# Lec 4 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cK1og4ElKE
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/-cK1og4ElKE

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 7:34 — Chapter 2 (7:34)
- 15:11 — Chapter 3 (15:11)
- 19:03 — Chapter 4 (19:03)
- 27:16 — Chapter 5 (27:16)
- 34:35 — Chapter 6 (34:35)
- 42:33 — Chapter 7 (42:33)
- 50:18 — Chapter 8 (50:18)
- 53:08 — Chapter 9 (53:08)
- 1:01:41 — Chapter 10 (61:41)
- 1:09:21 — Chapter 11 (69:21)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit mitop courseware at

**[0:28]:** ocw.mit.edu good afternoon so so in the last lecture we talked about uh you know the remarkable human brain and how owers our thoughts our feelings our desires our actions in the world and how we began to understand it remarkable complexity or at least Gras something of its complexity how we understand uh the essential for things like moral character and judgments the case of phineous gauge to produce language to speak our feelings and thoughts uh that's blocked in a patient like brokus patient with with brokus aasia we talked about the fact that split brain patients show us not only that the left and right hemispheres of the human brain uh mediate separate uh mental abilities but that they also seem to have almost independent forms of Consciousness or and don't have to be aware of one another and so my focus today is to say uh we really looked at we learned from very unusual clinical

**[1:23]:** cases and I'm going to focus today on tools we have to study the typical human brain uh and and what what what is it that we can do to understand how your brain in you know without having a hemispherectomy or a big stroke how does it operate and what are the principles of human brain function that give rise to the human mind so so what is the ways we can learn about the human brain and one thing we can't do is what animal researchers can do right that we can't literally go inside the brain except in rare very rare clinical situations I'll talk about them but that's a rare source of evidence so there's a million ways in which trying to understand which part of the brain does which part of the mind and we talked about uh the fact that you know phenology was a sort of a big misstep in assigning mental life

**[2:08]:** the functions of mental life to different parts of the brain and so we hope we can do a bit better than that and I'm going to review with you today some of the core methods and there's a number of them uh uh for studing human brain the reason there's a number is none of them get are sort of the magic answer all of them are limited in their own ways and we sort of need all of them uh to begin to grasp how your brain makes your mind there's three huge ways in which we know how the human brain uh is organized uh lesions injuries to the brain stimulation when you're allowed to stimulate the brain rarer but we'll talk about that and the most common the one you see all the times in books and magazines uh recording functional MRI EEG methods where we record brain activity and try to understand how that relates

**[2:54]:** to the life of the human mind and so we're going to go through these things a little bit and you know show you how they applied in some ways that I hope that that you'll find interesting uh we'll come back to many of these things as we go through the semester and as we talk about aging or Child Development or personality or other topics social cognition we'll come we'll use these tools to understand the brain bases of those kinds of aspects of our mental lives so what's a big injury you can have you can have a stroke where a where tissue in the brain no longer receives its vascular Supply that it depends on so greatly and a lot of different things like hypoxia lack of oxy o the brain is very sensitive to oxygen tumors can grow you can have degenerative disorders like Alzheimer's huntingtons Parkinson's and others epilepsy so there's lots of different

**[3:40]:** ways in which you can end up with brain injury and ultimately neuronal death so what's the strength of this form of evidence well first of all it's causal we've talked about the difference between causal and correlational sources of evidence causal ones being more powerful for scientific explanation a certain part of the brain is injured and you no longer can speak you you change your character you no longer can make memories we're pretty sure that part of the brain in some way is required or causal for that part of your mental life to operate the deficits you see following brain injuries can be amazing we talked about Phineas guge changing his character unable to produce language unable to make new memories we'll talk a little bit about patients with prosia it's a good big word to go home on spring break and if your parents ask you what have you learned about you say prosia right

**[4:27]:** that just means a deficit in recognizing faces patients with prosia will be unable to recognize their own spouse by their face they'll recognize it by their voice by their physical movements but not by their face we learn amazing uh things about the brain that you know until it happens we didn't know they could happen what people like to call counterintuitive so we we'll talk later in the course in a couple times about blindsight patients who say I see nothing but their behavior shows some part of their brain sees something we'll talk about category specific deficits where patients all of a sudden can no longer name living things but they can name non-living things okay so you wouldn't have thought of that if you didn't see that and we get separations in the brain between different things we talked about the difference between the left hemisphere being important for local features the right for Global the

**[5:14]:** left thinking in terms of functional things in the world the right in terms of appearances we talked about that already we'll talk about other things that the hippocampus is important for knowing that knowing a piece of information but the basil gangle is important for learning how to do things mental skills and physical skills we'll come back to all of those so it gives us this way to organize things so much of our most solid understanding of the human brain still comes from the history of Neurology and lesions but what are its limitations first brain injuries you know don't follow anatomical boundaries they sort of cross over things depending on the injury so they're not going to selectively damage one part of the brain and not touch an adjacent one that could be doing something different people can be variable in the response nearby systems if you you have two things in the brain that are

**[6:01]:** next door to one another do quite different things injuries are likely to injure them both and you will wrongly conclude have a wrong conclusion about the architecture of the human brain um when we test a patient and ask them to do things after a brain injury we don't really test the part of the brain that's not there we really test the part of the brain that is there people do the best they can so uh uh there's secondary degeneration to an injury there's recovery from an injury there's compensation from an injury when you test a patient with a brain injury you're testing what the rest of the brain can do in the absence of one of its uh part one of its Companions and finally can offer limited views of normal brain function let me pick one and we'll come back to this in the course we're very interested in variation in people individuality what's

**[6:47]:** the Neurology of individuality that's very hard to study in lesion cases because we don't see enough of a lesion we don't have enough Phineas gauges to ask would that injury look different if you uh grew up in one culture or another if you uh were outgoing versus shy those kinds of things are very hard to answer uh uh you know patient by patient but we can test large groups of people with imaging and ask what is the influence of culture on your brain organization what's the influence of Personality on how your brain's organized and you'll see later on in the semester evidence about those sorts of things so let's go back to Paul broka uh the the neurologist who you know gave the name to brokas area because he saw a patient like this like C that this patient had a big injury in this area and could no longer speak and every course you

**[7:34]:** ever take about the brain almost will include a discussion about broke his area so I'm going to uh warp your world in a very narrow way but maybe a shocking way and tell you we don't even know how to think about brok his area once we get more scientific than that okay so because this is MIT so we're willing to tell the truth okay so uh some years later Nina droners did the following thing she studied a large group of patients who are had brokas Aphasia by behavior that is uh they you know had trouble speaking but their comprehension was pretty good and then she made maps of their injuries and she overlaid those maps and she said who has brokos aasia and if you have brokos aasia what's the one part of the brain that every patient with brocus aasia has damaged to because these patients what you see in these Maps is you

