# The Shays Rebellion and Its Implications

**Channel:** My History Can Beat Up Your Politics
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5w_DqAj8qXg
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/5w_DqAj8qXg

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Opening Standoff at Springfield Armory
- 8:14 — The Battle and Its Immediate Aftermath
- 15:47 — National Alarm and Trade Disruption
- 23:33 — Postwar Boom Turns Into Debt Crisis
- 30:41 — Western Massachusetts Under Pressure
- 37:53 — Failed Coordination and Rebel Retreat
- 43:18 — Madison Sees a Constitutional Lesson
- 47:05 — Convention Begins Amid Unrest
- 53:05 — Constitutional Powers Against Insurrection
- 56:28 — Would the Constitution Change Anyway
- 59:40 — Legacy, Rebellion, and Modern Rights
- 1:08:20 — Weapons, Veterans, and Federal Power
- 1:15:36 — Closing Reflections and Farewell

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the podcast today is sponsored by Warby Parker w AR BY PA RK er Warby Parker is a maker of great eyeglasses be sure to head to Warby Parker comm slash my history to order your free home try ons today they're gonna send you a box and you get to try them on it's great on a hilltop in western Massachusetts a man in threadbare linen patched up cotton trousers and a crooked corn hat extends a musket he's defending as he sees it his liberties and at the end of his weapons line of fire is his tormentor as he sees it yet if we could reverse now spin and look around from the other side we would see not a Redcoat not a British soldier but a similar-looking Yankee man he might have the same musket maybe a nicer federal one purchased from the French during the Revolutionary War he may have the same trousers with a

**[1:13]:** few less patches perhaps two armies on two sides of a standoff on a bitter cold day two groups of New Englanders and a scant four years before they both would have fought side-by-side in the American Revolution now both just as equally feel they are fighting to preserve liberties that were gained in that conflict

**[1:55]:** it's a standoff that could very much determine how the Republic goes and yes on that hill in that snow some of the world we know today may have been etched though they can't possibly know it their shouts calls for surrender on both sides calls to let us pass equal calls to go home ignore the tension mounts a general in blue and buff with a Seward orders his men to load another general in blue and buff and a sword orders his men to do the same cold hands Griff muskets tight freeze that moment in your mind zoom in a government man one of about nine hundred militia led by captain Shepherd circling the Springfield Armory holding the Continental supplies he is from Lincoln in the east of Massachusetts right next to Concord one of those famous Minutemen the ready response who responded to defend American rights and protect the arms of the new nation now he's

**[3:14]:** responding to a call from the elected governor of the state in that nation to do the same zoom in on the other side captain Daniel Shays farmer from Pelham in the western part of Massachusetts also a veteran of the Battle of Concord as well as Bunker Hill as well as Ticonderoga and Saratoga initially a militia man Shay's was promoted all the way to Captain in the Continental Army because of his ability to lead he wears his Continental uniform today since then he's been brought to his court he's been paid and what revealed to be worthless scrip for his Revolutionary War service given a sword from the famous general Lafayette he has to sell it to keep his family sustained

**[4:17]:** that's not why he's here though he's a very reluctant leader he insists years later leader of them I was not just one of many committee men there are other names that didn't get recorded as well in history Luke day a group of wells known as Captain grip Henry McAuliffe who during this day he's on a horse shouting at the men Shay's at first refuses to lead the army that he's leading today and it's only when another rebel leader Luke day leads a revolution against one of the local courthouses is imprisoned and a mob forms to secure his release Daniel Shays agrees to both lead the mob to shape its actions and to negotiate hopefully day's release as some historians note this could very well have been called days rebellion but it's not Shay's agreed to speak to the farmers in his area with grievances facing prosecution facing foreclosure he agrees and once he does he

**[5:30]:** leads this group decisively his men are not all well armed some of them have their old Revolutionary War muskets some have sold them perhaps to pay debts indeed a sizable chunk of this group has nothing more than a curry clubs but they have drums may have fight and the drums play and the other captains along with Shay lead the men up the hill in a column formation impressing the other side with its order and discipline the goal of Shay's and his men is clear it is the federal armory in Springfield if the eastern militia sent out by the governor of Massachusetts gets it if they can hold it they can expect a prosecution and wholesale imprisonment the governor of the state has already suspended habeas corpus it's no laughing matter 27 men died in one detter prison in Massachusetts are alone during this year they can expect their livestock to be surrendered their cattle their

**[6:38]:** pigs and perhaps the farm itself to be surrendered if the militia arrives some of them now called insurgents and rebels in the newspapers in Boston will go to jail or will be hanged they call themselves regulator's and their aim just like where the name comes from the regulator's that also rebelled in South Carolina and North Carolina before the Revolutionary War the their goal is to regulate the government of the state it's only a small force that stands against these regulators and with resolve the regulator's should be able to take it or really they figure they'll be able to convince the other groups surrounding the armory to simply leave and let them have it how do they know this because once before just a month ago Shay's and his men had occupied a courthouse and Shepards men same leader had showed up to defend that courthouse but was convinced to leave and let the shays men

**[7:44]:** have it they figured the same will happen again Shay has just sent a note to the other leader Luke day who is north of him together they should have some 3,000 men against probably 900 and with arms they can make this real contest something else Springfield has barracks too and the men right now are very cold

**[8:14]:** yet Shepherds men now representing the state of Massachusetts are just as determined he knows that in a few days Revolutionary War hero Benjamin Lincoln will arrive with a larger and better funded army the official government army of the state of Massachusetts which the merchants of that state including the governor started a fund raiser and subscribed and supported he secures the perimeter of the Springfield Armory with his men now this is interesting because the weapons procured there are generally those purchased from the French by the federal government during the Revolutionary War there's also an artillery park full of cannon ample munitions the kind of thing that could keep an army going for some time it is not technically shepherd's to take anymore than it is Daniel Shays to take technically it is United States property the property of the Confederation government and a Confederation Congress has not authorized the state of Massachusetts to use it but

