Transcript
It's like who the going to stay in business and who's going to go out of business? It's really incredible. So, quickly before we get to today's show, this episode is brought to you by Pith. Pith Network is the fastest growing financial data company today. Trusted by Fidelity Investments, the US Department of Commerce, Revolute, Kelshi, Jain Street, Coinbase, and many more. They provide realtime financial market data across over 3,000 equities, commodities, crypto, FX rates, and again a lot more. They're the first and largest provider of 24/7 financial indices and offer the widest array of market data for the lowest cost.
So go to pith.network to take advantage of their free trial. Join me, Ral Pal, as I go on a journey of discovery through the macro, crypto, and exponential age landscapes. In the journeyman, I talk to the smartest people in the world so we can all become smarter together. Andreas, always good to have you on. Good to see you, my friend. There's a there's so much to dig into. Um, there's a lot going on and I think people going to be really interested in your thoughts and my thoughts and how we are thinking through this. So, what's on your mind? It strikes me that the companies that are building the most important technology in our lifetime are priced like dying businesses at the moment.
It's extraordin I know you you wrote that yesterday on X which is like I think this is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen. I'm kind of with you on this. It's insane. Yeah, it's it's obviously always something that could end up humbling you when you say that the market is incredibly wrong on something. Uh so let me try and be humble about it to begin with at least when you look at the forward price earnings of everything from Nvidia to Sandesk to Micron to even Anthropic uh based on the numbers we know ahead of of their IPO this month. I'd argue that we're pricing the whole AI spectrum at the very least at half the multiples of the average market and at a quarter of the multiples of Costco, Walmart and all of those stable names, right?
That is the exact mirror image of what happened in year 2000. The exact mirror image because Walmart, Costco, etc. were priced at 10 price earning months back in 2000 with Cisco and and all of the names at 100 price earnings. So unless there is a huge bubble in earnings, which I struggle to see right now, there's something odd going on here. And I've been tempted to say and I've said so for a while that um most PMs tend tend to fight the last war. And the last time that they've seen something like this, everything went wrong. which is why they're extremely cautious. And I get why if if you're if you've lived through the.com and maybe the GFC as well, I I get why you're a little bit cautious and I get why you're nervous.
The market is incredibly nervous. I mean, while we're recording the market is up 15% in all of the names that I just mentioned, right? Um so, one day down 20, the next day up 15. Never seen anything like it, but it just feels like the exact mirror image of the com to me. Yes. And I think people are scarred by that and they're assuming cyclicality and what they think is you can't price the forward because of the cyclicality. And the question you got to ask is are revenues going to go down or maybe stabilize for a bit. And I just don't see revenues going down. Every single component part of this trade, you and I have chatting about this recently.
Every single component part of this trade from TSMC to Nvidia to the hyperscalers to Anthropic are producing supernormal returns. They have so much demand that they cannot physically build enough compute. There's the inability to be to be able to build compute may slow down chips for a little bit. But then what we've also found and the labs are telling you this and nobody's listening is that more compute brings RSI which is AI training AI which creates needs for more compute because it keeps going exponential and I've got the rate of compute um output of intelligence per unit of energy my exponential age index doubling every 3.4 four months.
And the other way I frame this to people is this is the only good ever with infinite demand because the more compute you build, the the better the AI becomes, the more agents it uses, the more it does. And we barely started. The thing I hear the most from some of the veteran PMs involved in this trade is that a buildout always ends in tears because a market is by design always overshooting when there's a scarcity. So we'll end up building too much compute capacity. That is the push back I get every single time. Uh and another push back I get is that well in 2 3 4 years most of our simple tasks will just run on our iPhone or whatever uh mobile um device that we have.
Let me start with the with the first one. If if we look at the compute capacity if you listen to all of the labs right they still say that they have a a capacity issue. If you look at Anthropics third quarter, it was heavily dominated by a lack of capacity to fulfill the market demand. It wasn't a demand issue, it was a capacity issue. They're now getting closer to solving the capacity issue, we've seen great momentum in in the anthropic business over the past four to six weeks. But I've said continuously that the biggest risk to the Yanthropic case is that they have not secured enough compute on a forward basis.