**[8:23]:** know some patients have damage here or here or here but you line them all up and you say what's the one spot that you have to have injured to have brokas Aphasia and it's not this area that you saw in the picture it's this area in yellow an area called the uh precentral gyrus of the insula the insula is a fascinating mysterious little structure you have one on the left and one on the right that runs along from the temporal lobe up to the frontal cortex uh just a couple years ago there was a paper uh reporting that patients who had strok in posteri insula instantly gave us up smoking and never wanted to smoke again there's huge research efforts to help people quit smoking is because it's such a difficult health problem okay these patients this not nobody's doing insul lesions to help people stop smoking okay but it just stopped their smoking and

**[9:10]:** their desire to smoke just like that uh this now more towards the front of the brain this is not what anybody in a book or a course will tell you who broke his area that's out here but it turns out this is the hot spot and you could say well what about the original patient so kind of creatively Nina droners went back and they did an MRI of the brain of the deceased original broas AIC patient okay they they still had his brain they put it in a scanner and they ran an structural MRI and what they found was sure enough he had damaged way inside the the exterior limit of his damage as well as in white matter that connects to it so even now Imaging evidence lets us ReDiscover what is the true main basis of your ability to speak or its vulnerability to injury and it turns out not to be exactly

**[9:57]:** what broka was thought it was see he saw a big lesion and he said this is the part that matters it turns out as far as we understand it's a slightly different part that he thought was just at the edge and not important so we we can get better even going back 150 years of Imaging a brain we don't have many of those brains around um stimulation so you like to go in the brain and stimulate people who do animal work will go in and stimulate a neuron and see what happens uh it's rare you you only get in to the patient's brain when they have something when they have a Neurosurgical procedure and they're considering a rection or removal of tissue you can also do recordings by putting grids on top of those brains um and Penfield did famous studies for patients with epilepsy who uh you know where he would stimulate and map

**[10:39]:** things it contributed a lot to our thinking about the brain but that's a a rare source of evidence as you can imagine another one that's much more common there's one of these devices down the street uh in building 46 is transcranial magnetic stimulation or TMS so this is one in which people are allowed ethically and responsibly to give you a virtual lesion for a few moments moments okay uh if you volunteer to do so so they put a uh some sort of wire there's different configurations uh over your head and a targeted location it generates a magnetic field that passes through the skull and induces a current and what happens is the current drives lots of neurons to fire turns out this is kind of interesting if all your neurons are firing at the same moment in one sense it's as if none of them work because there's no information right there's a lot of

**[11:25]:** different ways you could think about that but for example if if on your uh three 100 Channel television you had all the channels on simultaneously on the same screen it wouldn't be very easy to watch okay something like that all the neurons firing is pretty much wipes out the function of that area people do you know do feel a little bit of a physical sensation uh if you're prone to epilepsy it's not a good idea to try this so it does require some careful supervision experimentally but you can do this with healthy people and if for example you do it on this side of the motor cortex people will twitch or say they felt somebody touch them nobody touched them but the the part of their brain that codes for touch just got turned on if you put it on the occipital cortex visual cortex and you turn it on at a certain moment you

**[12:07]:** can put a word up and a word down and the person will say they saw nothing you'll make them functionally cortically blind for a few moments okay so people have done experiments like this uh to suppress activity to enhance activity sometimes it makes people even faster like naming pictures and it's also been used uh there's still experimental studies of whether it can be helpful for treatments of Neuropsychiatric disorders so it's noninvasive in a sense of you're not going literally inside uh you have a causal thing because you're for turning the brain on or off um it's not very well targeted it can't go into subcortical areas but it's a very interesting tool so let's talk about recording brain structure for a moment so it's really important to separate this Concepts between recording structure which is a picture of anatomy or function which is a picture of physiology so there's old ones angiography and things like

**[12:58]:** that that I'll show you too computed tomography and Mr and a really cool measure called diffusion tensor Imaging and then there's functional measures and we'll talk about those EEG uh pad fmri Meg so here's some different images you can get from the brain so here's what a brain would look like roughly speaking uh actually this is a postmortem brain this is a cut brain here's the front here's the back it's it's if if a brain was open in front of you this is what you would see so here's an MRI magnetic resonance imaging and it's pretty good you can and I'll show you some more pictures in in showing you lots of information not as good as if you were in there but pretty good here's a CT sced computed tomography you know it's not as good it's more blurry and this thing that looks really sad right look like like you know get your

**[13:40]:** camera Focus right that's actually the quality of the picture that we see that underlies maybe the most widely used tool these days for understanding the human mind and brain functional magnetic resonance imaging it's a very smudgy picture but it has some really interesting properties so here's the kind of thing you go into for an MRI both structural or functional have some of you have almost certainly been participants in research or experiments or studies stick up your hand if you have just have oh a lot of you okay so you'll you'll speak up on this uh uh is it quiet or noisy it's super noisy okay so uh uh uh you know so you have to have ear plugs in and if you're doing H this and this is why people doing experiments with functional MRI want to do visual studies because auditory wants are tricky so Tyler or heti likes auditory stuff it's 10 times

**[14:25]:** harder to pull off those experiments so everybody tries to do visual stuff so you don't have the noise problem but you get some beautiful pictures so here's here's computed tomography and here's an MRI structural scan front of the brain the ventricles here's basil ganglia so you could see that with the MRI beautifully you can see the cortical the difference between white and gray matter I'm always impressed that the gray matter is just this thin ribbon I mean cortex really means bark it's just like the bark on our tree right and when you look at the brain this way look at how much white matter there is here's your frontal cortex look at all all that white matter and then this thin cortical mantle or Ribbon or bark that's you know what we think of as a smarts of language and social planning and things like that so that's a structural picture Okay um and then

**[15:11]:** these pictures are sort of fun you see them let's see this is uh uh just recorded down the street we're going to fly through your brain okay here we go

**[15:27]:** maybe

**[15:31]:** from one ear to the

**[15:35]:** other and you get amazing resolution it's not the same thing like being inside the brain there's things that you don't see we know that uh but you see a lot Isn't that cool so um let's examine you know what you can see now that we we used to have to wait only about 40 years ago you would have to have a person die to see this so this is a patient with Huntington disease we'll come back and talk about that that disorder here's a healthy person top of the brain this is a Cate here part of the basil ganglia and you can see in a patient who's passed away that part of the brain is completely withered away in Huntington's disease um you would have to wait till a person passed away to see something like that but with modern Imaging here's a healthy person top of the brain again lining the ventricles as the

**[16:19]:** codage and here in a living Huntington's patients you can see the great withering of the way some of Cortex 2 in later stages of the disease but especially in the basil ganglia here's a healthy older person about 70 years of age top of the brain bottom of the brain the ventricles uh here's on the left and the right of the hippocampus the structure we'll talk about without which you cannot learn any new fact or remember any event in your life okay any new event right so powerful for almost every sense of learning and look what happens in that structure in a same aged patient with with Alzheimer's disease it's virtually gone it's greatly withered uh you see it's much wider here because this tissue is greatly shrunk in the Alzheimer's patient so we can see these kinds of changes in living people um uh both for research purposes and clinical purposes uh here's one that's

