Transcript

the honorable the chief justice and the associate justices of the supreme court of the united states before the honorable the supreme court of the united states are admonished to draw near and give their attention for the court is now okay all right let's do it yep hey i'm chad abumrad this is more perfect mini series about the supreme court and um today's story from a reporter sean i always eff up your last name can you just say it ramos firm rama's firm i always put the accent in the wrong place anyhow let me set the table for you we live in a representative democracy and what does that actually mean practically speaking like when do we come in contact with that democracy two places seems to me mainly one when we vote right yeah are you asking me yeah i was deep and thought if you vote if you vote it's true i know like college educated super progressive human beings who are like why would i ever vote it doesn't mean anything exactly not to mention people who just don't even care about the world yeah it sort of makes my point like voting is the first way and for a lot of people it's entirely optional the second way is not you will be fined if you don't do it and i mean serving on a jury this is where like we the people decide who goes to jail who gets free who lives who dies this is where we actually do democracy today uh we start with the story of a guy who supreme who is supreme court famous would you say yeah he's in the books he's like a chapter yeah he's like one of the most important names you've never heard of because he's at the center of this ongoing battle about who gets to serve on juries and his name depending on who you are either symbolizes the best parts of american democracy or the most cynical should i say his name yeah go for it james batson james kirkland batson hey hello yeah sean i went to his house in louisville tell me tell me your full name and tell me where you're from and that james batson louisville kentucky james batson his name just kept coming up over and over again when i was looking through the history of jury selection in america so i called him up and i was like hey i'm this radio reporter in new york city and i'm really interested in your case because there's this other case before the court right now could i come talk to you and he's he was like oh yeah sure okay make sure my full name in city mentioned of course he's tall he's built like a fridge um he is a black man right now driving a truck local and cross country farce i've been is 15 hours one way where is that flora as a kid he was he was an a student graduated from orange technical high school he was uh in a like a vocational school specializing in electrical engineering industrial electricity he seemed really pretty popular in fact i got a perfect tennis award at sunday school when i was 18.

but shortly after that seemed like the bottom fell out so james batson grew up in the west end of louisville in the 1970s and the west end was super rough people selling dope prostitution just everything had to do with fast money and at a young age fast money was like the american dream i mean it's pretty hard when a lot of people around you got nice things and they got them because they're doing something illegal and you keep coming up with rabbit hairs you're shaking your head like you know what rabbit ears are what a rabbit is you pull both of your pockets out and ain't nothing neither one of them he said it all started when he was 10 he wanted to pair her shoes he couldn't afford them chuck taylor's well when they first came out if you didn't have a pair of those you had on what they call buddies what would buddies cheap tennis shoes him and his brother asked his mom for money and they she gave them some money but not enough so to make up the the difference they went out and they stole people's empty soda bottles and turned them in for like the deposits three centaur nickel a piece stolen enough pop bottles to get chuck taylors that was my first experience with illegal money stealing pop bottles so everything else advanced from there fast forward a couple years james is more grown up he starts doing some petty crime and he starts breaking into houses they they actually gave me a name call me the pants pocket burglar when the crime would happen burglar would take only stuff to fit in his pocket like purses and jewelry no merchandise he didn't fit in his pocket he wouldn't take it that was you i'm not admitting that was me plausible deniability those are his two middle names but i'm asking you was it you i'll take the field so james starts stealing bigger things and he starts getting arrested starts going in and out of the courts and then one of those small in and out cases became i think american legal history they got me out of a car 1982 cops pull them over they pulled me out the car they said you have the right to remain silent anything and went through that little protocol whatever they tell them some burglaries that happened in that area and they they said i did them were you were were you stealing stuff at the time yeah at the time i i i had been doing some burglaries or whatever but anyway james said he didn't do this one and that they didn't have the proof he was just driving around in his car and they picked him up when they arrested me i'm thinking they didn't really have a case against me they didn't catch me breaking into a house he got me out of a car you know fingerprints nowhere he thinks he can win i feel like i could be case so i'm like i'm on a jury trial and the mere fact that you and i are talking about james