**[9:26]:** this is 1787 the national government is weak slow answers take a long time and rebels move on the double quick Shepherd is right now with matters of federal state jurisdiction he pulls two cannons and puts them in front of the road by which the regulator's must advance in auditioning as a howitzer we all know everything that happens now and we're not going to pretend to know but we do know the results there's a 1955 book a little rebellion that in the style of books of that time gives us what might have been a little narrative between Shaye and a messenger sent a little narrative presuming to know the conversations will indulge a bit grain of salt taken with knowing that something like this might have been said why will you deny us Shea's asks I'm here in defense of the country that you endeavour to destroy the messenger replies if you defense of the country che says that we are both on the same side the messenger responds I expect we'll take different parts today chase

**[10:45]:** it's the part that I will take is that he'll the messenger responds if you advance you will face the men we are both accustomed to obey 250 feet separate the two groups the bulk of which are former Revolutionary War soldiers it's a tense moment Alfa Scholten is holding only a club and he believes that the men across from him will never fire on his comrades John Wheeler doesn't know that he still owns his trifold hat from his revolutionary war days and he is telling his men I will reach the Arsenal or the gates of hell on the other side David who wears a moccasin coat and readies his rifle he doesn't want to but he will follow his captain's orders regardless of how ugly it might be

**[11:50]:** both sides determine warnings unheeded and Shepherd orders the cannons to fire

**[12:01]:** but he orders them to fire over the heads of the regulator's something else Shepherd does not strictly does not order his men to fire their muskets musket shot is too personal men on men he figures that'll just retrigger return fire more determined fighting the cannon shot over the head is hopeful but not effective Shay's men are not deterred they advance prior to this they had accepted compromises they had accepted too perhaps the legislature to state would do something about their grievances that the courts would stop they've always been denied and this time they are not stopping Shepherd now orders a second shot this time at waist level

**[13:06]:** it hits the body of the men hard shot of this time the intention of a shot is to stop a body of men from moving with ballistic force that can roll through several men he orders the infantry to fire a howitzer filled with grapeshot the results are immediate three men are killed instantly another will die days later dozens are wounded it is a day the likes of which New England has never before seen says one man at the event murder murder the men shout murder there's a third cannon shot and a fourth and the regulator's break they don't all want to John Wheeler there's telling his men to regroup McCollum is still on his horse chase where's his sword each of these committee members commanders leading men captain Gribbs are trying to get their men to regroup but it's no use Adolphus warned the man we said was holding a club realizes how pitiful the

**[14:19]:** situation is and ruts

**[14:25]:** there's blood on the snowy ground before the army as the regulator's retreat this little firefight in southwestern Massachusetts is in a tiny village and should be of no consequence to the larger world to the kings and queens of Europe or even to the other states yet many are watching this a French Minister is sending reports about the Shiite activity he reads about in the Boston newspapers to his government British merchants doing trade sama the farmer rebellion as a credit risk another reason that dropped the Yankee business Boston merchants to cry the dictator Shaye's who wants to start his own country the newspapers say southern farmers watch the events and think about their chances for nearby governors are aware of and watching the rebellion offering massachusetts help Thomas Jefferson John Adams diplomats of their country in Europe trade letters about it Benjamin Franklin the president of Pennsylvania fund raises and builds a reward for Shea's days

**[15:42]:** and other men who are leading the rebellion

**[15:47]:** Sam Adams sees no patriotic a motive in the actions of these men he'll lead the Massachusetts legislature to develop a riot act more importantly from his Church in Mount Vernon George Washington is desperate for dispatches he tells Daniel Humphreys former aide please send me any reports that you are getting asks Humphrey to build a militia which might help combat this threat which he does he asks Benjamin Lincoln have your people gone mad he writes Henry Lee I am mortified beyond belief this is embarrassing he writes to Henry Knox we should buy our contact verify the predictions of our transatlantic faux Morden ox but for God's sakes what's the cause of these commotions is it British trouble or real grievances which admit of redress if the latter why are they delayed till the problem became so much agitated there is a side story to all this now this is so-called Shay's rebellion and that's that Washington

**[17:05]:** certainly is getting reports that Shay's and his men are stirred up by the British an evidence of that has not been documented but at the time this would many thought at Henry Knox is also providing this information to Washington from his sources in London the trouble does not start with the British

**[17:35]:** picture a local constable carrying away the family's pig from their farm the wife cries husband pleads no the pig that must be sold at a fraction of its cost now to pay the debt that you owe was the winter's food imagine how a neighbor feels this is not a alienated modern world where we don't know our neighbors these are your friends and not only do you want to help them but you worry that you may be next and it's not just pigs being sold it's all sorts of items that they can grab and eventually it's the family farm this is why you join the town meetings and when the town meetings protest and dispatch grievances to the legislature they're ignored this is why you join assembles this is why you form outside halls of government and courthouses and taverns and when all of that doesn't work this is why you grab your musket if you

**[18:54]:** own one what happened to cause this unusual tumult well the way to look at the years after the American Revolution especially in rural areas is that a large recession it doesn't get talked about that much in in our history a little bit but revolution ends and there's what can only be described as a recession perhaps a depression low prices combined the lack of hard money high debt loads no economic demand these are all the economic terms let's explain what really happened it starts with a bit of a boom the revolution ends the bang down south the Americans and the French at Yorktown trap Cornwallis but it takes a while for peace the British still occupy New York City hold the keys to an extent by 1783 deal has worked out evacuation happens and the United States is a nation this is great for a lot of reasons but for one there can now be trade