**[17:12]:** more cheerful and uh more reflecting your experience so here are studies of uh brain changes from age four to 21 so they follow people a large number of people at NIH from Age 4 to 21 and what this shows is this color coding is the thickness of the quartz and you might imagine that as you get older and smarter and go through grade school and middle school and high school and MIT College and as you head towards grad school your brain will get thicker and thicker with cortex it's exactly the opposite ever since you were about five years old you've been shedding neurons by the millions okay by them and connections among them by the trillions and you're still going to do that until you're probably about 22 or 23 then you Peak and you decline and become faculty members all right all right all right okay so uh but that's kind of really interesting

**[18:03]:** we'll come back to this that what happens as your brain gets smart experienced knowledgeable all the differences between you now if you're eight 17 18 19 20 and when you were four it all goes with your cortex Getting Thinner um and we'll come back to that and how people think about that but let's see if I can get this next movie to run so there's also an ordering and we'll come back to this but I want to show you this movie so the more blue you are the thinner you are are the more advanced you are in terms of ultimate young adult development here's visual cortex Vision coming in this is a somato motor cortex how you feel your body and how you move your uh self and what you see is as you go from Age 4 to 21 the blue spreads that spreading is your brain maturing in higher thought areas okay so

**[18:52]:** if we're going to review your life on average right now okay here you go

**[19:03]:** and now you're ready to graduate okay all right I it's kind of a Amazing Story fantastic brain changes that move you from every what you could do and not do at four to what you can do and not do at age 21 and you know we couldn't see these things we couldn't begin to see these things until just a few years ago in any scientific sense I mean all these things were like miraculous sources of information um so let let's pick a another thing and we'll tie it to schoolwork and then here's here's the structure we said the hippocampus so important for the formation of new memories uh on an everyday basis everything that's important and that you learn so here's a fun study they took and let's and we as you hear it think about it scientific limitation but it's fun you know as students to think about they looked at students in in

**[19:48]:** medical school uh in Germany um they looked at the a measure of anatomic thickness of the hippocampus uh before and after they studied like crazy for a huge exam okay over some number of periods so here's the before picture uh uh and the after this is the difference between the two sorry and what they're showing you is that as you study your hippocampus got thicker as you crammed for your test right so you know will there be a day where instead of having to give you tests we could just measure the thickness of your hippocampus and know how much you studied and you could just you zoom in and out of a scanner I don't know but one cool thing about it is it's showing you that we can see structural changes not just on a giant scale from from when you're 4 to 21 but from some number of months of experience we can

**[20:32]:** see a physical change in your brain now that's trivial for animal researchers they can show amazing things in seconds okay but to see the human brain physically changing so let's take look at another one uh slightly more controlled we'll look at two more examples um London taxi cab drivers now uh if you've traveled in various cities and gone in various uh taxis you may have had better and worse experiences whether the taxi driver knows where he or she is going exactly exactly London is famous for having a very high code taxi drivers have to take big exams to uh get their official taxi license okay so they they they they they they they create a very demanding thing and what they asked is the hippocampus if you learn lots of roots if you know tons of roots in London what happens to the hippocampus is it's memorizing all these spal roots and when they saw

**[21:19]:** the taxi drivers have a bigger hippocampi and the long and the longer uh they drove the bigger it was so is this a causal or correlational source of evidence it's correlational right you know so let's start with this they have bigger hippocampi and now now maybe that's simply because what maybe somebody who's an awesome hippocampus is ready to go to be a taxi driver right maybe they pass the test they said I'm an awesome ta and the one who got lost all the time was driving to the wrong airport and stuff small hippoc campus never became a taxi driver right so now the size of the hippoc campus is the cause of your success not the consequence because the longer you drove the bigger it got that kind of goes with that you know that but we could do they could you could do a causal experiment this way they taught people to juggle three

**[22:07]:** balls they practiced every day for three months three months juggling every day what you see in yellow are parts of the brain that's a statistical you know map parts of the brain that significantly got thicker in three months of practice so they could compare directly before and after it's a causal experiment uh and these are areas that are involved in visual motion and it makes sense that areas involved in visual motion would somehow change but the fact that we can see three months of experience change the structure of your brain is kind of remarkable and a way that we can measure and scientifically scrutinize you might be curious if you did three months of this and you were an pretty good juggler you're impressing your friends at parties uh your brain scan is different right uh what do you think happened they followed these people up after the juggling requirement stopped they kind of sto

**[22:57]:** most of to the people they went back they were too busy they would show off here and there but that was it they measured their brains again about 6 months later and this change was gone it came in and it went out with the activity okay it's activity dependent so depending on what you do you could think about every activity you mental and physical that you do is constantly slightly changing your brain and if you do a lot of it you're fundamentally changing it like in these individuals but if you stop doing it you go right back to where you were because you're going to be doing something else and another fun measure um uh that's kind of beautiful and intriguing is diffusion tensor Imaging now everything T we've talked about so far has been gray matter of the brain the neurons and and the circuits they form we're going to turn to white matter

**[23:39]:** which is the melinated axons that are the super uh conducting sort of uh highways of the of the brain and what diffusion tensor Imaging does it shows you something about the organization of that white matter measuring directly the movement of H water at very very tiny distances so this is a cross-section of a melinated nerve fiber those are the fibers that are covered with white matter that have to go some distance and the milin protects the quality and speed of that signal through your brain and you can see at the level of if you're a tiny tiny drop of water or smaller than that this is a pretty big bump in the road okay so imagine you're a little drop of water moving a little bit and you bump up against the milein you go oh can't go that way and you go back this way and you go with the flow you go parallel

**[24:27]:** with the mland it's hard to cross it at that microscopic scale but we can measure that movement in areas uh where it's highly constrained the the anisotropy of the water here's cerebral spinal fluid things can go anywhere here's where there's a lot of white matter and the water tends to flow along parallel with the white matter just for physical reasons it can't cross it over and here for example is a a statistical map comparing this measure of white matter organization between adults who either in their childhood had a diagnosis of Dyslexia reading was difficult for these individuals or people who had typical reading development were reading was you know you learned to read and it wasn't particularly difficult and you can see that in this area around the temporal parietal cortex there's a significant difference but when we look we can do one more thing these are reading scores this way this is the measure

**[25:20]:** of the white matter organization from the diffusion tense or Imaging each of these is an individual person now so the open Dots are the people who had typical reading development the filled dots are the people who had uh uh poor development and you can see it's pretty continuous even in the people with the Open Circles who never had a problem the better they read the more the organization is here okay so this is not just a difference between good and bad readers it's a difference between people who read are really good readers and medium readers and poor readers right continuous so now cause or effect where for those of you who had three who had awesome milin were going reading is a snap I love the stuff you know where's war in peace Mom right okay or or were you like the jugglers and you were ex you were reading a lot and you were exercising this part of the brain and you altered its physical structure and the answer is we don't know how could we know how could we know if you