batson's case 30 plus years later is amazing that's the prosecutor my name is joe gutman i'm from louisville kentucky grew up in louisville raised in louisville wanted to be a lawyer since he was a kid my parents went through a divorce when i was very young and i wanted to go to law school to help kids in divorces 1982 when joe gutman first gets the batson case he's 26 years old and had just become a lawyer uh james's case was in the first six months that i was in the prosecutor's office pretty impressive uh first year um no starting out i lost my first eight trials really yeah he says when he saw batson's case you know this low-level burglary a break-in of a house and a purse being stolen he was like oh maybe this will be my win the evidence appeared that he was guilty of the crime james was accused and identified as the one as having done it two eyewitnesses they're saying james did it but james is saying no i didn't you don't have any proof he says the cops probably showed these witnesses photos of him before because they need never seen them before in his life so so government's on the case it goes to trial and had a hung jury they ended up being a hung jury yeah people ray it means they couldn't come to a unanimous decision so james gets off why was it a hung jury well in kentucky you have to have a unanimous verdict so the defense is looking for that one juror that keeps from convicting there was apparently one juror who just didn't buy it didn't buy the evidence and thought james was legit it was a black woman one black lady came to visit me after the jury was over she said i really really don't think you're guilty the rest of the jury was trying to make me say that she was guilty and i was saying not guilty so it ended up being a hung jury i was disappointed at that point i was having second thoughts about you know is this the right career for me so joe gottman he says i'm gonna try this case one more time it was pretty close to guilty i had this one juror who hung it up so let me do it one more time and he does something this time a little differently just to set it up as you know when you get a jury summons you go in you're on a jury pool and at the beginning of a trial potential jurors please stand and raise your right hand you have jury's selection you and each of you do solemnly swear or affirm that you will true answers mate to such questions as may be asked you touching your qualifications that's where both sides of prosecution the defense sometimes the judge they get jurors into a room and they start asking lots of questions is there anyone here who's been the victim of a crime have any of you had family members that have been victims of crime okay i saw a couple of hands they start interviewing jurors do you have any opinions one way or the other about the criminal justice system in general to figure out which jurors do we want do you have any kids i do are you a member or are you involved in any organizations i'm a member of a church which jurors do we want to get rid of and that's the more important part of this process which jurors do we want to toss off this jury pool no so what are the rules to uh get rid of jurors there's two ways to get rid of jurors to get down to that group of 12 in this case and the first way is called striking for cause the state would move to excuse him for cause at this time striking for cause is like when they ask you can you be fair in this case if you say you know no i really can't i have really strong feelings about the people or the subject matter that's a strike for cause or it's like hey that lady who's sitting in the chair the defendant that's um that's my cousin we grew up together you know like conflict of interest blatant conflict that's my boss we go out every saturday for brunch whatever it is you're too close to this you can't be fair got it so that one's cause that's pretty much common sense it makes sense to everyone but the second way is the heart of this whole matter this whole story it's called a peremptory challenge preemptory or not preemptory per empty that's a word depending on how you punch it into google it'll be like that's a typo what does it mean what does per-empty mean peremptory challenge means you get a certain number of strikes just to get rid of people you think might not be fair to you but you can really use them any way you want and with these strikes you don't have to give any reason wow and how many of these do you get so it varies from state to state in some states it's 20 in other states it's four in kentucky then and now each side gets eight eight jurors that they just get to put the x on and say you're not gonna sit on this trial hook or crook and they don't have to explain themselves at all they don't explain anything and this isn't just some weird legal rule we made up like 20 years ago this is something that has been around it's older than america it goes back to england in the 11th 12th century and before that some say it goes back to like 104 bc roman times really really and the idea is i feel like the visualization is like a seesaw like okay we need to get to this perfect group of 12 people and you know there's going to be people who are biased to either side so each side gets to eliminate people you get three you get three you get four you get four and then we'll come to this balance in the jury of a group of people who are going to be fair so if both sides are sort of trying to tilt it their way from either side the thinking is it'll end up balanced yeah and also the thinking was that this would give both sides more faith in the process