**[20:12]:** between these two former warring powers and everybody is excited about this the United States even as an independent Asian is still going to Britain for the bulk of its trade it's the most logical it's the largest partner there are other ones

**[20:38]:** all right well if you got a chance to see some of the photos that I had on Twitter I'm at my histar Twitter of me with the road to nail podcast Benna Bob as part of the avett brothers at the beach festival it's a great time and we did a live podcast about us-mexico relations now you'll see me there sporting my Hawaiian shirt but also a pair of new eyeglasses and I got them from Warby Parker what's great about them is you get to try them at home before you buy them you order five pairs of glasses on the website they have great designs but for some reason there's a number of them that are named after presidential candidates maybe that's a my history can beat up your politics things Roosevelt the Wilkey the Seymour now I doubt they're naming their glasses after the 1868 Democratic presidential candidate ratio Seymour but I like to think

**[21:32]:** so anyway you pick out five on the website at Warby Parker comm slash my history and they're going to send five frames to you you try them on look at the mirror see how they fit ask others and see how they're really fit what ended up happening and I think it'll happen with you as well is what I thought I might end up purchasing when I ordered it online I ended up purchasing something else so it's great to have that real-world Tryon to be able to look into the mirror and see how they fit I've wore glasses all my life I'm a reader as you know Warby Parker glasses start at $95 including the prescription lenses the lenses include anti glare for important and anti scratch coatings there's a billion people in the world that don't have access to eyeglasses and worry Parker's doing something to help that for every pair of glasses you buy

**[22:25]:** pears distributes so I'm going to need so I'm gonna post a picture myself with my Warby Parker glasses on Twitter so go check that out of course do you have an iPhone X if you do be sure to download Warby Parker's app where you can use their brand new feature find your fit uses the iPhones true depth camera to map and measure key facial features using these measurements it recommends approximately twelve Warby Parker frames that are likely to best fit your face but the first thing you're gonna do is order that try at home kit head to Warby Parker comm slash my history to order your free home try ons today British merchants at first are very eager to sell their stuff and Americans are eager buyers the British nation can provide credit the major merging houses French merchant sums us up well I can offer lower prices but the Americans go to the British

**[23:26]:** as they can offer them credit

**[23:33]:** it's a flood of trade and it seems good war is over it's time to build Americans need nails they need axes they need window glass women are sewing and they will buy fabric and thread shoe buckles yarn it's time to farm so plow dishes are selling and every New England household needs pickling salt maybe beef and of course rum so you might go to a store like John Williams store in western Massachusetts Oliver Dickinson store Amherst and if it's 1783 the great part of it all is that you can get credit from that store or you can pay in goods you can pay in services your own promise of labor you can pay in your corn you can give dickerson your salted cod you can give John Williams the grains and get stuff some didn't say a little corn a promise to do a little work a yeoman can walk out with a great cloth

**[24:35]:** or a nice pewter porridge er that's not the best quality you know that porridge ER in Great Britain they might laugh at but here in the states it's as good as it gets YUM breakfast is better when you have something to hold it in Commerce Britain never really opens up all the trade see they are very willing to sell goods to the new United States they cut off American ships going to the British West Indies roof is king dealing with the court of st. James as the part of the national government says the president exasperated temper and Great Britain irritated Englishmen and required some retaliation it's true but also merchants are merchants are sort of directing British policy and maybe directing British policy in a way that favors them long term they want British vessels making these trips so they allow imports from Britain as

**[25:38]:** long they're on British ships American vessels are allowed to travel to Britain as long as they're carrying raw materials that Britain needs lumber is a big one cattle as well fish

**[25:56]:** there's never enough trade with France Americans try the Barbary States Spain Malaga Barcelona its rife with problems now the Yankee shipping has no British protection they try the Baltic everybody likes New England salted cod they sell a little this is a difficult trip John Williams as we said sells the Ginza he gets from Western Massachusetts farmers to China or tries to but everybody's figured out that it's a hot market the Chinese believe in the medicinal properties a better and there's a glut on that market and plus the trip is arduous he gets half the money he expected this is killing the American shipbuilding industry so many businesses merchants are starting to get affected by this in a way if you think about Tom Payne's writing and the promise of how much America will benefit from independence how big it is how strong it is how you know a continent is stronger than an island it

**[27:03]:** is kind of striking then in 1783 when one sees how important the British Empire and British policies the whims of their government still are to the United States we're still their main customer we seek them to be ours yes there's a few merchants that can make a living selling French products yes there are those that can import goods from the south and bring them to the north that's good what is needed is West Indies coffee sugar Rama and the British ship this to us and we have no business back for British goods fill the stores in Boston and Portsmouth in Newport in 1783 there's reports that these stores are stuffed with British goods and boats are going back to England with America's hard money there's an interesting comment from a person who had been a loyalist in one of the Boston newspapers such a scarcity of money has never been seen restrictions on trade deprived

**[28:09]:** them of the benefits they were to have from their glorious independence by 1784 there is a crash merchants can't pay says Abigail Adams from London 1784 New England merchants had so shackled and hampered themselves that they could not pay their debts

**[28:35]:** Boston merchants start going out of business for major London retailers will stop doing any business with American customers at all those that do will continue to sell but will require hard money pounds Spanish dollars gold coin there's never enough of that really in the state of Massachusetts but everyone tries to pay the debts as best they can and improve their books and so from 1784 to 1787 you have a downward financial spiral of debt British merchants go after American merchants or retailers wholesalers you might say the wholesalers go after their retail customers like Oliver Dickens Dickinson store in Amherst or John Williams storage on Worthington store on the Connecticut River John Worthington is called the River God because he's got a business that's pretty large and deals with most of the farmers in this area he and the other store owners are going to try to get their money to pay these debts from the