I mean, they took all of Elon's Colossus one. All of it. Yeah. Yeah, I think they paid $5 billion just for SpaceX um services in the third quarter, which is why they had a slightly weaker third quarter compared to the second quarter when you look at margins. They simply had to pay up for spot compute compared to uh to the forward deals that you can price at much better terms. Having said that, right, uh, now that we're on the other side of the midterms, I don't really buy the notion that the Democrats will end the AI buildout, but we do see issues related to everything from regulation uh to push backs from from the population in terms of the pace of the buildout, right?
So, it is actually difficult to build out in the pace needed to match the demand for compute. Uh I think that's a very very different environment to to the year 2000 buildout of uh of fiber lit right where you could just you just built it wasn't an issue a you could just build but you built before there was any demand this is the opposite you're trying to build as fast as you can because the demand is completely outstripping your ability to supply and then this notion that you'll end up with a lot of um over supply in the data center space because we end up using local models on our phones and what what have you.
Uh I think it is similar to stating that oh as soon as you got I don't know 16 gigabyte of memory space on your phone no one would use cloud after that because you have so much space on your phone locally that you would never end up uh consuming uh space in in yeah and people misunderstand that AI is going to be in every single object every single electronic object will have AI the it's not it's a Gvon's paradox it gets cheaper and you sell more of it. Right now I've got demand double doubling for every unit it goes down in price. So we're not seeing demand fall either which was the other argument.
They're like oh well it's just going to get so cheap all the margins going to get crushed. No margins have gone up at the frontier models as the actual AI has got cheaper. It's extraordinary. Exactly. And you know think of it this way. Yes. For example, anthropic, they've spent a lot of of dollars training their models. But if you look at the ratio between training and inference, we're moving so fast in the direction of, you know, paid services inference relative to training that it won't be an issue in 2, three, four quarters from now. It's not an issue already now. Um, they are cash flow positive by now, which is extraordinary given how much they spend, right?
Um and and and therefore I really struggle with this notion that AI is going to slow down incredibly fast into 2028 2029 which is what you get if you look at forward pricing basically. See the other one that's interesting in this equation is SpaceX. So Elon is always early in this stuff and he's like it was like 18 months ago talk about transformers. Everyone's like what the a transformer? and he's like there's there's issues there's going to be and so what basically he did he pre-secured all the stuff he then went and bought a gas turbine a mobile d gas turbine business before anybody had figured out what was going to go on so now he's going to put I don't know how many gigawatts of compute like 13 gigawatts of compute out next year when everybody else can't get stand up a data center Amazon Google Microsoft have all pre-sold all of theirs and he's taking advantage of the spot pricing.
It looks like if he gets this right, he'll have had a one-year payback. I mean, the return on capital is extraordinary. And yet, people don't want to believe it. They just don't believe it can happen. Also, this week, right, well, we got the quarterly report from Core Wee, you know, one of the NEOClouds that has faced the wrath of of the market with higher credit spreads and they haven't really been able to access the bond market for for a little while. And they basically told us that you know within the foreseeable future they can just fund their capex via the existing data center operations.
What if we relatively soon get to the point where the existing data center operations will fund the next data center operations where we don't need the funding markets at all. It's it's not a bizarre scenario. Well, because people misunderstand how much cash flows out of this and Elon's about to prove it. Now, yeah, look, he he does everything at a marginal higher margins than everybody else because he's just a brilliant engineer, but still, if he can do that, then he can just build infinite data centers because he'll just fund them out of cash flows. Yeah. And it's something that could happen say late 27, early 2028.