**[26:23]:** if you were a scientists and were given a pot of money to do this how could you know well yeah the entire life of multiple people lives yeah do a longitudinal study and start like before people read right and you could see is it different then you know are the people are we born to be big readers or by being big readers do we alter the the con the architecture of our brain you know what's the effort and what's the talent or what's the predisposition at Birth and what's the time you put in in creating this part and we don't know that yet yet but you know we have a place to look at that and then you can create these kinds of beautiful pictures and I'll say a word about this uh so this is an individual person's white matter organization so we could take this picture of you or anybody you know who wants to go in a scanner um and what you what's colorcoded are in blue are fibers that are

**[27:16]:** running up or down we can't tell whether the fibers which direction they're going kind of but we we can tell their their orientations up and down left and right in red up and down in blue and green is front to back let's see pretty cool huh I can tell you that I'll say a word about

**[27:39]:** this should we do that again okay I like it but I work in this area so I mean this is fantastic this is an individual person's white matter organization I mean you you know as information is Flowing around in your mind here's the path that it's flowing around in as you just do anything that's interesting in your in your feelings or thoughts it's fantastic I can tell you that um uh the the algorithms that are used to create these Maps there's some debate about the better ones okay so the last steps of this are a bit debated in a bit uh depending on the uh how cool you are as a as a visual engineer uh but there's a lot of things that's right about diffusion tensor Imaging so uh it's it's there's a lot of things I write about it um okay so function so uh you know most of all we're interested in

**[28:32]:** structure not just for itself but how it makes your mind do the things you can do and when we think about different functional measures that are available to neuroscientists or psychologists you know we often think in two Dimensions spatial resolution and temporal resolution how precise are we where we are and you know what's the time scale that we're measuring in you know millisecond are we averaging over uh many seconds many hours we know Al operations roughly speaking occur at the millisecond level or maybe 10 milliseconds it's there's no answer to that but we know lots of things happen that fast in the mind so uh as you look at this here you can see that for example if you're in animal work looking at size you can get down to the synapse or the dendrite we can't touch that in humans we can't touch that cellular stuff and it's not until we get up to

**[29:20]:** here you know which is like big patches of the brain that we can state things about people that's why it's all always going to be fundamental in Neuroscience to S link the human work to the animal work because we can't get to the neurons or anything like that in a person almost ever all right that has to come from animal work where you can do invasive work so we have to look at pretty big patches of the human brain how about time well we can get down to milliseconds in time uh in the human brain uh functional things like pet MRI are here in the order of multiple seconds I'll come back to this but you can see all these things have strengths now you don't always want to be down to a single synapse it's not clear that we would understand much of the organization brain at the level of a synapse okay there's

**[30:04]:** things happening synapse but a thing like knowledge or love or something like that probably we can study uh at the level of the synapse effectively yet bigger units are probably more interpretable so here's a fun one eegs electroencephalography so they put on your head some sort of a cap with electrodes uh and they measure uh changes in electrical activity that are being picked up through the skull um and there's you're picking up huge changes in hundreds of thousands of neurons but you're able to do it millisecond by millisecond at the speed of thought and the same kind of signals roughly used for E the same electrical signal for EEG and Erp that evoke response potentials with EEG uh you just watch it over time so you can see these different uh rhythms that go with a person in coma or deep sleep asleep drowsy relaxed you can see these sort of characteristic uh rhythms that

**[30:56]:** people can measure if you do an experiment you can time lock these you know Moment by moment to some stimulus or task you give the person so here we're going to time lock these and then you get a thing like this that says here's a response you know maybe the first moment after I see a word or the second moment after I see a word or something like that so you can time lock large electrical responses in the brain uh and you get some studies like this and we'll come back to this but here's here's a fun one in language for example you read a sentence like you see it it was his first day at work okay that's the Baseline condition in purple not a particularly exciting sentence okay although your first day at work is actually pretty interesting but now to read the sentence this right how about this one he spread the

**[31:39]:** warm bread with socks you go socks I'm shocked that makes no sense at all right what happens is you read it here's a a broken Blue Line you go whoa and that's called the N400 okay but that's kind of cool you know that's 400 milliseconds after you saw that word you said I get it socks but it doesn't make sense Okay so you're violating uh uh semantics or and then they have to do a control experiment and a lot of psychology and in a course like this we can't devote enough time to this but I can tell you high quality research has in Psychology has high quality thoughtfulness like in any other field you could say well maybe it's not the word socks that's bothering you maybe it's just because it's odd just like I'm weird it's like a weirded out signal okay it's a weirded out signal so they do they do this she

**[32:23]:** put on her high heeled shoes but they put shoes in big print that you didn't expect okay so now you're weirded out but it makes sense so what happens in your mind you have a very different response here so here the meaning is wrong here the size is wrong and so you can read a person's mind in this sense millisecond by millisecond as they understand something like a sentence you can do it with babies which is pretty cute okay and and Incredibly exciting too right uh so we can measure in the millisecond it's very lots of people can take doing it it's relatively inexpensive what's why don't we just run around and do that and we do that at MIT and lots of places do this too well it spatial resolution is really problematic we don't know where in the brain the signals are really coming from we know where the electrode is on the

**[33:06]:** head but that's picking up a lot of stuff below it we don't know where in the brain is coming from you know the way I think about it a little bit imagine you went to a football game and you were on the outside of the stadium and you heard big cheering on the side that you knew was MIT you might figured something good happen to MIT then you hear big cheering on the side where the Caltech teams you know sitting and there's fans right it be usual Rose Bowl uh and uh uh and uh and you know you might fig something good happened at Caltech but you don't really know exactly what happened and exactly where it happened right um so we don't know where the signals are coming from uh in a very precise way there's another method that's sort of very intriguing too and we're just installing it at MIT and you can

**[33:47]:** be amongst the first generation of participants if you so choose to be uh this is called magnetoencephalography uh active neurons produce small magnetic fields uh you can use a superconducting quantum uh device to measure that's tiny tiny changes in the magnetic field that are secondary to the neurons firing uh these signals are are problematic to measure because they're estimated to be 100 million times smaller than the Earth's magnetic field the and all these measures we have of human brain function all of them the signal is terrible compared to the noise it's terrible compared to the Noise Okay and Meg might be the worst okay there's a number of places that installed Meg uh and um had to take it out because the local traffic on the road was too big relative to the difference between the earth magnetic field and the signal they get signal to noise is terrible in every non-invasive human brain measure

