Transcript

this has been a lot of fun for me here's my uh well in theory here's my disclosure I took money from beyond meat at one point to a study called swap meat uh which I'll get into so I'm here's my outline and to go through this in 40ish minutes and leave 15 for questions and I'm really no stranger to trying to get media attention so I I hope you'll appreciate how hard we work on acronyms in our studies so we really try to make them sort of easy to remember and try to use the first letter of every word not the seventh and the 14th letter of the words make the word and skip the words so one of these had 1500 citations one had 800 citations more recently swap meat was the beyond meat study that is my favorite acronym of all I hope you'll appreciate that Fifi fo with the sonnenbergs doing microbiome and cell just a couple years ago that's been cited 800 times already and we did a Med study recently so you know trying to get in the newspaper and try to disseminate and it I don't know how many of you attended one of these but it's either 10 or 15 years ago when Stanford Communications held some faculty meetings and they said you are going to have to get out there on social media you're going to have to disseminate your results in new ways if you want to be out there and compete with your with your colleagues and just to get your message out there should I fix something yeah hang on everybody okay all right soybeans cha Masala steel cut oats okay it seems to work so as much as these were fine I was trying to listen to the um the comms people from Stanford about you know try to get out there try to do social media I'm pretty good at Twitter although Twitter going downhill now obviously I'm trying Blue Sky myc's director is trying to get me to do um Instagram I'm not very good at it I'm not very good at LinkedIn um but this this changed my life this is the most impact I've ever had in my entire life and it was basically a mistake and now that I see him in the room I just want to point out Kevin Schulman's it's his fault for having me in here thanks for coming today he he recommended this so if this is any good give him credit and if it's bad you give me most of the credit but give Errol a little because he had a better speaker than me and I'm the backup and so you should have had another backup other than me but okay thanks Kevin for attending this was wild it was just it's just been a roller coaster of a year and I I wanted to share to see what kind of feedback I had from any of you what kind of similar experiences maybe I'll Inspire some of you to stick your neck out a little more or as one of the colleagues in my division said as I presented this at our division Grand rounds if this happened to them they would run as far and as fast as they could change their name and hide under a rock I thought that is that's not the uh the response I expected so let me get something very clear it was not my idea the whole thing came from Lou sa Hoyos who is a producer one time he was a photographer for National Geographic and then he decided to make a documentary called the Cod if anybody remembers that it's a decade old actually who won an Academy Award for documentaries had to do with Dolphin Slaughter in Japan and they were feeding Mercury Laden Dolphins to the Japanese school kids and did Big expose got an Academy Award and then three years ago did game changers on Netflix which is a story about vegan athletes um that some of that was a little hokey but it got a lot of viewings on Netflix and he approached us the development officer said hey there's a producer who wants to talk to you about doing a study and he has has money so who would turn that down if somebody said they had money to do a study so I have now divided my life into before Louie before Netflix and after Netflix that's how I think of my career at this point so I grew up in New Hampshire in the Live Free or Die State went to Colgate as you said I skipped Berkeley I didn't put that on here just in case I get in trouble came as a postto in 93 I do a lot with the American Heart Association American Diabetes Association I helped start the menus of Chang University Research collaborative that was Stanford and The Culinary Institute of America starting that I've started a plant-based diet initiative on campus within our division and I have the tremendous honor of pooping and and feeding people on our microbiome studies with the sonenberg so we've done probably 10 recent microbiome studies and I'm 65 I I could retire I'd be pretty happy with that right there right but Louie had an idea and he approached us with this idea and so we had a whole lot of Zoom calls and he said have money I said well that really helps so this study idea okay and he said what I want is I want identical twins and I want uh one of the twins to go vegan and the other one to not other than that Christopher I don't know I don't know how many days I don't know what the outcomes are I don't know how you get them the food it's just my idea for a study do you think with those parameters and money you can come up with something so we did and this is not my best science I have to say but it was half a million dollars and we got uh 22 pairs of identical twins so 44 participants and we randomize them and for the ones going vegan if you can imagine it's it's not easy going vegan quickly that's a huge change to your diet so in a couple studies now what we've done is taken advantage of some of these food delivery services so if you contract with them and actually the last two have given us the food for the participants just so they could sort of Market that oh we were in a Stanford study so they delivered the food and that was for the first four weeks to the vegans and the omnivores for some little equipo there so both folks were getting their food delivered and then everybody had to cook their own food for the last four weeks and then we got blood and poop and surveys and we did this really fast because Louis gave me this very clear trajectory that he needed to release it on January 1st so he could take advantage of New Year's resolutions for people changing their diets this is all part of a big marketing thing and he said if I give you the money and this is back in 2022 in the fall you have to finish this or can you finish this in six months in 2023 because we told him there's a lot of analysis involved and then he needed a year to work on all the footage and they would pick uh four pairs of featured Twins and they