It's it's not 5 10 years down the road. is already happening. Um, and even more interesting is that this whole notion that old GPUs will not be able to provide the return needed for them to be funded going forward. Uh, it is, you know, the the actual evidence is wiping the floor with Michael Bur on this thesis, right? because his thesis is that the depreciation of a GPU is at max three maybe four years and again cow for example told us that they they're renting out their H100s for the next three four five years on forward deals and they're already paid back and you know we've been told that the H100s were useless as soon as we got the Vera rupins and what have you online that has not proven to be the case because of the scarcity right so and there's different use cases for different things you know inference doesn't require there are reubins training does for example you know there's just they can use all the compute yeah um so we're kind of we're kind of circle jerking now rather that you know everyone's not getting this but I I sincerely think that this is one of the most interesting crossroads I've ever been at from a market standpoint point where you have the market basically prices the semiconductor cycle to be down I don't know 40 50% by mid next year I mean the crash needs to happen very very soon for the market to be right on this and when you say a crash are you looking for rate of change which could slow down should slow down at some point or are you looking for absolute dollars to reduce absolute dollars yeah that's the bisau thing you know sure Bloomberg had an article this week where they say first stated that the first derivative of capex from the hyperscalers have now rolled over and I was like yeah that is pretty simple math I mean you cannot grow at a 150% forever you cannot at least not increase the growth rate but but if you let's say that they grow 50% a year from here in capex terms that is humongous in nominal dollars um I just made this simple exercise um in in in a research paper this week where I just said okay what if grow 25% capex from now and until 2035.
It it it means that we've already doubled capex from the current um uh state in 2 and a half years from now something like that given that 2007 27 is almost carved in stone. So if 28 grows to 25% 29 25% then we're already more than double up of the levels that we're currently at. Um I think we're underestimating this really underestimating this essentially as because the one thing that could kill this RA would be the bund vigilantes but if the cash flow is strong enough to give the bund vigilant is the middle finger which is probably going to be the case in a year from now at the latest then we shouldn't care about the bunt bucket.
Also, if you've look if you look at how this has played out so far and you see it Amazon's you can see this a lot. They do this big capex cycle and then by the time they finish the capex cycle profits go up again because you produce new efficiencies or new product. So any investment that they're all making now in this stuff just turns into output later. So people assume that they're going to be cash burning forever. What we could find is they cash burn for periods of time as of the heavy intensive stuff because this is a big new capex buildout. Then as soon as it starts coming online, their profits go up again because you see productivity rising and nobody wants to believe that yet either.
Productivity's gone up from the last three quarters from 1.1% to 3.6%. It's accelerating. Um and that's been the view to prove this out. If if productivity goes up, then everybody's going to win here. Yeah. You know I I sometimes like to keep it simple stupid around productivity. Productivity is very very difficult to measure in life but I I had a research team of 15 people producing maybe 15 20 research reports a week two two years ago. Now me and my partner Mickel produces more. We produce more than that of 15. When I keep it as simple as that, I cannot come to the conclusion that it's not a productivity gain.
I mean, it is a productivity gain of many X, right? So, one of the ways I'm looking at this is I think the scarce thing that we're now hitting is human attention, right? Because everybody can do what you're doing and everybody's doing it, right? So, it's like how do you read all this stuff? How do you absorb all this stuff? So everybody's doing it on their Claude or their chat GPT. So chat GPT or Claude is now reading all of your emails, reading all of your ex posts, you know, the information, distilling it down for you, reading all the research reports and it's now becoming the platform of our lives that everything is being absorbed into these things.
You either sort of plug in and access it through it and use the intelligence to overlay or they just build it themselves. And you were just mentioning this just before we started is you're like this is sort of Microsoft Windows or the operating system all over again. Yeah. So I've taken my you know the last few quarters every time I've sort of faced the obstacle that I had to create workarounds to get some of my existing software licenses into claude. I've just emailed my account manager say why don't you build it directly into claude because that is where my workflow is and three years ago I would have had the same view if they didn't provide an exit file for a windows application right so think of it this way you know to begin with a Bloomberg for example was a terminal right you sold hardware alongside that Bloomberg license at some point they took a big decision say okay we have to build this for Windows because that's where the users are.
I kind of struggle to wrap my head fully around it. But of course, Bloomberg needs to be incorporated in claw pretty soon. They haven't Yeah, they haven't come to that conclusion yet. But if they want to exist in 5 10 years, they probably need to function within the Claude ecosystem. In my opinion, I mean, I just got rid of mine. I got rid of it because I can get all of the information I need or construct it very simply because you nobody uses the 58,000 credit models and all that that's for some specialist, you know, the basic stuff. It it can do all of that very easily. You can access most of the information you'd ever need unless you're highly specialist in looking for off the run, you know, Lithuanian bonds from 1962, you know, like that.