and at the same time protect both sides from like the tyranny of a trial judge who has too much power gotcha okay anyway what happens in this case is the second trial begins so take me to the moment of jury selection which is i imagine early yeah that's that's the first thing that happens well the only people that were in the courtroom were some family members of mr batson his attorney a detective and me and the jury so the reason we're talking about this case and joe gutman and james batson is because the next thing that happens is joe gutman gets up there he scans the jury pool and at this point he says there were 13 people left four that were black nine that were white and he uses his peremptory challenges to strike off one two three four black jurors they're all gone leaving an all-white jerk do you remember striking for minority people off this jury well i mean i did do i specifically remember the reason for each no i don't i asked joe was the reason because they were in fact black no i can say that they were not stricken because of race and i remember specifically that one of the jurors lived in the neighborhood he doesn't exactly remember what his reasons were for all four black jurors but what's important for our story is to know that james batson is sitting there in the room as all this is happening and i'm like ah that's completely they struck all the blacks off the jury pool it ain't right i told my lawyer i said objective that they you know lawyer says why would i object james said because it's not fair he said no that's a long-standing rule he's allowed to do that he could strike whoever he won't was he lawyer white or was he black he was white and was the judge white or black he was white and aside from those four people that had just been struck off the jury everybody in the courtroom was white so again told my lawyer to object and again the lawyer says he said no i told you you can't object to this so what do you mean you can't you work for me you do what i say you just object anyway i don't care this long-standing rule object and he did and it all came behind that one objection this one tiny moment yeah what happened is after the jury was selected dug down james's attorney said judge i i want to make an objection we went up to the bench he said your honor you can see there's an all-white jury i would like for him to explain his strikes but before i could get another word out of my mouth judge ryan said mr gutman does not have to explain his rights it's not the law let's move on move on so they moved on with an all-white jury and i got found guilty i got 20 years for burglary yes so batson goes to prison danville kentucky and he says his first move when he got there appeal immediately and ultimately his appeal ends up in the hands of this guy david niehaus jefferson county public defenders office and niehaus decides to do something ambitious what we did is we call it taking a tour of the jurisdictions and his team start looking at other states looking at other regions to find out whether this is a problem elsewhere is this just something limited to the south or is it something else you mean like are people in other places doing what joe gottman did and using peremptories to kick black people off of juries right right right and what he found is that this was kentucky happening pretty much everywhere so they filed an appeal which worked its way up through the courts and in december 1985 thank you gentlemen the case is submitted we'll hear arguments next in batson against kentucky the case arrives at the supreme court of the united states i get a call one day from the associated press that's joe guptman saying uh how do you feel about the supreme court accepting the case of james kirkland batson and i was almost speechless and were you sitting on the bench i did uh go just to observe and learn mr niehaus i think you may proceed whenever you're ready thank you your honor mr chief justice and may it please the court so here's how it ultimately went down that's inside niehaus he argues that these strikes were being used to take black people off of juries and this was happening everywhere we were able to list some 25 jurisdictions and that the practice violated the 14th amendment which was equal protection and the sixth amendment which was a right to a jury of your peers a jury that is as representative of the community as possible so if louisville is like 17 black the jury should probably be about 17 black and the prosecutors shouldn't just be allowed to skew that without having to give a reason first of all kentucky's response to require an explanation of preemptory challenges would destroy we believe the historical nature and function of the device itself so kentucky's saying we shouldn't have to justify these strikes the court has told us that again and again it has always been unfettered and uncontrolled by the court unexplained and this practice goes back centuries and yes there may be some abuses but this is a tool that lawyers need thank you gentlemen the case is submitted four months later the court delivers its verdict and in a seven to two decision batson wins the court found that the prosecutor's actions for sure violated the 14th amendment they said racial discrimination of any kind in jury selection is not allowed cue dan rather the high court ruled today it is illegal totes illegal even on a preemptory challenge it is illegal for a lawyer to reject the juror on the basis of race james batson's sentence was immediately vacated how'd that feel kane is indescribable if you're in prison and you know your