**[29:44]:** only way they can the farmer customers and to collect when they cannot pay they avail themselves of the court system as if all of this wasn't bad enough the Massachusetts government in acts attacks they've got Revolutionary War debts to pay and may enact attacks on real property and rents that adds up to about one third of the income either the land value or the rental value of the income on those properties it's a huge tax now it's not only the merchants but also the government that will foreclose on non-payers there are 500 farms in arrears for tax collection 1786

**[30:41]:** in the Hampshire County Massachusetts Court Court cases for debt collection go up two hundred and sixty two percent between 1784 and 1786 here's one farmer writes the constables are daily seizing our property both real and personal our land after it is appraised sold at one-third of its price our cattle by about one half sir session Oliver Dickinson used to take goods chickens of promise to do work for payment at his store it was 3/4 of his business 1786 it's cash only now store shelves are full but his stores are empty he's got no new customers and he seeks payment from to collect from those some 18 percent of the males in western Massachusetts are in debt many of them will at this time be jailed until they can pay now it depends on the type of leniency that the the area might show in some cases for instance Luke day is one of these that

**[31:49]:** is put in jail for debt collection despite his service at the Battle of Saratoga he's allowed to leave during the day see his family and then come back and he actually skips the jail as some did but some of them are more harsh and they're actually men who die in debtors prison because the conditions are terrible Ethan Allen the hero of Green Mountain Fame says that he had not a copper to save him from the devil and so in the town meetings across the state and Hampshire at Springfield the Berkshires Amherst you see petitions you see grievances expressed to the state government veterans of the war or remembering how the scrimp that they were given after the Revolutionary War service just appreciated and they want that advantage in their transactions they want to be able to pay their debts in paper money they want stays on the foreclosures of family farms until this crisis can

**[32:53]:** be averted and their grievance is dealt with by the legislature Massachusetts is not able to discharge its own debt and so the legislators get the petitions but don't listen

**[33:07]:** and so all of a sudden in Boston they start getting reports that in these Western courthouses as Court is about to take session there are men coming sometimes just with clubs or unarmed sometimes just kind of standing in the courthouse there are groups of men stopping their courthouses from taking play in August 1786 a crowd of 1,500 people keep the Northampton Court from operating in September there's disruptions in Springfield Great Barrington tauten Concord and now there's a little bit of a break in October because after all these are farmers and they have to do their harvest and you can only in these days protest so much while they're harvesting in October James Bowdoin the governor of Massachusetts asked for hard measures the Massachusetts legislature grants it with the full support of patriot and former rebel himself Samuel Adams habeas corpus is suspended a law is passed that any group of more than twelve people who

**[34:22]:** are armed can be arrested but more than that sheriff's are empowered to kill rioters on the spot something else Bowden calls the militia in central Massachusetts but nothing happens with the governor's call there's no available men because the men are participating in the mop or they're more interested in their own farming matters in staying neutral no one's joining the government he's gonna have to go back and form his own militia and this is going to be formed of a lot of people in the city of Boston and in those c4 towns in Massachusetts it's going to be formed of some former Revolutionary War soldiers and it's going to be formed of some apprentices to major merchants and artisans in Boston you're going to have just a scant few people from towns like Pelham and Amherst and Springfield local people very few joint one is Hugh McClellan he's a former Revolutionary War so he knows everybody Shay's Day everybody involved in this rebellion but he decides to stand with the government he's going to play an important role later

**[35:52]:** despite the measures being passed in December there's going to be a crowd it's going to stop the general courts of appeals in Springfield Massachusetts an army under William Sheppard is going to go out there and try to protect the courthouse and they're relatively successful in doing so but the judges are convinced that for their own personal safety and the safety of the government men that they should not hear the case so the militia leaves allows Daniel Shays and his men to occupy and stop the courthouse soon no courts in the west side of the state are really functioning governor Bowden the legislature is just as enthusiastic led by Sam Adams calling for arrest without trial anywhere in the state to riot act and it has a disqualification procedure anyone who participates in these act will be forbidden from voting in the state nor will they have the opportunity to serve in the public service if

**[36:53]:** they participate in the rebellion so it is this that brings up the conflict in Springfield and the retreat after that cannon flash Daniel Shays army seeks the Springfield Armory in a bit of desperation after the habeas corpus is announced there's a fear that everyone's going to be arrested it's gonna be hundreds of arrests and if there's kind of a difference in opinion and there's people who kind of know the situation on the ground in western Massachusetts and those who do not the some of the people in Boston are just well there's a you know a small group of people causing trouble to call out the militia and stop it Abigail Adams writing from London says you know it's a ring of desperados Benjamin Lincoln who's going to be the general it's going to put down a lot of this response to the request at one point that if it's about just locking up a few

**[37:47]:** people they're going to have to lock up half the state

**[37:53]:** now there's a more to the story of the encounter and the retreat at the Springfield Armory the two leaders Daniel Shays and Luke Day had communicated they wanted to wait 24 hours before attacking and there's a lot of debate it's not well known why this was everything from he didn't like J's and there was a rivalry - he wanted to give more of an ultimatum to Shepard maybe to avoid bloodshed - even that his Presbyterian minister had told him not to rebel whatever reason that that occurs this message is brought to a tavern to convey to Shea's and it's captured by Shepard so Shea's never gets the message that half the force won't be attacking along with him