wouldn't film the others but they'd film the beginning and they'd film the results presentation at the end so we did it we cranked this out in six months that is the fastest turnaround we have ever done a study and uh he helped us recruit the identical twins which is pretty fun but as many of you know once you do this after you've written it up and submitted the paper then we all just sit there and wait for it to get rejected resubmit Etc and I kind of forgot about the film because it was it was months and months and months before this happened and he was off and we would hear he was doing other films and he was flying somewhere else and really didn't exactly know what was going to happen he had come to Justin sonnenberg's house to my house we did some stuff in here for the final presentation Etc and on November 2023 we got accepted in Jama Network open and we got a lot of views on Jama Network open and I was actually didn't think we were going to get in that level of Journal it was only 44 people it was only eight weeks so I thought you know stronger study design might have got somewhere else but what I what really occurred to me at that point was I think the identical twins was a hook for drama I think it's like oh my God you control genetics like who does that in nutrition recruitment's always super hard wow we just notched this up in the rigor of Science by a l what I'm super proud We got ajama that's great I don't know how many of you do alt metric scores or think about that but you know an altmetric score of 20 is good if you ask Google and so we're at 2,000 something for alt metric scores and I'm getting feedback and I'm getting pretty much love and and a lot of good feedback in November and December I thought oh yeah wait isn't the isn't the documentary coming out and the producer held a screening for this in the prio two weeks into December and I was always giving I was already giving a talk in cardiology in La that morning and I said you didn't even ask me for the day of the screening and so I like missed the whole screening I I took an early plane back and I saw the last 10 minutes of the screening and I I had to ask some of my friends did we look stupid were we in it did we end up on The Cutting Room floor I don't know they said no no we looked pretty good we're featured I said okay so now I have to wait to see what happens so um I did wait and on January 1 it came out and my email was just flooded with comments mostly love a little bit of criticism in fact enough criticism that uh somebody defended us on the internet guy named plant Chompers he's a tech techie guy who has a great following he does a really good job with videos uh and we even did I even went on Simon Hills the proof to do a two-hour defense of what we're doing okay so I'm going to get back to that but let there was a study it was it was a relatively good study it wasn't a great study but let's just go there okay so here are the fabulous co-authors that I got to work with so take a gander and see if there's anybody you know it was pretty straightforward if you if you randomize identical twins to a vegan or omnivore diet both of them healthy so this is important to me I didn't make a crappy on omore diet make a good omnivore diet and I'll show you proof of that in just a minute and you wait for eight weeks and you check it LDL cholesterol is a primary outcome which is pretty lame because a vegan diet is higher in fiber and lower in saturated fat so no one would be shocked that LDL went down and it did as was the primary outcome we measured a lot of other stuff The Producers said ah I have some more money have some more money measure more things measure everything you can so we can put it in this documentary a little uncom with that but we did measure quite a few things and you'll you'll see how much fun it turned out to be uh if anybody saw it some of the love I got was oh you did such an incredible job with representation you had a South American uh pair of uh participants and you had some black guys from the east coast and you had the two tall white guys and you had the Asian women I said well no it was really mostly white pal Alto women okay look there was four who are featured who were very diverse and representative the study was not this is what we get in our nutrition studies way more women than men and we get what's in the poala area so it's not very representative but the movie made it look like it was okay so again you get four weeks of food delivered four weeks on your own multiple blood and poop samplings lots of questioners Trifecta is the group just out of curiosity anybody ever order meals from Trifecta we got one shaking head there okay there's plenty of companies out there but we thought of that first four weeks is sort of an efficacy part of the trial so adherence was higher we didn't follow everybody to their to their homes and photographed them to see if they were eating at all but we delivered the food and we asked them if they were eating it and they said it was pretty good and then four weeks on their own so we could say well there's an Effectiveness part of this too so they actually have to buy it prepare it make it on their own I'm really proud of this little graph so let me explain it just for a minute in my world of nutrition there's ways to rank how healthy an overall diet is it's called the healthy eating index used in a lot of Publications and so we took sample meals from both diets to see what that healthy eating index would be and in the US sadly enough 100 is the best diet and the average American diet is 60 usually a little below 60 so America has a lot of room for improvement but interestingly at Baseline our Twins were right about there at the average American not very good diet with room for improvement and so when we were feeding them the meals quality went up quite a bit when we took the meals away and they made it on their own very proud of this they're still both healthier than when they started including the omnivorous group now they're not equal the lines aren't on top of each other but I'm making this point to suggest that in one of my new favorite words equipoise we really put some effort into making the omnivore diet not a straw man to knock over but a reasonably good healthier than their usual diet it makes me feel good making conclusions okay okay so stunningly the LDL cholesterol went down in the vegans because their fiber was higher and their saturated fat was lower that was statistically significant