sentence is being taken away i mean that's a great feeling i still brag every now and then and it's conversation come up i could just be hanging out playing chess i got a law in the law books batson rule and that was the biggest deal of all this the headline there was this new and rules the bats and bats and bats named after him justices put new limits on what is called preemptory challenge the batson rule the batson rule is this echo of what james did in court that day when you see people minorities getting booted off of a jury you can say your honor i think that's a that's in violation that's in violation and then the other side be it the defense of the prosecution has to provide non-racial reasons for why they eliminated that juror and for a lot of people this was a breakthrough this was like finally we figured out how to do this right there was a system in place to protect everyone and that system was even extended to civil cases and eventually to women as well uh it was a big deal when the case was decided and the initial elation was quickly tempered with a strong dose of reality this is jeff robinson he's the director of the aclu center for justice because what batson prevents is deliberate racial discrimination and almost immediately all over the country prosecutors started training each other teaching each other on how to get around batson that's brian stevenson he's the director of the equal justice initiative in montgomery alabama uh there were trainings all across the country and some of these are on video date and i found one i mean it's on youtube when you're picking a jewelry you gotta stay to these basic rules this is one of those videos this one it's a philadelphia prosecutor named jack mcmahon lecturing to a room full of young prosecutors on how to pick a jury you know in in selecting blacks you don't want the real educated ones in my experience black women young black women are very bad uh there's an antagonism i guess maybe because they're downtrodden on two respects they've got two minorities they're women and they're blacks and so they're downtrodden two areas and they somehow uh want to take it out on somebody and you don't want it to be you uh and so the craziest thing about this video is that it was filmed just a few months after the batson decision batson vs kentucky i'm sure you've all become aware of that case jack mcmahon basically tells these prosecutors look we've got this new rule here's how you break it you strike the black person off the jury but just say it's for another reason because that's what batson requires is a racially neutral reason my advice would be in that situation is when you do have a black jury you question them at length and on this little sheet that you have mark something down that you can articulate later time if something happens so let's say you strike three blacks to start with first three people write it down right then and there i'd write it right in my little box there you know the woman had a kid about the same age as the defendant and i thought she'd be sympathetic to him or she's unemployed and i just don't like unemployed people because i find they're not too stable this is almost this training to create a catalog of reasons that on the face were race neutral just say you're excluding them because they're too tall or they're too old oh that person was wearing a black sweater things like well he lives in a bad neighborhood a person wouldn't maintain eye contact their body language or they belong to a church tattoos were there a nurse any of those reasons have them marked down as long as a prosecutor doesn't say i excused that person because they're black batson says it's completely okay i was actually working on a case uh this is lawyer brian stevenson again my office the at the time was called the southern prisoner's defense committees when i was in atlanta georgia before i moved to uh to alabama and when was this this was 1986 and we were defending someone down in swainsboro georgia a guy by the name of gamble and the batson decision came down and objections were made when the prosecutor used his peremptory strikes to exclude all of the african-americans and we said wait a minute your honor there's a new decision batson versus kentucky which means that the prosecutor can't do this and the court said well i've read batson uh what this means is that the prosecutor has to give race neutral reasons until the prosecutor says i've got my race neutral reasons he said well i struck this woman because she looks just like the defendant the defendant was an african-american man i said wait a minute what is that no she does and the judge oh i see that he said i struck judge said i see that oh yes he did what the prosecutor said i struck this man because he lives in south waynesboro and that's where the defendant lives and we of course were saying look all the black people live in south swainsboro all the white people that's not a race no to reason the judge said no that is a race neutral reason he said i struck one person uh because this man was in the military and he was discharged after five years in the military and in my experience your honor you only get discharged honorably after an even number of years well the juror was put back on the stand we said well were you discharged from the military honorably yes i was i was actually decorated i got this medal i got this award i've got these things well i still accept the prosecutor's reading for excluding that person oh no my favorite was the prosecution some of those are your friends oh no it gets better it gets better said i