Yeah, fine. Other than that, you don't need it because Claude can do all of it and there's plenty of MCP connectors. I mean, we're looking at this for real vision as well. It's just saying, you know, we should just bring real vision inside of Claude, give you access to all of this stuff. And I'm looking at what I do with my GMI data as well. It's like, you might as well go where people are and let them use the intelligence layer that they're using. Yep. I I think it's it's spot on and it's it's also something that um you know I've been actively trying to promote within the companies that I I own or I've co-founded and in that sense okay if we try to you know finish this historical analogy Windows kind of made the rounds in 94 95 something like that if we were to make that comparison to the com then you know we we're incredibly early right because I don't even think that people have come to the conclusion that clone is the new Windows.
I think it will happen soon. But but um um so again I I really struggle with this notion that we're in 99 or 2000 very late in this cycle but um yeah so let me put it another way and we had this conversation on the RV pro chat is what happens if this is just all narrative and the fact is that financial conditions tightened because of of Iran and liquidity got tight. So prices have gone down because of liquidity and everyone's trying to pin a narrative on it. Okay. The best example of why I think that is true is the story about Jensen Huang. The story that he had an affair with a alleged Chinese spy was more than a week old when he emailed his employees and told him that he had an affair.
Nobody sold Nvidia when Wall Street Journal wrote about it 8 days prior to that email. When that email made the rounds, everyone started selling Nvidia probably because they found credit spreads to be tied. know it it's it's difficult to uh to measure it outside of of doing it via financial conditions, but I think you're right that the dollar has been too strong, credit spreads have been too wide, the oil price has been too high, you know, all of that. It just sucks liquidity out of the system and therefore any sort of bad news or or or something that's kind of misunderstood or the market just can't take it because there's not enough liquidity around.
Yeah. And if if you look at the degrossing that we've seen from especially hedge funds uh both long short hedge fund but also multistrat hedge funds through the month of October and into the early days of November they've all been probably been running very very close to their max capacity uh set by the risk manager right and when something like this shows up um okay there is a headline I know that I'm running close to my risk capacity I'll bring it down I think that that is what happens in practice. Uh, as I've also u posted on on social media outlets, I think more than a hundred of of um macro hedge fund PMs had to leave their pot through the month of October.
I'd never seen anything like it in my life. I mean, you've been on the hedge fund coverage for forever as well and you talked to many of them still. I I think it's the worst month ever for hedge funds October because of you know financial conditions forcing them to to simply exit positions and also you know I I've talked about this for a long time there is no diversification everything is risk on risk off and risk on risk off is just a function of liquidity liquidity is risk on when liquidity withdraws is risk off that's why everybody observes this trend so if you're a hedge fund and you're directional you have no choice but to be in the momentum trade because you don't make any money either.
Um, and so what happens is they all get washed out at the same time. And the leverage has increased in the system since the GFC and also since year 2000. I I know that many like to look at this uh margin depth from the FINRA organization and and you know take that as a ratio to GDP or M2 to to get a grip of of how much leverage there is. I I think it vastly underestimates the amount of leverage in the system because it's a very old school way of using leverage, right? You have leverage via ETFs now. Uh options have become much more widely available for retail investors. Uh I I have lost count of the amount of subscribers and um ex members etc that have messaged me in my inbox, do you think I should go 3x long the semiconductor index via an ETF?
And I'm always like, no, it's a crap product, but it's available through everyone, right? Um, and it's just so visible when you look at, for example, the price action in semiconductors that there are so many levered players that it goes in and out of these ETFs and other structures on a daily basis. It it exact it exaggerates the narratives uh the way that the market structure is there. So, a quick break in your regular programming. If you're serious about your future, grab my free report called Prepare for 2030. I think you've got five years to make as much money as possible. And this guide will help you navigate what's coming.
The link is in the description. Download it now. And you know that that's the way that bull markets continue. My old boss used to call them the pause that refreshes. And it's like if you're in a serious bull market, you have a bunch of these um and they wipe everybody out because everyone gets over their ski tips and then everyone looks back and go, "Well, why am I out of the position?" Used to happen to me and I never forget because I was running a book via the um during the uh um the 2000 bubble and I was very short and had a good few years based on that. But half the time you close out your positions, you know, when the market went against you and the next day you're like, "Fuck, I just want to put the positions back on again because you know where the trend is.