and when we looked at a battery of cardiometabolic outcomes fasting insulin was also lower and the vegans lost a little bit of weight and I'm going to come back to that toward the end so keep remembering that loss of a little bit of weight this is just in in eight weeks right uh if anybody's into tmao I don't know if any of the how many of the Cardiology folks are into trimethylamine oxide Stan Hazen from Cleveland Clinic who came up with this really likes it I know a lot of people who don't like it uh there was a little twist it wasn't initially significantly different but for those of you who understand the bizarre world of tmao it seems to be a risk factor but fish are loaded with it and if you eat fish which we think is good for cardiovascular health it spikes up because you just ate the fish so how can it be bad for you if it's in that I don't know but if you eliminated the three people who screwed up and ate fish right before their blood draw it was statistically significant but I'm willing to let that go okay uh we wrote this whole thing up in the paper and they took it so we said there's some outliers so we had an RCT we had identical twins we had great retention in fact only one person dropped out but because we were analyzing them as twins their pair got kicked out too so we had 21 out of 22 pairs finished everything it's a small sample size a small duration and it really wasn't very representative of the population we concluded that this vegan diet led to improved cardiometabolic outcomes really not rocket science at this point but we sure did get a lot of views so I uh the editor of Jama Network open sent us something how many um downloads we had of the abstract and it was it was enormous a few months after that came out another group took our um DNA data and did some biological clocks looking at epigenetic factors that might be related to aging and the producer really wanted this and I said you're nuts in eight weeks you're not going to make anybody younger well it turned out three of the biological clocks lined up and suggested that the vegans they have a number for it but I'm not even going to quote it because I don't think it makes any sense but they were statistically significantly younger than their Pairs and their telr their telr were longer in just eight weeks than the omnivores okay now so for those of you who you know look to see how our results get disseminated it was amazing how much the Aging things this sort of secondary outcome was there so here's the alt metric score that I'm super proud of of the main paper in Jama Network open and the epigenetic paper scored higher the secondary out like put Aging in the title and it I don't know anyway um I was a little worried about this but I know that Tim aim and show did this in a journal club and they went through it and I missed the last half of the journal Club but it was reasonable right show it wasn't it wasn't bad it was legit I I don't know how to interpret the genetics and that biological clock so I was a little worried that they were going to do this article in their Journal club and they did so Luchia Ronica was the lead for us uh she's a postto that worked with me previously and then she brought this to a group called true Diagnostics if I'm getting that right and so the lead author there is one of the um one of the scientists from True Diagnostics so stay tuned I don't know how well this is going to work out but the microbiome results are also very cool they're not out yet because the sonberg are so thorough they took these results which spoiler alert were better for the vegans and they brought it back to a mouse model so they could see that it was better in the vegans but they didn't have an explanation why it was better than the vegans and so uh Matt Carter who is just getting his PhD and is just leaving for a job has now taken this to a mouse model to see if you can come up with a mechanistic explanation for why it would have been better so hopefully look for this it's almost ready to submit so this is just a study that keeps giving so we're going to be sending out another result maybe we'll get another high op metric Factor okay but so now let's go back to the Netflix part so I do think it was a reasonable study I don't think it was our best work it was Innovative in some ways and it was really a blast to work with this guy but this whole Netflix thing was really quite a bit was really odd so I was on vacation uh on January 1st and on January 2nd or 3rd my wife said quick come out and I said why and they say you're third you're third on Netflix like just in a couple of days and so what why what does that mean oh my gosh okay so U having fun and this is why so here's the thing the identical twins were a hook I think for Jama Network open for notching this up a scientific rigor level but they're adorable right just for entertainment identical twins are adorable and interesting and so this is when they came here our results presentation actually was right here in this room and so that was one of the shots we took at the time and these are the featured pairs of four Twins and they got covered throughout doing a bunch of the tests that they were working on uh and so we had others in the documented the sonenberg are in there quite often because they did a lot of work and the filming was on at the home Etc but um it went beyond that this is one part I got um hard time about I don't think I covered it later in the slide so I'll just mention it now uh we had a super buff vegan bodybuilder train them and they all got Dex no they didn't all get dexes the producer wanted them all to get dexes and I said dude you are out of money I can't do another test and he said well I want to do the dexes only going to do the feature Twins and it didn't work very well the vegans lost weight and lost muscle mass they also lost visceral fat so it's kind of a wash I thought the producer would leave it out because it wasn't clear that it was a benefit for the vegans um but I know he wanted to show how ripped neemi Delgado was and so he put it in for that but I got so much grief for this because people saw this in the Netflix and they saw the Dex of results were not in the JAMA Network open paper they said you manipulative son of a you left out results that didn't go your way and nowhere in the Netflix did they say oh and by the way for scientific Integrity we did not have data available for the full set which is why Dr Gardner did not put this in the paper so I just got a ton