**[34:35]:** we have uh but you get something beautiful now any mental thought we have of any interest of any kind we pretty much understand to be the property not of a single part of the brain doing its thing but a remarkable concert of different parts of your brain uh playing or interacting with one another okay it's a symphony orchestra doing anything interesting in in the human mind and Meg can show that beautifully so here's an individual structural MRI that's been inflated theyve sort of blown it out like a balloon okay so it's sort of easy to look at and what you're going to see now from Dale and hren is an Meg measurement millisecond by millisecond of what your brain does roughly speaking when you read a single word okay here we go see back and forth back and forth there's all this interaction feeding forward from when you see it feeding backward from parts of your brain say I think I know what it is let's double check okay back and

**[35:32]:** forth back and forth let me do it one more time because I think it's just so cool okay anything interesting that your brain does is a incredibly complicated millisecond by millisecond uh interaction between large scale brain networks so here we go again reading a single word comes arrives in the back of the brain fronts thinking about back front back front back front we read the word okay all right uh you know so uh it's just amazing and I me G you know is one of the better measures for us to see this time-based way in which your mind accomplishes things um very it's very the strength are is has great temporal resolution non-invasive spatial resolution is maybe better than the EG or perhaps better not as good as fmri will come to that um and it only can measure neurons in the cortex that are parallel to the skull so we can't see lots of

**[36:22]:** things like subcortical structures like the hippocampus okay so now we're moving to the measures that you most often see but these other ones are all help us a lot and they they're all derived from the following things sadly for pet or fmri the most widely used studies to understand how your mind works uh we can't interrogate the neurons that compute your mind we can't they're off bounds to us okay the other measures you just saw are based on neurons what we have to do is we have to look for gossipy neighbors that is the vasculature that surrounds and supports the neurons that compute the mind and and we know that the neurons require oxygen and glucose uh metabolically to do their work right their cellular life and the Brain area is active there's increased blood flow and increased energy supplies that come to that so it's all the sort of inference by the secondary consequence

**[37:10]:** of neurons doing their business so the brain is about three and a half pounds is about 2% of your total body mass so it's has a tenfold 20% extra demand of body oxygen your brain cries out for oxygen at every moment so 2% of your body but 20% of the oxygen demand and it's so sensitive that only 10 minutes of loss of oxygen will can often cause irreversible brain damage especially in structures like the hippocampus now the first discovery uh uh that blood changes that are H going with brain changes blood changes that are the sort of The Echoes if you will the secondary consequence can be measured was is low Tech compared to our current machines uh this is work from Angelo moso in the late 188s and he saw a patient who had a unusual sort of malformation so he had almost no skull here okay and he put on it something that

**[38:04]:** measured the pressure there and he know and he also measured and what's shown here in in red is this pressure and as a control thing that's pretty clever he uh measured uh pulses of blood in the forearm so those are in in in h blue okay that's the control that's not just blood everywhere and what he did is the guy sitting there nothing happening and he noticed that when the church bells rang nearby boom this device picked up increased pressure over this part of the head that's pretty cool right it's it has to be blood it's not neurons okay it's blood okay uh but now he has the signature of mental life in your brain the blood consequence of a thought which is I hear the church then he asked the guy does it have to be something that you hear he says did you make your prayers today your AA Maria again nothing happening

**[38:53]:** peripherally but boom as he gives his answer a change and blood pressure there or do math problem boom a change there okay so all of a sudden blood changes over a part of the brain become the witness to that part of the brain supporting the mental operations to do that task and here's a pet studies the first way positron emission tomography which basically used measure local brain activity by looking at the consequences of of photons uh disintegrating as they're measured in this sort of a device and here's the way they use this ask to discover which parts to map the neural organization of the human mind so I need somebody who's comfortable who's willing to do a task at their seat uh and it's just going to be reading words or coming up with words okay thanks okay um here you go ready look at that in our field we call that fixation you're just

**[39:45]:** looking okay just looking all right good job okay ready for something else all right now just look at these things okay you see the words the technical word is reading okay right all right now imagine we did one more thing with you and actually if you were in a pet scanner here's what would happen if you're in a pet scanner you'd be sitting down there like that there'd be a physician you know in a lab coat like this there' be a physicist in the basement making up um uh some sort of a tracer they're going to inject into you every every round of this okay uh that and because that's where they need to S track this and it comes up an elevator and people take turns running down the hall with it because it has a pretty short halflife the shortness of its halflife is what makes it you able to do these multiple

**[40:26]:** measures okay so it's a pretty big deal process and in fact the the one or two pet sessions I ever attended you would rotate who would run down the field with a radio active substance so you share the radioactive substance okay uh so anyway so you've done that okay so now you've done that and you feel like that's I'm doing pretty good so now they come and they say are you ready for another injection they have something a catheter running into your arm and they inject you again here comes the radioactive stuff the oxy okay and uh now they're going to ask you to read the words aloud present it one at a time oops but why don't you just read them aloud one at time time go ahead okay and they say thank you very much and we're going to do one more injection if that's okay with you of radioactive substance okay uh

**[41:05]:** and now we're gon to ask you do one thing and this this is harder as you see each word tell us a verb that describes what you might do with that object what a person might do so go ahead for Rose tell usell perfect okay yeah I can tell you that in the experiment they present a lot of these and a lot of subjects after a while just go use use use use okay okay hold hold hold hold all right but you did a good job okay so U so here's what they say this is just looking at something this is looking at a word which is reading now don't forget we're the only species uh that ever read okay uh reading is been around in our culture only for about 700 years on any scale and reading is an incredible thing to read a word correctly and you saw the whole brain flicker to get it right uh

**[41:50]:** but now you're going to say the word in the next condition so you're not just looking at the word but you're also saying it and now now finally you're not only saying a word and looking at it but you're thinking about it to come up with smell or pet right so they say what we're going to do is we're going to do a hierarchy of your mind just looking reading reading and talking reading and talking and thinking and by comparing those different conditions we'll subtract them against each other and pull out the part of your mind that sees a word that speaks a word and that thinks about a word and we'll separate those out in the brain um so basically the subtraction method so when we compare looking at fixation versus looking at words we'll see what part of your brain discovers that it's a word knows how to read words looking at words

**[42:33]:** versus repeating them we'll discover the basis of speech uh speaking a word versus coming up with the verb thinking about stuff their meaning and and coming up with an answer so again the idea is if you're saying something like you know pet for the cat you're doing all these things or you might just be reading it aloud and we'll subtract them now in both these conditions here you saw a word and read it here you saw a word and came up and produced a verb you subtract these two and you end up with an statistical image like this this is not a raw image of blood all these figures you ever see those are statistics of areas that differed by some statistical Criterion between one condition another they're all statistics they're not blood or raw blood that underlies it but what you see is a

**[43:23]:** statistic and here's the statistic now in both of these cases you saw the word and in this case you simply read it in this case you read it in your head and you came up with a verb what why don't we see anything back here why don't we see the seeing of the word even though the seeing occurred in both conditions why don't we why isn't it visible in this brain picture because it's been subtracted out okay so always in these brain Imaging experiments for reasons I'm about to tell you almost always have to do some kind of subtraction and I'll tell you why okay but that's a subraction is very big because what you subtract out that's the heart of the experiment okay uh your decision about what's a legitimate subtraction and the reason we have to do it is this look at these two things here's one condition and here's the other condition

