Transcript

Hi everyone. Um, if I can have your attention. We are about to start a panel entitled creating investable supply at scale through Article 6 implementation. Uh, this isn't really about the carbon markets, the supply into Article 6, and we have on stage with us an amazing array of speakers. My name is Tommy Ricketts. I'm the CEO of a company called BZero. We do carbon ratings. Uh, we're going to be moderated today by Ooi Gi, who is the CEO of CIX, the Singapore Based Exchange. We're going to be joined by uh, Sandeep, who's the co-founder of VNV, one of the world's largest developers, Fred, who is the CEO of GenZero, um, and Juliana, who is from the Environmental Protection Agency in Ghana.

Uh, and hopefully you're going to learn about the the guts of implementing Article 6 and different perspectives on supply and how you construct that supply. Thank you very much for listening. Hi everyone. Thank you for joining us. My name is Ooi Gi. I'm from Climate Impact X. We're a global carbon credit exchange. Um, we recently just announced yesterday, uh, well two days ago, um, that we're working with EDB on a central procurement facility for Article 6 in Singapore for the carbon tax liable companies and and others who need Article 6. So we're very excited to be hosting this panel because we all want this to work at scale.

And Singapore of course has signed many, many implementation agreements, um, and I think what where we are now is the implement how to get this implementation agreements to fruition. And so I'm very happy to have here with me on this panel, a great panel to be debating across the different perspectives. We have Fred, who's the CEO of GenZero. Uh, we have Sandeep, who's the CEO of VNV, a project developer. Uh, we have Juliana Bempah from Environmental Protection Agency Ghana. And of course we have Tommy Ricketts, CEO of B Zero. Very very happy to have these enlightened folks here with us today.

So I'm going to start with a couple of questions. I'm going to start with Juliana and the most important from a government's point of view, from a host country perspective, what have been the significant friction points in moving from a signed agreement to an active project pipeline and credit issuance? And how can these be addressed by, you know, the stakeholders in the room? Thank you. I hope I'm audible. Okay. Thank you for inviting me on this panel and for Ghana to share what we have been doing with Singapore all this while. So maybe let me introduce myself once again. I'm Juliana. I work with the Environmental Protection Authority with the Carbon Market Office.

And so to begin with, we started with Singapore by signing an MOU in 2020 and then that was able to progress into we signing an implementation agreement with the government of Singapore in May 2024 after which we had a call for projects applications and based on that we have been able to receive various applications and with the Ghana portfolio, Singapore's pipeline of projects is the largest actually. We have about 46 projects within our pipeline which is the largest and it actually begins from forestry projects to energy projects to waste projects amongst others. And what we have been able to do over the period is to vet these projects due to the various stages of applications.

Singapore's implementation agreement is quite unique from the other ones that we have signed. It's the only implementation agreements that you need to go through a stage A, that is a concept stage, and then we have the stage B application that is also focused on the PDD stage, and then we have the stage C which is on the authorization, and then we have stage D which is the issuance transfer stage. So it's quite unique from all the other implementation agreements that we have signed. One of the friction areas that we have actually looked at has to do with the eligibility criteria list the ELs as we term it.

Usually we have the ELs that we usually would agree with from both Ghana side and also the Singapore side. And we realize that sometimes there are some methodologies that Ghana would want it to be onboarded onto the the EL list, and then sometimes Singapore would also have to onboard a number of methodologies onto the EL list. And that usually takes time because if you look at the Singapore process, you would usually have to bring together the joint committee to be able to approve each eligibility list at any given time. And this process actually takes a little bit of time. And so as part of that, we have actually to bridge that gap, come up with a TP and third party note to be able to give the joint committee the mandate to be able to update any time we have any new methodology that we want to enlist on the EL list.

So that is one of the barriers we have been able to cross over the period. And then looking at the stages that sometimes applications would have to go through stage A to stage D, sometimes it delays a bit, more especially when Ghana has its own country requirement for project applications to be able to comply with. For example, we have the technical advisory committee meetings, which is um on the Ghana side a requirement that project applicants would have to comply with. And so going through these stages, sometimes some of these processes um becomes a little bit of a friction for the project developers to be able to overcome over the period.

So these are some of the highlights of frictions that we currently um looking at. And then um another thing is that some project developers do not also know about the 5% and then the 2% OMGE that at the end of the day when assets are created would have to be deducted from the emission reductions of the project. So these are some of the areas that are quite of a friction in Ghana. Thank you. Thank you. That was really insightful. Um and I'd love to hear the project developer perspective. And you know, how how can well what are some of the friction points are you aligned with some of the the the folks the points that Juliana made?

And maybe do you have potential solutions for some of these friction points? Um yeah, thanks for that. I think no, I think aligning completely with with what Juliana said. Uh but yes, there are some friction points which are common to most countries and not just I think Ghana's done really well. So I think they're one of the front runners here. But a lot of other countries are struggling and I mentioned this yesterday as well because you know it is it is a complex issue to figure out how to deal on bilaterals, right? And it needs both sides to be really interested in getting it done. What we see is one side being interested, but there's no other side.

And that's one friction point that I see that has to be resolved. Number two is what I mean what what I see is um how to engage in 6.2. Like some countries want to do their own methodologies. Singapore's done a great thing where it said, no, there is, let's make it more flexible, let's broaden the methodologies, which I think is a great thing to do. The moment we try and do our own thing all the time, I think that's a big friction point. We can I think we need to get rid of that line of thinking. I do know that some countries are going to do it regardless, but I don't really agree with that. So that is number two.

I think this flexibility on methodologies will broaden the credit flow, and I think that's important. And number three is for when host countries are getting their six two policies done, I don't think a lot of project developers are consulted. And that is a problem because you come up with rules where project development financials don't work sometimes. And I'm not saying take all their views because obviously there is a biased view there. Everybody wants to fit do their projects, but it's a very important viewpoint because you can make like I keep saying, you can make all the rules, but who can do projects following those rules.

