Transcript

good morning welcome back um ah so the Red Sox won that's pretty convincing yeah very good yay Red Sox um so um as you can also tell I I have something of a cold so I will uh see if I make it my voice makes it through but what I wanted to do today if the voice allows was to talk about genomics now this is a little bit different than uh what we normally do in the class because I work on genomics it's something I I'm extremely interested in and so what I wanted to do today and I'll do it one more time near the end of the the uh term is to talk about research that's going on in genomics give you a sense of what's really going on I can assure you that almost nothing I say will be in the textbook or any other textbook um and I'm not entirely sure how this might appear on an exam so don't ask because I'm going to really just talk about research that's going on today and part of the purpose of doing that is to a show you that it's possible for you to understand the kind of research that's going on in this field and B I hope to excite you about what's going on in this field so each year I pick different things to talk about and I've picked a few things things and we'll see so feel free to interrupt and ask questions and all that uh but this is very much more uh sort of the edge of genomics including stuff that's going on you know right now as we speak so we'll fire away so a little introductory stuff I've called this we can actually leave the lights up I think people can people read that yeah it's fine good so we'll leave the lights up I can see people um so I think the thing that sets apart this revolution in biology that we're living through right now is the transformation of biology not just from being a study of living organisms to the study of chemicals and enzymes to the study of molecules but to the study of biology as information that is what's distinctive about this decade is the idea that the information Sciences have begun to merge with Biology uh or biology merged with information sciences and that it's having a profound effect on driving biomedicine in both of the two talks I'll give this one and near the end of the term that will be the common theme because I think that's the most important uh thing that's going on right now now just to remind you of course the idea that biology is about information is an old one it goes back to my hero Gregor mendle with the recognition that information was passed from parent to offspring according to rules and as you know the the history of of biology in the 20th century can be read as the development of that idea of biology's information the first quarter of the 20th century the development of the idea that the information lives in chromosomes the next quarter of the 20th century the idea that the information of the chromosomes resides in the DNA double helix and that information was contained in this molecule and somehow in its sequence and you know all this in the next quarter of the 20th century basically from at 1950 to 1975 understanding how it is that the cell reads out that information from DNA to RNA to protein how it uses a genetic code to translate rnas into proteins and the development of the tools of Rec combinant DNA that made it possible for us to read out the information that the cell reads out so that brought us three quarters of the way through the 20th century with the ability to read out genetic information at least in little ways but they were little ways you could write a PhD thesis around that time uh for sequencing 200 letters of DNA that would be you know considered an amazingly exciting PhD thesis the next quarter of the 20th century the last quarter of the 20th century was characterized by a voracious appetite to read as much of this information as possible started first with trying to read out the sequence of individual genes then then sets of genes then genomes of small organisms bacteria mediumsized organisms and then in a wonderful closure to 20th century the reading out of the nearly complete genetic information of the human being in the closing weeks of the 20th century when you remember that that um mendle was rediscovered in January of 1900 that's when the papers rediscovering mendle came out and you you figure you've got almost perfect bookends from the ReDiscover of mendal in January 1900 to the sequencing of the human genome in around 2000 you realize what a century can do it's not bad as centuries go you know to accomplish all that and it g because I mean you know as students you get a point estimate in time of what science knows but you guys aren't old enough yet and haven't lived long enough yet to measure the derivative and see how rapidly it's changing but just look at what happened over the course of that century and then just project forward to what that could mean for the next Century so what it's done is it's brought us to this picture I have a picture in my head of biology as a vast library of information a library of information in which Evolution has been taking patient notes evolution is a very good experimentalist and it's a very patient notetaker its notes of course are written in the genomes and uh every day Evolution wakes up changes a few nucleotides sees how the organism works if it was an improvement Evolution keeps the notes if it was uh disadvantageous Evolution discards the notes that by the way for those of you working in Labs is no longer considered appropriate laboratory practice you're obliged to keep your laboratory notes from failed experiments as well but evolution got into this before those rules were codified and so it discards the notes from unsuccessful experiments and keeps the notes from the successful experiments but nonetheless we have all the notes from the