**[38:42]:** Shepard Holtz as we know and so there is this 48-hour period where it's not clear what's going to happen because okay they won the first round but maybe of days and chase gets together they could take the armory again Shay's goes to his hometown he knows a good defensive position there on hills and he stays there it is then when the well-funded army of Benjamin Lincoln arrives grabs a few cannon from the Springfield Armory he once again wants to show flash and break up this motley group of rebels scatter them his troops end up marching through a blizzard they surprise Shay's men in the camp and capture 100 of them the army then breaks up essentially it's like you're on your own day goes to new hampshire he's actually captured Shay's goes to Vermont the people in Vermont are kind of sympathetic not really asking questions about who comes and who goes and chase stays

**[39:47]:** there it would be a mistake to think that this rebellion of 1786 and 1787 was just limited to Massachusetts or just limited to some guy Daniel shades we already talked about how many other leaders there were in the group who were also Revolutionary War soldiers it breaks out all over New England in Exeter New Hampshire 100 men surround the courthouse to shut it down there similar protests in Vermont in Rhode Island there's a mob forms in front of where the legislature meets asking for paper money and Connecticut there're riots the New Hampshire rebels are operating very close to and very aware of the Shay rebels but how each state handles it is a little different in New Hampshire the governor john sullivan you know he tells the rebels i'll close down the courthouse if you disperse and they do they scatter he then sends the militia after them and arrests the leaders Rhode Island and

**[40:53]:** this is something that the other states are going to be angered by especially Bowdoin Ann and Sullivan gives in to the farmers and enacts paper money laws and the country party that represents more of sympathetic interest to these rebels wins control the government just rogue island being rogue Island as far as the card money folks in the eastern part of these states in New England are concerned by February 25th 1787 Henry Knox is able to relay some good news to George Washington and he writes back on the prospect of the happy termination of this insurrection I sincerely congratulate you happily that good may result from the cloud of evils the threatened not only the hemisphere of Massachusetts but by spreading its baneful influence the tranquility of the Union there's a lot of discussion about what's going on with the rebels and they still haven't captured all of them you have Thomas Jefferson saying several times

**[41:59]:** to folks that well you know a little rebellion is a good thing from time to time one of the things that Jefferson is going to say is that look you know you have 13 colonies and it's been oh about nine years since the creation of the nation and you've had one rebellion it's not really that much don't get so excited I think some of the Jefferson's philosophy just comes out of who he was who's a philosophical finger some of it comes from being in Europe during this time because the the Adams has some similar feelings to John Adams is over in Great Britain as the representative of the confederal United States to Great Britain he kind of feels that this all just started because Massachusetts at the taxes too high but on the continent there's some more concern and James Madison who's a member of the confederal Congress from Virginia at this time an advocate

**[42:56]:** of a federal government that's more powerful is writing to Washington that he's worried still because a new crisis may be brought by the measures for disenfranchising and disarming those who participate in the rebellion the discontent he says is silenced but not subdued

**[43:18]:** and writes a pamphlet that goes out the vices of the political system of the United States in it he argues about how ineffective states were during this crisis we he also condemns states that are engaging in practices of paper money closing of courts using property as legal tender instead of money it's not going to be a very strong country strong political system if these things continue he argues at the same time he's not happy with how Massachusetts handled it he complains to Thomas Jefferson about 1,500 soldiers being brought to be stationed in western Massachusetts here's Madison writing to Washington and this is while at the same time the rebellion of Massachusetts is going on and the convention is about to start conceiving that an individual independence of the states is utterly irreconcilable with their aggregate sovereignty and then a consolidation of the whole into one simple Republic would be as inexpedient as in unattainable i've suffered some middle ground which may at once support a do supremacy of a National Authority and not exclude

**[44:38]:** the local authorities wherever they can be subordinate ly useful I would propose that in addition to the present federal powers the national government should be armed with positive and complete Authority in all cases which required uniformity such as the regulation of trade including the right of taxing both exports and imports the fixing and terms and forms of naturalization so he's really working some problems out in his letter to Washington and by the way I think the letters important because he's going to be successful in convincing Washington to come to the convention along with others he's gonna argue that a federal government will have a more balanced neutral view look at one of the things he says there's not been any moment since the peace at which the representatives of the Union would have given an assent to paper money or any other measure of a kindred nature we understand that the discontents in massachusetts which

**[45:34]:** lately produced an appeal to the sort are now producing a trial of strength in the field of electioneering the governor will be displaced the senate is said to be already of a popular complexion and it is expected that the other branch will be still more so paper money it is surmised to be the engine to be played off against creditors both public and private as the event of the elections however is not yet decided this information must be too blended with conjecture to read be regarded as a matter of certainty well he was right Hancock meant a little bit more of a populist but thinking is going to be elected to the to Massachusetts but I think you see in his letter to Washington in his statement about the vices of the political system the United States and his letters to Jefferson is where Madison sees evil in the system is not so much the

**[46:27]:** rebellion going on in Massachusetts but what state governments are going to do as a result of it that's part of the reason for the Constitution why do we look at Madison because he was one of the most important figures writing sections of the Constitution coming up with the Virginia Plan a group of people that agreed to and it got modified at the convention but you see a key thinker and then a key member of Congress afterwards as there is now talk about a constitutional convention in Philadelphia to amend the Articles of Confederation Madison makes it clear to Washington your name cannot be spared

**[47:05]:** that Washington probably made a decision about this is evident in a letter of April Henry Knox writes to a friend that it is probable that George Washington will attend the Constitutional Convention

**[47:26]:** June 17 87 small Western Massachusetts town two scaffolds are set up and men are brought to them captives of the government army that's been assembled by the state of Massachusetts Henry McAuliffe former leader of the regulator's and Jason partner another regulator who have been captured or set up to be hacked and there's a crowd watching the noose is actually put over the men's necks and I think all around the area people have been assembling and there is one tavern Inn in Amherst we're a group of the Shay I'd men the regulator's are going to go take an oath and actually surrender their arms and they will be free of punishment though under the Massachusetts law at that time they're going to be disenfranchised the person who accepts this oath is none under than the one man in the local area or one of the few who had sided with the government humic LOM and so