So for me, these are some of the very big basic issues that need to be looked at because if you look at some of the carbon frameworks that are coming out there, I wouldn't do a project in that country. I would be very very far away from those countries. And they have gone through a consultation process for two years and I see who they have consulted and I'm like, guys, this is wrong. And if I am going to stay away, I would take somebody very brave because we are very risk friendly. And but if we are staying away, that would mean that this is a big problem. So for me, three things need to really work out for the friction to become less friction less.

You know, so yeah. Thanks Sandeep. Fred, you're you're a big investor in this space, but we keep talking about supply as it's very weird, right? And VCM we keep complaining about demand, but in Article six, we're now complaining about supply, which is a very interesting dynamic. And it's often cited as the binding constraint for Article 6. And as an investor putting capital into projects aimed at Singapore's compliance market, where have you seen supply get stuck? Uh whether in host country authorization, early stage financing, or confidence in quality? And and what have you found most effective in getting uh projects across the line?

Okay. While there is definitely this talk about supply constraint, right OE, I think a lot of the problems related to financing and getting projects off the ground has still got to do with making sure that the demand is actually there in the first place. Just simply because there is a carbon agreement between two countries doesn't necessarily mean that it translates into a bankable project. Um there's still got to be I mean the framework is in place for you to get the Article 6 credits, but where is the demand actually coming from? So in the case of Singapore, you potentially could get uh 5% of the tax liability, right?

And that's how we do it. But that said, companies still have a choice to either pay the tax or buy the credits. It doesn't mean that simply because you have a framework that allows for 5% of it to be satisfied through credits, that necessarily the demand is there. And why that's the case, you can have a headline tax rate. But let's just assume that the headline rate now is $50 in Singapore. If a carbon credit is being sold at $49, now if we are all economically rational, you would say I would do the $49 because it's a dollar cheaper. But in reality, that is not the case. Because for that $1 discount, the company takes on administrative uh at additional administrative burden for procuring the for to procuring credits, they would have to diligence the project.

Then they will also potentially be subject to some reputational exposure if for whatever reason something goes wrong with the carbon project. So really at a $1 discount, would they actually do this? The answer is maybe not, right? And they would expect a much steeper discount. So first of all, there is the question that is the demand really there? So even before talking about the supply constraint and what is the price that will work. And on that, I would say it is important for governments to maintain a high enough headline tax rate because the effective clearing price for the credits to be tendered into such a program typically will require a 20 30% discount to the headline rate before it works.

So that's point number one. Point number two on supply. Some of our internal studies suggest that actually there are a lot of projects that currently would be eligible for many of these compliance programs. The problem is that they are either not cleared through the bilateral process or they are not yet in the pipeline for governments to actually issue a corresponding adjustment for those projects. Now the moment that we can have clearer rules. So in other words, right now there is still a fairly bespoke bilateral process. Singapore and the IAs are not the only one. If you take for example the Japanese crediting mechanism, they similarly have to go through a a fairly involved bilateral process to agree on the methodology and agree on projects.

So these things do happen. But imagine if governments are able to agree that if a project methodology is somewhat CCP labeled or has a or a particular project has a good enough minimal you know rating from two or three of the major rating companies, then they would generally be white listed unless there is a reason not to. Then that becomes a much more business friendly, market friendly way of allowing you know all of us, developers, governments, buyers, investors to know that we can move more quickly in opening up supply, right? And that they generally will be approved unless there's a good reason why they are not.

Okay? And then finally when we talk about the financing question, actually it's not about a lack of financing. If for example the demand is in place to be able to guarantee that this is an economically viable project, the financing is typically going to be available. Thanks Fred. Just a quick plug before I move to Tommy. I I think we do generally the stakeholders do recognize some of the friction issues on the buyer side. And I think that's clearly what we're trying to do with the Sing ICC Gateway program, which is to reduce the friction of buying so that the $1 may still be a optimal choice because as as Fred said, if it's $49 against 50, you may not do it because it's not just that $1 discount, you have to put a full team behind that.

And I think you know, EDB and ourselves feel that by putting together a coherent central procurement platform and facility that takes away a lot of the unknowns for buyers. But I think that's still not enough and and Fred touched upon it a little bit. And I want to ask Tommy this and he's Tommy's spent a lot of time, you know, talking to governments and getting into the programs and and trying to understand and support that. How are independent risk assessments going to help? You know, how they do the how do they help reduce some of these frictions? I mean, we hear about the sort of the stage A to stage D and where is it that you can play a part to and ratings agencies can play a part to help facilitate and accelerate some of these activities.

Uh thank you and thank you for the comments beforehand. Maybe to pick up on what you were talking about. Um you've got a market being born in real time with a bunch of countries who want to be have agency and how they develop it. So it's natural they all want to have their own flavor of implementation. But that's the antithesis of what creates a market. The market would be settled on a few rules on providing solutions, get your liquidity in and then grow it. So you've got a natural conflict between the market side of it trying to come together and say pick these lanes and these ways and the countries being self-deterministic and saying this is what I want, this is why I want it and here I have.

Which is kind of interesting to work in. So where we come in and we say well at a project level, what do you care about? You know, cuz actually it's all very common. Oh on behold you care about additionality, you care about carbon accounting, you care about permanence. Is the project really happening? You know, all these layers are actually very common. So beyond this layer of like oh we've all got to be unique, we've all got to it our way. Underneath that, what we try to explain to people is this this actually what you want is very similar. So you take you back to the idea of saying, okay, well then, can you settle on a market structure which allows you facilitates that um those transactions.

That's where so if we work with the Singapore government, we were hired as part of a public procurement process and we don't endorse uh really I don't endorse using a minimum rating as a procurement strategy. What we endorse is having project level analysis as part of the value chain. Up to you what you want to buy. I mean, as long as the low rated stuff is cheap and the higher rated stuff if there's efficiency there. But you know, if you want to buy a eligible credit that's lower value, you're still contributing to climate change and maybe it's a fantastic health project or it's got other metrics which are very strong on.