successful experiments and uh we can learn a tremendous amount from them there's a volume on that shelf corresponding to each species on the planet there's a volume on the Shelf corresponding to each individual within each species to each tissue within each individual within each species and there's information there about the DNA sequence about the RNA readouts about the protein expression levels and in principle even if not quite yet in practice we could pull down any volume we want and interrogate it and compare it for related species for individuals within a species some of who might have a disease some of whom might not for different kinds of tissues treated in different ways that is I think going to be a tremendous theme of biology going forward and that's why it's a particular pleasure to teach biology at MIT where you guys understand what that could mean that Fusion could mean now this idea of extracting genomic information in large scale is a relatively new one in the mid 1980s the scientific Community began debating what was a pretty radical idea sequencing the human genome uh this was floated in a couple of places in 1984 at one meeting somebody raised the idea uh you got to realize that that sequencing itself the idea of sequencing DNA only came from the late 70s So within six seven years of being able to sequence anything people were now saying let's sequence everything that was a reasonably audacious thing to do and it was controversial um there were many people who felt that the Human Genome Project was a terrible idea and with good reason because the initial version of the Human Genome Project was kind of a blunderbus approach it was let's immediately mount a massive factory and start sequencing the human genome with the just horrible Technologies of the mid 880s uh with radioactive sequencing gels and you know lots and lots of people doing stuff and so uh you know indeed many people in science were con were concerned that an entire generation of students would have to be chained to the bench sequencing DNA Sydney brener uh great molecular biologist proposed the whole thing be done in Penal institutions because uh and you know people could be sentenced to 20 million bases with time off for accuracy or things like that um and so what happened was the scientific Community came together well in in its best form um group a group was put together by the National Academy of Sciences who said well look this is a really good idea but we also need a carefully thought through program to do it we need intermediate goals that'll get us things that Advance the science along the way we need to improve the Technologies and laid out a plan the goals of that plan develop a genetic map a map showing the locations of DNA polymorphism sites of variation genetic markers just like Sturdivant did with fruit flies but to do it with humans and with DNA sequence differences to be used to trace inheritance that that that genetic map could be used to map human diseases and if all you accomplish was got a genetic map of the human being that would be a good thing then you could get a physical map of the human being all the pieces of DNA overlapping each other so that you would know if you had a genetic marker linked to cystic fibrosis you would be able to get the piece of DNA that contains the gene then if we managed to pull that off we could get a sequence of the human genome all three billion nucleotides on on the web so that you could just go to any place in the genome double click and up would pop the sequence now you guys of course don't laugh at that but about eight years ago when I would give talks about this I would speak about oh you'll be able to go double click and uple pop the sequence and of course everybody thought it was really funny and that was that was something people laughed at but of course you can just do that today if anybody has a wireless you can just double click and up will pop the sequence um and then of course a complete inventory of all the genes within that sequence and very importantly and from the very beginning the notion that all this information should be completely freely available to anybody regardless of where they were whether in Academia or industry in in First World countries third world countries that everybody should have free and un unrestricted access to that information so a plan was laid out I won't go into these details here but the plan was laid out that involved work in constructing genetic Maps physical maps sequence maps in the human in the mouse in some model organisms including the bacteria yeast fruit flies worms and uh quite remarkably it largely went according to plan over the course of about 15 years a lot of people in the scientific Community came together and took up different tasks um I should say with some pride that MIT was was uh by far one of the leading contributors to this whole effort having been involved in essentially every stage of this the genetic mapping of human and mouse the physical mapping of human and mouse and the sequencing of human and mouse and having been the leading contributor to that that latter and it's not an accident because MIT is a marvelous environment in which to undertake this kind of research it involved changing the way we do biology back in the mid 80s when we sequenced DNA we did it with radioactivity remember when I taught you how a sequence I said you can use a radioactive label and a gel and all that that's how we did it you stood behind this plastic shield and you loaded the gels and of course now it's done in a highly automated fashion this is the production floor at the Bro Institute which is here on MIT where robots prepare all the DNA samples so eoli grown up and then you have to crack open the cells