struck this man because he testified that he was a mason and he said your honor i just don't want anybody who's a member of a masonic lodge on my jury they have their own codes their own rituals their own culture i don't want that and the jury was put back on the stand we asked the juror are you a member of a masonic lodge and the jury said no i'm not he said i'm a brick mason and the judge says i still know what you mean i'll let you exclude that person oh my god right and so almost from the very beginning there was this cynicism this game playing i used to tell people batson's not going to eliminate racial bias and jury selection but it will make the jury selection process a lot more entertaining y'all should come to court and just watch the show so you could argue that not only did batson not change anything but batson made things worse um as one lawyer stephen bright put it to me i think what batson is really is basically a set of procedures to sort of legitimize and cover up the race discrimination that's going on you had this smelly putrid problem of racial discrimination and jury selection and instead of tossing it out we just prayed febreze all over it he just kind of perfumed it vaguely cheap cologne it's still there it just vaguely hidden and now with the batson rule if you think the prosecution or the defense is striking people off because of race you have to call them out and then you have to somehow try and prove that the reason they're providing is a lie and that's really really difficult to do since 1986 for example in the state of washington there have been probably 47 48 challenges on batson issues where people have been convicted and they've said wait a minute the prosecutors were excusing people of color from the jury because they were people of color out of those 46 to 50 challenges there's been one reversal the state of tennessee has not reversed a single case under batson and the 30 years for it since the batson decision came down as a result he says there's still many counties in america where the diversity of the jury has not increased very much at all so for example in one louisiana parish they looked at felony cases over an eight period and found that nearly half the black jurors were struck in houston county alabama over a five-year period the data established that 80 of the african-americans qualified for jury service were struck 80 percent 80 and that's in death penalty cases so i mean if you think about that like a big percentage of the time these are lawyers who are going around the batson rule going around the law going around the constitution to get these all-white juries who are then oftentimes putting black men to death and that reminds you of some pretty dark history yeah well super basic question yeah i mean that video training video the assumption in that video is that having black people on the jury would hurt that guy would hurt the prosecutor yeah is that should we just assume that or i mean is there any any data that would say that's even remotely true the hardest thing about looking at this stuff analytically is that juries are like a black box they don't let journalists and academics in often to study what's going on the jury's kind of sacred that way yeah but the few times we've gotten data like there's this group called the capital jury project that looks at data specifically in capital cases because that's where this stuff ends up being life or death so they looked at data in like 350 cases in 14 states over a number of years and they found that white men are more likely to go for the death penalty than black men when you get to sentencing that number that the difference between white and black gets really exaggerated like white men are seven times more likely to want the death penalty than a black person there's another study that was done in florida and this one looked at felony cases over like 10 years and they found that all white jury pools in florida convinced black defendants 16 more often than white defendants okay but what was really interesting is that that gap was practically eliminated when at least one member of the jury pool was black interesting you put one black person in the jury pool and that difference is annihilated i could ask the obvious question why i mean obviously criminal cases usually involve cops and the reason that's often cited is that you know black jurors are less likely to believe cops lecturers are more likely to insert some sense of suspicion into this the states or the the commonwealth or whatever is testimony yeah and almost everyone i talked to gave me a version of this that you know when you have black people in a jury they deliberate more and that black people are less likely to trust law enforcement especially jack mcmahon who was the guy we heard from in that video listen anybody knows me knows i am about as the anti-racist person that you could ever imagine i'm a stone cold liberal to the nth degree but i was talking about practicalities of picking a jury back then and uh i still stand by that i mean if you're a prosecutor all right let me and ask you this question and you're trying to drug case so to speak and you're in your defen and the defendant is going to claim that the cops are lying okay and you're the prosecutor now what demographic group has had more exposure to police lying than minority communities they have seen police lie and will believe police lie more than some white guy who lives in a rich area believes that police officer every time everything he says and so as a prosecutor you're trying to win the case and that person's