But the key thing is that you're recognizing that there is a lot of risk at the project level and you're building that into the equation. So if someone turns around to you and says, well, there's lots of risk over there, you say, sure, but we are aware of it and here's the reasons why we bought it and that's a sensible decision. Not hiding under the carpet as long as it passes some label, everything's fine. There's a conversation that's allowed and enabled by recognizing the risk, which is the bit that's hardest to sell. Because it would just be nice and convenient if it was labeled up, packaged up, sent off and everything was fine.

But these are living projects in living communities with dynamic risks. And so yeah, the main thing is to say on the one hand, it's quite common what you're experiencing on the other hand, don't run away from those risks, embrace them, build them into your system. And actually that creates a lot more self-correction, a lot more resilience in the in the system than just trying to go, okay, we'll just do this and everything's fine. So that's what we try to normally educate on and I think Singapore has been just to finish on that point, they don't use us on the outside, they use us on the inside.

They use us, they they commission ratings, they read the ratings. As far as they're concerned, they want multiple parties, which we obviously think's really important. It's up to them how they use the research, right? Like and I think that's also fine, right? We're not out there saying you have to, you know, if you don't have this rating or that rating, that's not the the point and they recognize that as well, but they do want to have third parties whose research and processes they really are support and endorse. And they recognize that they need the support themselves to have those perspectives.

So that's a very nice arrangement we believe. I want to if I can, right Tommy, I would take up on a point that you were mentioning around this fundamental tension between governments wanting to feel as if like they have some sovereign control over the carbon markets versus the need to actually have convergence and standardization to allow the market to thrive. I think a lot of the tension stems from a a fundamental misunderstanding. Sovereignty comes from the ability to regulate, but sovereignty does not necessarily come from having your own individual standard. So the the usual example I give is about car seats for babies, you know?

Singapore famously have a very low fertility rate. We have less than 30,000 babies now I think a year, right? Can you imagine if Singapore decides to have a unique way of designing car seats for babies only for the Singapore market? First of all, nobody will care about serving the Singapore market, right? And so therefore but do we still need to regulate? And we do. And we say that we will accept a UK standard, a US standard, a European standard, an Australian standard, right? So you are sovereign, you are regulating, but it doesn't mean that you have your own individual standard. So I thought I wanted to just land that point.

Thanks Fred. We'll we'll we'll stay with you around as an investor, right? What what signals do you think host countries and buyer governments for example such as clearer authorization timelines, pricing visibilities, or long-term offtake commitments do you think would change or significantly change how investors like Gen Zero deploy capital into the market? Yeah. I I think there are a few things and I would I would list down in terms of two points, right? One about consistency and two around the ability to think long-term and I'll talk about what the challenges are. First of all on consistency, some of the some of the areas where there are still uncertainties as as we are thinking about investing into some of these markets, really are the rules around how certain decisions are made, not about the decisions themselves.

So, for example, if we are talking about share of proceeds, we are talking about CAFEE determination. It is not about whether it's $5, it's $3, it's $10, or it's 10 10%, 20%, 30%. It is about what is the logic behind how you set this. And also, what is the framework for which you would decide to make changes? So, whether it is about the regularity of a frequency in which you make a change, or that the the change criteria is explicit upfront. Now, of course, you can more or less amend these things as you go along. But that is the clarity of the rules, not just about advocating for a level of taxation, a level of share of proceeds, or or things like that that is favorable to the market.

That's not it. Okay? So, that level of consistency. Now, I will move then on to the second point I want to make about the time time frame and the ability to actually think long term. One of the problems that we have been experiencing is the inability for compliance markets to actually enter into long-term offtake agreements. Why? Take CORSIA, for example. If you are going in phases and you're kind of like uncertain what phase two holds for you, whether the European Union is going to impose additional requirements on your CORSIA, whether or not CORSIA phase two is going to be existing and what kind of project types are actually going to be eligible for phase two or phase three or phase four, then it limits the ability of the airlines to do long-term planning, right?

Similarly, governments have to also understand the impact of Article 6 credits on their NDCs. But NDCs are formulated on a five-year five-year basis. So, frankly speaking now, if you want to get a government to enter into a long-term offtake agreement that runs all the way from 2030 to 2040 or 2045 or 2050, they will be a little bit reluctant because they don't know what their NDCs for post 2035 are going to look like. And if they don't know that, they cannot possibly on the supplier side agree to an indefinite kind of a program. I mean, at at the start it's fine because you still have a lot of buffer, right?

But as we progress, then it becomes a problem. And the buyers are also uncertain about what they need and what they will they will they will uh what kind of project types they actually come from. So these are the two areas that I would I would mention. The need to have consistent frameworks of not just about the decisions, but how you make the decisions. And then the second thing is really around the ability to have long-term uh thinking which is actually somewhat undermined by the way that compliance programs are set up because of NDCs, CORSIA phases and things like that. I actually really want to double click on that because we had a very interesting discussion yesterday about offtake agreements and their role more broadly in the carbon markets.

And the the view was that the offtake agreement should not be the tool, right? It does not promote the carbon markets in the depth and liquidity it should. But it also means that we need to be clear in particular in the compliance markets because we can send a deeper demand signal than the voluntary carbon markets, right? So what do you I know I know I'm just throwing this sort of at the at the group right now uh obviously for Fred first, but what do you think would be some of these demand signals? So for example, in the compliance market, as you said, we all kind of rely on the 5% and the you know, the the carbon tax mark and we think that these companies are going to buy or for CORSIA, for example, we assume that the airlines are going to buy.

Those are huge assumptions. How do we how do we help to crystallize that so that the market can move far more confidently into a spot market? Okay. So if I were to take one step back, what is the exam question here? The exam question is what would convince me as an investor to put in good money in order to fund a project that has climate impact? True? Right. Okay. So today I need to therefore understand what are the sources of my returns. Now, if the source of my returns is uniquely based on or singularly based on carbon credit pricing and carbon revenues, then I need to have that certainty on demand.

And in fact, not just the certainty of demand because there's the quantity side of it, I also need to have a some some sense of the pricing side of it, right? And then I got to do my T-leaf reading on on, you know, policy direction, DD data, and so on and so forth, okay? However, if the revenue or the economics do not come solely from the carbon markets, then I have other ways of trying to make the project work. Take for example, some of the more recent projects that we have done tend to be in sustainable forestry or agriculture. And the reason for that is because I have got alternative economic value streams beyond the carbon revenues, whether it's the underlying land land value, whether it's from the commercial aspect of the timber or the commercial aspect of the agroforestry products that I can potentially monetize or work with our farmers to actually monetize.