purify the DNA purify purify the plasmid do a sequencing reaction etc etc it's all done robotically there and this is capable of processing and does process in a given day about 200,000 samples per day they then go have and this is all equipment designed by people here at MIT and then commercially built for us um they then go to the back room where actually these are the previous generation of DNA sequencers commercial detectors those those capillary detectors that have the little lasers on them there's a whole Farm of them that sit there and are able to get data out and in the course of a single day we can now generate about 40 billion bases sorry in the course of a single year we can generate about 40 billion bases of DNA sequence the Genome Project itself was a collaboration involving 20 different groups around the world groups in the United States the United Kingdom and France and Germany and Japan and China they were of different sizes different they used different approaches uh but everybody was committed to one common cause of producing this information and making it freely available and everybody work together and for the rest of my life when it comes to Friday at 11 o'clock I will always you know think Genome Project because we had a weekly conference call uh of all the groups in the world working on this Fridays at 11: uh and it was a fascinating experience over the course of many many years for that so A draft sequence a rough draft sequence of the human Gena was published in in the year in February of 2001 it was announced with some Fanfare in June of 2000 um but the real scientific paper came out in February of 2001 this was not a perfect sequence of the human genome by any means this covered about 90% of the sequence of the human genome it still had about 150,000 gaps in it it had errors but it still did have about 90% of the sequence of human genome for the next three years people worked very hard and as of last April a sequence of the human genome was produced and was published a couple weeks ago and it contains our best guess about 99.3% of the human genome and it still has about 343 gaps they're you know we know where they are we know what they are but but they're not sequenceable with current Technologies that's the quote finished Human Genome what is it like well this is a picture of a genome do we have a pointer let's see here we do have a pointer uh this is your genome here this is chromosome number 11 and I'll call it ption to some interesting bits so these colored lines here represent genes or Gene predictions based on uh both sequencing of cdnas and mapping them back to the genome as well as computer programs that analyze the genome and uh they're they're right here you have a big pile up lots of genes very few genes over here lots of genes and few genes notice the places where there are lots of genes match up with the with these light gray bands which are the light gray bands in the microscope on chromosomes the place with very few genes match up with the dark bands in the chromosome and do you know why that is that the gene Rich regions are these chromosome light bands and the gene poor regions of the chromosome dark bands me neither nobody nobody has a clue uh it's it's really you know just one of these things we had no reason to expect that we'd see these striking patterns and other genomes eoli doesn't have this dense Urban cluster and these big rural PLS that are Gene port this is this is very weird um and it's distinctive to mammals uh you'll also notice that the gene Rich regions here are rich in G's and C's they have different distributions of some repeat elements all sorts of weirdness that just comes from looking at the genome the biggest weirdness was the number of genes the count of genes is our best guess about 22,500 genes if I had to pick a number today would be our count of genes and of course that's down from the 100,000 that was in some textbooks and it's down even from the 30 to 40,000 that was in the genome paper of February of 2001 our best guess is that it's really just about that range now the genes themselves are very interesting when you look at you know if we only have 22,000 genes you know what do we how do we manage to to run a human being with so few genes it is by the way probably fewer genes than the mustard wheed or redops thalana has so what do we do well humans uh one one thing we may take comfort in is that we although we only have about 22,000 genes there's a lot of alternative splicing and on average a typical gene on average has about two alternative splice products some have many some have few but probably when you're all done those 22,000 genes May encode 70 80,000 different proteins and it could be more than that because we don't know all the alternative splice products and and what they do uh but if you ask are you know can humans get credit for being uh really inventive or creative for having lots of new genes that make us human the answer is no not only are humans not different in their Gene complement from other mammals mammals as a group really haven't invented that much when you get down to it most of the recognizable subdomains of proteins proteins are built up of subdomains recognizable sequences that have certain motifs that fold up in certain ways or carry out certain enzymatic functions and it looks like our genomes our genes are mix and match combinations of many domains that were invented a long time ago in invertebr and before and that most of evolutionary innovation in the more complex multicellular animals has simply been mixing and matching these these domains in new ways to get slightly different functions you don't get a lot of points for creativity but it does seem to work now by far the most derivative of