not going to be a person that's going to be more questioning of your witnesses and you're given the opportunity through peremptory challenges to strike them why wouldn't you you'd be a fool not to well i guess i i see the argument that you know use your peremptory challenges to get the best jury you can to win right but doesn't eliminating a black juror because you believe they might have certain biases against a police officer versus a white juror in some way violate the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment no i don't think so uh not at all because it's not because of the color of their skin it's because of their demographics and where the who they've dealt with it's a societal demographic concept it's just it's just a fact of life it's just like but i think those facts of life and those societal demographical concepts all stem from the color of their skin well well that's that's that that may be a deeper issue that we can't deal with in jury selection you're right but the reality is the reality is that that that's what the situation is so so you're saying that if you're the prosecutor you should say oh well this guy will probably be worse uh for me he probably believes those cops are lying but i'm going to take them because i want to uphold the you know come on i mean that's just not realistic that's just there isn't a prosecutor in the country that would do that say well i want to i want to show my altruism and i'm going to keep this guy on my jury who may disbelieve my essential witnesses because i want to be altruistic i mean come on that's just not the way life is coming up how to solve a problem like batson more perfect we'll continue in a moment this is more perfect mini series about the supreme court i'm jadaboomrod i'm sean ramisferum let's just for a second explain how we got into this whole uh morass about racial bias and jury selection i think we should it's because of a case that was in front of the supreme court uh this term yep you'll hear argument first this morning in case 14 8349 foster versus chapman so basic facts this is a murder case in georgia a younger black man kills an elderly white woman the prosecutors dismiss a bunch of black jurors and the defense having this new batson rule says hold up can't do that and the prosecutors give these race neutral reasons and the judge says that looks good to me and then years later something sort of incredible happens through like one of those freedom of information act type things the defense actually gets to see the notes the prosecution had during the trial the notes they kept during jury selection this is one of those rare times when we pull back the curtain and we find out what the prosecutors were doing this is lawyer stephen bright he actually argued the foster case in front of the supreme court late last year and he says what you saw in these notes was that the prosecution they literally wrote a little b next to the name of each and every black jerk b1 b2 b3 uh highlighting all the blacks and and green on the on the list of all the people summoned for jury duty it's like racial discrimination is really hard to prove this is actual physical proof in a file in the state like this is the smoking gun we've been waiting for so what are the what did the prosecutor how did the prosecution argue this in front of the supreme court prosecution was like you know what actually once the notes were found they said we were just writing those b's because we wanted to make sure we noticed the black jurors we wanted to keep track of them the reasonable explanation in this case is four months prior to trial defense counsel files a motion and says the strike of any black juror we're filing a batson challenge that's the lawyer representing georgia beth burton and she's saying of course we're going to notice race this is the post batson world and we're going to note race and we're going to write it down i would be more surprised quite frankly if there wasn't some sort of highlighting or in other words the argument you're making here is that if i is that the reason he highlighted all the black jurors in green he being the original prosecutor uh and uh said black what about the black jurors and did all these different things was because he was preparing a defense in case of a batson challenge correct all right that's justice breyer asking well why didn't you make that argument like when the case was actually happening years and years ago and it was several years yeah this was not and that so if that had been his real reason why isn't it a little surprising that he never thought of it or didn't tell anybody until you raise this argument in your main breed and and i i would i would say that's on state habeas council so the good news is that in a seven to one decision the supreme court agreed that this prosecutor's reasons were utterly ridiculous isn't this i'm just going to ask you isn't this as clear about some violation as the court is ever going to see that's justice i don't think it is the bad news is that this case was in front of the supreme court at all it had to get appealed up to the highest court in the land before someone said oh yeah that's a batson violation that's how hard it is yeah and the supreme court though it made a forceful decision seven out of eight they didn't make a new rule they said this isn't how it works they didn't offer up a batson 2.0 or they didn't double down or throw it out or do some new rule no they said this is really wrong but they didn't go as far to say well clearly this doesn't work so we still got batson yeah still got