of grief for not having that in there Louie why did oh I know why you didn't leave it out you really wanted to show off neemi but he also interviewed three star Michelin Chef who had gone vegan in his restaurant in New York and he also showed Senator Booker and I'm not sure if I'm allowed to show this but he also showed uh mayor Adams and he also showed a chicken farmer who quit growing chickens and started raising mushrooms and he had facts about concentrated animal feeding operations he had a regenerative cattle rancher in it who went to eat at the vegan restaurant in New York he had more facts about millions of metrics of tons for what's happening to the environment and all those lagoons of manure that are there and he was really weaving the story in and out and he would bring our participants back oh they came back from their midstudy checkup oh they came back for something else oh now let me go interview somebody else one of them was someone whose household was affected by the lagoons of manure and her house was actually being sprayed by the feces that were coming out of this pig farm and they were on her house and on her clothes and her laundry and on her kids toys and there were lawyers involved and activists involved they even did a thing on the pathogens in chicken um that you have in the kitchen if you put a black light on it and and mark it up somehow Marian Nestle is a well-known nutrition scientist and had the nrdc in there he's weaving this whole story in and out of our study so our study really was featured it really was the thread that had held everything together but there was a lot more to it which I can't take any credit for this is all Louis sayo's doing this okay so this is just sort of mind-blowing for me that this is all going on and I'm I'm having a blast looking at this but it took some time it took a lot of time I got a lot of grief so pretty soon after it came out one of my buddies said dude they are ripping you over the coal raking you over the coals here and I said who is this Australian actor said why do I give a if the Australian actor is raking me over the cold they said well you know there's a health podcaster who runs it well he's got 213 subscribers uh thousand subscribers I how worried should I be I watched this whole hourlong thing and it was super hokey but but do you respond or do you not how do you decide whether to respond or not they were trash talking me and this is the so this was super fun this guy saved me before I even had time to decide so I thinking oh what kind of response should we get and Chris uh was a techie person oh actually he was the Handler of Steve Jobs at one point so he's um well off and retired and his passion is debunking nutrition myths like this and so he made this hourong thing oh no this is only 40 minutes he did a great job he pulled up all the people that have been trash talking you had them all talking over each other like saying oh Garder oh this study sucks oh it's horrible and then he went through them one by one and dismissed them and addressed them for me he showed me before he released it I said wow that is really good thank you and he even interviewed one of our um post dos so Kate Ward got to be in that uh and I thought this was a pretty nice quote so sorry egotistically I'll share this maybe that should have been episode five we did our own Instagram response which I'm not very good at but we uh uh Meg orari helped just put this together a thousand views okay so we didn't address very many comments with a thousand views but we tried that how many of you have heard of Peter Atia who wrote outlived I actually worked with Peter on one of my best studies ever done here the diet fit study he helped me get $5 million for it he used to um help run a group called Nui the new nutrition science initiative and he said we failed science 101 he wrote this whole blog about it I had to take him a little more seriously because he's quite popular categorical failure to isolate and test a specific independent variable with some other embellishments in there so that seemed like it warranted addressing and so this part's odd this like that's that's last century Peter so if you're going to compare a vegan diet to an omnivore diet there isn't any possible way to isolate one single variable so there were bigger increases in many things and there were bigger decreases in many things for the vegans versus the omnivores and that was food groups if you want to talk about nutrients there were a whole bunch of nutrients that were higher and nutrients that were lower that's just you can't do it that way that's such a bizarre comment so I actually was the lead for an American Heart Association scientific statement where the whole point was to PA compare popular dietary patterns this came out in 2023 we made this huge grid where at the top are all the dietary patterns and on the left are pretty much the 10 basic recommendations American heart has for a heart healthy diet and our job was to see how well each pattern matched up with the AHA guidelines and so we picked some patterns we picked 10 and said well there's actually even more names than that but there's probably 10 different patterns and if you want to define a pattern there are certain things it emphasizes some that it includes some that it limits and some that it avoids it's not like the Mediterranean diet is olive oil can't just drink olive oil and be medat that would be a way to isolate a variable right it doesn't work that way so Peter come on so today we don't focus on nutrients so much we've gone from nutrients to foods to patterns and the study was a vegan pattern versus an omnivore pattern that didn't seem so hard to rebut so here was another one about from Peter how insane to just say animal-based foods and plant-based Foods that's ridiculous no one does that actually the Harvard school public health does this all the time now they have a concept where they have a plant-based dietary index a healthy plant-based dietary index and an unhealthy one and the unhealthy one if you can imagine is refined grain added sugar Oreos sodas those are all plants they're all unhealthy and so blowing it up bigger for you and a number of the studies that they've done with this they can show benefit with a plant-based diet but if you separate it out into the healthier and the unhealthier components it makes a much bigger difference if you get rid of the added sugar the refined grain the sodas and the Oreos the plant-based diets do