You know what's going on. Um, and so you know what other what what else you going to trade?" And you said that there were prices where everything is cheap again. We've got off the frothy levels. Yeah. The NASDAQ was quite overbought at the top and it's now unwound itself pretty decently. It's back to its kind of logarithmic trend, fair value. It's like, "Yeah, okay. What's there not to like here? Unless the liquidity picture is going to get worse and I didn't like what happened yesterday and today in bonds and the dollar. It's that that's like I could do without this because if the dollar keeps going up from here then we do actually have bigger problems.
I think the simple answer to to this question Ral is that financial conditions are currently too tight to get a very strong rally in everything AI related and cryptoreated. for example, um even though the fundamentals are incredibly strong and improving by as we speak in all of it in crypto, everything everything's doing this but prices aren't. Uh but it doesn't matter as long as as the liquidity is not there. um and financial conditions. You know, the dollar is obviously the most important thing for financial conditions in my opinion, but the second most important thing is probably energy. And my famous last words of this podcast, because I've said those exact same words three or four times already this year, is that it looks like the worst is behind us in relation to energy prices and the Iran war and all of that.
And uh you and I had a chat earlier this week around, you know, the potential for, you know, Trump spending the last two years of his presidency, you know, basically trying to solve these things um out of legacy reasons. Yeah. Because he still wants the Nobel Peace Prize. Yeah. He he really wants it. I can tell you from speaking to my Norwegian friends up there, they they're pretty pissed with his phone calls after find out. Having said that, Ral, um there there is some momentum in my opinion um in relation to the Ukraine Russia. Yeah, we saw that today, right? The Kushner thing that they prisoner exchange and stuff like that.
It's positive. Yeah. And if Putin wants to seize this moment, he needs to seize it before there's a new president in the White House, right? Um what I struggle with is how the Europeans will respond to this because they're kind of left outside of the room. Um in many ways it seems like Russia and the US are trying to sort of redefine how how to view Europe between them. Um which which is obviously a weird thing to experience as a European not being present. But um just earlier this this morning um I I saw the Ukrainian president uh Volia Silinsky here in Copenhagen. He visited uh our prime minister and gave a speech in in the parliament and Denmark is by far and I repeat by far the country that provides the most support to Ukraine per capita and as a percent of GDP.
But many countries in Europe basically do not support Ukraine any longer economically. So I think several of these countries without them having explicitly stated it so far they have sympathy for what's going on between Trump and Putin now. Um and that that is my cynical view of what's going on. I think there is a fatigue uh that is getting more and more present also within the European Union on this topic and if they can solve the Ukraine war they can also solve the Iran war. I think the Ukraine war is the more difficult one of the two. Uh and it it still seems likely to me that the Republicans have basically concluded that they lost the midterms because of those wars.
Uh so they need to get rid of that if they want um a seat at the table after 28. And people don't really understand because of what the US did with Venezuela that Venezuelan oil will come on market and refineries will be built for it and all of the things. And if you can resolve both of these two situations, the price of oil collapses and stays low for an extended period of time. I mean, what do Russia and Iran do if they get open market access to sell oil? They'll sell as much of it as they possibly can to make up the revenue streams that they've been missing. And the Saudis aware of it. They all aware of it.
Um, it'll just happen. And that's oil back down in the 30s or 40s, which is a huge difference. But we got to get that to the other side because I've been think like you, I've been like, this is going to get resolved. It's in everybody's interest to resolve it, but it hasn't happened yet. Oil looks trading better, but dollar is not still. Probably as a lot of the oil products aren't really trading better yet. I mean, diesel is still incredibly elevated, right? Because of the lack of of refiners capacity and that isn't of course an issue for the Euro zone, Japan, some of the importers, right? So I I think we need to get a proper resolution to to to the Iran war and to the strikes on the refiners capacity in Russia and all of that to to get the energy market um to a place where the euro can appreciate versus the dollar again.
Uh but I think we're getting there and you know I I admittedly have a short dollar bias in my portfolio right now. slight lean, not not a big lean, but I I don't think the riskreward is super good in in chasing the dollar higher here. Yeah, but we've all got a short dollar bias by the nature of our bets because if the dollar rate of change goes up a lot from here, then that's the unwinding of liquidity and therefore that's the unwinding of all the beta trades. I think if you look into 2027, if these wars are not resolved, then I think there is a clear risk that the central banks will hike interest rates to an extent that will kill the business cycle due to financial conditions.