**[48:43]:** he's able to get a number of people spared but the leaders are not spared and so these two men are brought in there's crowd watching and for most of the local populace this is an extremely sad day there's appeals that go out to the governor for these folks you know the the mother of one of the accused man is saying oh he just got roped into it he didn't know he didn't mean to take arms he thought it was going to be a peaceful march you know this kind of thing for the government it looks like they're going to make some kind of an example of these folks so that others don't follow in rebellion again a lot of worries about what's going to happen when in rides just almost like a movie scene a man on a white horse with a letter and the letter is from governor Hancock and governor Hancock has decided

**[49:38]:** to pardon them but he wanted to put the men all the way through the experience and then pardoned them at the last second sort of a form of benign punishment that would occur during this time and they're not the only one would get this sort of like make you feel like you're getting hanged type punishment

**[50:00]:** Hancock is going going to slowly introduce a more conciliatory approach to the rebellion it's it's kind of an interesting event Shay's rebellion about the state government of Massachusetts changes right while the insurrection is still going on they just happen to be having a governor's election of course Hancock uses it to defeat Bowdoin Jay's is pardoned in 1788 and most of the men who are participated in the rebellion are pardoned and they're actually enfranchised they will participate they'll vote some of them will be at the ratification convention of the Constitution years later chase moves to Vermont then he lives in the rest of his life in New York while our false hanging was going on at the same time members are meeting in the same building where the Declaration of Independence was worked out inside in the Philadelphia in a Pennsylvania State House in Philadelphia members are meaning to create a constitution for the Union so

**[51:04]:** you have to see Shay's is not only bringing on the Constitutional Convention but actually the insurrection still going on it's on the minds of the members as they discuss things the Constitutional Convention begins in May 1787 je is still on the run during the opening speech of this convention Edmund Randolph mentions the disturbances in Massachusetts as an indication of the need for not just a little revision of the Articles of Confederation but for an entirely new plan and he does that in the opening speech of the convention Oliver Ellsworth another delegate mentions that Massachusetts couldn't even keep control of a rebellion 100 miles from a capital Elbridge Gerry says that the leveling spirit had gone too far Rufus King points out during the convention that look at how fickle states can be won governor Bowden of Massachusetts wants to hang rebel the other Governor John Hancock wants to pardon them but more than

**[52:19]:** that there are what you might call copycat rebellions yo men in Virginia protest against debt collections and in May 1787 while the delegates are talking King William County Courthouse is burnt down with all of its records so no one can collect it continues and there's several other court closings and some suspicious fires throughout Virginia it's worrying people like James Madison it's worrying people like Richard Henry Lee in Greenbrier 300 farmers stormed the courthouse there during 1786 and 1787 you also see disruptions in York Pennsylvania and in Maryland everybody meeting in that convention all knew it

**[53:05]:** in the document that they create there is specific language allowing the federal government to quell insurrections putting the control of the militia in such event in the hands of the commander-in-chief the President of the United States but there's also something else it's a little bit more of a two-way street than people think about sometimes there's also a guarantee from the federal government that a state will have a Republican government in other words the federal government of the United States is promising each citizen of the United States that they will enjoy a Republican government and if anyone tries to set up anything else presumably they'll have a problem not only with the citizens of that state but which the entire United States so that's in the Constitution as well James Madison to Thomas Jefferson my two last though written for the last two packets have unluckily been delayed till this conveyance your favor of June 20th

**[54:06]:** has been already acknowledged the last packet from France brought to me that August the second I have received also by the captain three boxes for wh bf and myself the articles included for Congress have been delivered and those of the two universities and for General Washington have been forwarded as have the various letters for your friends in Virginia and elsewhere the parcel of rice referred to in a letter to the delegates of South Carolina has met with some accident no account whatever can be gathered concerning it it probably was not shipped from France you will hear with receive the result of the convention which concluded its session till the 17th of September I take the liberty of making some observations on the subject

**[54:55]:** it was generally agreed that the objects of the union could not be secured by any system founded on the principle of a confederation of sovereign states of voluntary observance of the federal law by all the members could never be hoped for be reduced to practice hence wasn't braced the alternative of government which instead of operating on the States should operate without their intervention on the individuals composing them the do partition between the general and local governments was perhaps of all the most nice and difficult a few contended for an entire abolition of states some for indefinite power of legislation in the Congress with a negative on the laws of the states some for such power without a negative some for a limited power of legislation the majority finally for a limited power without the negative the question with regard to the negative underwent repeated discussions and was finally rejected by a bare majority without such

**[55:58]:** a check in the hole over the parts our system involves the evil of Imperia in imperial if a complete supremacy somewhere is not necessary in every society a controlling power is at least so by which the general Authority may be defended against encroachment to the subordinate authorities and by which the latter may be restrained from encroachments on each other

**[56:28]:** would there have been accounts to without Shay's rebellion I think so I see the nation evolving from the articles to the Constitution as what was going to be a natural process you have trade problems with Britain you have the inability of foreign nations to say hey you're a bunch of states and you don't agree on everything how can we deal with you you have issues of who's going to develop that western land this competition with other countries competition with each other Spain who had declared war in Britain during the American Revolutionary War and supported us now is blocking trade on the Mississippi have problems with interstate trade there's a Potomac Conference actually held in Washington's house in Mount Vernon to try to settle navigation of the Potomac River between Virginia and Maryland I can't really come to an agreement the recommendation of that conference is that we need a national system then there's a meeting