So that gives me a lot more levers to be able to have the confidence to underwrite that project. So if the exam question is what would it take for me to then say I will spend the money and invest into a particular project, it is true. I don't just need to depend on carbon credit demand. But if the more that it is dependent on carbon credit revenues for the economics, then the more that demand becomes important. Well, Sandeep, you know, we had some discussion, so I'd love to hear your views sort of spun a little bit differently on, you know, outside of offtake agreements, right? If we were to create different demand signals and the certainty of those signals, how do you think that can be shaped a lot better?

And and again, to Fred's point, not just quantity but price. Which is why I am a fan of 62. I'll tell you why, because Korschia is another, let's say it's a tax instrument which has a certain price to it. Not all grades of projects will work at that price. So if I'm develop we develop mangroves, I will never sell to Korschia. It doesn't work for me. Right now right now it doesn't. Nah, I mean it okay, it could possibly. Like I really hope to God that it does, yeah, so but we will have different taxing mechanisms creating different pricing mechanisms around compliances. And that's where 62 comes in.

Now, for example, Japan does a lot of renewable energy in North Africa with JCM. It's a trade thing, which is where you would possibly have some pricing as well. Japan's wrong example. I'll take that back. It could be any other country. You are trying 62 will inevitably work with trade agreements. And that for me is a good play as well because different countries have different priorities, which is why I tell countries, stop prioritizing your CFE, prioritize which sectors will get into Article 6. That's the first thing you need to work on at what prices. Then go back and talk about CFEs. Everybody gets to talk about, oh, but Ghana is charging this much.

Should we charge more? No, it's a market. If you charge too much, nobody comes to you. You'll have an amazing framework, but you will have zero projects. So it is about the thinking. It's about where will I get what pricing for what sectoral credit am I selling to? You will have a 64 mechanism, you will have a 62 mechanism, and you will have a VCM, which will be driven by net zero goals. That's fine. So that strategizing is where countries need to go, and which is where 62 fits in quite well on country to country priorities. And that is where I think you can determine pricing based on which sector you're selling.

You could have a very low $15 credit. You could have a $65 credit. It's fine. But that is why I think we will have to and that once you create that, I think you will create more sectoral trades happening. We will see more pricing happening in in platforms, and I do want to see 62 pricing in platforms as well, right? That's what will give certainty to a Fred to say, yes, you're developing something where I think there's a market. What we forget with offtakes is there's still an operational risk that the financier is taking. You will be selling the credit grade. Everybody gets so fixated, oh my god, I have a $40 offtake grade, but if your plans are not surviving, that doesn't work.

So these are very complex I mean, okay, I mean, we simplified it a bit, but it is complex in a way. So we looking at it the problem from the from the other side usually, you know, and offtake is one part of the risk for me, yeah? If I am looking at financing, and we do early stage financing ourselves, I'm like, yeah, but offtakes okay, great. But I will be looking at the underlying exactly like what are the revenue sources? How do you do that's an important part of the conversation. We get too fixated on offtakes. It's not the only solution. Demand yes is and that's where I think 62 will play a big part in the future.

There will be massive volumes, I think coming to Singapore shown the way. I do hope that a lot more other countries get in. Korea ETS is picking up, you know, Japan JCM is picking up. So Asia is actually showing the way in a lot of ways. I think China I mean, I really think if somebody's here from the EU like hurry up guys. I'm I'm like, we're still waiting. So I think there are other countries that are really really pushing the bar here. So yeah. Thanks Sandeep. Juliana, from a from a host country point of view, how how can we the private sector and investors and platforms and ratings agencies?

I assume that host countries also want to develop a deep and liquid carbon market, right? Because it it helps all of us. What do you think we could be doing to help host countries like yourselves? Well, in fact, when Fred was talking, I I was just thinking about some of the difficulties that we are experiencing when it comes to certainty from now until 2030 and beyond. Because if you look at Fred's project, is a little bit of a 40-year project, which is a forestry project. And then looking at the crediting period under the Paris Agreement, we are looking up until 2030. And so what happens after 2030, more especially when our NDC, even though we have the appetite extend to 2035, looking at Ghana's NDC 3.0.

But what happens after? There's a lot of uncertainty. So as an investor like him, what kind of certainty would he be able to put forward when it comes to his projects? Which is quite difficult for investors to really put in a lot of funds when it comes to especially with forestry projects. Because with forestry project for assets to be created, it takes quite some time before assets to be created. So these are some of the challenges that as host countries we are also experiencing because there's a lot of uncertainty ahead of us. But I think Juliana, one of the things that I mean it is important for everyone to also understand investors I mean the core business is about taking risks.

So the the idea here, the holy grail is not to get risk totally out of the equation. Right? We must take some risk because if there is no risk, there is no reward. So that to be fair. So I think which is why I think all we can ask for is that there is enough of that risk mitigation at least in the near term for the project to get past the decision stage and get to an investment decision and to actually execute the project. And of course within some constraints and also within some kind of risks that we think we can manage that might be acceptable even in the longer term, that's fine. That is what the investors are supposed to do, that's what the project developers are supposed to, everybody is supposed to do.

Everyone will need to take some risk. So we should also not get carried away with the idea that we are aiming for a zero risk thing where everything is sewn up, all the demand is spoken for, the pricing is very clear and everything will execute because after that then the nature will intervene and give us a rude shock about how trees will grow at the speed that they want to when the sun is shining or not shining. I want to stay on the demand and offtake piece. I think this is really really a fascinating discussion. So Tommy you know we talk about offtakes and spot market and you know and we talked about where we can be helping each other on on developing demand signals and clearer demand signals.