all and what characterizes our genome tremendously is when a gene Works make extra copies of it and let it diverge slightly and take up new functions really your genome is just characterized by large expansions of families imunoglobulin like genes intermediate filament proteins holding together the cyto skeleton there are 111 different keratin like genes in your genome they're all different they do different things but they all came from one gene that was copied copied copied at random randomly duplicated and then diverged to take up new functions uh growth factors flies and worms manage to get by just fine thank you with two growth factors of the TGF beta class whatever that is you have 42 growth factors of this TGF beta class all of which help communicate cells communicate in different ways and then of course olfactory receptors uh in your genome you have about a thousand genes for Ola Factory for smell receptors this is what Richard Axel and Linda Buck won a Nobel Prize for uh this year was their work on olfactory receptors um sad to say though out of your thousand olfactory receptors genes most of them are broken they're mostly pseudogenes um it's not true in dogs and mice who keep their olfactory receptor genes in pretty fine working order but it's very clear that in primates with color vision our olfactory receptor genes have been going to seed they have been piling up mutations and there's no selective pressure to keep many of them and in fact we've now shown in a paper that'll come out soon that this process is accelerating dramatically in the last 7 million years since we diverged from chimps and so humans have almost completely lost interest in smell that's not totally true some of these olfactory receptors surely matter for feris processes but most of them are probably irrelevant right now um and so anyway that's that's the nature of the genes there another interesting fact that's worth mentioning about your genome is half of your genome consists of transposable elements elements that simply duplicate themselves and Hop Around The genome elements that are like viruses they make a copy sometimes into RNA the RNA is copied back into DNA and slammed elsewhere in your genome uh these elements well the there are four classes Alo elements uh line elements retrovirus like elements all of these go through AR Na intermediates and use reverse transcription and then there's certain DNA transposons that go through a DNA intermediate the number of copies of the Aloo element the Aloo element that that's hopped around your genome is about a million you have a million fossils of this element that's hop and you say why is it there and the answer is because it's there because anything that knows how to make a copy of itself and insert itself in your genome you can't get rid of you could consider it if you wish an infection but half of your genome consists of an infection with these kinds of transposable elements now that said yes what about the well it's very interesting um what's the effect well they do some of them are transcribed and uh it's it's very interesting sometimes it's bad one of them will hop into a gene and mutate it and that's bad that that person will have a lethal mutation but uh the genome has probably begun to use them and and and uh count on their being there so when a bunch when a transposable goes in and creates a spacing if you if for example if if an engineering committee came in and cleaned up the genome by getting rid of all the transposable elements it would surely not work because we have evolutionarily come to count on the spacing there sort of like if if in your in some very um messy attic you put a cup of coffee down on top of a stack of papers those papers may be utterly irrelevant but now they're holding up that cup of coffee that you put down on it and if and if you were to just puff magically get rid of them the cuup coffee would come crashing to the ground so you know it they're just there taking up space now sometimes even more than that a few of them have actually been co-opted into being human genes we've know that a few of these transposable elements have mutated into being our genes that do something for us and others of them may do things in affecting the general neighborhood with regard to transcription and so instead of being a parasite think of them as a symbiot that it's a genomic symbion which takes some advantage of us and we may you know have worked out a compromise to take some advantage of it every time a copy is made of these and it hops in the genome some mutations may happen in the in the master element but when it lands in the new place we have a record of that hop and if you reconstruct the sequence of the million Alo elements you can see which ones are very close relatives of each other and had to have H hopped recently and which ones are somewhat more distant relatives and more dist relatives and you can build an evolutionary tree connecting all of the repeat elements that have hopped around your genome and thereby attach a date to each of them as to when they hopped so it really is a fossil record and you can figure out how many have been hopping at different times over history and we can even make a plot of that this is long ago sometime here uh some 30 million years ago there was a huge explosion in transposing in our transposons in our genome we don't know why that happened but it's very interesting it does correspond to very interesting periods in primate Evolution and then interestingly there's been a huge crash and transposition has dropped dramatically we have no clue why this is but we have a whole fossil record here of the rate of transposition of different kinds of repeat elements around our genome and people are now trying to