**[44:09]:** do you see that they look pretty similar okay again signal to noise your brain is busy all the time okay now we ask you to do something and see the difference and the difference is very tiny by the way we measured it's not tiny mentally it's not tiny in terms of the consequences for civilization in the world okay it's tiny because of the weird way we have to measure it all right so uh I can tell you that if if you if I put on an optimal checker board that psychophysicists have said this is super this turns on your visual cortex I'll get about a three to 5% change in your brain signal if if you wave your arm I can get three to 5% signal change in your cortex here if I ask you to do everything between seeing something and moving your lips or hand everything about thought emotion memory desire motivation everything

**[45:00]:** that that's big in our life we'll get something like a tenth of one% of a signal change a tenth of 1% of a signal change okay so is that yeah Tyler's like oh yeah because you know that means you have to test a lot of subjects and work 40 years on your PhD right uh so uhh so we have to do that subtraction because if we just take a picture of what's going on in your head it's so much that we can't tell what's going on at all and if we have you do something that's pretty big like seeing like a really provocative picture we'll just get a tenth of 1% of a signal change so we have to do the subtraction to have a hint and then we do one other weird thing we don't have to but we often do it we want to average people to make some general statement about Humanity

**[45:37]:** as far as we can do it based on the 10 MIT students we test okay uh and so we scrunch everybody's brain into a common space everybody's brain is a little bit different like their bodies are a little bit different we scrunch everybody to line them all up so we have a common physical space so by the time you see this picture it's a statistic on an average of people in most cases but you get an amazing story which up until these pictures uh the some years you know about uh now the late 1980s it was unimaginable that you could go inside a living person's brain and see what it is that allows you to hear a word in auditory cortex to see a word in visual cortex to move your mouth to speak or to think what's a verb that goes with that word okay unimaginable you know at your okay now I have

**[46:25]:** to do that quick math but you'll help me out what year was were you born in 82 92 I know my age at all Blends believe me 92 okay so just a year or two before you were born this was uh five years before you were unimaginable that you could see such a picture you know where I was a graduate student in Harvard and the people at Washington St Louis University did who did the first of these and did an incredible service to the field you know we oh my gosh it was like landing on the moon going inside the human brain and knowing which part of the brain endows us with human capacities um now we can be appreciative or we can be skeptical scientists and we can say this let's pick this one let's compare seeing a seeing a word like board versus seeing a fixation we do that subtraction and that seeing

**[47:09]:** a word just by Common Sense what's wrong with this comparison it's okay it's not terrible how could you control it better to understand what this part of the brain is really doing I heard something well partly it's a meaningful word versus something that doesn't mean anything to plus right but what else could you do say it's different between them yeah I go in this case oh my gosh yes and I'll come back to that but let me not do that one for the moment okay because that's a giant story which I can't fit in today that's yes your mind could be all over the place okay so that's definitely the case okay that's a good one yeah yeah small yeah that's perfect okay that's the way I was going the other one's great too two great comments uh yeah you could say like maybe this is a part of your brain that goes with five

**[48:03]:** things or something this big versus this big now go that's not so interesting the part of your brain that looks at something this big versus this big but that's just as legitimate a conclusion here right how about this five different things versus only this right there's a lot of different ways in which you can say what is the mental operation that I've discovered in the human brain and mind it all comes down to the comparison so here's what they did to try to do a better job they showed you you know a more complicated thing that doesn't mean anything a bunch of letters that you can't pronounce a bunch of letters that you can pronounce but it's not a real word and here's the real word itself so if you want to say what do you think this part of the mind is doing what is what is it what part of the Mind does

**[48:46]:** this part of the brain allow to happen in humans and only humans on this planet and every word you ever read only happens because this part of the brain does what it does what is that part of the brain doing is it just simply responding to complicated things five of them no not much okay a little bit but not much how about letters letters are pretty interesting but there can't be a word by English you can't pronounce this not too interested a word a set of letters you've never seen together before but you can pronounce by the rules of English boom right that's what I do says this part of the brain by the way that's what I do okay I say I see something and it's possibly a word and I can say it by the rules of English and by the way if it's a word I've done before I do that too

**[49:29]:** I'm I'm pretty flexible I can do new words I can do words I've known before it matches what you see with language that's reading that's only our species can take our visual system and the language he learn as a child and put them together and allow our our civilization to read and this is the part of the brain where those roads meet and by the way we talked about local and Global the forest and the trees uh and consistent with what we talked about split brain patients if you're looking at Global stuff right hemisphere if you're looking at local stuff left hemisphere so we like it when the information we have from split brain patients or stroke patients aligns with healthy people doing a task as they typically do because then we sort of believe there's something right about that so um good so pet uh pretty good spatial resolution I mean depends what you

**[50:18]:** mean by good uh my Neuroscience colleagues you know dismiss everything we ever do as sort of pathetically imprecise but 5 to 10 millimeters is not as good as fmri um the temporal resolution is very poor we can only take one picture that lasts about a minute um uh and averages everything across that you have to inject people with radioactive stuff uh and and it's correlational okay but it has one other thing that's really really interesting uh positron emission tomography because you're injecting a radioactive label you can create different kinds of labels that go to different parts of the brain so here's Parkinson's disease which we know involves d damage to the substanti in the basil ganglia here's a healthy person substanti and here's a personent with Parkinson's disease where these cells have died away uh typically at least 80% of these have to die before a person shows Parkinson's disease uh symptoms clinically here's an

**[51:11]:** injection of a radioactive stuff using pet that binds to dopamine receiving neurons and you can see that in the living Parkinson's patient there's tremendous reduction in these receptors waiting for dopamine in a living patient specifically dopamine receptors so that's a disease here's here's why video games are taking over the world oh no not yet we can do one more thing sorry we can track a disease you know from a typical person to a person with moderate uh Parkinson diseas or severe so not only within the disease we can see differences gradation but here's why video games are taking over the world uh because if we take a healthy person uh young adults uh give them this kind of dopamine binding uh Tracer and have them play a video game two things happen happen a the parts of your brain that are involved in reward dopamine is the strongest reward neurotransmitter that we know things you

**[52:02]:** know uh go crazy and what this graph is showing you is uh the better you do the more rewarded you are this is why you will go for the next level okay because to get that dopamine fixed you got to keep going all right the better you are so I mean every you know and we think these reward mechanisms underly everything in many ways they relate to everything you know why do you do whatever you do because at some level in some way you find it rewarding uh and and and the data is very compelling that way the last method I'll talk about is functional MRI and um uh it's the one that's OB you know maybe most widely visible so you sit in a scanner stimul are presented to you you perform a task we do a lot of stuff in our lab with children we show them you know how the Frog would