I mean we've had a fantastic partnership with B Zero and other ratings agencies on trying to be very transparent as to you know the project level, the ratings and all of that in the VCM world. Where do you think this is going to play out on Article six and how can we do this so that we are creating a of potentially an offset market but also a spot market because we have to service the smaller companies who are just not able to do offsets, right? We have to create products that are easily accessible and understandable and and so ratings agencies I feel have a critical role to play in this. Your thoughts please.

Um sounds like a good pitch to be the CEO of Exchange. We have to have somewhere else that's not offsets to put your transactions. Um um That is it's good, it's good, it's important. You're also a contributor. I I think um we could ask this question from our side is different way of redefining what Sandeep said. So a project-based carbon is one of the three ways that you address your emissions. If it's tax you got tax which is great. Which is have a global tax so we can all go home. You have cap and trade essentially emissions trading schemes which give you allocative efficiency i.e. if if I can reduce cheaper I can trade that difference which is very helpful.

And then you have project-based carbon which is a market-based instrument which has a bunch of in my view other benefits like world transfer to the global south, preparing for preservation and restoration, you know social benefits etc. Um the project-based carbon is the same. It doesn't matter what market you're trading it in. The the the project on the ground in Ghana is the same project. Whether you're voluntarily buying it, you're buying it from a country's perspective under six two, from a six four, from an airline, still the same intervention using the same approach. There might just be a few different labels on it.

To your point about car seats you know you have to have the right stamps to maybe enter these things but actually it's the same intervention. So our point is more like just just remember that. So for a rating is two things, was three things. It's a letter, fine. But it's a fundamental analysis of the project and it's a living analysis of that project. And so, you know, you're there to basically be pointing these things out and to give people the confidence that whatever market it's trading in and I'll come back to sales pitch for CIEX in a second. But the that it that it's the same thing. Actually sometimes we forget that.

You know, it is it's just a it's just a credit that's operating in different market. To your point about on screen, if you are trying to buy a credit, you should be able to go and buy it easily. Obviously. And the market should have already solved for the majority of the diligence and you know, underlying contractual obligations at the point of purchase. It's incredibly easy. You can all open your phones up, I imagine if you have this, and you can buy a stock like I could do it in 30 seconds. But that is an extremely complicated thing that sits behind me buying one stock of whatever, you know, company.

There's a bunch of regulations and different countries and different flavors with global accounting standards and years of of of systems and negotiations, but the transaction's extremely easy. So it's also about going like stop people need to remember that it can be simple. That doesn't mean that it's not complicated to get there. So that's what I say on on the sales pitch to your side. The The main thing though, which is a tricky challenge is sustainability teams or generally company treasuries, they don't usually have trading accounts. And in in in financial terms, a retail investor is a person, a professional investor institution is a is an an organization.

In the carbon market, the retail investor is the corporate. They're the In my view, they're the they're the last one at the end of the value chain. They're the C in the in the sort of B to C. It's not normal that you would open an exchange account in an institutionally regulated environment to have to transact something which is essentially a quite a marginal part of your liability management. So so the question, the challenge here is how do you whoever they steer off to, they they are facilitating it in the background. Because it may not be that you're Coca Colas of this world for a large company, they don't have a Bloomberg account.

They don't have a a registry account with uh S&P to go and buy corporate bonds. They do it through a bank. So that's also an just an element there. I'm not entirely sure that the the solution is going and convincing corporates to open up institutionally regulated accounts on liquid marketplaces. It's the some it's the person in between them that that needs to basically make sure that that happens. So I'll just add to that point um and and my view is for example, if you wanted to go and buy a stock on the Singapore Stock Exchange, you don't buy it from the Stock Exchange. You actually go into the Stock Exchange and look at the quality discovery and price discovery.

What do I mean by that? There's prospectus, you read about the business, you look at what's being priced in the market, and then you call your broker and it connects you. The broker connects you to the exchange. So it's not necessarily you don't need to directly get work with directly with the exchange. Like you say, corporates have a different procurement timeline, but you can certainly work with teams. So we have a team that sits outside the screen that helps corporates do that. But what's important is that everything is centralized on a screen and it's standardized information. So I think that's where it will help the smaller corporates who don't have necessarily the tools.

So I can say that one thing that's really important with your point about price discovery, if these trades are all happening bilaterally over the counter, no one knows what the prices are. And you know, the guy built probably the best pricing agency in the in the industry, but it's really hard to get decent pricing data because actually sometimes people were intentionally hiding it because they don't want you to pay. They don't want you to know what they're paying. So the the added benefit to liquidity is just people having the discovery to say actually that's a fair price. And you know, maybe you're above or below it for various reasons or whatever the case may be.

But that's the bigger challenge I think. It's not just getting it into your into the exchanges, it's actually having convincing people to let them have their transaction published. Does that make sense? That, that point. Okay. Um, I was I was trying to make this point as well because there is no market without a secondary market. And we need to be very clear about that. We need the wholesalers, we need the aggregators, we need this for a functioning market. This entire obsession with offtakes, there's a primary offtake happening. This is not a market. There are the mid sectors missing from this market.

The guys that you talked about, they're not here. We're talking about four, five marquee buyers. That's not a market. So we cannot base an entire market infrastructure basis offtakes that happen here and there. So secondary market essential. There are people who can price risk. The risk is not the problem here. I mentioned this yesterday as well. We've been pricing risk all our centuries of trading has been pricing risk. That's not the problem here. But how do you get the financial sector involved in this? Because without them, there is no market. Now what would they need? They need regulation, they need certainty of regulation because you need that, right?

And you just need to regulate markets like you regulate everything else. Why does this have to be seen in a different way? That's it. So that secondary market for me is essential for really scale up of the market. There's no two ways about it, you know? But you know, there are a lot of developments in this market that act against that. So like for example, one of the reasons why we set up CIX was to precisely get that price transparency out there because we understand that intermediaries can sometimes hide the pricing and therefore the buyers actually don't know what they are really, you know, who where the money is going to.