even better so Peter that's it's not unique it's actually done all the time and Simon Hill had me on if anybody follows him I don't know how he pulls this off but the interview was two hours long and some of the interviews are longer than this do you any of you watch podcasts that are longer than two hours uh Rich R I did one with him that was more than two hours oh my God don't understand how people watch these really long things I thought everybody's attention span was quite short and then here's another one that came up that was really informative for me so this actually had going back to the paper if you went to the supplement we had a little display of the calories that were involved in um feeding all these people and this is one of our not main paper but suppl tables and a reviewer I don't know who he was he just wrote me and he said ah that study was manipulative in that phase where they were feeding people the food Gardener delivered less food to the vegans that made them lose weight could probably explain all the results here with the weight loss had nothing to do with a vegan diet so that was a pretty good comment but I said all right I'm I'm pretty good at tweet torial so I made like a 10 tweet thing and I was trying to be kind of said hey at stus whoever you are good job going to those supplemental materials you missed a little bit here so what happens is we asked Trifecta to make the same number of calories for both groups and they delivered the same number of calories for both groups we were not there forcing people to eat them with a gavage so we said you eat until you're full and so we were reporting that they ate less and there's probably at least a couple reasons one maybe with a limited selection of food they just weren't hungry for more another maybe they didn't like the food and they didn't eat as much but I did not trick them into eating less we gave them the same number of calories and the next day it wasn't actually this person this is one of my greatest successes of the last year Dr tro trolls me all the time this is a physician who was quite heavy and he lost a lot of weight and he is a really vehement uh proponent of Keto diets and local carb and so every time I say anything that's not low carb he trashes me on social media and this time he read my response to this and apparently he had trashed me and I didn't know it because he said I appreciate his explanation I apologize for my quick judgment on it on this specific matter I was wrong and it wasn't just written it was a video apology on Twitter thank you very much that that made my day right I mean there's a lot of trash on social media and a wow a video apology I felt like it was a little bit of karma because the year months before he had said something and I wrote back and I said I agree with you see we agree on some things we don't disagree on everything but this was the best of all so I didn't even receive this or I didn't find this one so someone forwarded it to me probably one the best pieces of Psych I've seen today you know what makes it so good most people have no idea they're even watching science and this is part of a multi- tweet post and it turns out KY is a Harvard Professor who helped get out the madna vaccine and my reading of it is her comment was based on her frustration getting that vaccine out faster than anybody thought they could get it out and people weren't taking it thought they were getting injected with poisons and inserting other things so please more scom that's just plain entertainment so I don't know this is my experience it has been pretty wild it has led to just so you know to wrap up uh a cancer survivor who's a San Francisco firefighter and leads the San Francisco firefighters Cancer Foundation went vegan to fight his cancer saw the documentary wrote me one of the thousand emails that I read egotistically I should not have read them but I read them all just because it just my head was getting big and he said a lot of people said this why didn't you do this why didn't you do the other thing you should have done something else and his started with have you ever thought about doing this in firefighters for cancer but the last line was the best and we have money so he said what would it cost to do this in firefighters and I said well even for a small study minimum is half a million dollars says that's what we have he gave me a half a million dollars and then somebody else who was following me on Twitter was mad that I didn't um do the dexas for the twin study and he was talking to that plant Choppers guy and not me on social media saying why didn't Gardener do this oh Gardener didn't have enough money I said why don't you write Gardener so he wrote me he said so you're doing another study and I said yeah and he said you want a half a million dollars so I got a million dollars to do firefighters and then last month I got invited to ha sessions to be part of a panel of from the lab to the living room and to be talking about taking some of the results that we get in our studies and sharing them in different ways other than publishing in a journal and trying to get traditional coverage and uh you know our traditional scientific ways so that's it that's this bizarre story I've had um really makes me think a lot about health communication and scientific work we do so much amazing work here and some of it doesn't get out there this was not intentional for me this is to Total luck total Serendipity but boy it sure has me thinking so with a shout out to all the folks who helped us do this and it's just an incredible team to Netflix or not hell yes I I would do this again in a minute in fact a documentarian has volunteered so far well not volunteered we're going to give him some money but we don't have as much uh to film the firefighters because I mean if twins are adorable aren't firefighter can you imagine the firefighter diet calendar right I don't know I'm thinking I'm thinking how to get those results out there the Netflix part of all this was 6 million doll I thought I got a lot of money with the 500 but the Netflix thing was way more than that and all we have so far for the documentarian for firefighters is $25,000 so it won't be of the same caliber but I really fascinated in this whole idea and would love to take questions for as long as you want to hang out about social media being exposed in this way being critiqued in this way how do you reply how do you skip it how do you not reply how do you not take it personally and