batson so okay if we want diverse juries and we know that batson doesn't really work what do we do so i asked everyone i talked to that question and got a lot of different answers but this was the obvious one and nancy nancy martyr who's a professor of law iit chicago kent college of law starts us off what i'd like the court to do is eliminate peremptory challenges it's a no-brainer again that stephen bright is a lawyer uh we have to i mean it's like it's like the supreme court gives you these rules of preemptory challenges to strike people and then says well wait a minute don't just strike people you know we're going to look into all the ways that you strike the people well then they'll give them at all then for crying out loud it's real simple even jack mcmahon the guy from that training video he was open to it take him away we've had 30 years of experiment with batson and it's not working we now have to go the route that justice marshall suggested back in batson this court is never stated and i dare not speak for that's a good constitutional rule isn't it so in the batson decision you've got thurgood marshall like the most important attorney in the civil rights movement turned the first black supreme court justice he in the same paragraph called the batson decision historic and then said this isn't going to work this decision isn't going to do anything he was basically a fortune teller he said both those things in the same breath in one paragraph he started out going this decision today historic by the end of the paragraph you're never going to fix this until you get rid of preemptory challenges to both sides just do away with perimetry strikes would that violate the constitution if both sides could exercise proper challenges if both sides are denied correctory challenges no survey would not violate the constitution he said as long as you have peremptory challenges you will have discrimination but what surprised me most in reporting this story is that like i talk to people on the left side of the criminal justice system on the right side of the criminal justice system aclu types law professors academics conservative prosecutors all of these people when you say guys we've got to get rid of preemptive challenges right almost every single one will say no no no it's kind of that's a crucially important tool we need them it is crucially important you know it it's an easy solution just get rid of peremptories no no editor law professor sun wolf from santa clara university and lawyer david niehaus again and here's one of the arguments i heard if you take these things away all the decisions about striking jurors would be made by the judge on the question of whether juror could be fair and impartial and for that to work you have to have a fair judge and they're an awful lot of judges who aren't fair here's another argument i heard from jeffrey robinson from the aclu and this is based on my experience of 34 years in the criminal justice system jeff robinson says if you can find some way to take race out of the equation peremptories are super useful and he told me about this one case very high profile homicide case in the state of washington this case was incredibly complicated and also potentially involved a coerced confession by some undercover cops and there's a police officer on the jury panel he says i can be fair i know the police officers that investigated this case i've worked with them before i think they're really good people but don't worry i can be fair everything about his background was saying i do not want this man to serve on this jury but he was saying i can be fair i could not exclude him on a challenge for cause why not because he said he could be fair the fact that he's a police officer doesn't mean he can't be fair but isn't saying i know some of these people involved in this case enough to get him uh dismissed for cause it's enough to get more questioning but how well do you know him not very well so you're saying in that case if you said okay judge i'd like to dismiss juror 17 for congress because the judge would say there's not a record for cause i don't think any judge in this country would dismiss that juror for cause and so a peremptory challenge is important so i've watched more jury selection videos on youtube than any person ever should and it's this amazing thing where you see these people they're not necessarily used to being in a courtroom they're certainly not used to being grilled in public by a bunch of people in suits they get up there to the jury panel and they get asked these questions does everyone agree that bias doesn't have any place in the trial over and over again can you be fair and impartial yes sir you're like a blank slate you're just going to listen to the evidence can you do all that yes i could okay nobody says no everyone feels like yes i can be fair and you know this is the time to tell us that's why we're asking you this i'm thinking i could okay i can be totally unbiased and i think some of them believe that they can actually do this nearly impossible task and others they know they can't but they might say yes anyway anyone who tries the case believe me knows that misters come in they don't reveal things they lie about things there's people that when you're questioning them in a jury that you know they're lying to you they're either trying to get on the jury or trying to get off the jury biased people are being allowed to serve so any tool that can help reduce the number of biased jurors on jurors is essential to justice so yeah if you've got a really crappy outlook on jurors and humans