But let me let me let me put it another way. There is sometimes a problem in this industry because we are not just talking about a pure, pure commodity. It the carbon story is often conflated with sense of like social equity and justice, climate justice, what should be owed to the Global South and and so on so forth. So a very simple expression of this is when we study economics 101, price is meant to be a signal or scarcity. Yes. But today it is conflated with the question of quality. Oh, you're paying for a $5 credit. Can it possibly be real? Is it really good? Now that's a weird question to ask because I think, you know, Tommy will be able to share with you that sometimes some cheap credits can actually be very very good quality.

But it is further complicated not just about quality but around equity. So if you are now buying a cheap credit from the Global South, is that fair? That is a that is not a market question to ask. Because it is it is a little bit difficult to answer that question because there is differences in terms of cost structure and and so on and so forth. So the question is therefore um because price is now such a mixed and completed signal for so many different things, all legitimate objectives that we want to pursue. It is also a little bit difficult to say that once you have price full price transparency, what is actually the implication that comes from that?

And what kind of conversations will we be having and will it be actually a confusing one? Although be be very clear, I'm all for price transparency. No, I I mean we can let our colleague here go in. I um it's very Hayekian, which is very funny word to use that quote, but to go too market heavy on this. The only thing is if you don't have I don't think price is scarcity in economics 101. Maybe I studied a different economics degree, but uh it's it's an it's an expression of whatever you think the value of something is. And that's it's a conveyor of information. That's what I think the price does.

So if the information more information, there's the more ability to to do things. So I don't I don't know I don't just I mean maybe it shows people's caring about morality, maybe it doesn't. I mean you pay a lot more for a organic coffee than you do an inorganic one and they do give both give you caffeine. But that that's fine. Let the but the information is being conveyed there. In the absence of that information, it's very hard for there to be capital formation behind that. And so that's bent that's our pitch was our pitch to Gen Zero, but we don't see ourselves we only see ourselves as information infrastructure.

That's why I think my business does. We provide information at an infrastructure level to support price discovery and risk taking. And that in all of itself actually supports further risk taking and price taking. Not necessarily everyone wins from that transaction. The price doesn't necessarily tell everyone what they want they want to hear. But without yeah. But Tommy, very simple, right? If that kind of product is highly available, there is a lot of quantity and quantity outstrips demand, right? Uh the supply outstrips demand, prices will come down. So at the end of the day, price is always uh an expression of some kind of a dynamic between demand and supply.

Quality is definitely a part of it, but ultimately it is a demand and supply question that determines price, right? Thank you. So I'm I'm going to add on the complication and I'm going to make Sandeep answer a difficult question. So we talked about price, we talked about price transparency. Let me layer on the complexity of the different monetization pathways that a project developer might have. And you know, we we did some work with Gates Foundation uh I think that was launched earlier this year on Indian Ag Credits and one of the potential monetization pathways, right? So it's not just about one pathway into Article Six as we talked about.

A project developer can develop into Article Six, they can develop into VCM. It can develop into um corsia. And so, you know, Sandeep, how how would you advise a project developer today amongst all these complexities of of pricing and schemes? What what would you say what would you say to someone who comes to you and say, you know, I want to do something? How should I do it? I mean, it's it's financial prudent prudency to know where you will sell before you create the credit, yeah? I think that's very important because there are different segments. For example, if you ask me Indian Ag, if you're doing a I mean, I would look at the super polluters and look at that as a market, yeah?

I would look for agroforestry as for net zeros as BTI tail end 2050 and 2030 short term. If I had a landfill gas project, I will look at the white list and see where I could do a bilateral 62. So I think from that perspective, every project I will have a different kind of buyer who will be interested in it and it's super super critical to know that before you deploy. For us, it's easier because we can aggregate. Even if two projects go wrong, it's fine, you know, eight will go right out of 10. It's okay. That's fine. And that's why I'm a big fan of aggregation because somebody will have to aggregate.

Now, we aggregate ourselves, but we are not the only market. If you have a project developer here and there and there, somebody will need to aggregate them and that's the risk pool and that's risk. Everybody knows this. Within that portfolio, each project is going to sell to different segments. And that is fine, you know, and that needs to be really looked at from a lens that we we have a we would like, okay, it's fungibility. So what what can I do with this credit? Some credit clearly will never be for compliance. For example, if I have a credit in India right now, it is not for compliance unless it's part of a list and even then that's too risky for me.

I would not bet on that. But it has a lot of a lot of manufacturing happens in India. So a lot of of companies operate there. So that's a segment. If I have a project in Lao right now, I'm looking at what do they have? They have JCM, they have Singapore. That's my primary market then, right? So I would obviously look at that. So it's just look at in terms of where is the policy, where are the buyers because a wrong project in a wrong country will not have a buyer. That's it. If we talk about big tech and buying from a very heavily from a country which has a very heavy political risk, it will never happen.

I keep telling these guys like, oh, Microsoft's buying at $50. I'm like, not from this country, my friend. Will not happen. So let's not go down that road, yeah? So there is a lot of conflicting information about pricing as well going around. People are developing biochar projects all over the world thinking the durable carbon credits are going to fetch $200 a ton. Not all projects will get it even if it's a A-rated from from Tommy. So I think that's something that's very important to understand. It is not a simple answer. But sorry, go on. Uh no, no, I just wanted to sort of double click a little bit like because Article 6 and Costa obviously requires host countries um support.

So you know, what would you teach how would you teach a project developer in in in like where they need to go and what they need to do? Do you think it's a very natural thing that do you think there's still capacity building that's needed? Okay, so um yes. Before I even go into the issues of um capacity building to to add on to the discussions that was already ongoing, um you realize that um I think he had mentioned issues of having a rigorous regulatory um framework, a rigorous policy systems in place. Yes. Before Fred and his co-partners will come into a host country to invest, there has to be that kind of legal certainty for them to go ahead and do um any kind of investment.

So as a host country, what we have done is to have a very robust regulatory framework. And then we were also working with Act 490 which didn't really have a lot of anchorage on issues of climate change, issues of carbon market. And so with coming on board of carbon market and then giving a lot of legal certainty, we have been able to develop a new act that has replaced the old one. It's called Environmental Protection Act 1124 that has now got a lot of anchorage on issues of carbon market. I think it's section 149 to 15 9 deep dives more into issues of carbon market when it comes to regulation.