figure out what in the world this means so all this is sort of their inherence in the sequence and if you want the sequence as I say you can go to to the web and pull all this stuff down so uh now how do we how do we understand this sequence well I've told you a little bit about it from the the simple things that we've done but there's a lot more that needs to be learned about this sequence and so what I really want to turn to is how we're extracting information out of this sequence so DNA sequence is long and boring it's only marginally more interesting than reading your hard dis because it has four letters instead of ones and zeros but it's you know it's really pretty boring if you take a look at how do you attach meaning to all this stuff one of the most powerful ways is by comparison with other genomes and so comparing the human genome to the mouse genome is very informative in many ways so as soon as the human genome was far along uh a portion of the international Consortium set to work getting a sequence of the mouse genome and that was published in December of 2002 we have a nice map of the mouse genome with all these things it too shows these Gene Rich regions Gene poor regions all sorts of funny things and if we look closely at a portion of the human genome over here I've picked about a million bases of the human genome and we take any little spot in that million bases of the human genome let's say over here we take out the DNA sequence corresponding to this spot and we run it in the computer against the mouse genome and ask where in the mouse genome do we get the best match to this the best match to this is here now let's do it for this piece here the best match anywhere in the mouse genome lands in the same million bases here of the mouse genome in fact for every single sequence that we pull out from this million bases of the human genome the best match is in this is in this million basis of the mouse genome that's very interesting why is that sorry no people do know in this it was a good good try though um this million bases of the mouse genome and this million bases of the human genome represent the evolutionary descendants of a common million bases that occurred in our common ancestor 75 million years ago this is a clear evidence of the evolution here because we can see this is a segment of DNA from our common ancestor that really hasn't undergone much rearrangement and we can just line up the sequences and see in fact we can build a whole map across the mouse genome like this for any bit of the mouse genome I don't know here's a bit on Mouse chromosome number 17 this whole stretch corresponds to a portion of human chromosome number eight this stretch here I don't know this so this green color here on chromosome number six corresponds to chromosome four in the human and so we can build a lookup table that says for any portion of the human genome what's the corresponding portion of the mouse genome that came from the same ancestor and has basically the same complement of genes in it and then only about 330 such regions that we need to cut and paste the human genome order into the mouse genome order roughly speaking there's a lot of little local rearrangements but at this gross level so now if we go back more closely and we look at this we say okay so now we look at this region we now know these two regions descend from a common ancestor if we do a careful evolutionary analysis lining up all the sequences and see how well preserved the sequences are some are much better preserved than others Evolution has been much more lovingly conserving certain sequences than others and so let's let's now zoom in on a gene this is a gene that goes by the name PP R gamma I'm fond of this Gene but no it doesn't matter um if look I've indicated all the regions here in which there's a high degree of conservation the sequence is well conserved here here here here here here here and here here here here here here these ones correspond to the exons of the PPA gamma gene they encode the protein of the Gene and the the splicing goes like this okay these things here do not correspond to the exons people have no idea what they are in fact this is not supposed to be here uh the official textbook picture says the vast majority of what matters for a gene what evolution should preserve is the exons plus the promoter here's the promoter but in fact what we found is an awful lot more is being preserved in fact across the genome our best estimate is there about 500,000 conserved elements across the genome and only a third of them are protein coating exons that means two thirds of the stuff Evolution has been interested in is not protein coating exons and the truth is we do not know what it is this was a very radical finding when this Mouse paper came out about a year and a half about two years ago now uh what it must be I think but we're guessing are regulatory signals structural elements in chromosomes RNA genes but there's an awful lot more of it than we had imagined and we've now in this F fting situation where computational analysis has told us what's on Evolution's mind and now we have to go to the lab and figure out what in the world it does but there's no doubt that it must do something because Evolution has preserved it quite well now I oversimplified greatly in this discussion um me first say then I'll come back to that we do know that if we take some of those elements here's one there a 41 base pair element that's 84% identical between human and mouse you could write yourself a little statistical model to say that's way unusual to have something so well preserved when Eddie Rubin and his colleagues in Berkeley made a knockout mouse that deleted that segment this knockout Mouse loses regulation of three