I think that risk is clear. Uh also given that this supply shock has now gotten some of the co- members of the F reserve committee talking about 50 basis points at a time and all of that what was that what's Waller going on about the the weird thing R is that you know essentially by by not providing forward guidance Kevin Wor has now handed the keys to the Federal Reserve to some of his lieutenants because they're still providing forward guidance and Waller said 50 basis points and the market just chased that even though you know we don't have a clue whether the other members support it or whether Kevin Walsh supports it but I think it is such a bad idea for the chairman not to provide forward guidance when all of his lieutenants run around and provide forward guidance on a running basis either or right or say nothing and let the market decide but you can't have one and not the other because Wars wants the market to decide which I hold I I I sincerely hold sympathy for for for the direction he's trying to take the Fed in but then he needs to silence his lieutenants as well.
Tell them to shut up. It's as simple as that. If Waller keeps stating that, okay, we're considering 50 basis points, then there's no point in Boris not providing forward guidance because he's providing it for him. But how can they raise? I I just don't understand. We're already talking about financial conditions have tightened because rates have gone up, the dollar's gone up, and oil was high. So, what good is it to raise rates? Does it stop the capex boom? No, because the hyperscalers don't really care and they've already locked in so much funding at, you know, a 10-year funding plus. Um, the only person that hurts at the front end is actually the US government because they're the biggest issue at the short end.
And if rates go up, they're their whole interest payment curve goes up again. Yet another I think if you look if you look at the construction cycle for example in the US a good old business cycle indicator outside of data centers and you know the grid expansion the business cycle is doing very bad. Yeah, we've got a K-shaped economy and the Fed don't want to acknowledge it because they see the shiny thing of the biggest revenue generating machines in history spending a lot of money on stuff to build more revenue and they're not seeing the fact that Main Street's pretty right now. You know, the whole commercial office space, the the construction industry, the mortgage markets, all of it is a mess.
And especially given that K shape, I don't understand why we trade Walmart at plus 40 forward earnings and the part of the economy that I can can actually cope with high interest rates at, I don't know, five, four or 5x forward earnings. That's weird to me because, you know, good old school consumption will suffer. Well, Walmart, do they get really hit because they're they're just like the Microsoft windows of stuff, right? It's like everybody go everybody else will die and Walmart and Amazon will live. Yeah, that's that's a fair point. I mean, because they kind of take everything because they can be the lowest cost producer of everything.
Costco as well. The the interesting counterargument to that Walmart trade, right? some people because consumer staples have traded incredibly well through this AI cycle which is an anomaly. Well, consumer discretionary has been killed. Yes. But look at it this way, Ralph. I haven't made up my mind on that thesis yet, but Walmart, they've had a um fantastic cooperation uh with one of the u you know manufacturers of um of warehousing robotics and they've made incredible gains using robotics in their warehousing over the past two or three years. And given that Walmart is a low margin business to begin with, maybe that is the exact type of business that will see from a percentage standpoint the biggest increase in margins if robotics, you know, work.
So we can test this because Amazon did it. So by 2019 they were piling money into robotics and capex and out the other side they stopped hiring people. They stopped hiring people in about 2019 and they haven't really hired again. Yet their number of robots will exceed the number of humans by next year and their productivity's gone up. So their profits per employee have gone up massively. Their margins have gone up. So, Amazon is like a giant experiment of the US economy as it implements AI and robotics and they're proving it and Wilmark's proving it or will prove it and everybody will follow suit in the end because they'll have to because if not, you're going out of business.
So, there's that K shape that's going to continue as well is like who the going to stay in business and who's going to go out of business. It's it's really incredible and that is why you know I had the discussion with a portfolio manager earlier today on a call which sectors can we actually price with a decent visibility over the next 5 to 10 years. Uh I'd argue that Amazon can be priced with a decent visibility. Uh Walmart may be the same. At least they're doing some of the right things. They're maybe doing it too slow but they're doing some of the right things. uh Bloomberg. Can we price that with a decent visibility?