so thanks for listening that's what I had to share today we'll start with questions we have a couple hundred online as well but let's start questions in house first H Dr shman thanks for inviting me Kevin this is great I mean I think um you know our our challenge really is getting the message out there it's going to be unfortunately even more important starting January 20th because if we don't have a positive message out there all these other messages are going to be all the public heers so with that like who else who helped you with this I mean that that's the amazing thing how'd you come up with this and who's our resource at the department or at the school to help figure some of these Pathways out I I think all the Stanford comps people are amazing Lisa Kim who does those 92nd things um uh Margarita is really good that we work with so we've actually we were fortunate enough to have some funds to hire a full-time comms person just to work with our nutrition group I don't know how long we'll be able to afford her but she actually worked for Michelle Obama at one point on the let's move program and some other things and she's so good at at picking out which which types of things to do so I didn't do threads I'm trying to do blue sky she does a lot of them for me because I don't have time and she'll send does this look good for this and I still haven't figured out Instagram so she posts on Instagram for me but sharing some of these resources can be really helpful and this knowledge of oh you know uh now she's trying to get me on LinkedIn which ones should you participate in how should you use them I really think there's some great talented people that could be shared around campus and and built more into some of our programs that can help us disseminate in this new way and it it's pretty tiring but it's pretty fun sometimes when it works well it's pretty intoxicating to see that your work is getting farther than you thought it would so yeah I'd love to continue working with others on on that Dr matth here hey Christopher great presentation a lot of things to digest for the audience so you know early on in my career I was getting beat up just like you were and my good friend and colleague and Mentor Rob Caleb told me hey Ken if you're not being criticized you're probably not doing anything worthwhile ah okay so I I think the audience needs to hear that now I know you handle this and in some ways it's a little bit of a sport handling this criticism and trying to decide what you want to tackle and what you don't but give us some insights and what you did to help support your team especially the younger faculty and the trainees that were part of this research that also come under the whole umbrella of the criticism and the social media exposure yep yep yep so uh two of the posts are in our Instagram re two of the post st's our first author of the main paper uh and we worked with all of them and you know we have weekly lab meetings deciding what we're responding to and what we're not responding to I mean one of my quick hints is it's really easy to see how many followers have someone has so somebody has 10 followers and they're giving you crap I'm not going to pay attention but if Peter AA does we have to stop and we have to figure this out because a lot of people are looking at this right now or if you see the same criticism again and again and again then we have to address it so just in lab group meetings uh it's just part of our culture now that we're getting this kind of exposure we we talk about it in weekly lab group meetings and they're all getting pretty good at social media on their own so exposure with less risk for them right now because I I take most of the risk I think hopefully that's a strategy arol somebody else yeah jump I'll jump online real quick to our next week presenter Dr Chen ask how how do you decide whether to deal with onike critics if seem to be done in bad faith some Fair mixed with the ad hominum type of comments how do you decide what you engaged with and what you didn't and and so part of this seriously is do I have time oh my God there's a grant next week screw it I don't have any time I'm not responding to these and there's no real to me there's no real clear Fallout from not dealing with it I do remember one time we got a real serious criticism that seemed horrific and I talked to a couple people and I was pretty stressed out and they said wait three days and see if anyone else is still repeating that no one was repeating it in three days nobody had seen it it hadn't gone viral and I saved all that time not responding to it so part of it is do I have time do I have a good answer right so if I like I was I had a lot of fun responding with that tutorial to the thing about feeding them the different number of calories oh wow I have a really good and I actually turned it into a lesson I said so just so you know in nutrition studies let me share this with everybody and so my followers went up because I was explaining that oh you deliver the same amount of food but you have to report what they're eating oh my God they're not in a metabolic Ward you can't be assured that they're eating at all so good for you for publishing what they reported eating wow they're learning more sort of about the pros and cons of the science along the way there isn't a hard fast rule you have to just go comment by comment and not get sucked into it so really my main rule is I can walk away anytime there a couple times I just walked away for a month or two and I I don't remember any repercussions from dropping it completely because it was draining uh thank you for this incredible lecture um I have a question uh just from the perspective of how inspirational this is I see a lot of younger people in the audience and I'm pretty early in my career as well I'm interested in knowing what advice you would give to people early in their career who are interested in science communication what advice do you have about getting started how to start um letting the public know in terms of social media Etc um about your important work and so I got some really great I got a great comment from a colleague that I don't always work well with um but he's out there and has a lot of followers and he always sticks to the science he said don't don't trash talk them back don't get stuck in Tit for Tat if you go with science and stick with evidence nobody can can get on your case for being petty about this thing and so pretty much all my stuff is just