different genes in the neighborhood saying that this must be a regulatory sequence that affects multiple genes in the neighborhood that's good that's one there's about 300,000 such elements to go uh in order to attach meaning to them and so doing this entirely by knocking out mice will be a slow process one's going to need need other ways to be able to attach meaning but uh there's no doubt now there's some other interesting papers where people have knocked some of these things out and they've seen no effect on the mouse they get a totally viable Mouse can you conclude from that that they have no function why not The Knockout Mouse is viable could be redundant could be redundant could even not be redundant yes so it could be redundant but you couldn't knock out both of two things turns out suppose knocking it out affected the mouse's viability by one part and 10 to the3 it was only 99.9% as fertile would you be able to see that in the laboratory no would that matter to Evolution it would be lethal in an evolutionary sense such mutation could never propagate through the population one part and 10 to the 3 is massive selection against from an evolutionary point of view but almost undetectable at the laboratory bench Evolution has a far more sensitive assay than we do now I I won't go into detail but for the mathematically inclined here showing that there really were about 5% of the human genome under under evolutionary selection was a complicated affair because with only two genomes what we really had to do and if this doesn't make sense ignore it we looked at the background distribution of conservation in the genome in unimportant elements in those repeat elements that we knew to be uh functionally broken we looked at the overall conservation of the genome and found that the overall genome had this rightward tail by subtracting the distributions we were able to see how much excess conservation there was that's because we only had two genomes we had to draw inferences if we had more genomes like The Mouse and the rat and the dog and the this and the that we would be able to extract signal from noise we would be able to see right away which bits were well conserved we wouldn't have to do this as a sensitive statistical analysis so in fact we need more Mamon genomes so so right now there's been a sequence of the Rat genome in the past year or so there is a sequence of the dog genome we're writing up that paper now but it's on the web already there's a sequence of the chimpanzee genome writing up a paper on that this is in collaboration with our friends in the in the genome sequencing Community we're currently sequencing a variety of other organisms as well and if you had enough organisms you ought to just be able to line it up and say what is evolution preserved and figure out exactly which nucleotides matter and which nucleotides don't are allowed to drift freely at the background rate how far could you go with this well we decided to try an interesting experiment we said since since mammals are very big and we're going to need a lot of genome sequence how about we try a small organism like yeast what if we were to try to do this this kind of evolutionary genomic analysis on something like the yeast genome and so this is work that I'll describe that was between uh a bunch of people here at MIT who do genome sequencing and a student in computer science manoli Kelly who was a PhD student in computer science he's now Jo joined the faculty here at MIT and computer science uh but it was a really great example of how biology and computer science could come together so the genome sequencing folks sequenced three related species to our friend the baker's yeast sacris seris Workhorse of geneticists these three different species are separated by different evolutionary distances from sacris Cici uh when you line up their genomes just like with human and mouse you find the genes occur largely in the same order and uh you know it's not hard to pick out that oh yeah there's this Gene there there this is all lined up you get these evolutionary segments and very few rearrangements have occurred across these species despite the fact that they're about 20 million years apart in the extreme uh but here's an interesting thing when the yeast genome sacr my cice was first published in 1995 the paper describing it reported 6,200 genes now how did they know there were 6,200 genes they ran a computer program looking for open reading frames any open reading frame consecutive code on without a stop that was sufficiently long was called a gene but statistically you could by chance just have a long stretch of codons without a stop codon and so if I saw a 100 codons in a row without a stop they called it a gene but it might just be chance and they knew that of course they wrote that in the paper but for many years people then had 6,200 open reading frames which were the yeast genes could Evolution now tell us which of them were real and which weren't well it turns out Evolution was tremendously powerful at doing that if you take something that's a well-known Gene that has been extensively studied by yeast geneticists and you line it up across all four species you almost never see deletions and when you do see delions here in Gray they're always a multiple of three why are they a multiple of three they preserve the reading frame by contrast if I take some clear intergenic DNA that's not protein coding and I compare it across the four species I see lots and lots of frame shifting deletions that occur Evolution tolerates frame shifting deletions and if I just write down the rates frame shifting deletions are 75 times more common in intergenic DNA than genic DNA this provides a very powerful test test run this test across the