I don't think so because it it it it takes they need to take some incredibly bold decisions to stay alive in my opinion. I've said the same to my all of my financial software account managers. I've said it three years running. If you do not take the right strategic decisions, I will cease being a client within 5 years. I'm certain about that. Yeah. Well, I had this conversation with Bloomberg and they said, "Fuck you." And I said, "Thank here. You know, I've been a client at Bloomberg since 1992 and I've I just cancelled. I said, "No, I'm just not doing this anymore. It's pointless." And you can't charge me claiming you have a monopoly, you know, $30,000 a year for this when basically I don't need you.
And look at it this way, Ralph. I spend substantially less on Claude than on Bloomberg. Even though my workflow is in cloud now and I probably create 90% of my charts within the cloud ecosystem occasionally with Bloomberg data short occasionally when you're looking at 1962 off the run Lithuanian bonds maybe yeah enough about my portfolio but but maybe the only moat that's left you know speaking of this lack of human attention whatever you called it early in the in in this show the only moat that's left is that many of my counterparts they do not reply to emails anymore if you try to you know write them okay your your subscription is up for the annual renewal that is not being brought forward by their claude scanner or whatever they have in place right so when you ping them on Bloomberg you can actually get in contact with people that's that's very valuable for me still but it's the only reason why I have the subscription more or less it's the only reason and and I pay $30k for that a year and I I happen to admit to it because you know it's it's still the people business to sell subscriptions to many people um within within the uh fund management industry etc.
But I think maybe in 5 10 years from now you know who cares about the Bloomberg chat because everyone's already connected via the MTP that I've built within the claude ecosystem and all of that. But but I've even noticed a slowdown in email traffic from you know like GMI subscribers and it's not because they're less engaged. is because people are overwhelmed and there's just they don't do that people just stop doing it now. WhatsApp seems to be the most effective way of speaking to everybody now for me you know because nothing else people people don't you people stop using email but I I cannot I I I'm still trying to figure out whether this is a paradise or a nightmare for me because everyone's turning into the same kind of person that I've been for all of my life.
You know, I've always lacked the attention span to read stuff from uh my counterparts via email and stuff. I never responded to emails and never been like that, right? I I I only respond to things that I get notified with on my phone, right? And um but now everyone's like that. And it it's it's something that I need to to learn how to deal with because I've I've typically dealt with someone actually reading what I sent to them and they don't do that anymore. No. And that's a weird thing because you know how much of your own research do you write do they actually sit down and read versus put it into their claude and say you know just take this into account how Andreas is thinking about this.
Does this change my positions? It's like it's kind of weird. one of our one of our members at Real Vision Ralph U sent me a screenshot of an uh agents that she set up to only provide her with the summary of the stuff stuff that I put in caps lock in in the research papers I write and it was actually damn good because I always put it in caps lock when I sincerely mean something by this. So yeah, I just put mine in bold. She's like there's a bold text that you don't need to read the rest. Just read that in the titles and that's fine. Exactly. But I don't know how the world deal. I don't I know there's something bigger in this and I'm still trying to think it through.
This scarcity of human attention. We've saturated it. I can see it on X. I can see it everywhere. I can see it in businesses. We've saturated human attention. And I don't know how that changes things and who it changes for what. But I think we'll end up with less platforms and more super platforms. Yeah. Um, you know, it's hard enough to flip between, you know, X and then your WhatsApp and then your email and then Real Vision and then something YouTube and then whatever. All of these things like it's too hard. There's too much context switching in different platforms and different things when it feels that a lot of this is all going to be served in one place in a way that's digestible.
But then it's weird because there's AI writing articles for AIs who are digesting articles. But I and compressing it for humans because we're too stupid to be able to process this amount of bandwidth. But from an entrepreneurial standpoint, well, I I'm involved in a lot of, you know, angel investments within software in Northern Europe and many of the cases that I've invested in. Um, they have they already have the clients and given the speed of their coding now, they can basically deliver on all promises to all clients at the same time within, you know, 45 minutes. They just ask their account managers to sit out there, record the conversation with a client and then it is basically automatically coded within the software ecosystem within days um at max.