**[52:47]:** do it uh for those of you who've done a functional M experiment because there were so many hands that were put up do any of you want to say a word about your experience doing that what was it like easy huge fun recommend no not so much fun it'll vary a little bit we said

**[53:08]:** noisy some people find it claustrophobic yeah um I don't know you didn't really do anything I just had to sit there for a really long time and not oh so they didn't ask you to do a task maybe well who knows for a big part of it I was watching a movie so so the answer oh you were okay so for the student they were watching ing a movie and not doing anything right and you were you were doing yes or no clicks okay so that would be a typical functional MRI kind of experiments some of them are more obnoxious some are less some are funny some are not as funny you're endlessly pushing for things that are any other experiences was it comfortable not so comfortable medium okay anybody else want to share No Okay um so how does this work so functional MRI takes advantage of MRI but but it focuses on on

**[54:00]:** on hemoglobin the stuff that carries oxygen in your blood and it rests on the fact that deoxygenated hemoglobin after oxygen has been extracted is has is more sensitive to the magnetic field than oxygenated hemoglobin so it's like this here's your here's basically capillaries uh and and veins and arteries and veins and as as you go through the capillary bed the smallest uh vessels right neurons are extracting oxygen to support their physical life what happens when this part of the brain gets active is that more oxygen is extracted to support the active neurons so uh and we call this bold effect blood oxygen level dependence so we're measuring the change in blood changes the ratio of oxygenated to Deo oxygen hemoglobins that changes the magnetic field as we measure it and that's what we directly measure that's not the neurons so if the neurons are using up oxygen why does the Bold signal increase why does

**[54:55]:** this ratio go up and because intuitively you think it would go down right because oxygen is being extracted at a higher rate but here's what happens there's if you look at oxygen being extracted right after something happens 10 milliseconds there's a 10 seconds there's a uh initial dip of oxygen that's the neurons extracting the oxygen to replenish themselves from their activity their activity has been to give your mind its life um then what happens is is there's this vast oversupply for a much longer time you know the intuitively it's as if we said it's so important to metabolically support the neurons that make up our minds that if if some area is demanding a lot of blood we send over way too much extra as soon as we can from a distance to make sure everything's okay all right and because our measurement is so sad uh we almost can never measure this initial dip

**[55:54]:** we almost almost always measure the sustained over supply of oxygen to that part of the brain so you can say it's such a house of cards right the over supply of the blood going to a part of the brain changes the balance of oxygena to De oxygen hemoglobin that changes the magnetic property and that's how we tried to figure out what that part of the brain is doing for your mind but it works pretty well in some cases um decent spatial resolution uh no injection uh you can zoom in a scanner and do a lot of different things uh modest temporal resolution because it's not milliseconds it's all on the order of seconds um and it's correlational uh not causal but you get some amazing results I'm just going to present to you two or three um so here's one a thing we're very interested about humans is empathy right how much we understand and

**[56:46]:** feel other people's uh happiness or sadness or pain so the observation or imagination of another person in a particular emotional state autom automatically activates a representation of that state The Observer empathy the how do we understand how another person feels and we think that's a big thing in how we relate to one another as humans so uh uh Tanya singer did the following experiment she said we talked about this before a little bit embodied cognition that we understand others out there by the feelings we know within us we don't know their feelings but we know our feelings inside us right so here's what she did she brought in pairs of people who were uh friends or romantic Partners okay pretty close friends and she either had them get some pain it was a shock within ethical boundary okay but not pleasant okay that's the pain or you got to watch through a video camera while

**[57:41]:** you're being imaged your partner getting the shock so think about somebody you care about and think about them getting something painful okay and how you would feel at that moment and they asked in the brain what's similar and dissimilar and they focused on with similar right now between feeling pain yourself and observing pain in somebody you care about empathizing with the pain you see them having and what they found is two areas something of in the anterior singulate and something in the insula we talked about before where there was a lot of overlap so this phrase I'm feeling your pain in your brain when you feel for somebody else's pain in this physical sense you turn on some of the same brain areas as when you feel physical pain directly it's as if the basis to imagine another person's feelings is the feelings you know so well yourself okay and this is literally shown now

**[58:32]:** by the brain Imaging it could have been a story a metaphor an argument you know this is scientific evidence that supports that likelihood so we're going to expand it in a slightly fun way um so there's been a lot of study about in neuroeconomics thinking about how we think about for example things like trust so one game and there's a number of them is called the ultimatum game many of you probably know this but let me remind you of this this version of it has two players a proposer and a responder and what they do is they give the proposer a certain amount of money the proposer um and uh uh and then the proposer is allowed to make an offer to the responder if the responder says no nobody gets any money if the and usually people offer about 50% so let's make this concrete just for a moment so can I can I

**[59:22]:** pick you for a second are you sorry you can decline okay all right you're okay okay you're right there okay so imagine imagine if uh Tyler came over to me and gave me $10 10 Single dollars and I said how would you feel if I gave you five and I kept five would you what do you think might you go for it yeah okay I mean you go you're I'm $5 ahead you're $5 ahead you know you know Tyler uh won't eat this month because graduate students typend are modest but you know we just it's a zero some game in the end okay so uh uh okay okay so now Tyler comes over and hands me 10 more dollars and uh and I offer you one what's your first feeling assuming that I wasn't your teacher grading you I don't know you saw me get 10 I say here's one what's your feeling think about

**[1:00:10]:** it just you feel kind of Che yeah now you don't have to by a purely economic perspective would you be ahead by taking that dollar yeah okay dollar is a dollar $2 is $2 right but people have a sense of fairness okay even to their own detriment uh if you offered $2 that and lower even knowing that you're just ruining a dollar or two you would have gotten for nothing except saying yes people half the time will say no right it's like you are so unfair you were saying to me I would never say this to you you are so unfair that you know we're going to take us both down rather than you have the pleasure or the $8 okay it's so unfair that my sense of fairness is is Disturbed okay okay it's kind of it's an interesting way to think about it somebody you know imagine a friend of yours is handed

**[1:00:58]:** $10 and they offer you half and if you say no nobody gets anything okay so you have it's a trust game so they had the people in the scanner playing this game with two people they saw in a video monitor the two people they're playing with our setup okay the person in the scanner is the real participant the people out there they see are Confederates they're play actors and one is a fair person here's $5 thank you here's $5 thank you okay here's $6 oh you're awesome you know we can get along there's and then there's an unfair player here's a dollar you go why why is this guy a jerk right all right how about $2 no no and after a while you go I really the fair player was very decent this unfair player who you believe is part of the experiment but is a setup okay you're thinking why is this person