genome looking for the density of frame shifting deletions any place that doesn't tolerate frame shifting deletions is probably a real Gene anything that does tolerate it is probably not when you sorted through all this it turned out that 528 of the official yeast genes were clearly not open not real genes they were just chocka block full of these frame shifting delions and that and but a bunch of others could be confirmed and so the yeast Gene count and I won't tell you all the experimental and other evidence that shows that this this is right but the yeast genome has now been revised downward to 5700 genes and we have great confidence that almost all of those are real genes there about 20 at the margins that we're not sure of out of that and new genes could be found in this way and uh here was a really audacious thing this this graduate student in computer science said I think based on these other species there was a mistake made in the sequencing of the first yeast and the reason these things are called two separate genes is that somebody made a sequencing error that got a stop coat on here but I think these are really part of just one Gene and so somebody went back and resequenced some of these and sure enough he had correctly predicted that there had been a mistake made at that letter and that these were in fact a single Gene the computational analysis was incredibly powerful in this regard now you could go further than this you could ask could I also figure out the way genes are regulated in this fashion could I work out the intergen signals in the promoter regions remember that lack repressor binds to a certain operator site well all of these regulatory proteins bind to different sequences could we figure out what the sequences were computationally well if we look closely at a genic intergenic region here's one where there are two genes being transcribed in opposite directions gal 1 and gal 10 both involved in galactose metabolism and there's a particular protein a a transcription Factor here called galor that binds in this region and it has a particular sequence that it likes ccg 11 bases GGC so that gal forite we see is very well preserved across all of the species so a known regulatory sequence is well preserved in fact let's look at this closely this gfor binding site is a measly crummy six nucleotides of information at random it's going to occur many places in the East genome but not be a real important gal forite right some of them matter some of them don't how do we figure out which of these occurrences are real gal forides well if we look across all four species what we find is that those occurrences that occur in promoter regions are much more likely to be conserved by Evolution than those that don't so there's a special property here conservation of The Motif in promoter regions in fact this particular sequence is four times more likely to be preserved when it occurs in a promoter region than what it occurs in a coding region and for a typical control region the opposite is true since genes since coding sequences are better preserved in general for a randomly chosen sequence I don't know a g GCA T it's more likely to be preserved in in coding regions than non-coding regions so this gal for Motif has the very funky property that on average it's 12 times more likely than background to be preserved when it occurs in a promoter now that's a test you could apply to another Motif and another Motif in fact you could by computer test all possible motifs and ask which ones have that property take make a scatter plot most motifs are better conserved when they occur in coding regions than promoter regions some however are better preserved in promoter regions than in coding regions our friend gal 4 is up there but there are a lot more things like it that are better preserved by evolution in promoters you can make a list of them you can get about 72 well-conserved regulatory motifs and it turns out that 20 years of yeast work produced knowledge about things like the gal for site and other sites almost all the known regulatory sites that had been discovered over the course of 20 years through experimental work appear on this list that falls out of the computer analysis of evolutionary comparison of genomes you can actually go a step further I'll hesitate to tell you but I'll try anyway if you wanted to find out without knowing in advance what these motifs were doing what their biological function was you can do that informationally too turns out that if I take my Motif gal 4 and I asked which genes does it occur in front of well across sacris cier you find this crummy little Motif in many many places because as I said most of this is just noise but if I ask which genes have this Motif in all four species these genes there's a huge overlap with a class of genes involved in carbohydrate metabolism so if I didn't know in advance that the gal 4 Motif was involved in regulating genes in carbohydrate metabolism I could tell just from the fact that the genes that had conserved it are genes involved in carbohydrate metabolism you can do that using all sorts of Tricks expression of genes protein Mass Spec blah blah blah blah and the short answer is for almost all of those motifs that you can find in the computer by Consulting public databases of sets of genes that are coexpressed or have similar properties and all that the computer can also offer you a pretty good hypothesis about what that Mo Motif is associated with you can even go a step further than that you can begin to look at pairs of motifs you can say if I have a certain regulatory sequence and a number one and another regulatory sequence number two do they tend to be preserved in of the same genes as each other is is their conservation