science and I try to be a little funny and a little entertaining like one time I was responding to the um calorie thing and I got a picture of a duck with a gavage going down his throat on Twitter but they wouldn't allow it they stripped it from Twitter so I was like wait I put extra effort into finding the picture of the dock with the Gage so I could make the point and apparently that looked like animal abuse and so they stripped it from Twitter without ask ah I looked really hard for that so part of it is is uh cutting yourself some slack and having fun with it because it it can be fun I'm sure it's not fun for everyone but it can be fun so um just dabble the front part for me was just dabbling and finding that level that I was willing to participate in and not getting too sucked in because it can be a time suck Dr Rogers here hi thanks so much for this wonderful talk I'm an ICU doctor here at Stanford and I think one of the hardest things for us was you know working in covid and seeing that there was such incredible scientific Advance both in terms of our own care in the ICU and vaccine development and at the same time the degree to which we recognize that the public doesn't really care what academic medicine says and he had all these people not trusting it so clearly the kind of work you're doing is really important um and my question for you is you know on the other hand it sounds kind of exhausting and it just sounds like it took tremendous amounts of your time so as academics you know what all of what you you know the alt metrics all that you know other than citations there's not much academic currency for what you're doing and my question for you is should that change clearly from a society perspective I think more of us need to be more out there but the way that we are promoted or you know sort of build our things is much more about jamama Network open and less about the fact that two million people heard about veganism through your study so curious what you think about how academic medicine should change Well you certainly have to talk to leadership to what they think about promotions Etc but to be honest part of it for me is just the joy of my job so it took more time but it was more fun and there was a grant that didn't go in and a paper that didn't go in that wasn't as good as it should have been and it got rejected and I had to resubmit it again but it was more joyful and I was having more fun with science and communicating and meeting people who were having fun talking about science like this part about Making Science fun like Bill NY the Science Guy type stuff um it's a little hard for everybody to channel Bill NY but that that idea that wow the science there's rules and regulations and we have to stick to it and part of that's really dry part of it really exciting and so if you think like that critically it's probably going to help you in lots of other things in life so hey I'm a scientist let's have some fun with science so it's it's finding that balance of how much time you're willing to put in there when some other things do suffer I love the idea of thinking about some of these metrics for promotion and maybe it's not so much you know how many followers you have but is there a way to measure the impact can you is interestingly enough I didn't know the metric that you had the 700 million minutes or what like I don't know how to do that I know that the producer of the film said Netflix wouldn't tell him how many people viewed it for some reason and somebody else told him 50 million people watched it in January so he uses that but he doesn't use the whole year so part of it is these metrics that calms people or really getting really effective at sharing with us to understand what they are okay now this is going to sound really stupid but if you uh if you go back and think of the all metric for the epigenetic biological clock and for the main paper there were different colored circles and the different colored circles was because um the one about epigenetics was strictly traditional media and the one in the main paper was a lot of social media and so you can even tease apart how much traditional media versus social media what countries is it's in how WID is it being disseminated so that would be really interesting if that could be part of it I would hate to be honest I would hate for someone who's not inclined to work that way to somehow be discredited for not doing that what if they're just brilliant they're doing you know Nobel prize winning stuff and they're they're kind of isolated and that's why they're so productive that would be horrible to ding them for that but wouldn't it be great if you could get extra points for doing some of this yeah don't know how to do that but hi um sorry my name is Jenny I'm in the clinical ethics Fellowship here at the center for biomedical ethics cool so yeah it sounded like um a lot of the challenges you encountered and hurdles along the way were like ethical in nature like you alluded to well you explicitly talked about like should I respond should I not respond should I engage not engage and your colleague described some of that as like well this is like a sport like I have to navigate this is like a game so I'm curious like both in the past and looking forward how did you navigate like these ethical conundrums like you mentioned coms but like were there other resources or people you consulted and like what in the future looking forward like what would be your recommendation to people as they're navigating these ethical quandaries yeah so wouldn't be that wouldn't that be great if we went to bioethics on campus like I mean you don't yeah if you're looking for a plug yeah so for people who wouldn't know how to respond or for me for our next response that we're not clear on there were definitely things where I went to this comm's director and said I think we should do this and she said no you should do that I said well I'm the pi I'm the boss we get to oh no I should listen to you because you're comms a third opinion might be from a bioethical point of view you should do this so as more of us do this um it would be great to know what some of the resources are to have someplace that you could just ask a quick question and get some quick support back sounds great yeah but you'd have to have a critical mass of people looking into that to to develop that resource I'd be happy to contribute to developing that resource thanks um to make cucumber tasty we usually salt it sprinkle it