Right? I think that will make their moat even stronger compared to the two guys in a basement trying to create a new software product because what those two guys at the basement cannot do now compared to earlier is to build something that will take a lot of time to replicate. Yes. But those guys that you invest in would do better to allow it to also plug into claude. Sure. So then people have one operating system and it becomes one of their tools that Claude uses like you know my trading view. Yes I use the thing but I also have the feed into my claude and I've got the MCP connector and I get my stuff from Trading View there and I can analy an analyze charts and go back and say hey what do you think of the chart of the dollar and claude will give me a you know a look at it and say yeah you like demarks and this is where I think the demarks are all of that stuff without ever opening my trading view.
That kind of I think is where it's all going. Yeah, because the intelligence layer is too important. But that Yeah, that Yeah, I I don't know. I haven't kind of figured it all out yet, but there's something about this human attention scarcity that everything has to now get compressed for us because the reality is is intelligence ran on carbon for the entire existence of us understanding anything. You know, the planet, everything runs on carbon intelligence. You basically put an energy through carbon and get intelligence and it's just switched substrate to silicon. And so we now put electricity through sand and we generate super intelligence and it's a million times faster.
We can't deal with that. It's why there's a million times more output of articles and nobody can deal with it. And the only thing they can deal with is AI itself because it's a million times faster. And that is why I've launched a live standup tour in Denmark because I don't know what to do. This makes total sense. Yeah. And people want us to be chatting on camera because it it compresses information. All of the writing, all of the stuff. It comes down to the conversation in a way that's digestible that people think, "Okay, I kind of feel like I I'm I'm in touch with all of that now." Yeah. So, it doesn't go away.
So, anything else you're looking at or is that pretty much the whole world? I mean, these are the most important things. I can't think of anything else that really matters. Well, the only thing that has surprised me a little bit during these months of a stronger dollar is actually how crypto has outperformed a lot of peers through this. Uh, I probably wouldn't have had that on my bingo card. No, I looked at the the ratio of the NASDAQ versus Bitcoin. was two standard deviations oversold in its log trend. So it was really oversold but yeah it's done pretty well was it seemed that there was a rotation and it although it still can't you know it can't get traction because there's not enough liquidity yet but I think as soon as liquidity comes back as soon as it comes back then you know it's got to like catch up.
I just struggle with the notion that it's either crypto or AI. Yeah. And I mean those two themes go hand in hand for a range of obvious reasons. But it just seems like that narrative exists because people do not have enough liquidity to invest in both themes at the same time at the moment. And you can see that because you can see Robin Hood's earnings. You can see Coinbase people even Robin Hood people don't have enough money really to invest. So it's, you know, there's a capac capacity constraint from households that they don't have a lot of money because earnings haven't really been going up.
Mortgage costs are high, rents are high, food costs are high, and that's not getting resolved. So, you know, the only way around that is liquidity and lending and all of that stuff. And that's not really happening because the yield curve's too flat. It all comes back to the same thing. It's always liquidity in the end. Yeah. And um, cla windows. I want I wanted to say that as a oneliner before rounding off here and I don't know whether OpenAI is the Mac of the desktop space that who knows or or Gemini. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I thought it's kind of the Mac but no we'll see. It's a whole new world. Listen mate, fantastic conversation.
Hopefully we've added a bit of value and not confused everybody. But uh we both think that the market unless something dramatically changes with liquidity, the market is mispricing all of this. Yeah, I agree. All right, see you next time, mate. Take care. This episode is brought to you by Pith. Piff Network is the fastest growing financial data company today. Trusted by Fidelity Investments, the US Department of Commerce, Revolute, Kelsey, Jane Street, Coinbase, and many more. They provide realtime financial market data across over 3,000 equities, commodities, crypto, FX, rates, and again a lot more.
They're the first and largest provider of 24/7 financial indices and offer the widest array of market data for the lowest cost. So go to pith.network to take advantage of their free trial. So you obviously like this video enough that you've got to the end. That's quite a big task. But listen, do me a favor. Hit the like and subscribe button and also check out what videos next because I think you'll love it. But if you want even more, and when I'm talking more, I'm talking about memberergenerated ideas, incredible alpha research, everything there to help you in your journey, just head to realton.com/join for the best financial intelligence out there and the pure alpha that's within the platform.