And then we also have now converted the already known carbon market framework into a regulation. We are now at the final stages where the attorney general is now looking into it to incorporate all the comments we have given them into a regulation so that investors will have a lot of legal certainty when it comes to issues of carbon market transactions in Ghana. On the capacity building, we had lent a very bad lesson in the past where within the CDM era, we realized that we couldn't really take a lot of advantage within the market purposely because a lot of our Ghanaian stakeholders didn't really have in-depth knowledge when it comes to CDM transactions.

And so with this carbon market phase, what we have been doing on capacity building is that we needed to come up with a proposal to be able to educate and then sensitize people within the financial space because we realized that even within our portfolio of about 91 projects just about 10% of that came from typical Ghanaian businesses. So we realized that there was still that gap that we had to also fill. And so we developed a very detailed proposal and then we put them in various clusters. So the first thing that we had to do was to build capacities of the financial institutions because they realized that the risk was quite huge.

They didn't understand the ecosystem. So how then then do they put funds into the ecosystem? So we had to also build their capacity, sensitize them for them to know the steps to step stages that project developers are supposed to go through based on which assets will be created and also to manage their expectation that you don't just put in funds and then immediately carbon assets are created. It takes time. So you need to to understand that at the back of your mind before you even put in any kind of investment. We also had to train quite a number of project developers and also the businesses because they want to understand the landscape and see how they can also invest in.

One thing is that now we've been rolling out master class. We've done the first two on foundation class, master class for businesses, for financial institutions, and even the academic landscape for them to able to understand what we are doing within the carbon market space. So these are some of the areas that we are building capacity to ensure that a lot of Ghanaian businesses and then the financial institutions are able to come into this carbon market ecosystem. Thanks. Thank you. That's wonderful. I'm going to We have a few minutes for Q and A. So there any questions from the Wow. You're very active audience here.

Thank you very much. My I'm from Ethiopia, your next host. So I just wanted to ask what is the balance between getting consistency in regulatory infrastructure of host governments versus trying the host countries to trying to become over regulated. Like for instance, the equity concerns that you have that that that are entering into the space of market approaches, which is disrupting. Like for instance, benefit sharing regulation so that most of the carbon revenue or profit would go to you know, the communities. Is that really appealing to the investors from the other side? Do we need to legislate that so that it will become you know, posited so that there is no room for negotiation even.

Just one. Wow. Anyone, please. This is a really interesting question. In some ways, it is always useful to have room for negotiation. But it is useful to nevertheless have certain anchoring points because this question around what is an appropriate share of proceeds or the percentage for benefit sharing actually differs project by project, geography by geography. I It is very difficult for me to say to you that 10% is appropriate because in some cases you need to do 30, 40, maybe even more. But in other cases, if you insist on a 20 30% uh profit share or share of proceeds, then it may be very difficult to get the project off the ground.

So while now the reason why I ask for some consistency is at a level of a principle or the framework of how you decide. So for example, it is not about deciding that 10 or 20% is enough. It is about like articulating maybe these are the three or four considerations that I have and I will also be referencing best in class guidance from say some of the independent standards or say some of the NGOs that have been quite thoughtful in deciding what uh good uh benefit sharing mechanism should look like, right? So for example, is there sufficient consultation with the uh community, right? Is there proper governance around the way that the money will be spent?

What is your theory of change for sustainable development in the host country? So one of the things that I have realized in doing uh carbon projects, especially for the nature ones in Global South, right? Is this we are not just called to be financial investors. I'm actually my guys have to be sociologists, economists, human development experts, you know, uh social scientists. Why? Because we have got to have some understanding of does this particular activity make sense? Like why not just a pure reforestation project in a very poor part of a of a country? Because what kind of jobs will it create?

After I grow the trees and the trees are standing, will there be ongoing economic community uh activity that will benefit the local community? Maybe maybe not. And in some of those cases, would a sustainable commercial forestry kind of a project or agroforestry project become very important? Even in the selection of say native species, which today always enjoys a premium, right? Everybody wants to do native species reforestation. But are there actually non-timber types of forestry products that that can create ongoing income streams for the local community? If not, I'm just sterilizing the land for them.

So what is the long-term logic for sustainable development? So I I I think that it is not so much about like saying that there are rules around 20% 30% or whatever, but a consistent framework around these are my stated principles around how I will make a decision and that is where the negotiation or the conversation comes in. I hope that that helps. Maybe let's Sorry, go go go. After you. I Yeah, I want to add to um what Fred just said. Looking at Fred's project, in fact, during the site visit, I was really impressed with the kind of sustainable um development systems that and then enhanced livelihood systems that they had put in place because you go to the the the field and you you realize that they had given some um local plantations to the communities.

And within the plantation, you realize that they have planted some food crops. And the arrangement is that when the crops are due, it belongs to the farmers, it belongs to the communities. And this is a way of enhancing the livelihoods of the farmers within those localities. So I just wanted to to add to that because it's a very good system that they had put in place to support the community even after the trees are fully grown. Yeah, just one one I agree with Fred entirely about setting the rules. It's also to your point about price up to you what you define as being a a reasonable benefit share.

You know, if you explain it and you justify it, it's up to the buyer to determine if they think it's appropriate. So that's also important. I would just add one point to this. It's not always the case that communities and conservation are working in the same direction. And so the the reason why we have a carbon rating and a beyond carbon assessment and they're not like together is because they they're completely different things. And in some very high conservation integrity projects, you might have some genuine risks that in terms of the community engagement and what's going on there, some some removals, all these sort of things.

And these add a whole different layer. And to just a echo again what went, it's very localized. A ton is a ton atmospherically. That stuff is fine, but local conditions are extremely localized. So it's so you know having one rule to rule them always is not really appropriate. But likewise when you go and assess them as you were saying, it's a completely different framework on the which you're assessing the the benefits and risks from a social or wider ecological perspective. That's a whole another kind of conversation basically. 10 seconds. It is not a competitive play. For me, all my government engagements stop at two, not Ghana and not How much should I charge for my corresponding adjustment?