**[57:31]:** in Annapolis in fall 86 not all the states show up as delegates from four or five states but it's indecisive but it's indicative of the momentum so I do think that there would have been some kind of movement towards a better system just on trade and commerce issues alone absent the shays rebellion but the shays rebellion added a bit of emotional vigor to some of these efforts and most importantly I think given the letters that you read that it's Shay's rebellion that convinced Washington to come to the Constitutional Convention act as leaders something that he was always very reluctant once he gave up that sword he was reluctant to leave Mount Vernon and would rather let other people handle things like the fact takes no part for instance in the Annapolis conference now if we say that it's cause of Shay's that Washington steps in then we can say that because Washington steps in you have a very different type of Constitution I believe then you may have seen otherwise for instance

**[58:45]:** because you have Washington there at that convention everyone at the convention knows that he's going to be the first executive I think you have a stronger executive in the document so in that way you have a direct connection between what happened with Shay's and the regulator's and the concept of a strong presidency because you have Washington in the room and what could have happened absent Shay's and absent Washington's attendance at a constitutional convention which might have happened otherwise as you might have just seen a mere revision of the articles or you might have seen a Constitution that would have been changed in 15-20 years Shay's helps to put forward a constitution and underline stood extent the positions of the states at the time

**[59:40]:** there are two statues in Petersham Massachusetts

**[59:48]:** one statues built in 1927 and it celebrates the route of Shay's and the men trying to overthrow the Republic and on the bottom it says obedience to the law is true Liberty

**[1:00:07]:** but there's a second statue right next to it and that one was constructed in 1987 and it talks about how Shea's men were surprised and routed by an army financed by the wealthy merchants of Boston and the bottom of that statue it says true liberty and justice may require resistance to law these two dueling statues reflect the conflict over the legacy of what Shay's rebellion means and issues that were still dealing with today in fact Shay's rebellion is rich in its connection to politics of today I'm gonna talk about several different issues that are debated today at which one is reflected in what we might call today a right of rebellion do all American citizens have it the answer is not as easy as what it seems I mean read New Hampshire State Constitution not just the one from 1776 but today makes rebellion a natural thing you can resist the government and now New

**[1:01:15]:** Hampshire's Constitution is clear it requires that you would resist the government if it is perverted and the public Liberty is manifestly endangered and that every other means of redress has been pursued maryland the original constitution of maryland requires the same thing where for the ends of government are perverted all other means of redress ineffectual the people may and of right ought to reform the old or establish a new government but forget New Hampshire Maryland for a second let's just look at the head of all the laws of the United States the Declaration of Independence whenever any form of government becomes destructive of those ends it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it an institute new government whenever any form of government so one of those things that back when it was said they knew very well of what they spoke there was still a great fear that foreign government or an

**[1:02:24]:** internal dictator could take over a weak Republic system and create the dictatorship and you hear discussions about this all the time what we have the right a rebellion senator Joni Ernst of Iowa I do believe in a right to defend myself and my family whether it is from an intruder or whether it's from the government should they decide my rights are no longer important now there's been a lot of clipping of her quote where some people are ending at the point where it says an intruder or whether it's from the government and not saying the last part should they decide my rights are no longer important that caused a lot of controversy but obviously not enough for her to not win the election this is the way many feel so I think Shay's rebellion in and of itself doesn't add a lot to the second amendment debate actually all the precedent there is that in

**[1:03:23]:** Western Massachusetts there are a number of people who had their own arms many of them were former Revolutionary War soldiers who kept their arms there was ownership of arms and they kept those arms at home there is also a large station of arms in the Springfield Armory and there was a desire on the part of the government to not have access to that go to any group in rebellion but in terms of individual rights for the Second Amendment I think Shay's adds a lot there it's on the next set of debate that you're seeing which is is one of the justifications for arms to defend yourself from a government and what type of arms can you own we'll get into that second part a little bit later let's start with the first if we consider that Shay's rebellion is a founding event of the Constitution I think it tells us a lot about what how

**[1:04:18]:** the Constitution should be interpreted and would seem to be logical one of the things in his letter to Jefferson and to Washington and Madison complains about the authorities and masses disenfranchising and disarming the rebels now I think that's an interesting point in no way is Madison the support of insurrection in fact he's very scared by it but he is concerned about the Massachusetts government then taking away individual rights and includes arming as one of them so you see a clear distinction among all of the actions of the government in between the individual right to keep and bear arms and the right to rebellion or the right to get a group of people together and rebel because you don't like elected governments policy when a group of people and keep in mind this is a group of people that if an election were held in Western Massachusetts they would be in the majority this is a

**[1:05:22]:** group of people if a militia was called to constrain them they wouldn't join it so in this area they had the majority of opinion and they felt they were right to take arms this was a rebellion that everyone felt and he got Franklin you got Sam Adams got Washington you got Madison you got everyone felt should be crushed now Thomas Jefferson's a little more sympathetic says a little rebellion from time to time is good but actually if you read what he's saying he does think that the rebellion should be put down and that he feels that people should be given the facts he feels that the reason for rebellion is that there's not enough education of the individuals and they should be persuaded with facts and debate and given an opportunity to better participate in the political process but no one's siding with rebels in terms of their ability to overturn the state government in

**[1:06:19]:** fact this is a great fear and it's embedded in the Constitution with mechanisms for the federal government to stop it how do we then put these two issues together because I agree they're contradictory and that's why it's great in political debates I mean we could go on this one and just you know you'll you'll see those debates on Facebook which just boom boom boom one after the other one after the other and I think in most cases people on one or the other side of a debate are only thinking about the points that support their argument and so you can go on forever because no one's really interested in putting it together but if you start to meld these things here's where I think it goes there is support to say that you need an armed populace to protect against tyranny and that's what the founders if you will want it because they certainly set