**[1:01:41]:** such a jerk they're constantly getting $10 and they're constantly giving me one or two no no no thank you all right now these people uh now you get a shock and you see these two strangers one of whom was a wonderful Fair player and one of whom was an absurdly unfair player you see them get a shock okay and they had both men and women in the scanner watching these things happen and here's what happened and it's kind of funny but you know whatever uh for the women they had overlap again between the parts of the brain that turned on here in the insula when they got a shock and when either the fair player got a shock or the unfair player they felt bad for both by this measure okay look at the men in the study I feel bad if the fair guy gets it right but this part of the brain is

**[1:02:30]:** like yeah give it to him can't you push up the voltage you know I mean it just came out this way I whether it would work that way under all circumstances you know all ages all societies other groups of men and women don't know but in in this sample the United Kingdom uh uh you know the men had no empathy for the it's worse than that okay it's worse than they had no empathy let me show you this um if they asked to indicate their desire for revenge against this is a behavioral response their desire for revenge against the bad player okay now they're not I don't think they pursued the unfair player down the street and you know but just that feeling like and wom said a little bit the men said yes you know I mean if only I could take down this person that would be great and here's the amazing thing

**[1:03:14]:** we'll come back to the structure called the nucleus cumbent and sits in the bottom of the basil of the basal ganglia it's the structure that in the human brain is most identified with reward and pleasure most identified with reward and pleasure by fmri Imaging look at the nucleus that cumbin when the unfair player gets Zapped okay uh you're watching the women Ah that's not nothing much the men Boom Big reward revenge is rewarding in their brain okay no sympathy and lots of Revenge satisfaction for the unfair player now you can decide in your own life you know who this applies to or not but it's kind of sort of fun it's sort of fun to explore uh these different things how we form ideas about empathy Trust you know whether they they are in the society we give in we grow up in somewhat different on average in men and women huge ranges within men

**[1:04:00]:** huge ranges with women so but it's a sort of fun thing to explore so let me end with something that's much more uh uh uh difficult and disturbing uh but another place where Imaging is giving us insites that we could not have imagined having some time ago so this is a very difficult case I don't know if any of you have gone through it I don't wish it for you many of you some of you probably have and many of you will at sometime in your life when you have to make an end of life decision and among the most famous of these cases uh oops sorry was um Terry Sho now I don't know if you and that name even rings a bell for you but it got very very famous amongst these kinds of cases so she had a cardiac arrest she took a lot of diet pills and that may have contributed

**[1:04:40]:** in February 25th 1990 she went into a coma and then a vegetative state so vegetative state is when a person seems to be kind of awake but when you talk with them they're not very aware they're not responsive they're not noticing they're not talking but their eyes are open and they're awake they not eyes are not closed so that's what she is uh and they put in her a feeding tube because without that she wouldn't live she couldn't uh uh eat and feed herself it was a heartbreaking difference of opinion between her husband and her parents her husband petitioned uh by uh some years later actually eight years later to remove the feeding tube and let her pass away the parents oppos that they said that's not her wishes she would want to keep on going with the feeding tube the husband said no I don't believe that's her wishes so you had this very

**[1:05:24]:** tragic confrontation between the parents who loved her and the husband who presumably loved her having different ideas about what uh to do with her whether to end her life or not so finally her tube was removed but then the parents went to court and the judge reversed it and they put the tube back in here she became sadly kind of back and forth uh uh living non-living on judicial decisions her face her case became particularly famous uh for a bunch of reasons uh and they it went back and forth from from court to court you know moving up into state courts and and there were several US Supreme Court decisions about whether to remove the tube or keep the tube in and you know TR it's a tragic thing it's a tragic choice between the parents and the husband it got to the US Congress and the US Senate President Bush signed a bill to

**[1:06:11]:** keep her alive okay I mean it was the highest everybody got involved uh with various opinions finally the Supreme Court made a series of decisions she it was her it was disconnected in 2005 and she died in March 31 of that year so a tragic difficult decision and a tragic family situation that became kind of a political and judicial football so what's going on in the mind of somebody like this and how could we even begin to interpret it for a person who can't speak for themselves and can't respond so let me tell you about a different case we don't know her case uh uh so here again a vegetative state is is one where you appear to be awake but there's no sign of awareness eyes are open but the person's not talking or responding to anything in their environment so here's a different one woman 23 years old in 2005 she had a

**[1:06:56]:** road traffic accident severe traumatic brain injury 5 months later she's unresponsive but she has preserved sleep wake she's waking up going to sleep waking up going to sleep eyes open but unresponsive in every other way they put her into an fmri scanner as well as healthy comparison people and they have them do two mental imagery tasks okay now because and they can't give instru they read instructions to the her but here's what here you go into the scanner and you know tell to imagine two different things playing tennis so imagine in your mind's eye you playing tennis for a moment imagine that or imagine visiting all the rooms of your house starting with your front door in the house that you are living in now or where you grew up imagine those two scen in your mind now first of all just at a pure cognitive Neuroscience level and we'll come back to that imagination

**[1:07:44]:** is a really interesting thing and it turns out when we imagine things again we use the parts of our brain that does them imagination is perception run backwards we can see imagination in the human brain and depending on what you're imagining you use the same systems that you uh see with if you imagine something you're looking at you know will turn on your visual system and it's even more specific than that so let's first look at what happens with the controls when they imagine they're playing tennis they turn on the supplementary motor area that's a part of your brain that plans your physical movements okay you're not moving but you're thinking about it this is Imagination of movement when you plan a movement you turn that on when you go around your house you turn on spatial areas that are uh in the perample cortex and similar area parial cortex and perample cortex that are

**[1:08:32]:** turned on if we show you a movie where you're moving around in spaces if you see spaces you turn those on if you imagine spaces you turn them on so imagination in the brain is perception run backwards or physical action run backwards you're not actually doing it but look at this patient who got in the scanner who's non-responsive you read her the instructions and you see what what she does and look at her brain asked to imagine tennis asked to imagine the rooms in her house and it looks just like that what does that mean just in a common sense what does that mean did she understand the instruction at some level yes right she she she wouldn't turn on those parts of the brain if she didn't understand not only does she understand the instruction she imagines the thing you ask her to instruct so this gu on the front page of the New

**[1:09:21]:** York Times that fmri could tell you the internal mental life of a person who could no longer speak or communicate in any other way now it's turned out since then that when they put in other patients into the scanner most of them don't show this pattern okay so it's not that every patient in a vegetative state is is full of mental life like this person and in a deeper way we don't really understand what this mental life is like we don't know whether she simply understands some things but doesn't have feelings or plans or desires or whether she has those two okay we don't understand really the full range of mental life but we know we know that she can understand an instruction and her brain follows through with it okay most patients it turns out don't look like that in vegetative States so again brain imaging has taken us inside the mind of somebody

**[1:10:09]:** who cannot communicate for themselves and let us say something about what it is that's going on in that mind so in conclusion we've talked about different ways of learning about the brain different methods to record structure and function that vary in their temporal and spatial acui and you know incredibly different ways in which we can understand the organization in time and space of how the brain supports the human mind

**[1:10:52]:** thanks