How much should I mean what should be my minimum mandate for benefit sharing? And my first question is benefit sharing for what project? And there's like I bet it should be 60 no? I mean like why? So this that's the whole idea. This these two questions are the wrong starting point here because we have made this entire narrative that there's money to be made from carbon. So you need a framework. Without a framework nobody's going to oh sorry. You need to open up. And then somebody says yeah but we need to regulate. How do we regulate? We need a framework. Okay so I come up with a framework. And then what?

So and that framework clearly and like I said I will look at a lot of those framework and said I would never do a project there. You know so that is where. So there is no good or bad. And there is no competitiveness in the number. You could be having an amazing project with 10% benefit sharing as well. You know so it is a complex subject and we have we have somehow got it down to a number game. And now governments are competing against each other on this number. Great for cops. No projects. All right. We have time for I think we had the lady who had a question and then the gentleman over there.

And I'm sorry after this you can mob the speakers. Yeah maybe we should do that. Maybe we can take a few questions. All right. Hafsa here from Pakistan and my question to you Sandeep being a project developer and it's a very interesting session. I get to know know same things from the different perspective I would say. So the question is that being a project developer, what are the two to three main things you look into the project? Because from where I see, we develop a lot of pins. We do develop some of the PDDs also, but when it gets to monetization, when it gets to implementation, there are a lot of challenges.

So what would be your take on that that as a project developer, these are the two to three things you look as an investable, bankable, ready to get into the project simply. Thank you. Gentlemen. Hi, such a wonderful panel. Um, I have a question related to the brokerage aspect Tommy you talked about or the wholesale versus retail aspect Sandeep you talked about. What would be the appropriate level of brokerage fees assuming that this is like shares or the wholesale wholesale to retail markup? Because I'm from London. My the law firm that represents us, I understand is is buying carbon credits at $200 per ton.

I think these are VCM V4 station credits. But I don't I know I know no one in the world who sold at I don't know 200 similar carbon credits. They probably sold it at 10. So I think there's a lot of it's great to talk about how how benefits are going into the local communities, but I think if the markup is too big, you're missing a big chunk. Thank you. All right, we have one at the back. Gentleman at the back. Thank you. And then one at the front. Okay, thank you. Mine is a legal question. When it comes to carbon rights, transfer ownership of the same, does it create does it affect the integrity of certificate of title?

To build on that, if today you you lease land, that lease is registered. If you transfer, that transfer is registered. If it's an encumbrance like for instance a charge, that charge is registered. For carbon rights. What interest is affected in that title? Is it Is it registered? And if in If not, if the community gets into that project, do they have, you know, full rights, full bundle of rights to that particular title? And And on the benefit sharing, is there a universally agreed benefit sharing model? Because in my country, the the legal framework is a bit new. I'm I'm I'm from Kenya. The The regulations date up to actually this year, and then and we are struggling with certain lacunas in law in terms of this law says this and another law says this, and then that conflict is bringing some problems.

Any other I think that's all. Any other Okay. We Okay. So we have one on choice of project, and then I think you can probably cover the gentleman's question on the carbon rights. If not, we can add in, and then the buy side can Yeah, you guys do the buy side part, but on this this on this part, I think one of the biggest things I look at is the the social designing. Like for us, you are not going to be And this I tell to my buyers who are due diligencing 19,000 small holder contracts, and I'm like, you are a Silicon Valley company. Are Are you going to sue one farmer in Pakistan? Like it's not going to work, right?

So for us in carbon project development, especially for some kind, especially ones we are involved in, it's about the community trust and the social contract that you're building, which is why I have a lot of social scientists on my team, because to understand that is super important because legal agreements in a lot of places that we work are not tenable. Our lawyers love it, and I have our lawyer in this room right now, but the fact is we are not We cannot salvage a product project legally in most cases unless you're talking about concessional land. Again there, you will have lots of issues with communities if you don't have them on your side.

So for us, that's the first, that's rule number one, two, three, and then we get into the financing element of it. If this is not tenable for 40 years, don't do it. You know, and how will you carry it on for 40 years comes from the program design. Everybody talks about growth of trees, but what happens when the tree grows, there's an anti-thesis because the tree is then a very very good commodity. For for me, when mangroves are growing very well, I get worried about charcoal logging, right? So these are things that I would be again, there are lots of different pulls and pushes. It's to understand that design is really important.

Everybody looks at the money they can make. That's fine. You can. This is really important. The base, social contracting for me is absolutely crucial. Carbon rights? I don't I I don't uh what we look at from our perspective, from the rating is permanence. So the property rights essentially and how they are defined and enshrined in either local law or in the contract itself. Because what you often have, and this is I I got asked this question by an African journalist, uh the global South rate better than the global North in our in our rating system. And that's interesting because permanence is where and additionality additionality is generally high, permanence is is often challenging, but in those areas you often get like in areas of of of Ghana very strong property rights in those locations.

So you can actually make it you don't have to solve a national issue to actually solve a local a localized property like carbon rights issue. They can be enshrined contractually without having to have like a national jurisdiction. And we do find that's generally the case in in Kenya as well, right? And so we look into that what's what's backing it up, etc. We have one minute, so Juliana, please close. that. So um it depends on your your country, but for Ghana we have to land tenure systems which could either be statutory or that land could also belong to the the the So usually what as a as a regulator, we usually would do is that we ensure you bring to us a lease agreement of the land.

And once it's going to be a forestry project, we ensure that the lease agreements that you are submitting to us should be over 10 years. So we look at the lease agreement that you're submitting to us and then we ensure that you also submit a letter from the forestry commission saying that the land that you are you are going to use for the forestry project has not already been used for any other forestry project. And so we take a letter of approval and then a letter of no objection from the lands ministry clarifying that yes, you can go ahead and use that particular land in case or to to the risk issues of permanence.

So usually these are the documentation that we'll take from the developer for the process when it comes to forestry projects. Thanks. Thank you everyone. I'll answer your question after this. But thank you everyone for participating. Thank you to the speakers for wonderful engaging dialogue. Thank you.

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

[COP31] Creating Investable Supply at Scale through Article 6 Implementation Agreements