with salt we have studies on sodium content and how to make a vegan uh diet tasty or with low sodium ah yeah no it's a great question and it has to do with my new partners in research are chefs I hug a chef all the time now right and so I actually once worked with Google chefs and one of the ideas was not to lower sodium but to come up with new flavor profiles and in the process of coming up with new flavor profiles they use less salt and in the process of that somebody pointed out to them I don't know how many of you cook or have salt in an open container but a standard cook thing is take a three-finger thing of salt and throw it in and throw it in and throw it in and they became much more aware of how often they were putting salt in and they came up with some great herbal Blends that they shared with one another so Google has a lot of cafes and so this was a study with a clinician that deals with hypertension so she initiated this this idea of working with a chef on new flavor profiles that were lower in sodium um so that's one part of the answer and the other part of the answer is lot of kimchi and sauerkraut has salt in it but if you eat that you get fermented food and you get fiber right and so there's a little bit of balance of oh you know I'm going to take I'm GNA take it on and have some of this extra sodium because I'm having more fiber and more fermented food good for my microbiome so part of it is a balance yes we need a lower sodium but there's also sorry one more thing in this Chef group that I work with there's a company that's making Hollow crystals of salt and so from a mouth field perspective when the crystal hits your tongue you get the surface area sensation of that much salt but it's Hollow so it's not delivering as much sodium to your meal so there's a culinary perspective to this there's a messaging perspective this but really I've been having a lot of fun Errol joked in the beginning about deliciousness a term I use all the time now is Unapologetic deliciousness because after many years of working in nutrition studies and saying hey I know this cardboard will lower your cholesterol this cardboard is high in fiber and low in saturated fat and people looked at me like I'm a I'm not eating cardboard but I can get a chef to make an amazing lentil dish that's got some African Middle Eastern whatever background it's delicious and salt is delicious it is so there's ways to use it and not use too much and cut back I don't know if you're familiar with this idea that um Americans eat a whole crap ton of sodium and Campbell Soup once said is it Campbell said we are going to do the right thing and we're going to cut back on sodium we're going to label our cansas low sodium and their sales tanked and they put the sodium right back in it another group lowered it without saying it and got it to 50% of the level and then fed it back to test consumers at the full level they said what did you do to this this is so salty it's disgusting so we actually acclimate to lower and lower sodium levels but we'll only do that if the whole food industry does that at once if only one company does it they're screwed because people will stick with the other ones but we can't a lot of people in in American Heart are working on that sodium level working with culinarians to lower it and it's possible so sorry there were multiple ideas for you Dr Sol is here thanks so much this is fast fasinating um obviously I hope you can see how engaged the audience has been um I have a question going back to this idea of um kind of incentivizing in some way science communication um and in particular on social media social media I I use it a lot it's been very helpful to me in my career and it's a double edged sword yes we see all the time people who get into big trouble for things they have posted on the internet and lose their jobs um I'm wondering what you think about about what kind of support organizations should provide in terms of backing people up for um things they may have said on social media because on the one side I think if you're going to say yes we want our faculty for example to be on social media and to put their science out there then I think we we have to support them in assuming the risk that that comes with um but I'm curious what you think about that and what that support might look like yeah that's a great question to end on and we do need to end in a minute to respect everybody's time early on in Twitter I said something nasty about a colleague and I didn't have very many followers but my division Chief approached me a year later and said something has surfaced where you said something not very appropriate at all about someone on campus this is not trivial I said okay and then I listened to the other guy that just said just do science just do evidence-based science this idea of having resources whether it's bioethics or whether it's someone who's just helped you understand social media it needs to be fun and engaging and sometimes a little Saucy helps it to be engaging but it doesn't have to be disrespectful or trash talking so finding that balance for people who are interested I mean part of it is reading through social media yourself and saying wow that is offensive that is Bland and boring that's that's got my attention there is a middle ground there and it takes some practice so maybe collectively we can start working on it together thanks for your time there's a comment on here uh you consider getting chanting chadum on board for your firefighter stud thank you okay can I ask one quick one there's a lot of questions online about this how does this affected your diet if you don't mind sharing so I've been a vegan for 40 years so I was pretty much just studying what I do for the most part my most recent changes um I have avocado toast with kimchi after working with the sonnenbergs because they're they got me into fermented food and the microbiome and one last comment about the firefighters it turns out that there is a Stanford Graduate it firefighter woman who is an identical twin who we hope will be in the documentary whose twin sister was one of the Baywatch lifeguards are we ready or are we ready let's do firefighters thank you I think we can end on that thank you so much the proceeding program is copyrighted by the Board of Trustees of the Leland Stanford Jr University please visit us at med.stanford.edu

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

"Communicating What to Eat – To Netflix or Not" | 11 December 2024