correlated and you can build a map of these two guys tend when this guy's correlated this guy tends to be correlated and this guy and you can say oh those proteins must be talking to each other and you can read that off from the pattern of evolution as well there are two Regulators one called sterile 12 one called tech one this computational analysis shows that they tend to co-occur in a conserved fashion far more often than you would expect by chance and when you do the analysis you find that those genes that just have a conserved sterile 12 those genes tend to be involved in mating genes that just have a conserved instance of Tech 1 tend to be involved in the budding of the yeast and those genes that have conserved occurrences of both tend to be involved in filamentation now all that can be read out which is way cool this is not the way we used to do biology now don't get me wrong there's a ton of experiments that underlay creating these databases and there's a ton of experiments that have to be done to check any of these things but what we have is one of the most powerful hypothesis generators that's ever been seen here evolution by telling us what to focus on is giving us on a silver platter hundreds of hypotheses about who's interacting with whom and sending us back to the lab then to to test these hypothesis now what are the implications of all of this for the human genome could we do this for the human genome well these species sacris paradoxus MTI bis are they a good model for mammals Well turns out that their evolutionary distance from each other is the same as the distance of human to lemur to dog to Mouse so they were chosen a purpose those actually are fairly good models for the human so could we do exactly the same analysis for the human for the entire Human Genome if we had human lemur dog and mouse or basically four species human mouse rat and dog well there's one little fly in the ointment the human genome is 20 times bigger than the yeast genome if I want to analyze the whole Human Genome I have a problem of signal to noise the genome's 20 times bigger I got 20 times as much noise to get rid of I won't walk you through it but I need more evolutionary information to get rid of all that noise and you can do a simple calculation that says my evolutionary tree needs to be bigger its Branch length needs to be bigger by about the natural log of 20 to get rid of 20 fold more noise and uh that would mean I need more species I need about 16 species or something like that to be able to do that but if I built an evolutionary tree that had a branch length of four that is four substitutions per base across this evolutionary tree as indicated by these colored lines here I should have enough power to analyze the entire Human Genome the way we just did the yeast genome so we currently have human chimp mouse rat dog as of this fall during in fact right at the beginning of of this term the National Institutes of Health signed off on sequencing of these additional eight mammals these mammals are now in process and in fact the elephant is done and the armadillo is in process and the tree shrew is being caught I think at the moment we have the 10 the ten don't don't talk about the Tre shrews anyway uh the ten is is uh actually being tested right now Etc and all this is going on right now as we speak and I think that by next summer we should have much of and by certainly NE by about a year from now we should have almost all of this information to do such an analysis now that said we're of course you know very impatient people you could just take the human the mouse the rat and the dog and I said that's not enough if you wanted to analyze the whole genome but suppose you just wanted to analyze a portion of the genome maybe about a yeast siiz piece of the genome well let's see you got 20,000 genes I don't know suppose I take I don't know two kilobases around each of 20,000 genes well that's you know 40 megabases of DNA it's only a couple fold more than yeast maybe if I just focused on a limited region around each promoter I could start reading out these regulatory signals with just four species so in fact a post fellow is has been working on this problem over the summer and uh and a little bit from the spring the summer uh together with with manoli Kelly who's now in the computer science department and uh I think we have a preliminary list for the human genome that's fallen out over the course of the past couple of months and we're in the process right now of finishing up a paper that we're hoping to get submitted by Friday with a preliminary list of the regulatory signals in the human genome read out from evolution of human mouse rat and dog it won't be everything we don't have full power to pick up all possible signals but we're picking up a lot of the signals we're picking up a very large fraction of previously discovered signals and lots more new signals as well are falling out of that analysis so anyway I can assure you that that's not in the textbooks because it actually hasn't been submitted yet um this other stuff I've described about the yeast analyses uh this if you do want to look it up there was a paper in nature about a year and change ago Kelly at all describes this yeast work this is what's going on um this is what's fun about teaching at MIT is I can tell you this stuff and you guys have a sense for the convergence that's going on in our field much of what I've tried to make the biology you know in making the biology clear I've talked about how the different directions genetics biochemistry have converged together what we're really seeing now is information science is converging with that as well and I got to say it's a tremendous amount of fun see on Monday good luck on the quiz