I keep piling on the intervals SE double crossovers will happen which won't produce Rec type so you have to but don't worry about we can just add percentages for today and when you do all this it works Sturdivant did this all in one evening in his autobiography that he wrote about 50 years later he says I went home one evening blew off all of my homework and stayed up all night and was able to make sense out of all these data so I think this is an example of a productive allnighter and also this is this is an example of when it's the right choice to blow off your homework if anyone wishes to do things like this and be as productive you're certainly entitled to blow off the homework here too so um but do bring in good data like this when you're done anyway this notion is a genetic map a genetic map was a totally abstract concept much like mle's abstract concept that there were even genes now we're going further and we're saying whatever genes are we still don't know that their DNA etc etc whatever they are they live on line and they behave as if they live on the on a line and they undergo recombinations Etc and when I see a recombination rate a recombination frequency a recombination rate that's zero it must mean the genes very close together if I see a recombination rate you know very very close never recombine recombination rates oh I don't know maybe 10% or something well there's some distance between them and if they get further and further and further away or totally different chromosomes what would be the recombination right here for two different chromosomes a half half of these are non-parental types so when I get up to a recombination rate of 50% then it means that they live on that they are so-called unlined to each other either they're on different chromosomes entirely or I suppose it's possible and in fact it is possible that there's so far away on the same chromosome that the probability of crossovers occurring is so high that they're decorrelated from each other and I can't observe any recombination rate less than 50% it turns out many chromosomes are sufficiently big that lots of crossovers can occur and you can't actually detect linkage at the two ends of the chromosome but if you string together some genes in between you can see that this is linked to this it's linked to this it's linked to this it's linked to this it's linked to this okay all right good so Sturdivant is another one of my heroes because he comes up with this utterly abstract model here of chromosomes of of genetic maps all right oops meant to get that bored someone have a call so okay so last of all me take section four here this begins to provide fairly convincing evidence for the chromosomal Theory because it made a whole lot of pretty wacky predictions and they pretty much hold up here's another thing that provided a lot of good evidence for it and that was sex linkage also in Morgan's lab which was a very productive place I much say folks were wondering about the fact that chromosomes although they almost always occurred in pairs that lined up with each other perfectly in many species there was one Odd Couple a pair of chromosomes that always paired up with each other but they didn't look the same this one looks like an X this one kind of had the shape of Y and hence they got the names the X and the Y chromosomes now here was something very interesting in fruit flies it was always the males that had an XY pair in females it was always an XX pair what does that tell us about these chromosomes and what they do sorry itet gend determines gender wait a minute why do you believe it determines gender just correlated with gender females have these two funny chromosomes males have sorry F females have these two x's males have an X and Y does it have to mean that that that they determine gender maybe gender determines them maybe what happens is that in female cells you get both chromosomes but in male cells some some enzyme comes along and chews off the end of the chromosome no no no really I mean maybe this is some physiological state of the chromosomes why do why why are you so ready to LEAP to the conclusion that the chromosomes determin sex rather the gender than the gender determines chromosomes because you know the answer and you've been told all this Etc but I again invite you to take apart what support you have for that and ask how would you know right all of these things you get told but you know how would you know and there was great argument about was this really the case so how could you convince people that this was true it's not obvious to know which way it would go the most convincing evidence not the only evidence but the most convincing evidence came from a single fly that had been isolated in Morgan's lab an f-zero fly that had the very interesting property that instead of the normal red dropa eyes this fly had white eyes whereas this was the normal fly with red eyes and we'll use a female here when you cross together the white eyee fly and the Redeye fly what you find is that is in the F1 generation all the Flies males and females or normal red eyes when I take however a normal female and I cross her back sorry a normal female from from emerging from this F1 generation and now I I cross her to a normal male here's what happens all of her daughters are normal but her sons half are normal and half are white died again that's weird for the first time we have a genetic trait eye color that is showing correlation in its inheritance with sex so that says for the first time we're beginning to see something that looks like linkage like genetic correlation genetic near lless like genetic mapping that would relate eye color to sex what's the model well of course the model here is that this fly we know the answer is X over y it's a male and the X chromosome here has a mutation that makes it white eyed what's this normal fly over here X overx and its X chromosomes are normal when we go to the Next Generation what kind of offspring are there the the daughters of this cross what's their genotype what they get from Dad they always get a normal X chromosome from Dad that's for Mom I mean what did they get from Dad these daughters they always got the X with the white eye why didn't they get the Y because they're daughters right if they got the Y they'd be Sons but they're daughters so the daughters always are getting this chromosome now when you mate these back to a normal male X over y the daughters are of what type what did they get from their dad always an X+ and what did they get from their mom either an X with the mutation or an X+ either way they're normal because we're assuming that this white-eyed mutation is recessive what did the Sons get what did they get from their dad why why don't they get the X because they're Sons what did they get from their mom half of them get the X+ half of them get the X mutant and that explains cleanly what's going on now the Y chromosome being a short stubby little chromosome doesn't have a copy of this Gene for eye color at all so you might as well regard it as being you know recessive as carrying the the AL for the recessive tradeit it doesn't have any functional copy so for a male he only gets get a copy from Mom and what he got from Mom completely determines his phenotype thus the transmission of iolar a trait controlled by a gene on the X chromosome correlated so beautifully with the transmission of the trait sex that provided a convincing argument that it was the chromosomes controlling sex rather than the sex controlling chromosomes all right so you know all this stuff you've all heard of mendal you've all heard of Rec combination you've heard I suppose of genetic Maps you know about X and Y chromosomes and things like that but I want you to take away from all of this is that in order to really know things you have to struggle against models you have to understand whether the model is just being made up to explain the data or whether the model has been proved in by by testing it in any serious kinds of ways all this stuff took 30 or 40 Years of serious Battle Before the last people caved in and said this is all proven of course going forward we'll assume it's all proven and you know what to do with it and onward to next time