then maybe you need more pancreatic challenges but the way jeffrey robinson put it to me was that if you're using preemptory challenges the right way it forces you to be like equal opportunity suspicious suspicious of like everyone and that's the only way to be fair my parents were both active in the civil rights movement in memphis tennessee as active as two people you could ever want to meet both black i would never let my mother sit on a criminal defense jury because my mother's view about black defendants was you're the reason i have to lock the door in my neighborhood you're the reason that i get disrespected when i go out into the community and i'm gonna take it out on you my father's position would be i wouldn't believe a police officer if he told me it was raining and the water was coming down on my head and so what this is about is actually putting into effect what the rules say talk to jurors and find out what they think but what about thurgood marshall's idea that you know if you have peremptory challenges if you give people a way to discriminate they will discriminate well i was born in 1956 and so in 1954 thurgood marshall argued brown versus the board of education which had a significant impact on my life thurgood marshall was someone that i have respected and someone i have admired virtually my entire life but i can't agree with him that i want all preemptory challenges eliminated and why do you think thurgood marshall justice marshall went straight to no parent i think justice marshall concluded that he did not have faith in america to be able to make these kind of decisions and i understand why he concluded that and you do you have that faith i still do and how long that will last i don't know but i still do right now robinson says that to give up on these peremptories is like giving up on who we might be one day because of who we are right now that's conceding that we are so divided by race that we will never be able to try and fix it and i'm not prepared to concede that okay one last thing from my trip to louisville tojo hey what's up james something that blew me away i'm joe gottman i'm a teacher at central high school also an attorney at law i'm james batson truck driver and a construction worker amongst other things i probably should add that i'm the former prosecutor of mr batson's cases joe gutman and james batson those two people whose conflict in a courtroom back in 1983 gave us the batson rule they are now in 2016 friends and i talked to him all the time yeah i still we yeah we're friends now how often is it that a prosecutor becomes friends with someone he helped convict not not often i mean he he retired from uh prosecuting i i left in 2001.

i had seen too many awful things to make a long story short it was time for me to do something else joe gutman retires from being a prosecutor and starts teaching at a high school in louisville that's 80 percent black um we're doing we're opposing drug testing because we're on the student side my name is antoine jackson okay well drug testing in schools seems like a good idea but in actuality it isn't so the day i visited joe gutman's classroom which is like a full-on mock courtroom in a classroom he was doing these mock trials with his students so there's many reasons why group testing should not be allowed in schools and public schools because there's no funding for it when it's all said and done i would prefer to be known more for the accomplishments in this classroom than for batson as for james after the batson case eventually i retired from illegal activities and he wrote a book called a war on jails concept is me trying to get people to stop doing crime and the book's actually how these two sort of met up again uh one day a few years ago james came to joe's school to give him a copy he gave me a copy of his book and asked me if i'd look over it i wanted his opinion on it i read the book that night actually and he got 50 books into the school system here in jefferson county now so what happened in the past is in the past 30 years ago he did what he did i did what i did let it go as far as the legacy of the batson challenge goes it's really interesting to hear them talk about it especially because in the eyes of a lot of people who know these issues joe was a villain that was always the painful part about the decision in batson is the label of being a racist prosecutor what did that mean well that was a horrible label yeah i mean it's a horrible label but batson started a needed discussion and a needed change on jury selection in america you know maybe i was just there whether it be fate or whatever that this was the start of change so i mean take it for what it's worth but maybe if robinson's right we can look at all this and have a little tiny bit of hope i think we're but maybe not more perfect actually sean came up with the name more perfect more perfect is produced by me jadaboom rods susie lechtenberg tobin low kelsey padgett and andy mills with soren wheeler ellie mistahl david herrmann alex overington karen duffin sean ramisforum katherine wells barry finkel and michelle harris special thanks to aideno klein brian orr julie tulle gee charles and sarah vader supreme court audio is from oyea a free law project in collaboration with the legal information institute at cornell more perfect is funded in part by the william and flora hewlett foundation the charles evans hughes memorial foundation and the joyce foundation you

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Object Anyway | Radiolab Presents: More Perfect Podcast | Season 1 Episode 6