**[1:07:04]:** up those mechanisms and they certainly tolerated and supported people keeping the arms the in the Continental Congress in lieu of being able to pay soldiers which we'll talk about allowed people to keep their weapons I mean right there is a symbol among everything else the second and everything else is that there was a certain right to arms or right to keep and bear and things like that there was a concern about tyranny 8th 18th century concern about tyranny a concern about tyranny that you have to put in the perspective of that time even when there's a constitution the nation's being founded that there could be a French fleet a British army a Spanish army coming from the south and the experiment with democracy was so untried at that point that there could even be an intern threat where someone takes over the mechanism of government and starts a tyranny and by that meaning nothing end

**[1:07:56]:** the Republican system there's a real danger of that van with each year the danger got less and less so I think you have to look at a concept like that like concept of what tyranny even means and look at it from a 18th century perspective and think about if it's even relevant to a debate today

**[1:08:20]:** because the misuse of those type of thoughts and those type of concepts that were real in the 18th century that may or may not be real now would be that tyranny is anytime there's an opposite political party in government or the government's doing something that I don't like one of things is gonna happen after Shay's rebellion and after the new government is forms that Henry Knox is going to be made the Secretary of War and he's going to ask Congress and they agree to create more armories so you had that federal armory in Springfield you also got one in Carlisle Pennsylvania you're going to establish one in Harpers Ferry Virginia there is one established in Fort Washington which is now downtown Cincinnati there's fortifications at Annapolis all owned by the federal government he's going to ask if they'd be strengthened and preserved so there's an interest from the early federal government from the very beginning

**[1:09:22]:** of preserving large-scale weaponry and ordnance big debate uh yeah I don't know if it's a big debate this is a small debate that even has some very vehement gun rights people arguing among themselves too is that can you own anything does the second give you the right now the Heller decision 2008 says that there's not a right to any weapon whatsoever any time can you own a tank can you own a bazooka can you want a rocket launcher the argument on the other side is well you can own anything that the army might have because you have to be ready as an armed populace to one day face the army in case there was tyranny but I think Shay's rebellion is illuminating in that respect in that there was an attempt to take a federal Armory and the government responded and in that armory there was an Artillery Park as I said you know history might be very different we might

**[1:10:25]:** have Italy at minimum two states of Massachusetts and maybe two different countries in that area if Shay's was able to obtain ordnance weapons as you saw in the Springfield Armory battle that was decisive there wasn't a musket shot fired so ordnance in those days could decide battles one of the most important things for when the British Army occupied Boston during the Revolution is that we were able to bring siege guns overlooking Boston when the British were forced to leave so a lot of those battles at that time revolved around who could get cannon and who couldn't so you see a big debate now about what type of weapons somebody can own can you want a tank and by the way there's many states we can in most cases you're supposed to remove the armament on it what kind of weapons can you won't the point chill here is that what people own private cannon in

**[1:11:19]:** those days and I'm not disagreeing with that point I do think a lot of the ownership of private cannon was in a couple of ways to then donate to a militia use usually the private person raise funds it was the only way the army could raise funds in the Revolutionary War days in some cases private people raised funds for the benefit of the Association the Continental Congress they then donated their efforts donated their time donated their equipment to the militia purpose or to the Continental art eggs Alexander Hamilton is one who drills with a private artillery company in New York prior to the revolution

**[1:12:00]:** another group that might have some kind of large ordinance was those who own ships those who engaged in privateering however I think that has to be seen that the use of those cans was limited to shipboard use

**[1:12:21]:** the use of armories by the federal even before it was a federal government under the Constitution even as a confederal Congress demonstrated that there was a desire to keep ordinance separate from arms and it's some degree to keep a large amount of arms separate that there wasn't a total commitment to an absolute lack of a standing army as there always was one even when it was small I think that event in American history is seminal it's rich in precedence across a variety of issues that we're debating right now it's also useful for understanding a precedent of protest in the early American public and that there was a tolerance of setting up a system where you could quell the rebellion but let's Institute some pardoned procedures because that's reflected both in the actions have saved John Hancock and in the system that we'd set up in the federal government and when there's whiskey rebellion the 1790s

**[1:13:23]:** and George Washington goes out with his army to put that down he's also going to use those pardon powers in the same way if you're looking for a precedent of how protest is handled in a Republican government from the very beginning you can't keep courts from functioning you can't keep government from functioning what we're gonna try to dress grievances through the Republican process there's another issue that Chase brings out different one and this is the issue of returning to vets because it's the entire story of Shay's rebellion Daniel Shays Henry McCullough Luke day all of them were heroes of the nation they retreated terribly never given the promised hate that States and the Continental Congress had promised them they were paid in worthless scrip securities that were rendered worthless during the period we're talking about in later when the Constitution is founded they were bought up by speculators who made fortunes on them and we

**[1:14:28]:** discussed a lot about James Madison in this cast and you may have seen a little bit more of a federalist side to Madison in that and I think because the time period we're talking about this is where his head was one of things that's gonna turn him is going to be the treatment of veterans when we do federal government will be do a consolidation of all the debts of the states or the Revolutionary War into the federal government debt and there are securities he's gonna want to make a provision to reward veterans who previously owned these securities and it's voted down and that's one of the things that's going to turn a bit politically against some of the larger expansions the type that that Hamilton's doing now in the case of the Revolutionary War veterans American governments are going to start to issue pensions at first for disability then just for service and also then

**[1:15:23]:** to some wives and family Daniel Shays himself applies for a pension in 1818 it gets it

**[1:15:36]:** it's a reminder now as we have many returning vets that we don't have always a great history of treating them well and as a nation we can do better hope you enjoyed this look I want to thank you for listening the website is WWSD can beat up your politics.com if you go there one of the things we have there's a link where you can donate make any donation thanks for listening

**[1:16:16]:** you
